Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

retroactively it was not any of her business

Files

Comments

Maude Reads Things

I dunno how amicable you and Danny are Dorothy but sure. And yeah, I'm willing to see how long Joyce can Not Discuss what happened with Dorothy.

5099 5618 v2.0

Right, so, look out for the big toothy grin when Joyce is trying to avoid [ (talking about stuff ) | (consequences of her actions) ]. Got it.

Jennifer Novelli

Oh, this isn't gonna blow up in anyone's face. 😉

MST3K.fan: The Cheesy Movie Essays

Correct me if I’m wrong. I haven’t read their Slipshine yet, but railing would require one or the other of them to wear a strap on, right? Or is it just a figure of speech?

Logibear

"Never Tell Dorothy About This" - Joe literally minutes before disaster strikes.

Harold

@BBCC: At least long enough to get RAILED again. And again. And...

Crunchos cereal

I’m old, and not a native speaker, but I think it is just a figure of speech here. There is a lot of railing to be done with other parts of the body. (And at least Joyce now knows what is a strap-on.)

Logibear

"Oh don't worry, I won't outright say it but I will make it seem like there is something from this conversation that I either omitted or forgot to mention that would greatly change the context of our relationship.... just like I did here too"

Harold

Joyce: "Yes! Ha-Ha! Exes! Which we totally and completely are, and have been since Sunday! EXES! HA-HA-HA!" Dorothy: "Jesus Christ, I didn't know a human being could HAVE that many teeth."

Astariel

It's nice to see that Dorothy supports Joyce being on good terms with Joe, despite her issues with him in the past. Everything about that last panel is perfect, especially Joyce's big grin.

Astariel

They haven't been shown using one in the Slipshine or the other Patreon, so I'm guessing probably a figure of speech.

Railway Series Book Club

i love those last two panels so so much the intimate and absolutely adorable bonking of heads together followed by dorothy's wonderful reaction to joyce's shit-eating grin... doa theocracy you will always be the greatest to ever do it

Astariel

They seemed pretty amicable up until Dorothy's bi realization. Besides, just because she prefers it that way doesn't mean she always succeeds.

tifani

Dorothy. I don’t think you’re on amicable terms with Walky OR Danny at the moment.

Calder Johnson

Gawd, it's so true. But like, I get it - it's something that can happen when there's something someone really WANTS to say but also feels like they can't/shouldn't/are afraid of the consequeces. Some kind of...truth-edging?

GundamBradley

Dorothy's notion of who Joe is really does kind of illuminate how iffy her ability to read people is, and why stuff like the "who might take over for Ruth as RA?" happened the way it did. She's really not great at recognizing how much of a box she puts people into sometimes.

GundamBradley

It's not her preferred state, but given how shaken up she's been since the protest and how awkwardly she's been behaving, it's probably the best she can really expect.

KiasyonSFM

We are probably about to witness a generational meltdown from one of these two. Prepare the bunkers! 😫

Lazuli

how long do you think?

C.T. Phipps

Dorothy is incapable of thinking of Joe as a human being instead of a horndog.

Sajuuk-Khar

Joyce Brown you are smooth like a smooth lion

Tessea

That is NOT the humor/expression we've come to expect from Joyce. I love how much she's loosening up, especially around Dorothy. I was surprised to see her so happy and chipper so soon after what happened with Joe. Hopefully she's not just bottling it up like ..... well... everything that worries her. Happy thoughts. Happy thoughts.

Shane Wegner

Agreed, she doesn't want to update her mental map. If she talks too much trash about him, it reflects badly on Joyce, who likes the good parts of him Dorothy doesn't know about.

Shane Wegner

Potential conflict if Dorothy leans too heavily on not liking Joe. Dorothy: "Joe is bad and one of your flaws (I helped you fix) was liking him!" "EXCUSE me?!"

Shane Wegner

If cops ever ask her about Amazi-girl I dunno how long until she cracks.

Tessea

I don't think/hope that Dorothy isn't _that_ tactless. But as for conflict I can't see Joyce remaining unable to confess what she did. Not trusting Joe or Dorothy to work out for themselves how they can interact and making the decision for them via omission will sting. Joyce has already been hit with the Joe half of the situation, how long before the other shoe drops?

Dmitri0240

Dorothy has known Joe a good deal longer than most of the rest of the case, and for the large majority of that time he was a complete scumbag. I think she's earned the right to be skeptical of the degree and permanence of Joe's apparent change.

5099 5618 v2.0

@Minzoku Bokumetsu Mrs. 5099 thinks it's nearly inevitable that Joe will at least offer to [ (take them to) | ( get them a gift certificate to) ] a local sex shop. Or, like, Bad Dragon. I suspect he needs a little time to himself, first, but that outcome would not surprise me.

5099 5618 v2.0

@Lazuli In comic time or reader time?

