Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Evelyn drove home, ate three edibles, and fell into a dreamless sleep. She awoke the next afternoon groggy and checked her phone, disappointed to see that Elijah hadn't texted her.

That went on for several days, and once the weekend came, Evelyn couldn't take the silence any longer.

Evelyn: Good morning! Want to do something today?

She stared at the message for a moment, half hoping Elijah would reply right away. But of course, he didn’t, so she went about her morning routine. She got ready, made a latte, then sat on the couch and played Crusaders for several hours. An endless feed of notifications poured into her phone. Of people subscribing to her OnlyFans. Of people DMing her on socials. Of countless texts from countless club goers. All of which she ignored.

But when Elijah’s message came hours later, she opened it immediately.

Elijah: Hey. Yeah I could do that.

Her heart raced as she scanned the message several times. This wasn't a typical response from Elijah. He was never this cold to her. Feeling her nerves begin to rise, she quickly typed a reply.

Evelyn: Ok. If today doesn't work, we could always meet another time.

Elijah: Today works.

Evelyn: Cool. Everything alright?

Elijah: Yeah. just tired.

Evelyn: Ok, what do you wanna do?

Elijah: Whatever

Evelyn: Cool, meet me at Sherby Shakes? 12?

Elijah thumbs-upped the message. Evelyn sat back and let out a deep breath. She knew this pattern. She had seen it before. It was the same dance she had performed more times than she could count. It was why she tested him so early, why she brought him to Ivan’s party, and why she had held back for so long.

She wanted him to leave before she began to feel something.

It seemed like he’d missed the deadline.

Her body moved on its own. She went into her bathroom and got ready, making sure to find an outfit that actually fit into Elijah’s world. After several pairs of baggy jeans, graphic tees, and thrifted jackets, she found it. She went into her cabinet and pulled out a pair of gold wireframe glasses. She put them on, stared at herself in the mirror, and smiled.

She couldn’t wait to see what Elijah would say. She checked her phone once more, gathered her keys, and headed for the door.

–

Sherby’s Shakes was a cute burger place. Built out of a shining steel trailer, it carried the iconic look of the 1950s. Its floors were tiled in black and white, and all the servers wore the classic carhop uniforms. Elvis played from a jukebox in the corner as Evelyn and Elijah sat at a booth enjoying their meal.

"How’s the banana shake?" Evelyn asked. Elijah looked up at her.

"Hmm, oh yeah, it's good," he said flatly.

"Glad to hear…" She looked down at her strawberry shake and spun her metal straw.

Elijah hadn't seemed to notice her outfit.

"Is everything alright?" she asked.

Elijah looked like he’d just been caught stealing.

"Shit, am I not hiding it well?" he asked.

Evelyn shook her head.

"I'm sorry,” he said.

"What is it?" she asked.

"It's nothing, really. Just my own issues."

"No, seriously, tell me,” Evelyn’s voice grew firm.

Elijah sighed. "Ivan… he sent a picture of you two sleeping together the other night.”

Evelyn’s hands began to tremble. She hid them under the table.

“Wait, when we were fucking?”

“No, like, actually sleeping,” Elijah rubbed his temples. “You were uh… naked in his arms…”

He sounded really upset this time. It was unmistakable.

"Oh," Evelyn said, burying herself away.  

"Yeah."

"And that bothered you?"

Elijah nodded. The pain stung deeper than Evelyn imagined.

"That bothered you more than me fucking him, huh?" she said sharply, unable to stop herself.

Elijah shrank back.

"I know, it's stupid. I know you were going to spend the night. I just… it… was so intimate." He shook his head and closed his eyes tightly. "I don’t know, I guess it felt similar to when we first spent the night together."

Evelyn stared in disbelief. It wasn't anything like that at all. But how could she expect him to understand? How could she be mad at him for saying something so honest?

“And… there’s more,” he continued.

Evelyn’s jaw clenched. She didn’t dare say a word. Elijah cleared his throat.

“Ivan called me when you two were together and left the phone on. I’m pretty sure he was just trying to fuck with me. But… I ended up listening,” Elijah said.

That, for some reason, hurt even more. Evelyn stared at him. A cold, dead stare.

“I shouldn’t have,” he continued, “I should have just hung up, but… I don’t know.”

“Hey, at least you got to enjoy yourself though, right?” Evelyn said sharply.

Elijah looked down in shame.

“Is that what you like about me?” she asked. “Is that what this has been for you?”

Elijah shook his head, “No, not at all, I… you’re so much more to me than that.”

“But the other night it got too real, right?”  

She knew this was coming. She always knew. She was fucked up. He was fucked up. It was all fucked up. It never stood a chance.

“Evelyn, it’s not that at all. I made a bad choice, and now I’m dealing with my own mistakes, and I’m really sorry. But that has nothing to do with you, you know that, right?”

"Yeah," Evelyn said, pulling out her phone to check nothing. Stepping back into her shell and letting it harden.

A message from Ivan found her there.

Ivan: Come again tonight?

"Listen, I know it was stupid," Elijah continued.

"Uh huh…" Evelyn said, typing back.

Evelyn: Sure. But order me dinner.

