This is a bad take… (Patreon)
Content
I see this kind of talk a lot these days. And it’s dangerously flawed.
What is “America’s backyard?” Here’s a little test. Take a moment to imagine what the geographic center of the United States is.
What did you guess? Something like South Dakota? It’s actually Hawaii. Because what this kind of analysis always forgets is all the US territories in Guam, CNMI, American Samoa. America’s backyard is the Pacific.
This isn’t even to mention American allies like the Philippines, which is under constant CCP threat. Do we just abandon the entire region to the CCP? Do you really think that wouldn’t have devastating consequences for the US? $5 trillion of shipping goes through the South China Sea. Do we let the CCP control that? Do we abandon our security promises to Taiwan (and the semiconductors that are the lifeblood of all our tech).
I think if the US did that, very quickly we’d find that the world isn’t divided between the US, Russia, and China with their own spheres of influence. It would be a CCP dominate world and we’d all be vassals. No disrespect to @WarClandestine, I’ve seen this take many places, and I just don’t think it operates on a full picture.