Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Mel tried to ignore the sounds of sex coming from Rachel’s apartment, but it had simply been too much. She didn’t know who Rachel had brought over this time, and frankly, she didn’t really care anymore. She clearly was never going to learn her lesson. And after everything that had happened with Allison, Mel felt she had done more harm than good getting involved. So, in an effort to mind her own business, she grabbed her backpack and promptly headed out to the courtyard of her apartment building.

It was a sunny afternoon, and the courtyard was empty. It was a quiet little area, surrounded by trees and a well-maintained garden. A selection of black wooden tables and benches lined the walkways and well-trimmed patches of grass. Over the past few months, it had become one of Mel’s favorite retreats.

She made her way to a small circular table that rested beside a moss-covered statue fountain and pulled out a web-covered chair.

She dusted the webs off carefully, stopping to admire several spiders that scurried off into the grass. She picked one up that was struggling and gently placed it on a flower before sitting down with a deep sigh.

She opened her book but found the words impossible to read. She wouldn't need to try for very long, however. Within a few minutes, the back door of the apartment building swung open, and Noah stumbled out of it. Mel glanced up, cheeks flushing instantly at the sight of him.

His hair was messy, and the baggy shirt he wore hugged his broad shoulders perfectly. He walked with that worried manner of his, and Mel could only guess as to why. God, she felt so sorry for him.

She fought the urge to wave to him over, in fear that he might be upset about what had happened the other day. So instead, she silently watched from the corner of the courtyard as he began to wander aimlessly. He hobbled over a cobblestone walkway, stopping to admire some squirrels sitting on a low tree branch. After staring for a moment with a bright smile, Noah reached out his hand and tried to coax one down. Mel had to fight back a laugh at that.  

When the squirrels bolted up the tree, Noah sighed and continued on a path that led to her table. Mel’s face went bright red as she curled up, hoping he would not see her. And surprisingly, he didn't seem to. He walked right in front of her table without so much as a glance and stopped to admire the fountain next to her. As she stared longingly at him, Noah ran a hand through his hair with a soft sigh.

Mel melted at the sight and couldn't contain herself any longer.

"Hey," she said sheepishly. Noah jumped with a shout, stumbling away from Mel, who covered her mouth in embarrassment.

"Holy shit!" he said.

"I'm so sorry, I didn't mean to startle you,” Mel said as she fought back a laugh.

“Oh! Mel… shit… It’s alright. I didn’t see you there,” Noah said, catching his breath.

"I was being pretty quiet,” Mel said gently.

"Yeah."

They stared at each other for a moment. Mel knew what she wanted to say, but found herself too afraid to speak a single word.

"How… how've you been?" Noah asked.

"I've been better," Mel admitted. "How about you?"

"Same," Noah said flatly. Mel nodded.

"So, listen… about the other day…"

"It's fine," Noah said quickly.

"I had no idea who she was." Mel was half-lying, but meant it truthfully. She just wanted to understand him more. Had she known what Allison was, Mel never would have reached out to her. “I… I feel terrible… I didn’t realize that—”

"Really, I get it,” Noah interrupted, his voice gentle and sweet. “Allison has a way of… making you think she's someone she's not. She can be pretty deceiving."

Mel raised an eyebrow.

"Deceiving?" she said.

"What? You don't think so?"

"No offense, but as soon as I started talking to her, I knew she was trouble."

Noah stared at the fountain in silence.

“Maybe I’m just the idiot, then,” he said somberly.

“No, you’re not.” Mel meant every word, but she could tell they didn’t reach him. He stared at the trickling water a while longer before speaking.

"Why were you with her?" he asked, turning to look at Mel.

Her voice caught in her throat for a moment. It was his eyes. The gentle sound of his voice. The way his hair blew in the breeze. Her breath shook as she forced out the words.

"Do… you really want to know?" she said.

Noah paused. "I do."

Mel shifted uncomfortably.

