Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Rachel dropped her bags as soon as she saw her sister’s open arms.

"Seeester!!" Jackeline said, opening her arms wide as Rachel landed in her embrace.

"Oh my god, I missed you so much!" Rachel said, pulling her close. She laughed loudly as Jackeline gave her a squeeze and dropped her.

"Geez, girl, you weigh like a thousand pounds!"

"Hey!" Rachel said, slapping her hand away playfully. Jackeline laughed loudly.

"No! I meant it in a good way! It means you got some muscle on you! Have you been working out?"

Rachel blushed. "I mean… technically?"

Jackeline gave a knowing smirk.

"Ah… that's right. And how has the… training been going?” she asked, raising an eyebrow as she comically leaned in.

“Ooooh boy… do I have stories to tell…”  

As they spoke, their mother rolled down the driver's window of her Cadillac and peeked her head out, phone in hand. Her white, wide-brimmed hat caught on the frame, pushing her designer glasses down her nose.

"Darlings, I need you both to hop in the car. I want to arrive before twelve. Yes, Charles, I know that, I'm simply saying…" Her voice muffled as she slipped her head back into the car and rolled up the window. Jackeline rolled her eyes at Rachel and grabbed their bags.

“Guess we can talk about your training later?”

“Yes, let’s save it,” Rachel confirmed.

"You do look good, though,” Jackeline said.

"Thanks! You do too, are you still doing your marathon training?"

“Nah! Switched over to pure aesthetics at this point. I just want a fatty dump truck and abs.”

“Oh my god,” Rachel said with a laugh.

Jackeline, as always, carried that indomitable confidence that Rachel adored. She had always been the more beautiful between them. She was tall, had platinum blonde hair, vibrant green eyes, an athletic, curvy body, and a great sense of humor. Everywhere she went, whatever she did, Jackeline always seemed to succeed. And, as always, Rachel fell into the role of little sister. Happily following behind her with a beaming smile. Rachel was already taking notes on her sister’s latest outfit. Baggy jeans, pointed shoes, a crop top, and a leather jacket.

"I love what you’re wearing," Rachel said, helping Jackeline throw their bags into the back of the SUV. As they opened the trunk, they heard their mother continue to speak on the phone.

"Charles, I don't care what the stock limitations are. We simply must have that blend on our menu. No, I don't care how much it will cost, have it…" Her voice disappeared again as Jackeline closed the trunk.

"Thanks, it's all the rage in New York right now. I'm too busy to explore my own stuff anymore, so I've become a bit of a follower."

"I don't believe that for a second," Rachel said, walking over to the rear door.

“Believe me, it’s nothing special. Ever since I started with this lawyer shit, I barely have time to think!”

“Then you should quit,” Rachel said. Jackeline let out one loud laugh.  

“And give up my pay and sabaticals? Yeah right. We sitting in the back together?” she asked.

"Uh, always??" Rachel said, popping open the door and giving her sister a playful bow. “Your highness.”

“Oh my god, stop it!” Jackeline gave her sister a kiss on the head as she stepped in. “Come on!”

Rachel slid in behind her. As they buckled their seatbelts, their mother looked at them through the rearview mirror.

“Charles, I have to go. Just please handle it, alright? Ta ta, darling.” She pulled the phone away from her ear and delicately hit the end call button with an index finger.

“Did you get the beans, Mom?” Jackeline asked playfully.

Their mother laughed softly and shook her head.

“Ah, yes. The beans. My plights of life.”

They all laughed together at that. This is how it was between them when Rachel’s father wasn’t around. Safe, happy, warm. It was almost like they were a normal family.

“Are my little Chikiti’s excited for their vacation?!” Their mom said, pulling slowly out of the driveway.

“Yes!” Jackeline and Rachel said in unison. Their mother pressed a hand to her heart exaggeratedly as she started down the road.

“Oh, how precious! It’s just like when you two were little! You two have made my spring, I hope you two know that.”

“We love you, mother,” Jackeline said, reaching over her mom's shoulder. Her mother reached back and took her hand, squeezing it gently before jumping in her seat excitedly. “Oh, how splendid! The three of us roughing it in the mountains together, I simply cannot wait.”

Rachel and Jackeline looked at each other before simultaneously rolling their eyes and settling in for the long drive.

Things were finally starting to look up. Rachel was about to spend spring break with her sister, and she couldn't have left Godfrey on a better note. She’d even gotten the chance to spend a day with Mike and Ethan before she’d left, and what a day it’d been.

