Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

too much recognizing!!! dial back the recognizing!!!!

Files

Comments

Andrea Andrew

Damn it, Jocelyn! At least Dorothy gets second hand embarrassment of her girlfriend’s charms.

Logibear

Set em up. Knock em down

Corronchilejano

Imagine now Mary coming by with a drive-by about this too. Mary's all for it isn't she?

Joe360

Yeah, that "alt-present" is pretty bad.

Megh

something something something DOA is earth we live in hell

Mark Thompson

Ah. The direct approach. On a preexisting tender subject. This'll be productive. *popcorn gif*

Astariel

Well, that threw a wrench into the conversation. Just need a record scratch sound effect in there.

C

Robin: *runs by with the Drama Tag, screaming*

Harold

Welp. There have been many conversational segues over the years, and that was certainly one of them.

jafortee

the part of jugs has being filled by jugular

Steve McSheffrey

Jocelyne doesn't care that Dorothy has to live with the aftermath of this, does she?

jafortee

I never thought we’d see the day that Carla felt *too* seen

5099 5618 v2.0

Feel free to mention these concerns to Joyce later, D. Maybe not until BedTime, tho. She'll need time to respond.

Harold

Dumbing of Age, Book 16: Bring Me Back Jugs, Please

voyager-ngc5195

Suddenly realizing that every real US presidental election is just Rutten Family VS Brown Family.

GundamBradley

The level to which Jocelyn is much better at this than Dorothy is kind of hilarious, but she's got considerably more experience, and isn't high off of her budding romance to the extent where she's constantly fixated on it, so the clarity is probably helpful.

Lazuli

when reality kicks in

Packy Anderson

Jocelyn knows how to wrap a request in a compliment.

voyager-ngc5195

The Killdozer of communication techniques.

Tessea

Emotional damage... er... whiplash! Panel 3 seems to be something of a dig at a certain social media owner. This Alt-present that we live in really sucks for a lot of people.

Logibear

I also don't think Dorothys cottoned on to the fact that there might be splash damage either.

Lazuli

“here’s a saddle, carla, for when you wanna get back on your high horse”

Lazuli

well. yes.

Sajuuk-Khar

Jocelyne, in Disco Elysium terms, has a 5 in Rhetoric, a 4 in Suggestion, and just fucking botched the shit out of an Empathy red check

Fart Captor

What the fuck kind of spash damage are do you expect to come from talking to Carla about her parents profiting from war and genocide?

Fart Captor

People like Mary are one thousand percent into it IRL because they want all the Jews and Muslims to kill each other and also bring about biblical Armageddon

Irene Knapp

ouch. ouch, ouch, ouch. (panel 3)

ArdieBea

Maybe not! Let's see what comes next. Carla might prefer to deal with the subject with someone she's not in a romantic relationship with.

Lazuli

short packed!robin??? what are *you* doing here???

Simon Magid

Robin: I don't know! What is *any* of me doing *anywhere*?!

Sajuuk-Khar

also like, what aftermath even Carla’s dramatic, not vindictive

5099 5618 v2.0

@Packy Anderson And that around a brick.

5099 5618 v2.0

@Harold First read as "Bring Back Me Jugs [1], Please." [1] - Arr, matey. Arr.

Shane Wegner

As a species we really should disband all bombs and missiles. But the current USA administration seems basically at the “war crimes are fine” level.

Mohmi

EMPATHY: I would advise not pressing the issue further, who knows what she has gone through in her journey. Allow her the grace of seeing her parents in a positive light, even in this instant- HALF LIGHT: She called your sister jugs, you called her parents mass murderers, it's fair play. ELECTROCHEMISTRY: You should celebrate with a nice big sack of crack.