"Because I knew she was your ex," Mel admitted.

“So… you wanted to talk to her?”

“Yes…”

Noah shook his head. "I don't understand."

Mel let out a pained laugh. Of course he wouldn’t.

"God, Noah!" Mel pushed her hair back as she looked away from him. "You kill me, you know that, right?"

"I'm sorry, I don't mean to."

Mel shook her head. "Forget it. It was stupid. I should never have talked to her in the first place, and I'm sorry that she's a problem again."

"Yeah… I am too." Noah dropped into the chair next to Mel. "It really sucks that she's at Godfrey now."

Mel glanced over at him, watching as Noah stared off at the swaying trees. Clouds covered the sunlight overhead, dipping the afternoon air into a comfortable cool breeze. She couldn’t help but imagine what this moment would’ve felt like if they were together.

Without Rachel.

Without Allison.

Because then, she could finally say the words that were right on the edge of her tongue and racing heart.

"Noah," she said.

"Hmmm?" He rolled his head over to her with a tired smile.

"I… I heard about what Allison did," she said, watching as Noah's face went pale.

"Let's not talk about that," he said quickly.

"Of course, I just wanted to say that I was sorry you went through that."

"Let's not talk about it," Noah said again.

"Sure," Mel's heart panged for him. It must have been so hard to have a woman as toxic as that back in his life. Honestly, Mel couldn’t imagine it. She wanted to tell him that he wasn’t alone, that she would do whatever she could to keep him safe.

But she had done enough already. So instead, she remained silent and watched the clouds pass with Noah.

"That one looks like a dog," he said, pointing to a cloud that definitely looked more like a giraffe.

"What kind of dogs are you walking?" Mel asked. Noah laughed.

"You don't think that looks like a dog?!"

"Noah! Are you serious? That looks like a giraffe."

"It does not!" Noah leaned over in his chair as he laughed, and for a brief moment, Mel saw his pain slip away.

Noah came to life. Mel did too.

Only, it pained her to know that he couldn’t see it. That he was so blind to what they were and what they had.

But it didn’t matter. Mel couldn’t leave him. If nothing else, they at least had this. These small moments of reprieve, this gentle space between them.

And if that was all they could have, Mel would treasure every minute of it.

She leaned towards him, infected by his perfect smile.

“It absolutely does look like a giraffe,” she said, her hand inching towards his.

“The neck isn’t long enough!”

“Well then, it's a mini giraffe!”

“Oh my god, Mel.” Noah covered his face and laughed loudly. Mel joined him as her finger grazed his.

At her touch, Noah’s laughter faded. He looked down at their hands, then back up to her.  

Then, just as quickly as he’d appeared, Noah left. His smile faded as he pulled his hand away. He cleared his throat and looked at the ground.

"Why did you want to talk with my ex?" he asked.

Mel swallowed.

"I… wanted to know… what she was like." Mel was so very careful with her words. Terrified that if she said too much, he would leave her forever.

And after she said it, Noah finally looked at her.

He really looked at her.

And Mel swore she could see it in his eyes. The realization of what they were. The feeling that they had been dancing around since they'd met. The same one Mel had been trying to run from all this time. He opened his mouth to speak, stumbling through mumbles before finally uttering a single word.

"Oh," he said.

"Yeah," Mel said with an awkward laugh.

Noah joined in.

Slowly at first.

Then the laughter rose, and finally, like a valve opening, the two lost it.

They laughed through waves of tension and pain.

They laughed through the things they couldn't and wouldn't say.

Through the feelings that tied her to him, no matter how much she tried to pull away.

And after a while, it settled slowly. First into chuckles, then into sighs of relief as they stared back up at the clouds.

"Now that one," Mel said, pointing to a cloud that clearly looked like a dog. "That one looks like a dog."

"If you say so," Noah said reluctantly. Mel smiled so brightly it hurt her cheeks, but when she glanced over at Noah, it faded quickly. He was staring up at the apartment building, right at Rachel's balcony.