Rachel was pleased that Ethan seemed to finally be coming around, in his own way. Though she would never admit it out loud, Rachel had hoped to get the chance to be double-teamed by Ethan and Mike for the longest time, and her fantasy didn’t disappoint. She had only wished Ethan had stayed a bit longer so they could’ve tried some other positions and locations.

She couldn’t wait to tell Jackeline all the details.

And Mike… well… Mike was Mike. Once Ethan had left, they continued to fuck like animals. She could still feel the way that thick cock of his filled her, and she already missed being carried around in his arms.

Whether or not Rachel wanted to believe it, Mike was addicting. It was the way he smelled after getting sweaty. The way his cum tasted on her tongue as he'd rut himself into her mouth. The way he’d eat the soul out of her pussy. His willingness to explore everything and anything with her.

Mike always managed to bring out her wild side, and their little send-off was no different. She’d gotten so wrapped up in their moment that Rachel hadn't even realized Noah was gone until Mike carried her over to the bedroom and threw her down on the mattress. She looked over his shoulder as he climbed on top of her, confused that Noah wasn’t following.

"Wait, where's Noah?" she asked.

"Oh! Right, he said he had to step out for some air,” Mike said nonchalantly, latching his lips around one of her nipples and sucking it hard.

Rachel squirmed underneath him as his fingers found her clit. "Did… did he say to wait?"

Mike popped off her nipple and slowly pushed his fingers inside her.

"Nah, he just said he had to step out. I told him we'd hold the place down so… I think he was chill with us fucking."

Rachel bit her lip, moaning as Mike pumped his fingers. Her nails dug into his thick back muscles.

"Are… are you sure?" she asked.

Mike stared into her eyes longingly, finger fucking her into a frenzy.

"I think so," he said. Leaning in and pressing his lips against hers. She breathed deeply as Mike’s fingers slipped out and were replaced by the sensation of his cock pressing firmly against her pussy. Rachel pulled away from his lips with a gasp.

"Should I… text him?" she said between breaths, watching as Mike’s shaft slid between her with long, powerful thrusts.

"He really did seem ok with it, but you can if you want," Mike said sincerely. He pressed his chest against hers. Rachel’s lips parted in ecstasy as he gently kissed her forehead.

She stared into his eyes for a moment, pulling him close as he continued to hump her. They grew lost in rhythm for minutes, until finally, she bit his neck and guided his tip to her entrance.

"Fuck me,” she said.

He smiled before kissing her deeply and shoving himself inside her. He ravaged her after that, and Rachel let him. For as long as he wanted. For as many times as he wanted. She wanted Mike to have all of her. He lifted her into his lap and gripped her waist tightly, bouncing her up and down by the waist. He stood from the bed and leaned forward, thrusting rapidly until she came midair. He threw her back down into a sea of pillows and kissed her tenderly as he slowly came inside her.

Then, they kissed until he was hard, and started again.

He lay his weight down on top of her, reaching behind her and grabbing her ass with both hands. He pulled her into his thrusts, sucking on her neck as he rammed so hard Rachel thought she might split. And with every thrust, she felt a little part of her slip. But into what, she wasn’t sure.

Mike pulled out and straddled her waist, pushing her full, round breasts together and shoving his cock between them. Rachel rubbed herself as she watched Mike thrust between her tits.

Encouraging him with soft kisses on his tip as the tempo grew.

Opening her mouth wide as he grabbed his cock and began to stroke it.

Smiling as he sprayed her face with his glorious cum.

And, like the animal he was, Mike didn’t stop. He kissed her again, thrusting between her legs until he was hard once more.

Rachel fell into a stupor after that.

They fucked for so long that Rachel grew concerned when Noah didn't appear. After Mike had cum for the third time and took a water break in the kitchen, Noah finally entered the apartment.

Rachel leaped out of bed as soon as she heard the front door unlock, reaching it just as he stepped inside.

"Hey!" she said, walking over to him with open arms.

"Hey!" Noah said back, more gently than Rachel noticed. She went in for a kiss, but he withdrew.

"Oh…" she said.

"Sorry, it's… You have…" Noah pointed at her face, smiling shyly.

Rachel blushed instantly, realizing her face was still glistening with Mike’s cum.

"Oh my god! I'm so sorry, Mike. He… well… he finished, and we kept going. And I forgot to…" Rachel couldn't help but laugh as she scampered over to the dining room table and grabbed some napkins. She wiped her face quickly as she turned back to Noah.

“Where did you head off to?" she said.

"I just needed some air," Noah said, slipping off his shoes and looking around the apartment. "Who's all still here?"