Jennifer Novelli

I'm predicting she starts dropping hints almost immediately, but will blurt something out when Dorothy decides she needs to speak to Joe for...reasons.

Jennifer Novelli

Has she even spoken to Walky since Joyce pulled that shit?

Lazuli

@5099 comic time @jennifer something like "okay so like. theres something i gotta say about joe"

Shane Wegner

That's a good point- Joe doesn't operate in a vacuum, half of it is Joyce's Choices™. I can imgaine Dorothy at least implying Joe was an error on Joyce's part- it's only a half step from how she's referring to him in panel 5. We'll see if Dorothy steps on that mine or no.

joe mcguire

He was a high school kid, which doesn’t magically make up for his behavior, but I feel should provide a type of context that allows for more forgiveness or expectation of growth one might afford an adult. Of course Dorothy is also recently a kid, despite her mature persona and probably doesn’t fully grasp that people are supposed to change from high school into college. Not everybody does, some people just calcify, but when people like Joe actually grow and change, they shouldn’t necessarily be rewarded just for becoming good people, but they certainly shouldn’t be punished. College is literally supposed to be a place where you grow and change, so it’s frustrating how many people in the story seem convinced that it’s impossible. But they’re kids too, so 🤷🏻‍♂️

thejeff

All true, but even going into college change is rarely overnight and easily accepting that someone who was for years a complete scumbag towards girls has changed is actually risky.

thejeff

Yeah, she's really bad at reading people because she hasn't completely changed her views on the guy she knew for years as horndog when she was dating his best friend and who she avoids because of it and who spent a lot of time while he was changing hiding it from everyone (except sometimes Joyce)

tifani

She has NOT spoken to Walky since. She left the fallout of what Joyce did for Billie to handle and has been actively keeping herself busy worrying about other people’s feelings who are not his (Becky most notably) since before the last update she got on Walky and Danny from Sal that they’re both pissed at her. So she might “prefer” to be on amicable terms with exes but she doesn’t seem to be making any kind of effort to help that be a reality. So her saying this to Joyce feels like she’s just saying what she thinks she should. It’s her idea of who she should be and wants to be perceived as vs what her actual actions show clashing yet again. And it reminds me that this girl is a politician to her bones but not a very good one.

Girlycore

I mean... did he or did he not show real joy at having facilitated said railing by wingmanning? I think she's probably still pretty on the money, the man likes hearing about sex even if he's grown as a person in the last couple months. (As thejeff says: after years of knowing him as someone who behaved exactly as she expects).

Girlycore

Someone thinking poorly of you because of your past shitty actions is absolutely not "being punished" even if you have changed and become a good person. Other people are under no obligation to change their opinions of you, especially if you spent a long time ingraining them. TL;DR: Dorothy isn't "punishing" Joe by not changing her feelings and impressions about him.

Girlycore

Until a couple months ago, that's how Joe preferred it.

tifani

Interesting thing about this scene is both girls trying to present to each other false ideas of themselves for their gf. Joyce is going over board on the “everything’s fine” her preferred method of coping. We KNOW what Joyce just went through literally moments ago but here we have Joyce with a lecherous smile so wide it has to hurt putting forth the accepted false image of Joe as a horn dog because that’s how Dorothy wants to think of him and how Joyce is going to have to oversimplify to hide her own hurt and suspicion from Dorothy. And also live in the altered reality Joe created for her with his retroactive dumping and keeping her promise to him best she can. Meanwhile we have Dorothy saying “I prefer to stay on good terms with my exes” pretending this whole thing is so civil and mature when we know for a fact she’s not on good terms with either ex and has done not a thing to help that along. But she still wants Joyce to look at her like she knows exactly the right thing to do and has done it.

tifani

I think to reconcile her behavior with how she views herself she has had to oversimplify who she now knows Joe to be.

tifani

God I hope so.

tifani

Is she bad at reading people or is she good at ignoring what she knows about people to mold them into who she needs them to be inside her head? I don’t think this is her not getting who Joe is. I think this is her actively pretending he’s still high school Joe to cope.

tifani

Becky does it too.

Jayne Lindgren

Man, people are really ragging on Dorothy for not having read the comic. How *dare* this woman not have access to information about things that happened when she wasn't there and nobody has told her about. She's so unreasonable for not having adopted a third-person omniscient viewpoint that would allow her to judge Joe by his internal thoughts and incredibly intimate moments with people that aren't her. What a bitch!

Dmitri0240

Yes, it's normal to change when going to college, but not everyone changes for the better. And quite a few scumbags had a brief period where a relationship compelled them to be on good behavior, before reverting to their old ways immediately after said relationship ended. We, the audience, have very good reasons to trust Joe's sincerity. But the other characters do not have the same amount of information, and are entirely justified if they need more proof, or are simply uninterested in giving him another chance.