Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

When you sit on a story hook for a few years, you have a lot of time to think of what changes you'd make when you eventually return to it. And at one point, I'd decided to use this second sequence in the strip to establish a longer history between Joe and Dorothy. I dunno, interesting, right? well okay a few logistical issues

1) saying that joe had been pestering dorothy about being a lesbian starting in hebrew school means that he started when he was in like first grade, and that's a little much even for joe

2) we know dorothy was raised irreligiously, so her going to hebrew school would probably be a bigger retcon than the joe/dorothy history lengthening

3) also there's a bonus strip where we see the very moment joe hits puberty and suddenly gets a horny expression, and it definitely would've been after all this would've had to've happened

SO WHATEVER. First attempt at changes to the original take were made, then discarded.

so i reverted back to the original "well, it still isn't" response, which is better anyway, and then... look, I don't even know what this was about. It was probably me just fooling around. It's a very Walky punchline and not a Joe one.

But I did change the original's "when I was sixteen" to "when I was fifteen," which does give them another year of knowing each other.

So I sat back, tried to get some perspective, and then decided, okay, let's remember what's actually going on in the strip, and center this in the now, on the facts on the ground, rather than what I'd brainstormed about over the past few years. It's two Dorothy Face strips in a row, but I think it still worked:

 

Files

Comments

Tom @ Magic Chopstick Games

The one you went with is the best to my mind. The Joejitsu keeping Dorothy off-kilter is 😙👌

Harold

"Mayhaps perchance" definitely sounds like something Walky would say.

C

The magic of Dorothy's last expression was definitely the best result.

Andrea Andrew

Woah! Joe and Dorothy both went to Hebrew school?! Joyce really does have a type!

Harold

@Andrea Andrew: Well, Willis does say here that he decided that Dorothy *didn't* go to Hebrew school after all, as that would clash with what we know about how she was raised. But your point holds, since Dorothy is half-Jewish by birth.

Packy Anderson

My unreciprocated love for process strips continues!

C.T. Phipps

I think the whole sequence is one of your best Willis because of the mix of humor, drama, and the genuine anger at the microaggressions that Dorothy repressed.

Maude Reads Things

The idea of these two in Hebrew school would've been really funny because I can imagine the shenanigans, but ultimately I think you made the right call. It clashes too much with established history.

Inquiring Raven

As a newer Patreon member… sound like I need to go looking for a Joe strip. I’m a try myself, but if anyone has a link it would be appreciated.

Harold

@Andrea Andrew: Indeed!

David M Willis

Thanks for digging that up! I've linked it within the write-up.

Joseph

Second Dorothy face is fine. It works because it emphasizes that Dorothy is going through it at the moment.

Maya

Huh. In the published strip, didn't read this as "Joe knew Dorothy when he was 15." I just read it as just Joe saying that he used to think it was funny to joke that ALL girls uninterested in him were "lesbians" and that he was still behaving that way until his recent personal growth.

Harold

@Maya: Well, we do know that Joe knew Dorothy when he was 15 - he, Dorothy and Danny all went to high school together.