"Just me, bud!" Mike shouted from the kitchen, stepping into view as he chugged from a gallon of orange juice.

"Oh my god, Mike! We talked about this!"

"Oh shit… sorry… glass…" he promptly turned around and disappeared back into the kitchen.

Rachel shook her head, chuckling as she finished wiping Mike's cum from her face and stepped towards Noah.

"Did I get it all?" she asked.

Noah stared at her a moment before rubbing his thumb across her chin. She felt a slick wetness pass with it.

"Now you did," he said. She smiled brightly and leaned in to kiss him.

And god that kiss, nothing had ever tasted so sweet. It felt like coming home. Which is why Rachel was confused when she felt a tinge of guilt at the sound of Mike's voice.

"So… I’m not gonna lie, I'm pretty fucking spent,” Mike said as he reappeared from the kitchen. Both Noah and Rachel turned to him. “I don’t think I have it in me to do another threesome.”

Noah laughed as he rubbed his brow with his hand. “Mike, only you could be apologetic about something like that.”

“I just wanna be upfront! I know I’m the fucking machine and all that… I’m just so gassed,” Mike said.

“It’s fine, Mike. We can call it a day,” she said sweetly, letting her eyes trail down his perfectly chiseled naked body.

“Well, that’s the thing. I’d still love to hang with you,” Mike said, before quickly correcting himself. “Both of you, I mean. You guys wanna watch a movie or something?"

Rachel leaned into Noah and looked up at him.

"What do you think, babe?" she said.

Noah shrugged.

"Honestly, I'm kind of beat. Maybe we could…" his tone lowered, “have some alone time?”

Rachel didn’t miss a beat.

"I think that Noah and I need to call it a day, Mike,” she spoke almost apologetically.

The look on Mike’s face made her heart skip. It was the same look he’d given her in the shower. The one she couldn’t seem to forget.

Rachel pried her eyes from him and fixed them on Noah.

"Right, yeah… totally," Mike said. Clearing his throat and grabbing his things from the living room. Those few minutes were some of the longest of Rachel's life, and she hated that they were. She hated how sad she felt knowing they wouldn't get more time together before she left. She hated knowing that she wouldn’t be able to tell him how much she’d miss him, out of respect for Noah.

Because she loved Noah. She did. It was just that… with Mike…

"So how long are you gone for?" Mike asked, pulling up his pants and tightening his belt.

"Oh, about a week and a half," Rachel said.

"Got it, I'll be sure to have some ideas ready for you when you’re back," he said, looking at her with a weak smile. She let out a short breath and shook her head.

"We'll see," she said.

"Yeah. We will."

The tension was painfully palpable. Rachel was afraid to look at Noah out of fear of what he might think. Mike stepped towards them both with his usual stupid grin.

"Well, guess that's it," he said.

"Guess so," Rachel replied.

Their gaze hung painfully between them.

"Is it cool if I hug you guys?" he asked. Though deep down, Rachel knew what he truly meant by the question.

"Of course," she said. And, finally mustering up enough courage, she turned and looked at Noah. "You good with it?"

"Hmmm? Oh, yeah. Sure," he said.

"Sweeet. Come here, little man!" Mike shouted, wrapping Noah in a bear hug. Rachel was relieved to see Noah hug him back with a smile. "We'll have to get up to some trouble while she's away."

"For sure," Noah said.

Rachel found the comment cute at first. That is, until she realized Mike was probably serious. They weren’t exclusive, after all. This was just casual. And, without her around to satiate him, Mike would probably find… alternatives to hold him over.

And the thought of that made Rachel’s stomach turn.

"Not too much trouble!" she said before thinking. Mike laughed loudly.

"Don't worry, I'll keep him safe," he said, letting Noah go and giving him a playful punch.

But it wasn't Noah Rachel was worried about.

Mike turned and wrapped her in his big, strong arms. He squeezed gently, and it felt amazing.

"Have a safe trip," he said softly. She hugged him back and smelled him one last time.

"You stay out of trouble," she said.

Mike laughed.

"I'll do my best," he said, letting her go. Then, with a sigh, he made his way to the door.

Rachel's skin prickled at the sight of him leaving. But she quickly stamped down the feelings once she saw Noah walk into the living room without a word. She followed behind him, clearing her throat as he sat down.

"Did you have a good time?" she asked sweetly. He glanced at her before nodding slowly.

"Yeah… yeah I did…"

Rachel frowned.

"That doesn't sound like someone who had a good time."

Noah laughed loudly.

"God… I can't keep anything from you, can I?"