"I'm just… can we put it behind us? Start fresh?"

"Sure," she said dryly. Looking at him through a fake smile. Her phone vibrated in her hand.

Ivan: Be here at 7.

Elijah smiled weakly, looking at her shake.

"Can I try it?" he asked.

She pushed it to him with a dead expression.

"Knock yourself out."

Elijah stared for a moment, clearly pained and concerned.

"I really am sorry,” he said sincerely.  

"Yeah, I know, it's all good. Really." Evelyn stood. Unable to stand the pain any longer. She wasn’t mad at Elijah for listening, not really. But she did grieve the cold, hard reality before her. That she couldn’t make the leap. That she was terrified of what would happen if she did.

That whatever she thought she had with Elijah was just a dream, and she couldn't run after it anymore.

"You doing anything tonight?" he asked.

"Why?"

"I… I'm actually going to a cosplay rave."

"Where's it at?"

"The old Shed Station. Are you familiar with it?"

"Very.” Evelyn didn’t look in his direction. She knew tears would come if she did.

Elijah cleared his throat. "You want to come?"

"You want me to?" Her question was vulnerable, but it sounded cold.

He smiled weakly. "It'd make my day."

Evelyn stared at Elijah’s olive branch, but couldn’t bring herself to take it.

"I got work, sorry," she said. Elijah’s eyes dimmed as he nodded slowly.

"No worries, be safe,” he said.

Evelyn looked away as her lips began to tremble.

"I will." She stepped outside without looking back.

Evelyn drove with a lead foot. She drove in silence. Making peace with the fact that they’d had a good run, but it always ended like this. She was just going to help speed it along. She stopped at a red light and stared at the city skyline, catching her reflection in the rearview mirror.

She wondered if this was who she could have been had things gone differently.

If the world were different.

Her phone buzzed again. She checked it, assuming it was Ivan. Instead, she saw Elijah had sent her a photo.

Fearing the worst, she opened it.

And saw it was her leaving Sherby’s Shakes. He had caught her on quarter angle, fixing her hair as she pushed open one of the entry doors.

Elijah: OMG, I can't believe I didn't notice you were wearing such a cute outfit! It looked amazing. Again, so sorry about all that. I just want to say you mean the world to me. And I don't plan on going anywhere. I know what I did was messed up, and I understand if it crossed a boundary. But if you want to work on it, I’ll be here.

He typed for a moment longer, paused, then began typing again.

Elijah: Be safe, ok?

Evelyn let out a broken laugh, which spilled into a cry. The light turned green, and the car behind her honked. She let out a short scream as she jerked forward, pulling into a parking lot.

Then she wept. Not really knowing why.

But in that one message, Evelyn found something she had buried a long time ago.

He had stayed. He really wanted to be here. He was taking the leap of faith.

Why shouldn’t she?

Before she had time to overthink, Evelyn pulled out her phone and quickly typed a message to Ivan.

Evelyn: Hey, I changed my mind.

He replied almost instantly.

Ivan: About tonight?

Evelyn: No, the whole thing. I'll send your deposit back.

She flipped open her pay app and returned the funds without a second thought. Ivan called immediately, and Evelyn put her phone on silent. Then, she started her car and drove.

–

Evelyn walked through the Shed Station's wooden double doors. Passing through crowds cosplaying as characters she didn’t recognize. Then, she watched as someone dressed as Sweeny danced past her, pulling a string of fake plushy rabbits behind her.

She followed those rabbits through the crowd. Through the music. Through the flashing lights and swell of energy.  

And finally found him. He had dressed as Swoony, the male counterpart to Sweeny. Elijah swore it was his favorite character, and for the longest time, Evelyn didn't believe him.

Until now.

He was with Juan and Ryan, both dressed as characters Evelyn didn't recognize. They danced to the music's rhythm, raising their plastic cups as the drop came.

Elijah bounced and turned, stopping when he saw her.

They stared at one another, smiling, then slowly drew close.

“Hey,” he said gently.

Evelyn’s smile trembled. “Hey.”

"You came," he said.

She wrapped her arms around his neck.

"I couldn't leave you."

"What about work?"

Evelyn smiled. "I canceled."

Elijah smiled back.

“Evelyn, I just want to say, I’m really—”

“It’s ok,” she said. “Let’s start fresh.”

He pulled her close as she stood on her toes and kissed him. He wrapped his arms around her tightly, and they began dancing to the beat of the music. The room swelled, and they moved with it. Juan and Ryan saw them from a distance, said hello for a moment, then left them with winks and nudges.

Time passed like water in Elijah's arms. He held her perfectly, and she didn't want to be anywhere else.

They danced until her hair was damp with sweat. Until their legs barely moved. Until the sun slowly began to crawl in a pale blue dawn.

Elijah leaned over and whispered the words she had been praying to hear.

"Do you want to get out of here?" he asked.

"Yeah," Evelyn answered, unable to contain her smile as he began pulling her off the dance floor.

They stumbled through the streets to his apartment and fumbled inside, doing their best not to wake Ryan. They snuck into his bedroom, and Elijah closed the door with a soft click.