"Is that what you were getting away from?" Mel asked.

Noah answered with a shrug and slight nod.

"Who's up there this time?"

"It feels weird saying," Noah said.

"Then don't," Mel said gently. Noah nodded.

“Thanks… for everything.”

“Don’t mention it.”

Mel wanted him to look at her again. It was a longing so great that it hurt her chest. Instead, he sighed as he kicked a small pebble across the walkway.

"I should probably get back up there,” he said.

"You don’t have to. You could… stare here… with me." Mel let the words hang in the air. When she saw Noah’s shoulders tense and his foot tap, she continued. "Only if you want."

Noah shifted in his seat, then glanced down at the book in Mel's hand.

"What are you reading?"

Mel felt herself blush bright red.

"I'm embarrassed to say."

"No, come on! You can tell me," Noah said.

Mel cautiously raised the book to show off its cover.

"Battle Bacherlotte," she said sheepishly.

"Never heard of it. What's it about?"

"Oh my god, don't make me explain!" Mel said. Noah had already pulled out his phone and was typing. “Are you looking it up?!”

"Ohhhhh," Noah said.

"What?! Oh god, did you find it?!"

"I didn't know you were into THOSE kinds of books."

Mel erupted into another pained and longing laugh as she watched Noah smile brightly. And had she would have looked at him for eternity, if only it weren’t for the tears forming in her eyes.

–

"Keep going, Ethan!" Rachel screamed, slamming down onto his dick with what little strength she had left. "Keep fucking going!"

She rode him reverse cowgirl, and the sight of her perfect ass bouncing short-circuited Ethan’s brain. Rachel’s pussy stretched and gripped his dick like a fucking vice. He watched her lips latch onto him as her juices dripped down his shaft.

She was the first girl he'd fucked who could take his whole length.

The first girl he found himself obsessing over.

And whether or not he wanted to admit it, she had him wrapped around her finger.

He felt her nails dig into his legs as his hands crawled up her ass cheeks. He squeezed her pinked flesh in an effort to slow her down so he wouldn't cum. That, in turn, made her move all the more.

"Oh FUCK!" Her legs shook as she pulled off Ethan's cock and sprayed into his lap. It took everything he had not to explode as her folds danced against his tip and her juices seeped between his legs.

"Fuck you hit my cervix so good!" Rachel said breathlessly as she turned around and straddled him again.

Ethan answered by wrapping his arms around her waist and burying himself in her breasts. They completely enveloped his face as she slowly sat back down on him. He felt her pussy tighten as he hit her cervix again.

It made Ethan groan.

"That's right," Rachel whispered in her ear. "Get me nice and deep."

She could barely bounce on her shaking legs, so Ethan took charge. He thrust upward, pounding into her with as much force as he could muster. The slaps rang out long and loud. Ethan sucked on Rachel's nipples as she gasped in ecstasy.

They were drunk on each other, and despite Ethan’s dignity, he had lost control.

He moved like an animal until sweat dripped down his forehead. Until he couldn't hold his orgasm back a moment longer. He gripped Rachel’s giant breasts tightly as he exploded inside her. He pushed upward, pressing his dick into her cervix as he lost his mind in the best orgasm he’d ever had.

"Holy fuck, Ethan…" Rachel said into his ear, slowly rocking back and forth. "That was amazing."

Ethan didn't know how to respond. He wanted to say it back, but truthfully, he was still struggling to gather his words. Rachel was the only woman who could turn him into a babbling idiot. And Mike definitely didn't make it any easier. Before Ethan even had a chance to collect himself, he was already walking towards them.

"You did it, my man! Wasn't so bad, right?" Mike said, lifting Rachel by her waist and pulling her off Ethan’s cock. She laughed loudly as Ethan felt her pussy latch onto him. He glanced down as he exited her, and his cum streamed down her leg.

"Mike!! I was talking to him!" Rachel protested.