Rachel dropped beside him, that old familiar feeling of love filling up her chest. It was… confusing.

"No, you can't," she teased. She trailed a finger along his arm. "Is it… something I did?"

Noah shook his head.

"No! Not at all. It's… fuck it's embarrassing to say."

"You can tell me," Rachel said gently.

Noah glanced over at her.

"It's Allison."

Rachel nodded slowly, uncertain what he meant.

"Oh, ok. Was she on your mind?"

Noah nodded. "Yeah, I know it’s been a few days, but ever since seeing her, it’s been hard to concentrate.”

"That makes sense. Is… that why you had to step out?" she asked.

Noah nodded. "Yeah, I just wasn't in the right headspace."

Rachel swallowed nervously.

"I hope… it was ok that I kept going."

"Oh yeah, it was fine," Noah said. "Really, don't worry about that."

"Are you sure?"

"Yeah, I think we're at the stage where I don't need to be there every time."

Hearing that warmed Rachel's heart. Noah was right, they had come so far since Herferd.

"Well, I'm glad you did what was best for you." She cuddled up against him. "Are you going to be ok without me?"

"Yeah, I think so," Noah said, glancing over at her with a smile.

“You sure? I could always ask my mom to let you come with us.”

“No way! It’s a family trip. You and Jacky deserve some time together,” Noah said happily.

Rachel buried her nose into his shoulder before kissing it tenderly.

“I love you so much,” she said.

Noah kissed her head.

“I love you too.”

As always, the night fell into perfect cadence. They started their show, ordered their favorite foods, and later that night, Noah made slow, sweet love to her in her bed.

It felt just as good as Mike did.

The memories slowly faded away as the Colorado mountains came into view. As she listened to her sister's city drama. As her mother went over their itinerary and insisted that they both get new outfits while visiting Denver. All of it culminated in a perfect state of bliss and optimism.

That, despite all the little hiccups along the way, Rachel's life was going well.

"And here we are, darlings," her mother said. Pulling into a brick driveway that led to their large mountain retreat home. Her mother’s dream home. The home her father had spared no expense on. It offered a marvelous view of the mountains, ample square footage, and a list of amenities that made Rachel somewhat embarrassed. It had seven bedrooms, a double-bay garage, a metal roof, a tennis court, an outdoor pool, a large gazebo with a hot tub, a sauna hut, partial brick siding, and beautiful, large living room and kitchen spaces to top it all off.

"Oh, isn't it just lovely! And look, Laura is already here," her mother said, pulling up next to a black Ford Bronco as she spoke. Both Jackeline and Rachel looked at each other as their mother killed the engine.

"Laura, Mom?" Jackeline asked.

"As in, Jack's mom, Laura?" Rachel added.

"Hmmm? Oh, did I not mention Laura was coming?" she said sheepishly.

"Nooo!" Jackeline and Rachel said in unison.

"I thought this was going to be a family retreat?!" Rachel said as she hopped out of her side of the car and followed her mother to the back.

"Oh, darling, it will be! But you know how it is. Laura and I were visiting the other day, and it was so wonderful hearing from her, so naturally… I had to invite her… and Jack."

"Her AND Jack?!" Rachel shouted.

"Darling, keep your voice down. There's no need to make a scene," her mother said tersely.

"You really are outdoing yourself this time, mom," Jackeline said dully as she began unloading the bags and handing them to her mother and Rachel.

"What?! Oh come now, it is a large house, we will have our alone time!"

"Mhmmm, is this why you were insisting on a group dinner as part of our 'itinerary' tonight?" Jackeline asked.

"Well, naturally, we should all get acquainted, come now, you too, there's no need to make a big deal about it." Rachel's mom adjusted her glasses and set herself toward the house.

Jackeline handed Rachel her luggage.

“I’m really sorry she’s still doing this to you,” she said.

Rachel sighed. “Too late to turn back now…”

Jackeline smirked as they followed their mother to the home’s large front door. And as she approached, Laura opened it and stepped out, waving excitedly.

"Laura, darling!" their mother said.

"Oh, Mary! How stunning you are!" Laura said, giving her a half-hug before turning her attention to Rachel and Jackeline. "And look at these two angels of yours!"

She strode towards them, her shimmering dark hair blowing in the breeze as if she were on a movie set.

"Hey, Mrs. Buller," Jackeline and Rachel said in unison, each giving her a hug as she gently kissed them on their cheeks.

"I'm so happy we're finally getting the chance to have a little family time again," Laura said, looking at Rachel. "After I saw you and Jack dancing the other night, it made me WISH we were able to spend more time together."

