Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It's today's comic, but earlier!  It was a good moment, but I figured Sarah needed to be provoked more than once to achieve That Particular Level of Sarah, so I circled back around to it later.

What replaced it below:

And how it eventually properly emerged:

Files

Comments

Packy Anderson

It's also better without Joyce and Walky there to witness it. The accusation "You're just here to bone Walky" would have been extra awkward if Walky was standing right there.

darklion

Now-me 20 years removed from college would take this in stride, and say back to Sarah "yeah that's fair, you never heard of me before that" whereas then-me would've been unable to take her seriously and ask her what ate her today.

darklion

I think with J&W there it gives both a certain credence ("I'm just spittin' facts") AND a plausible deniability ("I'm just givin' you shit") to what Sarah says, in that she's willing to say it in front of them. Ironically, if Lucy was willing to respond with either humility or good humor, she'd be that much closer to being accepted. In the comic as written, it's more mean-spirited and tone-deaf.

Simon Magid

The whole situation struck me as extraordinarily uncomfortable (which is clearly a testament to Willis' writing skill) and I found myself unable to judge anyone in it. Especially Sarah. Given my tendency to hit back hard when provoked it would be the height of hypocrisy for me to denounce her.

Sajuuk-Khar

It was definitely the right call to hold this till now, because it’s undoubtedly a great bit of Sarah at her most acidic, but like you mentioned she’d need the extra provocation and it’s so much better after we clearly see that Lucy hurt her so she’s doing the Sarah thing and hitting the obliterate button.

Maude Reads Things

Yeah, Sarah needed a reason to go Peak Smart but Mean

Daibhid Ceannaideach

Huh, I see it as pretty much the same, except that Lucy has provoked her more, like Willis said, making the mean-spiritedness more understandable. Joyce's "k-kidding" in the rejected one, however, is making me rapidly recalibrate my sense of "Is Sarah even right that this is how her friendship works and everyone understands that?" in a way that the published "Sarah's concerned she went too far and Joyce responds by teasing right back" didn't.

Arania Webb

Frankly, I would have told Sarah to f off long ago. If I wanted to be insulted and hurt - in public! - I'd have stayed with my parents.

Dev

I'm definitely of the opinion that Sarah is taking this further than she necessarily should and is justifying to herself a bit more than is necessarily warranted.

Aris Katsaris

I think Sarah in the deleted comic is actually nicer: She actually has *Joyce* communicate to Lucy that *Joyce* is okay with what what Sarah said, rather than just asserting herself that "saying mean things because they're fun is what being friends is", which is frankly a toxic message. And if she's is to bash Lucy's and Walky's relationship one way or another, atleast doing it when they're both there is I think arguably a tad nicer than going behind Walky's back to do so, as she did in the canon comic.