"Well, now you're fucking me," Mike said before kissing her deeply.

Rachel kissed back.

And it felt like a million fucking daggers.

Ethan sat frozen in place as Mike carried Rachel off like a caveman and dropped her in the middle of the living room. As if they’d rehearsed it, she immediately propped herself up and opened her mouth wide. Mike deepthroated her instantly. Ethan watched the outline of Mike’s cock slide down her throat. She gagged as he pumped slowly and pushed his balls into her face.

"Isn't she the best?" Mike said, looking over at Ethan.

The indifferent dominance in those words made Ethan's blood boil. He stood abruptly and quickly gathered his things. Mike watched for a moment, then returned his attention to Rachel when she began moving her head with slow bobs.

"Fuck you're horny today, aren't you?" Mike said.

Rachel pulled off his cock with a gasp.

You bring it out of me!" she said playfully, wrapping both her hands around the base of his cock and pumping it slowly.

Then, as Ethan put on his shirt, Rachel glanced over at him.

"Aw, you’re already leaving?" she asked.

Ethan couldn't bear to look at her. He wanted to be cool with it. He wanted to not give a fuck about Rachel banging other dudes. But holy shit, it threw him into a fucking rage when he saw the way she treated Mike compared to him.

"Yeah, I gotta get rolling, I’ve got practice later today," he said coldly.

"That's too bad. I was hoping you two would double-team me again," Rachel said.

For some reason, that pissed Ethan off even more. He wasn't a fucktoy to be used. He was a D-1 basketball player, and it was about fucking time Rachel realized how lucky she was to fuck him.

"Yeah, no. This was a one-off thing, alright? You want me again? It’s gonna be ONLY you and me. I'm not making a habit of this shit."

"Well, ok. I won't force you," Rachel said.

The fuck you won't. That's what Ethan wanted to say. But he couldn't bring himself to. Especially when he glanced over and saw Rachel gently kiss Mike's cock, who, in response, pushed his fingers into her hair and pressed forward eagerly.

Ethan looked away just as the two gazed longingly at each other while she swallowed him whole.  

They didn't even bother with a fucking goodbye. Ethan had to leave to the sound of Rachel's slurping and gagging.

His senses only started coming back once Ethan was a few feet down the common hallway. He slapped his face a few times, trying to clear his head and stay focused.

“Fucking come on, man! What the fuck are you doing?!” Ethan muttered to himself.

He had told himself time and time again not to get distracted with pussy. That it was bullshit and was going to ruin his chances at making it to the NBA.

But fucking Rachel, man.

He didn't even know if he liked her. He honestly wasn’t sure what that even meant. What drove him insane was the fact that, despite all the tricks he had pulled, Rachel was the one woman who didn't seem to be chasing him.

The one woman he couldn’t get off his mind.

The one woman that he was constantly texting.

The one fucking woman that had somehow convinced him to sit in a fucking room and watch as other dudes fucked her.

It was fucking disgusting, and Ethan was disgusted with himself. But today was the last time that was ever going to happen. He wasn't a fucking cuck, and he never would be. Rachel was going to do things on his terms, or not at all.

He was going to fucking win.

Ethan stormed down the apartment stairwell and pushed open the back door, entering the courtyard. He stopped when he heard the sound of laughter. Ethan glanced over, surprised to find Noah and Mel sitting near a statue fountain.

They both went silent as they caught his gaze.

Ethan hesitantly waved, and they waved back. Then, cautiously, he walked over to them.

"Hey," he said.

“Hey,” Mel said back, a bright blush on her face. Ethan had known Mel a long time; not once did he ever remember seeing her so happy.

"Hey," Noah added with a nervous smile.

Ethan stopped in front of them, glancing between the two before clearing his throat. It quickly occurred to him that Mel might be curious why he was coming out of Rachel’s apartment building. And, wanting to save face, he began to ramble.