"Wait, you saw us?" Rachel asked.

"Yes! I was visiting the campus with Jack, but I didn't get a chance to say hello! I'm so excited to catch up and see how you are both doing!"

"It's going to be fantastic," Jackeline said with an overly playful tone. The one that only Rachel knew was sarcastic. They glanced at each other knowingly.

And as Laura spoke eagerly to Jackeline, Rachel watched Jack appear at the front door. Their eyes locked instantly, and her heart raced like it always had when staring at him.

He smiled and waved sheepishly, and Rachel, already knowing trouble awaited, waved back. He was as handsome as usual. Just like his mother, Jack had a Hollywood, old-money presence. He wore a loose-fitting white button-down, off-green linen pants, and freshly cleaned white sneakers. His medium-length hair, perfectly swept behind his ears, blew faintly in the wind.

He watched as Rachel approached, quickly speaking once she was in earshot.

“Fancy seeing you here,” he said.

Rachel stopped a few steps below him and stared, waiting to see what he would say. Getting the hint, Jack laughed uncomfortably and gave an apologetic nod.

“I promise, this wasn’t my idea,” he said.  

“Did you know I was going to be here?” Rachel asked.

Jack blushed. “It… crossed my mind.”

Rachel rolled her eyes and stepped past him, entering the home. The interior boasted a minimalist rustic decor. With native artifacts, pastel impressionist paintings, walls of windows, and pale wood accents. Plants lent a lively feel throughout the home and complemented the first floor's open-space concept. A design complemented by the vaulted ceilings throughout the living, dining, and lounge areas. Rachel pulled her luggage into the dining area overlooking the mountains and sat at the long, wooden dinner table her mother had insisted be custom-made. Jack followed her wearily, standing at the kitchen island a healthy distance away.

“You have a good trip?” he asked.

“We did,” Rachel said. Jack nodded, clearing his throat as he looked out over the mountains.

“I really did miss this view,” he said.

Rachel followed his gaze to the scenery.

“So your parents have a retreat here, too?” she said. Jack shook his head.

“No, they usually rent out a cabin. It’s been a while since we’ve come back out this way.”

“Hmm, well, I guess we have my mom to thank for that,” Rachel said, looking back to the front door. She could see her mother and Laura chatting eagerly with Jackeline, the three erupting in laughter at one of Jackeline’s stories.

“Yeah… and now here we are,” Jack said.

“Here. We. Are,” Rachel confirmed playfully.  

Jack laughed softly. “You had a long trip. I’ll let you get settled. See you at dinner.”

Rachel peeked over at him as he stepped towards the foyer staircase.

“What room are you staying in?” she asked. Jack looked back at her with a playful smile.

“The southern bedroom.”

“Then I’ll take the north,” she said teasingly. Jack laughed and shook his head.

“I wouldn’t have it any other way.”

Files

Comments

northdrop

Whilst there are a number of folks here who have begun to demonize Rachel a bit, I maintain the goodness of her character. She loves Noah, comments to herself how sex with him feels just as good as it does with Mike, gets just as excited for their long snuggle sessions and relaxing, intimate evenings together, worries for Noah when he’s not there to be a part of their kink…she is totally present and deeply involved in their relationship. With Mike, he is something totally different from Noah; he’s the sex machine, the wild energy, the SPICE that hits differently from Noah. Not superior, but wonderful in its own way. You can love pizza but still crave a burger. Rachel is experiencing this now; that as much as she loves Noah and their relationship, she is finding that mixing it up with Mike is deeply satisfying, too…and it’s a confusing feeling for her. She feels like she aught to only have affections for one person…and yet is finding joy and satisfaction in multiple. This is perfectly normal and expected. The question will be how it affects her connection with Noah. Some great foreshadowing with Noah saying, “we are at the stage where I don’t always have to be there.” It’s likely that Rachel and Jack will get into it and will take video/facetime or maybe just after the fact for Noah. On that note, (and I don’t think this would happen) but a hangout with Mike and Noah watching a video of Rachel where they goon to it would be just thing that Mike would suggest nonchalantly lol The characterization of Jacky and Mom are fantastic and feel like their own people; the voice really comes through:) wonderful chapter, as always!!