Shane Wegner

The logical flaw in Jocelyn’s panel 5 is, the highly accurate Ruttech guidance systems guide the munition the where they’re targeted by the person dropping the points. They’re not inherently trans-kid seeking. We have a Law of War which specifically says only military targets are allowed. (Bulmeria might or might not.) No reasonable targeteers will accept kids as a valid military targets, although another reality is kids definitely do get hit sometimes anyway. The next question is “Do nations have a right to self defense?” (If every nation disbanded all weapons, maybe there would be no need, but good luck with that.) And in say Anthropic’s case “What’s my tolerance for where I draw a line and say I won’t sell to the government?” (Anthropic’s was entirely happy to sell to the government up until their specific red line.) For Ruttech’s case, the escalation goes something like: Ruttech sold precision GPS to the government. Did they know they would be used in weapons? Did they know those weapons would be sold to other countries? Did they know those countries would carelessly or even deliberately strike civilian targets? And then: At what point on this chain is a company obligated to walk away or else face being complicit? Anthropic showed that there are extreme penalties for trying to withdraw, granted this administration is extra unreasonable. Even supposing Ruttech and U Indiana say “You know what? You’re 100% right. We divest/quit forever”, what’s next for Jocelyn? Is Bulmeria saved? Jocelyn can sleep soundly knowing the Bulmerian kids are getting blasted by the Russian non-guided cluster munitions the Bulmerian government replaced the lost sales with, and she’s not very indirectly complicit anymore. Every tax dollar (sales included) Jocelyn pays supports that same government. The only way to totally divest would be to leave the country and renounce citizenship. Anything less is somewhat participating while trying to do good from within, which may well be exactly how Ruttentech sees themselves.

SmurfJuice

Appeal to sympathy? Direct? I know not what you mean, all that was heard is "Carla is awesome".

SmurfJuice

Oh boy, have I got words to say about *lobbyists*, then! (Can't be president without an agenda set against an uncooperative Congress that's paid to be so! 👍🫪👍)

Tessea

"We have a Law of War which specifically says only military targets are allowed." Tell that to that school of young girls that was hit at the start of this pointless war. The reality is that regular people suffer in war, and a percentage of those are going to be trans just by sheer sample size. Jocelyn may not end the war with Ruttech and the university cutting ties, but when it's people and institutions that she respects that are involved, convincing them to pull out is important to her. And if such high profile entities turn their backs on such a war, others may follow.

Katrina Marie Paton

And there it is. Just as well I had the popcorn premade.

Pangab

She explicitly told Dorothy what she was going to do before going there

Star Ringer

You seem to have immense faith in the people with the missiles and zero faith in everyone else.

thejeff

I have little faith in either, but millennia of history suggests pretty strongly that "just stop making weapons" isn't a practical answer for any country.

thejeff

In the abstract we should. World peace would be nice. But how do we get there? How do we make our leaders do that? What do we do with the countries that don't disband theirs? Who now have all the bombs and missiles?

Empress of Robots

Panel 3 enacted more psychic damage on me than anything else in all of DoA.

Johanne

How do we get there? By going on strike and demanding better.

Zesstra

Saving panel 3 with the caption CurbYourEnthusiasmTheme.mp3

Shane Wegner

I’ve been giving that a think too. South Sudan doubtfully has any GPS guided munitions, but the children there are still in plenty of danger. Humans can and do genocide with machetes when they put their minds to it.

VengeanceKnight

I mean, Carla *can* be *extremely* vindictive, but the only known person to get her to that point is Mary. I think Joyce is safe.

VengeanceKnight

The first book ended with Joyce almost getting date-SA’d. This comic came with the drama tag yanked out.

Seth Aaron Hershman has they/she pronouns

important question for you shane: countries like the united states and israel frequently claim that valid military targets are hidden inside of schools and hospitals, and that therefore bombing schools and hospitals is necessary. do you believe this constitutes "targeting children"?

C Bonesmith

I'm really interested to see where this plotline goes- we know what Jocelyn wants, and what she thinks might work, but... will it? *Can* it? Ruttech clearly isn't just a mom and pop shop. And while mom and pop care a great deal about their daughter's happiness, does "the founders' daughter hates this" carry any weight with the C-suite, legal department, and board? It'll be interesting to see how this shakes out. Is this going to do anything other than possibly alienate Carla from her support system after she confronts them and gets told "no, we can't do that?" Granted, DoA world works on a sort of different ruleset, one that lets heroic actions get rewarded (everything with Amazi-girl and that truck defied reality, but who cares, it was great to read and she earned it! She's a hero!) and puts people like Blaine and Ross in the ground, so I'd like to hope that good things come of this.