"So, I was just uhh… dropping some things off to a friend and–"

"She knows, Ethan," Noah said.

Ethan could feel his face growing hot. He prayed Noah hadn't told her everything. The last thing he needed was rumors going around campus that he was a cuck.

"Right," he glanced at Mel bashfully as a smirk formed on her face.

"She got to you too, huh?" she said.

Ethan wanted to crawl into a hole and die.

"It's just casual shit, it doesn't mean anything," Ethan said defensively. Mel rolled her eyes.

"Trust me, I know. We used to hook up, remember?"

"Wait, we did?"

"Oh my fucking god, are you fucking serious?!" Mel shot back.

Ethan smiled, feeling the confidence that Rachel had drained away coming back.

"I fucking got you!" he said.

The three of them laughed.

"You're such an asshole, Ethan," Mel said.

"Yeah, yeah, what are you two doing out here?" he asked.

"Just hanging out," Noah said. "I needed to take a breather."

Ethan scoffed as he looked back at the apartment building. "Yeah, I feel that… wait, when did you leave?"

"I don't know, ten or twenty minutes ago?"

"Shit… didn't even notice," Ethan said, rubbing the back of his head.

"Yeah…" Noah sat back in his chair uncomfortably.

"Shit, I didn't mean it like that. There was a lot going on up there."

"Always seems to be," Mel chimed in.

"What? You want to get in on it?" Ethan asked. Mel threw her head back and laughed.

"Not on your fucking life!"

The waves of shame were palpable.

"Fair enough," Ethan said. His gaze fell on Noah once again. "For real though, you good?"

"I'll be alright."

Ethan sighed. "Look, Noah… I know I can be…"

"An asshole?" Mel interjected. Ethan and Noah both smiled at that.

"Jesus girl! Let me finish, alright? I'm trying to say something nice here."

"So say it!" Mel said.

"Fuck, look, all I'm saying is I know I have my issues, alright? And I know I was kind of a dick to you. But I just want you to know, you have my fucking respect." Ethan was never great with this kind of stuff. He hoped Noah knew what he meant.

"Uh… thanks?"

"For real, man, Rachel is really lucky to have you," he said. It surprised him to see Mel bristle at the comment. Noah, on the other hand, simply nodded slowly. Barely seeming to register what Ethan had just said.

"Thanks, dude.”

"For sure. So when are you and Rachel heading out for vacation?"

"Oh, I'm not going with her. It's a family trip,” Noah said dispondently.

Ethan looked with surprise.

"Oh," he said.

"Yeah."

"Well, if you're ever looking for something to do… feel free to hit me up… or… whatever." Ethan began to fumble with his words once more. He had no idea why he was offering this olive branch to Noah. Perhaps part of him thought it would help put Rachel behind him. Perhaps he just felt bad for the guy. But whatever the reason, he was barely able to get the words out.

Noah smiled politely and nodded.

"Yeah, I’ll let you know," he said.

"Alright then," Ethan cleared his throat. "Guess I'm going to head out. I'll see you around."

"For sure, have a good break!" Noah said.

Ethan looked at Mel, half expecting her to say something. When she looked at him with a deadpan expression, however, he took the hint and turned the opposite way.

It wasn't how Ethan had imagined his day going. But, then again, he never knew what to expect with Rachel. Maybe that's why she was so damn addictive in the first place.

Files

Comments

Yngtokyo

I think Mel while she did mess up, she cares deeply for Noah, Im rooting for her and Noah, she would give him I feel like more of an emotional connection. It’s slowly seeming like things could go in that direction especially while this break happens and Rachel being on a family trip? Mel could have the advantage and honestly that would be a good thing I think. While Rachel’s spiral into this lust has driven her sex crazy, especially towards Mike, it’s ending her relationship in the worst way possible. And in the beginning of the series, Ethan was honestly one of the ones to watch out for but yet here he is being nice to Noah and even understanding so I’m excited for the next chapter !