ToSch

Yeah, that's mostly what the comment section predicted in the last chapters. Jack makes a "surprise" appearance, Rachel's mom continues scheming, Rachel gaslights herself, Mike makes things worse, and Noah once again refuses to speak honestly about his problems. He may even have undermined himself again with his offhand comment that he doesn't need to be there all the time for her fun. This could create opportunities for Rachel, who has recently been eager to take advantage of them, even if that wasn't his intention. I just hope Jackeline is able and willing to "run interference" on her sister and set her straight. From what little we've seen of her so far, she seemed very aware of how Noah and Rachel's "arrangement" could easily turn into what it is right now. Hopefully, she will see the red flags in Rachel's stories and talk some sense into her. In the meantime, I'm clinging to my last shred of wishful thinking that, now that Rachel is temporarily gone, Noah and Mike can talk like friends and figure things out. Maybe Noah will even find solace and normalcy with Mel.

NaughtiWolf

After the last few chapters, it was good to see that Rachel still admits that she loves Noah and enjoys being with him just as much as she likes being with Mike. Her feelings for Mike are complicated. I also like that Noah at least mentioned why he left. It's at least some communication but not nearly enough. I am wary of Rachel's acceptance of Noah not being around when Rachel plays with others. That feels like Noah is continuing to distance himself, pulling back in a way that feels like self-sabotage. I also think it's worth noting that Noah refused to kiss Rachel while she was covered in Mike's cum when he had zero issue kissing Rachel in the locker room when she was covered in Ethan's cum. That tells me that he isn't okay with what happened but he's burying it under politeness and distance. I knew that Rachel's mom was going to invite Jack along. There was no way her mother would not take this opportunity to insinuate her own agenda onto Rachel's life. Her parents really are two toxic pieces of shit. Her father's the upfront, domineering bully that demands obedience. Her mother's the subtler, manipulative poison seeping in through an open cut. I have no doubt that Jack and Rachel are going to hook up at some point during this vacation or at the very least test the waters, so to speak. The potential for Noah and Mike, Noah and Ethan, or potentially all three of them to spend time together without Rachel around is intriguing. I'm curious to see how those men interact when the one commonality between them, Rachel, is not present.

NaughtiWolf

I think it's going further than that. I think Rachel is developing genuine feelings for Mike. Not in the same way as Noah but there's more than just a physical relationship, even if she doesn't fully want to admit it to herself.

Banana23

The story seems like it is really being set up for Rachel and Noah's eventual break-up. Even when Rachel noticed that Noah was gone, she still chose to dismiss it in favor of having more sex with Mike. And whenever the author writes that Rachel still loves Noah, it just feels empty and hollow (this is just my subjective view on it). And I guess that's the point of it, since any affection (if any remains at all) that Rachel has for Noah is meaningless now and pales in comparison to the sexual and emotional chemistry and affection she has with Mike. I don't remember any portrayal of Rachel's love for Noah in the past dozens of chapters aside from their usual peace and comfort in each other's presence, which is shown more like safety in routine rather than genuine affection (at least that's how I see it.) It also doesn't help that Noah is still not fully being honest with his issues. So it feels like he has mentally and emotionally checked out of the relationship and are just letting things play along since he's too afraid to confront his problems. Truthfully I actually like where the story is heading because I am invested in Noah's development or ruin (whichever path the author has for him is equally fascinating to me). Unfortunately, I've lost interest in Rachel as a character and I mostly view her as a tool to progress Noah's story. Even in this chapter that is focused on Rachel, all I can think of is how it would affect Noah in the end, especially Jack's unsurprising presence at the retreat.

ToSch

Yeah, I also found the part where she notices Noah's absence and chooses to prioritise her own pleasure and Mike over checking on him rather telling. The embers of her love for Noah are still there. They just don't seem important enough to her to act on or prioritise. Only once the temptation is removed will she fall back into her old habits and her supposed happiness / safety blanket with Noah. I assume that once the sisters have settled down for Rachel's story time, during which she probably gushes about Mike and expresses her lust for Ethan while making only a few mentions of Noah, Jackeline will be the one to point all of this out, echoing what the comment section has said again and again in the last couple of chapters.

