Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

i didn't want dozens of people telling me "um actually the dowry comes from the wife's family" so i just rewrote the punchline into something better, life finds a way

final strip below:

Files

Comments

Machalt

Um, actually, the wife's family provides the dowry

Coal

Six Nuggets! Such is the wretched pace of inflation.

Angie Penrose

Actually, it can go either way -- it depends on the culture and the time period. Sometimes the wife's family pays a dowry, and sometimes the groom's family pays a brideprice. In at least one African culture (sorry, forget which one I specifically read about) the bride's father did ask for cows as a brideprice, so that's where I thought you were going with the top strip. :)

Jetstream

You could've just called it a "bride price." :P

Simon Magid

Cows seem to be a common theme here. They got used as a bride gift/price in Denmark about a thousand years ago, too, not sure how long it went on

Dean Argiris

Lyle should have held out for 50 McNuggets. Walky can't respect someone who'd settle for 6.

Angie Penrose

I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of cultures used whatever the primary agricultural animal was as dowry/brideprice at some point. Cows, horses, camels, oxen, sheep, pigs.... I can see poorer people using chickens, ducks, guineapigs (originally domesticated as a food animal), rabbits, etc.

Jyrki Lahtonen

Some tribe somewhere also had the custom that the bride's fathers can ask for ten cows from the groom. But only after the sixth kid is born. A fair trade, I suppose.

Hteph

Yeah, back in the days here in pre-Sweden it was supposedly dependent on many things, some went to the new family some went to the family that "lost" their child, and some went from the family with the higher status to the lower. For the Upper class this was a veeery complicated negotiation with a lot of moving parts and deliberations. When Sweden was coming around and things started to be written down the marriage contracts could be very elaborated.

Coal

Inflationary pressure is real.

Wednesday

Oh geez, cow dowry. Now all I can think about is that terrible Johnny Lingo movie.

Some Ed

I like the second unused comic. Forget complicated tribal practices that treat Lucy like property, cartoons are clearly where the action is. Though, to be fair, can Lyle buy Walky pajama jeans? I seem to recall that's also an important consideration.

Harold

The second strip isn't another alternate - it's the final version that was published.

Dean Reilly

C'mon Lyle, at least ask for some dipping sauce.

ValdVin

"Do you think I'm made of McNuggets? That I carry dozens of them around all the time?"

Coal

Lyle: Dare you court my kin without a strength nor a foresight to carry McNuggets?!

Maude Reads Things

I agree, that's a pretty great deal considering Walky gets Lucy

Bagge

There are two of them now, Lucy

Daibhid Ceannaideach

Lucy's expression in the final panel is funny either way, but I feel like it's funnier when Walky is going along with it than when he's just bewildered. Like Bagge said, there's two of them now. But that aside, the published version is pretty great.

Borg Lord

If anybody said anything about a dowry, you could point out that Lyle is obviously talking about a bride price, not a dowry. He all but says it exactly!

WillowD

I used to go to week long belly dance workshops in Manhattan. One evening near the end of the workshop we would go to a restaurant and put on a show for each other. On year there was a Catholic bishop there. He started to pretend to auction us off for sheep and goats. That was a fun evening.

Carl Cravens

So I was reading up on dowries and bride prices awhile back... various cultures have very different ideas about who owes who and why. In some cultures, the bride's family is sending along either something to get the family started, or support for the bride. (In some of those cultures, the bride _owns_ the property that comes with her and passes it to her daughters.) In other cultures, the groom's family pays the bride's family to compensate for the loss of her labor... literally buying the bride. So Walky paying is entirely appropriate to the right culture.