ToSch

Yeah, as I wrote in the last chapter, it's kind of funny that it's actually Ethan who seems to understand Noah and feels the same way, because they're on the same wavelength regarding Rachel. It's actually Rachel and Mike who don't seem to care at all. They straight up ignored the fact that Noah had a panic attack and left. I'm 100% #TeamMel at this point.

Ryo

I think it was a few chapters ago that I mentioned Mel seemed to exist solely to make Noah's life even more complicated in this story despite her good intentions. However, after this chapter, it seems clearer than ever that she is exactly the person Noah needs to help him overcome his traumas and insecurities. Mel appeared to accumulate quite a few red flags in previous chapters, but the fact that in this chapter she is able to admit that she may never be able to be with Noah in the way she truly wants, and that she would still be happy just having him as a friend, makes me feel that she is genuinely the right person for him. Mel seems to be the only character in this story who truly cares about Noah and has no intention of taking advantage of him. I can already see Noah and Mel growing closer during Rachel's absence, and something similar to what happened when they attended the wedding together will probably occur, with Rachel feeling betrayed and blaming Noah for it. But honestly, I don't care. I just hope Noah realizes soon that it's not worth wasting time on someone who doesn't even notice when you've left her apartment. In a way, it makes me sad, because this is not how I expected or wanted the story to develop. I really liked and enjoyed Rachel and Noah's relationship at the beginning, but now I see their relationship as so dead and empty that it no longer inspires any excitement or hope in me.

northdrop

Damn, the sex scene was hot as hell; I will never tire of Rachel being an absolutely top-tier slut:) The soft moments between Noah and Mel were beautiful and the triangle between them and Rachel is as fantastic as it is heartbreaking. Would Mel and Noah be a good couple? Of course! No one denies they have a sweet, easy relationship. Are Rachel and Noah a good couple? Of course! They love each other deeply and are exploring both of their kinks together. What Rachel and Noah are doing is going to be messy until they find their stride in it. Would Mel be an easier time? Maybe…but it won’t stop Noah from wanting to see HER explore that, too. He will always want it. He needs someone like Rachel who will do this with him. The ONLY reason this is a problem is because Noah has it in his head that he’s not good enough for her (thanks to Rachel’s dad) and letting that insecurity fester. Had that lunch meeting never happened, Noah would be having a blast watching Rachel getting railed and wouldn’t have left the room! Hell, he would have joined in! They make an excellent couple and have a wonderful partnership…they just need to be honest with each other about what they are experiencing; she is finding herself loving the sex with Mike (which is perfectly natural) and keeping it to herself whilst Noah is battling a crippling, secret anxiety (which is perfectly reasonable under the circumstances) and keeping it to himself. This is easily fixable if they are willing to be vulnerable and confront their own feelings and share them….but then, there wouldn’t be any drama :) I have to remind myself that these folks are freshmen in college (I think), not seasoned adults :p