NaughtiWolf

To Banana: What you described is not meaningless unless you are looking at this from a monogamous perspective. Speaking as someone who has spent a decade-plus in polyamory, different relationships can and often do offer vastly different experiences. With Noah, Rachel has support, intimate and romantic sexual experiences, and emotional safety. With Mike, she has passion, fire, and aggressive sex with tender moments. With Ethan, she gets to indulge in the experience of being fully stretched and filled in a way very few can provide. One of the problems with Rachel and Noah is that neither of them are taking the time to fully communicate their concerns to one another. Noah is pulling away because of his own self-worth issues. I'm not saying that Rachel continuing to have sex with Mike after noticing Noah wasn't present was not a red flag. It certainly is and it's one that is distressing for the safety of their relationship. But as her flashback showed, once Mike was gone, she focused solely on being with Noah, which shows that he is still deeply important to her. To ToSch: I don't see it as embers but rather as a completely separate paradigm. As I mentioned above: with Mike, Rachel can unleash and be primal and passionate. With Noah, that passion isn't subdued but redirected into something slower and more intimate. Both are valid and wonderful in their own ways. You and I have agreed before that their lack of solid communication is a problem and I'll continue to agree with you on that point. Where I will disagree is that I think your perspective comes from a monogamy-based point of view, which sees things from a hierarchical stance. I may be wrong and please correct me if I am but that's the general feeling I get.

NaughtiWolf

I'm sure Jackeline is going to give Rachel a good talk when they finally get some alone time together. She'll be supportive but I get the feeling that Jackeline won't sugarcoat things too much with Rachel.

northdrop

That’s a solid point; seeing Noah hanging with the other male characters alone would be telling. I’m also hoping that Jacky is honest with Rachel in her response to whatever Rachel shares. No sugarcoating or pulling punches; for better or worse, Rachel needs the straight-talk she isn’t getting from Noah. This exchange would be a great opportunity for some wrongs to be righted…or everything made far, far worse.

NaughtiWolf

I don't think it will go worse. Jackeline was the one who told Rachel a few chapters ago that she needed to set boundaries, which Rachel hasn't done. If anything, I think Jackeline will be the one to make Rachel take a long, difficult look at the imbalances of the relationships and work on creating a framework that will benefit all of them.

Banana23

I agree with you that I am looking at it from a monogamous perspective since that's what I assume Noah and Rachel's relationship has been portrayed as so far. I don't think Noah and Rachel agreed to be poly, and my understanding was that Mike and Ethan are only supposed to be sex friends or bulls. Whats more, something about the following part bothers me a little bit: "Don't worry, I'll keep him safe," he said, letting Noah go and giving him a playful punch. But it wasn't Noah Rachel was worried about. Given how Rachel was portrayed to be extremely jealous of Mel during and after the wedding incident, and with Rachel seeing Mel present during the recent Allison incident, why would Rachel not be worried about Noah and be worried about Mike instead? I know i am being biased, but it feels again like Mike is occupying so much of Rachel's attention and affection that the only way for her to focus back on Noah is for her to "stamp down her feelings". Even if this was a polyamorous relationship (which it isn't yet from my point of view), do you have to stamp out your feelings for a other person just to focus on your other partner?

NaughtiWolf

To Banana: You do when you're unable to reconcile what you're feeling. "Rachel dropped beside him, that old familiar feeling of love filling up her chest. It was… confusing." Rachel loves Noah, that much is clear. But there's also this passage: "She hated how sad she felt knowing they wouldn't get more time together before she left. She hated knowing that she wouldn’t be able to tell him how much she’d miss him, out of respect for Noah. Because she loved Noah. She did. It was just that… with Mike…" Rachel has developed genuine romantic feelings for Mike. Much like your perspective, Rachel and Noah are grappling with shifting from a monogamous point of view to something closer to a poly or non-monogamous point of view. I mentioned poly since it's my perspective but ethical non-monogamy might be a better label. The problem so far is that this hasn't been ethical in the strictest sense. It's deeply flawed and causing confusion and pain. ENM is messy, though not in the same ways monogamy is messy. Compersion is not a requirement for ethical non-monogamy. I think that Rachel and Noah both dove into this without setting up proper guard rails for their relationship and they are having to work backwards, which is not a good way to do this kind of relationship.

Yngtokyo

Team Mel over here atp 😂🙌🏾

NaughtiWolf

I would add that when BoF started, it definitely was following the idea of a monogamous, consensual cuckolding/hotwife dynamic. MrJakobs would even agree that this story shifted away from that at some point as he began to plot things out more thoroughly. What we're seeing now is a Why Choose narrative, where the woman MC navigates romantic relationships with multiple lovers. Why Choose leans heavily into ENM or polyamorous dynamics, in most cases. The shift in narrative focus is part of why the last ten to fifteen chapters have felt off compared to the earlier chapters of the story.

Banana23

Thanks for clarifying things for me. I know next to nothing about these kinds of relationships so I'm mostly speaking from my limited perspective. And I agree, the biggest source of issues in Noah and Rachel experimenting is the lack of proper boundaries and guard rails. I think this is also why I'm not expecting Jackeline to have much effect even if she talks to Rachel. She already advised Rachel before to set boundaries, and Rachel and Noah still failed to properly do so.

