Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This strip didn't start out as a megastrip!  It was just those five panels to begin with.  I thought, okay, there are like two people in this world who will appreciate Rich Mullins content, and I'm one of them, and so I figured this should be a one-and-done mini montage.  

1) We've previously established that the music comes from Becky's phone, so here's a reminder that the music is diegetic.  Joe's in the background, where he spots Joyce with friends!  He's wistful from a distance.  

2) Music!  Mostly I liked teasing that, no, the final music montage song is not "Black Parade," it's this dang ol' Contemporary Christian number, lol.

3) A peek at what's going on with Liz.  The lyrics are about seeing things in perspective from a distance!  and she is far from home

4) And closure on Amber's weeping.  And an attribution to Rich Mullins for the lyrics.  Yeah, this song is almost as old as I am.  I thought it was from the 90s, but I learned he wrote it when he was college-aged and kept on redoing it because it was important to him -- which is pretty apt for Dumbing of Age, really.  

but...

...there's an earlier bit of lyrics, "it's okay to be lonely so long as you're free" which WORKED TOO WELL and I wanted to use it, but it meant, uh, more panels.  Lots more panels.  And asking folks unfamiliar with this song (nearly everybody) to endure TWO days of comic strip about it seemed like pushing it.  BUT THEN A WEEK LATER I REALIZED OH HEY WHAT IF I PUBLISH THEM STACKED ON THE SAME DAY, and this solved the issue for me, and now we had two strips, now encompassing that lyric I wanted to include.

1) Have to start out with Joyce's group again, because we're establishing that's where the music's from.  Again, diegetic.  

2) the panel I was after

3) Figured this panel's lyrics worked best with Joyce's struggles, though the "you" meaning "God" seems to be attributed to Dorothy and Becky now.

4) Danny and Sal moved up to here, because the pauper/prince dynamic is about as disparate as this ukulele nerd and this biker chick.  

5) Nihilism!  Of course Ethan goes here.  Getting Ethan in here was another plus in favor of expanding the strip to two.

6) Walky is another new addition, with the poster (and the lyrics) reminding us of Mike's death.  But it's kind of a static image for that important a bit of lyrics, don't you think?

7) Joe!  If you notice, his panel mirrors Amber's above.  Amber, placed next to Joyce, is thinking about Mike.  Joe, next to Mike's... poster, is thinking about Joyce.  (and holding where he got punched by both of them)

The rest the same.

MONTHS later (buffer of 5 months, remember), I was like, WAIT, you absolute FOOL, if viewed from a certain perspective, Mike's accident LOOKS LIKE AN ASCENSION INTO HEAVEN, ELIJAH-STYLE.  And I was like, wait, is this too much?  And I asked my wife, who is safe to ask on these things because 1) she still has not heard this song and so she is like my readership and 2) she's smart, if this was too much.  And she was like, naw, this makes sense.  And so, sadly, Walky had to go, and a flashback panel put in its place.  Properly, Joe was placed next to an image of Mike, the anxiety he was trading with Amber above him.

and then shortly after that, maybe like a month ago, i was like okay maybe it'd help if we had an actual introduction to this, because it might be confusing if we just jump into this song, and the introductory panel of Joyce/Dorothy/Becky listening to music wasn't helpful enough

And so the first row was born!!!  Which gave me the opportunity to put Walky back in.  I *could* have had the first strip run by itself, followed by the double strip, but at that point I had like FOUR MONTHS of uploaded strip buffer, and scooting everything back a day would have been insane, so.  The triple megastrip was born.  And with Dorothy and Joyce properly attributing the author of the lyrics in dialogue, I could drop the attribution at the very end.PHEW.

anyway

jordan is waiting

Files

Comments

Alice

seconded! I've revisted this particular scene in the comic several handfuls of times, it's just so good, and even then I didn't clock the amber-joe mirroring (can't unsee it now!) So huzzah for the patreon unused strips section, and David your thoughtfulness in planning out book-spanning arcs was never in doubt, but now I *really* see how much thought and care ya put into individual strips and I take my hat off to you! ^_^

Drazi

I'm not on the same wavelength as you regarding the song, but it's fascinating to see your thought process. Thank you for sharing.

Amós Batista

When I saw the poll, I thought you were going to put 3 strips at same time, like, from now on. lol

Amós Batista

Another point: how could the reader never know about Rich Mullins? You told about him a lot in the past, Willis. Is for real people didn't read comics since the benging? Anyway: Jordan.

David M Willis

i mean there's a difference between remembering a guy's name that the strip has mentioned and being familiar enough with his work for there to be resonance

Jacob Glad

I absolutely love behind the scenes, "making of" posts like this! It's so interesting to get a peek behind the curtains and see the thought process, and the intentionality behind everything.

Lee Jackson

It's like the "Get Back" of webcomics.

Spencer

"Jordan is waiting" folks it's happening Edit: oh, it's a lyric dangit

Madison

the evolution of this is SO GOOD!

Spencer

Much as I love my favorite ship, I think the emphasis for Joe being about getting punched by Mike is a good move. I like that swapping guilt with Amber is something that's actually pretty hard for him, and it gives him a little punctuation to being a good brother to Amber instead of just focusing on Joyce. Like it's still a pensive moment for him, but it's a little triumphant in comparison to how he didn't go to the party: he's carrying a weight for Amber, but carrying it is hard

The Balloon Animal

Love these looks at the process. This last week of strips has been some of my favorite from the series so thank you for some extra time with them.

mirror

Now this is premium content! thanks for a look inside, Willis!

Populuxe

I love these unused strips posts. Its fascinating to see the amount of thought that goes into everything you post.

Steve McSheffrey

I was reading all this and thinking how Mullins was just a name from the past and that Amy Grant was the contemporary Christian artist I connected with back when. I just Wiki'd Mullins and lo and behold one of my favorite songs she sang was written by him.

Anna K

It could be both. Willis is smart like that.

William Tessmer

It seems like a lot of the process is that Willis is always making, or thinking about, or revising comics. See also: the comic buffer, currently sitting around 150ish strips. I also appreciate this making of - some of the unused comics are just a less funny version of the final product, but this is sort of a masterpiece. Turns out the buffer has USES beyond the obvious vacations.

▲ndrusi

Smart and/or weird.

Olivia Montero

I love the unused strips and the explanations, they give us so much insight into the decisions behind DoA!

Inahc

Tbh I thought Joe was still worrying about Liz.

bunnitos

Echoing what a lot of others have said but it's really great to see the thought processes behind the construction of the strips and the story arc there. It's really evident the thought that goes into each panel and it's cool to see how the elements come together.

Gale Tazzin

I hadn't even noticed the significance of Amber and Joe's positions represented the traded anxieties! That's such a neat touch! And I appreciated the Jordan tease too

Gale Tazzin

I think a lot of Joe's anxiety about Liz is wrapped up in his feelings for Joyce, and he's letting Amber worry about that for him momentarily

Onyx

This was one of the most amazing things you've done, and that is saying a LOT

Onyx

Also, since Jordan is waiting, that probably means Willis's working on a strip and we won't get to that storyline for four months.

Sarah Manx

I'm the kind of person who wants "hear" music in my head when it's in comics. So I definitely paused reading in the second row, looked up the song on YouTube, and proceeded reading the whole strip while the song was playing. Nicely done, and I also really enjoyed reading this breakdown of the thought process.

yaoi boi

Jordan is waiting for you... In the test chamber