Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Well this one's just embarrassing! Did you know that originally, we didn't have any of the Dorothy lying awake at night, Becky talking to her, or Becky summoning Walky? Just cutting straight to Dorothy waking up from a nightmare beside Walky in his bed, somehow. What.

Like, what was I even thinking. That whole sequence was incredibly important, and it almost wasn't even there. Instead, this speedrun of what became May 22/23's strips, which removes a lot of the meat.

I feel bad showing this! Was I sick that day? What was going on???

Files

Comments

Sajuuk-Khar

It’s even missing the all-important loophole in Dorothy’s Nile River Cruise!

Andrea Andrew

Good call. Man, I don’t understand how Dorothy can be this much in denial.

Harold

Thank you for adding those strips, especially May 17th (Becky reveals her true feelings to Dorothy). "Incredibly important" is an understatement.

Smoochie

Because fear is the mind killer, and who is Dorothy but one of the sharpest minds in-comic?

Andrea Andrew

I hope Dorothy doesn’t go down the homophobic centrist/right wing rabbit hole.

Jasmijn Wellner

Wow yeah it reads like you were in a hurry to get through it all in one strip or something

Sajuuk-Khar

Y E S Like holy shit this has some of the dialogue but it’s like a skeleton by comparison

Sajuuk-Khar

Without the development that we got, I think this set of statements by Dorothy would be really whiplash-inspiring, because we’d watch her go straight from a big romantic moment to a trauma flashback to rationalization, and it’d be unclear how she really *felt*. Which is a huge disservice to her, because despite Sarah’s accusation to the contrary, Dorothy quietly is a very emotional person! She just likes to keep it under wraps! And when we see her feel and wrestle with her feelings it’s really strong character work. And THAT was what we got with the published strips: a clear demonstration of Dorothy in romantic agony, and desperately rationalizing to push down her feelings in a way we recognize and love through anguish. Also it gave Becky a wonderful and much-needed moment.

Maude Reads Things

You wanted to get to the good stuff but I'm glad the sequence got to breathe some more.

T Campbell

Had David come to me with this shorter strip and expressed doubts, I might have hesitated to recommend replacing it. It does have a few advantages: if Dorothy gets through her anguish quicker, then Walky seems a bit less oblivious. And it implies that she went straight from tension with Joyce to sleeping with her actual boyfriend, which rhymes with the sexting subplot and is a valid way to go. Buuuuut in the end, the longer treatment has more to recommend it. It has greater emotional range from Dorothy, which sells her conflict better. It shows more of her dynamic with Walky, underlining the difficult choices she faces. And of course, it has a star turn from Becky, whose performative obnoxiousness can't mask her quiet determination that no one around her will ever be allowed to succumb to depression the way her mother did.

Dread Pirate Robin

She's in a stressful point in her life and now she's in love with her best friend who's with someone else, it makes sense to deny her feelings just because, on the surface, it feels like it makes life more manageable. Just trying to cork the bottle back the way it was.