He stepped towards her. Evelyn's fingers trailed down his neck as Elijah kissed her forehead. He slipped off her jacket as she undid her pants. Her glasses got stuck on her shirt as Elijah pulled it over her head.

They laughed as he took them off and tossed them onto his desk. Then he held her face between his hands and stared deep into her eyes.

“Evelyn,” he said softly.

“Yeah?”

"I love you," he said.

The words swept through them like a torrent, and Evelyn let it take her away.

"I love you too," she whispered.

They fell onto his bed, kissing each other as they touched. Evelyn's hand slid onto Elijah’s bulge as he lifted her shirt and sucked on her breast. Her back arched as his tongue swirled around her nipple. He slowly undid his pants and pulled them down, then he climbed on top of her. Evelyn felt his swollen cock press against her underwear.

He thrusted forward, long enough for her panties to grow soaking wet.

Long enough for her to get lost in his eyes.

She moved her panties to the side, moaning as she felt his pulsing cock slide against her wet heat. They stayed that way for a while, rubbing against one another as they kissed softly.

Long enough for Evelyn’s body to burn with desire.

“Please,” she said softly, guiding Elijah’s hands to her panties, holding him close as he peeled them off her.

“Take me.”

His lean muscles flexed as he grabbed her hips.

Evelyn's breath quivered as she felt the tip of his cock slide to her entrance.

She moaned softly as he slowly pushed forward.

She gripped Elijah's flexing triceps as his head entered her, then pulled out. He rubbed himself against her clit, kissing her gently before pushing himself back inside.

He filled her slowly. Inch by inch.

Evelyn's grip tightened as she closed her eyes and moaned.

Bliss found her as Elijah filled her fully.

She couldn’t have imagined such a perfect fit.

He grabbed a pillow beside her and moved it under her hips. Then, he began to thrust, hitting her in the perfect spot each time.

Evelyn was soaking as his pace quickened. She pushed her full, round tits together with her arms, her breath shortening as she started to grow close.

"Elijah," she whispered.

He answered with deep, powerful thrusts.  

Her thighs jiggled, her legs began to quiver, and finally, she erupted. It was a feeling unlike any she'd ever had before. Evelyn’s body shivered in ecstasy as she fought back tears.

Elijah pulled her close, pushing himself deep inside her and rocking slowly.

She dug her nails into his back, burying her face into his neck as the waves of her orgasm passed.

Then Elijah kissed her and continued. He turned her on her side and entered her again, pushing with more force. His cheap bedframe creaked as his headboard banged against his wall.

Evelyn never realized how strong he was. He gripped her tightly, pulling her onto his waist as he rolled onto his back. She began to bounce on his cock without hesitation.

Her pale, hourglass figure was silhouetted in the dim light seeping through Elijah’s curtains. She squeezed her pelvic walls as she rocked back and forth. Elijah grabbed her soft breasts and squeezed them tightly. Then, he sat up and wrapped his arms tightly around her waist. Her legs shook, and she fell forward, pushing her breasts into Elijah's face. He kissed them, then her neck, and finally her lips. He thrust upwards quickly, pounding into her pussy. Her juices covered him, soaking into the bedsheets.

"Fuck Elijah," Evelyn said as another orgasm hit her. He slowed as she shook. "You're really good at this."

Elijah smiled and kissed her.

"It's easy with you,” he stared a moment. “I love you so much.”

With that, Evelyn dropped her shell. She pushed Elijah down with one finger, then reversed herself and sat back down on his cock. Bouncing with perfect rhythm.

“Make me yours,” she said.

She felt Elijah grab her round ass, squeezing it tightly. She looked back at him, biting her lip when she saw his mesmerized gaze.

He began to thrust upward, and it wasn't long before he rose to his knees and pushed her down on all fours. Evelyn obediently pressed herself against the bedsheets. She raised her ass high in the air, moaning as he took her from behind.

Evelyn rubbed her clit as Elijah’s slams sent her forward.

Their bodies glistened with sweat as they tumbled between one another.

When they grew tired, their tempo slowed. And after kissing softly for a spell, they would start up all over again.

Eventually, Evelyn found herself on her back once more. She wrapped her legs around Elijah, smiling as his pace quickened and body clenched.

“I’m close,” he said.

"Cum in me," she said, wrapping her arms around his neck and tightening her legs. "Make me yours, Elijah."

He groaned, pushing forward and emptying his hot seed inside her.

They kissed as he throbbed.

They held each other as he filled her.

Then, as he slowly softened, they curled closely together, falling into a peaceful sleep.

Files

Comments

northdrop

I haven’t teared up whilst reading an erotica in a long, long time. This was beautiful:) thank you.

Flash_1996 x

This very much could be the final chapter and in many ways I hope it is. A lovely ending for the both of them

Mr Jakobs

The series still has some story left, but this would mark the end of the first book/arc! Very satisfying to get here.

Ryo

I wasn't expecting that twist at all, but I'm so happy that happened.

JRockk

Finally! Elijah and Evelyn found love in each other and had sex. I'm so happy she canceled on Ivan and ran back to Elijah. I'm glad that Elijah was truthful to Evelyn ang decided to stay with her.