NaughtiWolf

I have thoughts. "Then the laughter rose, and finally, like a valve opening, the two lost it. They laughed through waves of tension and pain. They laughed through the things they couldn't and wouldn't say. Through the feelings that tied her to him, no matter how much she tried to pull away." It's not that they couldn't say these things, it's that they refuse to. Mike, Noah, Rachel, Mel, Ethan... none of them seem able to actually speak their minds because of massive insecurities. All of these people need therapy, not the deeply-flawed version of polyamory they've been attempting. "For some reason, that pissed Ethan off even more. He wasn't a fucktoy to be used. He was a D-1 basketball player, and it was about fucking time Rachel realized how lucky she was to fuck him." "It was fucking disgusting, and Ethan was disgusted with himself. But today was the last time that was ever going to happen. He wasn't a fucking cuck, and he never would be. Rachel was going to do things on his terms, or not at all. He was going to fucking win." Last chapter I mentioned that Ethan's insecurities are channeled through a toxic "alpha" mentality. This is what I'm talking about. Furthermore, he admits that he's not even sure that he "likes" Rachel, despite during their first time together in her apartment saying he wanted to marry her and impregnate her. Looking back, those statements feel like performative machismo focused solely on "ownership" of Rachel's body. Ethan's used to women chasing him. Rachel doesn't and we know why: Rachel's own internal voice showed us that she likes Ethan in small doses precisely because of the attitude he displays in the above passages. I'm also not sure how I feel about Ethan and Noah spending time together. That could either cause both men to become more circumspect or it could amplify their worst personality traits. Mel and Noah connecting felt like a good way for Noah to decompress from the events of the last chapter. Mel does have some red flags but this chapter helped solidify that she cares for Noah a great deal, even if he's not quite ready to reciprocate those feelings. The break from Rachel should give Noah and Mel a chance to deepen that connection. At this point, I want Noah to spend time away from Rachel. He needs space away from her. Rachel and Mike are too lost in their unspoken feelings for each other to notice anything else. I won't hate on Rachel. She's making decisions that are easy and pleasurable, which is understandable but not commendable. At some point, Rachel needs a reality check. My hope is that Jakeline, her older sister, is the one to give Rachel that proverbial wake-up call during the Colorado trip. If Rachel doesn't stop and actually face what she's been doing, she is going to cause greater harm than she intends to. As the saying goes, intentions matter less than impact. The impact of her decisions regarding Mike, Ethan, and especially Noah are going to have drastic repercussions if she's not careful.

ToSch

It would actually be hilariously hypocritical if Rachel were offended by something happening between Noah and Mel while she's gone. At this point, she is more or less cheating on Noah by being way out of bounds emotionally and physically, even if you consider that this is a cuckold relationship. Noah isn't even an afterthought anymore. It seems like she didn't even notice that her supposed love of her life and partner, with whom she supposedly wants to share these moments, left the apartment half an hour ago. She was too busy chasing her BBC high and worshipping Mike.

Ryo

Yeah, it would be very hypocritical on her part, and yet I still think it's quite possible that it could happen. Rachel could hold on to the fact that she told him that if he ever wanted to experiment with another girl, he should let her know first. That said, I don't see Noah cheating on Rachel. I can't even imagine him asking for permission to be with someone else. Noah is far too loyal and loves her too much. So if something happens it will be an out of context or something like that. It's also worth keeping in mind that, so far, Noah doesn't seem to have shown any romantic interest in Mel. Despite all the sweet moments they share, there's nothing that Noah doesn't already have with Rachel. I think the way Mel could earn a place in Noah's heart is by being able to have that conversation that Noah is avoiding about his trauma and insecurities. On the other hand, ironically, a closer relationship between Mel and Noah could actually help Noah's relationship with Rachel. Rachel takes it for granted that Noah will always be there for her and that everything is fine between them. Seeing that Noah seems to enjoy spending time with Mel could make her realize that she could lose him. We've already seen how jealous she can get, so perhaps if she fears losing Noah, she'll pay more attention to him and be able to recognize what's going wrong in their relationship. But that's probably too optimistic a thought for this story, so I think it's far more likely that everything will just keep getting more complicated and remain a complete mess, haha.

NaughtiWolf

I disagree. I don't think Rachel and Noah are a good couple at this point. Based on the last few chapters, Rachel is struggling to see herself with Noah like she did before, replacing Noah with Mike more and more. I also don't Noah knows what he actually wants. His trauma from prom night and the humiliation Allison put him through before that night has altered his self-esteem to accept humiliation as love. That is a deeply unhealthy place to be, since it means he accepts less than he deserves. And this isn't hate on Rachel. She's rebelling against the manipulative family dynamic she grew up in but she's hurting someone she claims to love in the process.

ToSch

I certainly agree with your take, NaughtiWolf. This relationship left the "healthy" stage on Rachel's side around chapter 17 and, as you rightly pointed out, it arguably never even reached that positive point on Noah's side in the first place, thanks to the fact that his entire fetish is trauma-induced.