Shane Wegner

@Seth - Tabling USA and Israel and what they claim for now, let's talk some specifics as best I understand them relating to the literal question about targetting children. I'll try and keep it to a small novel. "Targetting" has a very particular meaning in this military context that matters. It's taking the military entity being considered for engagement and removal from the battlespace (which could mean degradation of their abilities, but often just means "destruction"), then pairing it up with a capability (this often just means "weapon system") to form a strike package. This will also include a Collateral Damage Assessment about what other damage is probable, including lives lost of people NOT the military target. So for example a military entity could be the Bulmerian Royal Guard, 2nd Regiment, 1st company, boiled down to "They've got 10 guys with assault rifles in this small tent group, we'd like them gone." OR, "The Bulmerian New Dawn, People's Brigade", which isn't a recognized military unit by Geneva flagged nation-state standards, but the Bulmerian government has designated them enemy combatants, and they DO have ten guys with AKs holed up in an abadoned apartment complex and have been firing off mortars all week. Something not in a military status isn't a military target. "That kid with the soccer ball" or "that baby holding the red lollipop" just don't have any meaning as a military designation, they're not a military asset adding to any unit's capability in the battlespace. Where the children fit in is on that Collateral Damage Assessment. I'm aware this is an ice cold distinction at best. Let's say the New Dawn, Peoples' Brigade move their AKs and mortars into a hospital. Their mortars are killing 50 people a day, 10 of them children, for 3 days, and Bulmerian Command wants them gone but hasn't been able to drive them out with foot troops in the area. If Bulmeria had a perfect Orbital Death Ray that sends a 1mm laser beam with unerring accuracy, maybe they could target it onto just those 10 gunmen. But they don't have that, it's probably for the best. What they DO have is 2,000lb bombs the Bulmerian Air Force can drop in. Let's pretend they have a 99% fatality rate for 100m and a 70% fatality rate for 300m beyond that. That's the whole hospital. Bulmerian intelligence knows there are at least 20 children and mothers in the maternity ward of the hospital that have been too sick to move. They're stuck in some kind of ugly human shield/hostage situation they didn't sign up for. Bulmerian Intelligence estimates the New Dawn guys have enough food and ammo to keep those mortars firing at least 10 more days. Does the Bulmerian commander for the theater let them fire all 10 days, signing the death warrant of 500 people, 100 of them children? Or do they approve the 2000lb bomb strike package, the only package they have that silences those 10 guys but also snuffs out the 20 souls in the maternity ward? As a pure numbers game, both are awful, but one has smaller numbers. But in any case, the Target isn't the kids. The Target is the mortars guys. If the New Dawn guys arrange for ambulances to move the maternity ward civilians, Bulmeria doesn't update the bomb coordinates to their houses to make sure they still die. They don't have much reason to do this, because they know the second that last ambulance leaves, the 2000lb is arriving. If the mortar guys surrender (maybe they were granted amnesty), the strike is off because there aren't any more Targets. I'm aware this example is cleaner than real life to try and show a core principle. So no. I don't "believe" children are being targeted in your examples, becaues children are not the Target, instead they're incidentally on the CDA. If the actual military targets left the building, the children are of no interest militarily. Children don't belong on a CDA of course either, but if militants move into a hospital or anywhere else children are, it becomes much more likely. From the rebel point of view, trying to fight an unjust force 1000x stronger than them may not leave a lot of good options either. Maybe humans could stop using violence all around. If children WERE deiberately made the primary target for any reason*, be it to "end a civilization", break the enemy's will, get a better negotiating position, or any other reason, that could only be considered rankest terrorism. If there were a case where the stated Targets were just a cover used an excuse to kill more kids on the CDA, who were secretly the actual Targets, that's sneaky terrorism, which is somehow feels even worse. *OK, the exception is the god awful one of child soldiers being forced to pick up weapons and fight, where there's not a lot of choice but to target them like anyone else. I think we all understand that ain't the Hospital Kids we're talking about. If we have devolved into an age where military professionalism has given way to official terrorism, it's going to take a lot more than some student protests to turn that around.

Shane Wegner

TLDR- I know my long take is more the JAG answer than the average person one If you're just asking if I think USA and Israel are trying to snuff out kids and make it look like an accident, my answer is "I hope tf not, but my faith in either entity is not near an all-time high right now."

Maude Reads Things

Yeah, this is a heavy topic coming up that's going to be hard to come up with a real answer for for Carla

thejeff

WTF does going on strike do?