NaughtiWolf

The seeds of what we're seeing now were definitely planted (no pun intended) in chapters like "Homework" and "About Mike". It all rolls back to the refrain quite a few of us have been saying repeatedly in the comments: none of the people in this story communicate properly because they are absolutely terrified of the consequences, good or bad.

JRockk

Yeah I'm completely on board with Noah and Mel becoming an official couple. I think Rachel needs to just break up with Noah and be single and have sex with all the guys she wants. It's obvious she doesn't realize the suffering Noah is going through and she's too busy enjoying her freedom. Mel made some mistakes but she has genuine love for Noah and that's what he needs at this point.

northdrop

This is also a response to ToSch: it’s entirely possible that my personal bias is coming into play here. If you remove the other people and just focus on Rachel and Noah, they are sweet, loving, and supportive of each other. That’s a wonderful, healthy relationship. Where it becomes complicated is that Noah wanted Rachel to experiment with other men. He wanted to see it happen and she accepted it out of love for him. In the early chapters, it was hard for her, if you recall. Over time, she opened up to it with Mike and has come to enjoy it, just as Noah does. Yes, Noah noticed that Mike makes Rachel feel things during sex that he hasn’t seen with Rachel himself, but that didn’t actually bother him UNTIL the conversation with the dad. It was only at that point that he started viewing it in a different light. For Rachel’s part, she loves Noah dearly and is doing something that he wanted her to do. Yes, she’s finding the sexual chemistry with Mike to be easy and fun, but she doesn’t say she wants to replace Noah, only that because it’s so effortless that she could see herself with Mike. There are women in my life that I could see myself with if I wasn’t desperately in love with my fiance. Where we all agree is that the characters aren’t sharing what’s going on. If Noah told Rachel what her father said, you can bet your ass Rachel would pull all the stops to do whatever it takes to make Noah feel like he is everything to her.

ToSch

Heya Northdrop! We certainly agree on two things: First, that poor communication is the number one problem in this story, and second, that Noah and Rachel had a very good relationship when it all started. I think our biggest disagreement stems from our interpretation of Rachel's actions, thoughts and behaviour since then. While Noah's passivity and doormat behaviour are certainly a big part of the problem, I believe that Rachel is actively making things worse. As NaughtiWolf pointed out, we've seen quite a few times by now, especially in her own POVs, that she's long past the point where it's just good sexual chemistry with Mike. She's increasingly substituting Noah with Mike, even in moments when they're not "playing" and she's alone with Noah. She even recognises and agonises about this in a couple of chapters, but like a classic addict, even when she recognises the problem, she either cannot or does not want to stop. This chapter is just the latest in a growing list of infractions against Noah and Rachel's relationship. From what we've seen in Noah's and Ethan's POVs, it doesn't seem like she's even noticed that the guy who should supposedly be her number one priority has long since vacated the premises. She was too busy indulging her own cravings and, as even Ethan notices, she's far too into pleasing Mike for this to just be a physical, utilitarian bull arrangement.

NaughtiWolf

This a reply to Northdrop's second comment: I avoid throwing hate in Rachel's direction because she is doing the same thing that Noah, Mike, Mel, and Ethan are doing: avoiding reality. All of them are terrified of the negative consequences of their actions catching up with them. On some level, Rachel loves Noah. The question now is: does she love Noah the person or does she love the idea of Noah? The same goes for Noah: does he love Rachel as a person or as a conduit for his trauma-induced fetish? There are moments were they have a healthy relationship but those aren't happening as frequently. This isn't the same couple from "I Know" or even "Locker Room". Something is fundamentally skewed for them and neither are willing to have the difficult conversations that need to happen to make this work.

NaughtiWolf

Mel has some red flags, but I agree with you. While I don't think she would ever replace Rachel in Noah's heart, I think they should at least try and see what can develop between them.