ToSch

NaughtiWolf, you're probably right that my perception of Rachel's actions is coloured by my view as a monogamous person on this situation. Coming from that side of things, my own comfort zone in these stories will always be more in what is, as far as I'm aware, described as Stag and Vixen dynamics. Those are to my taste the closest to "normal" relationships, just with the occasional bull thrown in. This also seems to be the kind of arrangement that Rachel and Noah envisioned when they started out. But it's a relationship system that includes and relies heavily on rules, boundaries, honesty, and open communication. As we have agreed multiple times before, Noah and Rachel do not fulfill or observe any of these important aspects. Where I assign more blame to Rachel is in my interpretation of these relationships as hierarchical, as you yourself noticed. To me, the core relationship between Rachel and Noah should always come first. But that's not the case for Rachel anymore, in my opinion. I wouldn't have a problem with her using different men to satisfy different cravings if she always defaulted to Noah. But that ceased to be the case some chapters ago. Currently, she only defaults to Noah if there are no other options available, or at least that's my interpretation, and that's why I'm so harsh with her.

NaughtiWolf

To Banana: Trust me on this: even with a decade-plus involvement in ENM or poly, I still find myself thinking in terms of mononormative behaviors and hierarchies from time to time. When you've been steeped in that culture your entire life, it's difficult to shift to something else, even when it feels more natural like it does for me. True enough. Rachel was still at school, neck deep in her tangled relationship when Jacky told her to set boundaries, so she really didn't have the time to dwell on it. Now, she is somewhat removed, although Jack's presence is going to cause a wrinkle. Here's the interesting question: Do Rachel and Jackeline have their heart-to-heart conversation before or after she hooks up with Jack?

NaughtiWolf

To ToSch: I definitely see where you're coming from and I agree that the story started off in that direction but it shifted to something completely different. Blame can be assigned to both Noah and Rachel because, as we've both pointed out, neither of them have set the necessary boundaries for this kind of relationship. This is why I mentioned a couple of chapters ago that kink is not a substitute for therapy. Both of them have issues with self-worth and seeking validation or emotional safety from others. ENM is honestly not healthy for people with the kinds of trauma Noah and Rachel both carry without emotional safeguards in place, which neither of them have truly taken the time to build.

Banana23

I really hope it happens before Rachel hooks up with Jack. Rachel is trying to distance herself from Jack for obvious reasons, which should give her more chances to have a long talk with her sister. Given how e excited Rachel was during the car ride to share her experiences with her sister, i could even see their talk happening right after dinner.

ToSch

Jackeline will probably notice something developing between Rachel and Jack after Noah unwittingly gave Rachel a hall pass, and she will take her sister aside before anything happens to talk with her. However, since this story tends to be somewhat depressing, I could also see Rachel messing around with Jack and getting a stern lecture from her sister afterwards.

AppleJuice

I think Rachel could thrive in a polyamorous relationship - she has all the makings of it. Although it’s important to note that Rachel is only open to having multiple male partners, but she seems completely unwilling to share them with other women, as evidenced by her jealousy of Mike in the last chapter. But I don’t think that suits Noah. Even the cuckold dynamic increasingly seems like just a temporary way for him to cope with past trauma, rather than a constant, natural desire. And even in this scenario, it seems as though he’s increasingly going along with it under pressure from circumstances, simply not wanting to flat-out reject Rachel. And polyamory is definitely beyond his limits. Ethan is also absolutely unsuited for this kind of arrangement. The only ones who could serve as the foundation for such a relationship are Mike and Rachel, if they were to find a partner or partners within their own couple who were equally open to it.

NaughtiWolf

To AppleJuice: Rachel's jealousy is part of the mindset that also causes her confusion about her feelings for Noah and Mike. She cannot admit that she is falling for Mike. Noah's trauma has to be dealt with before he can effectively be part of this dynamic. His self-esteem issues have to be dealt with as well. Until that happens, he and Rachel will not be able to have the kind of relationship they deserve.

Craven

I see this in a more socioeconomic context. Rachel, Mike, Ethan and Jack all grew up in a more privileged environment. The road rises to their feet in a way they are not even aware of. Even though Mike is not very intelligent it's taken for granted he will be bought success. Rachel doesn't really have to worry about her reputation because consequences don't really exist. Noah and to a lesser extent Mel have a very different perspective. Noah understands he has little real power in this group. He must work for everything and can lose it all easily. The defence mechanism for that is be ultra flexible and easy going for the other. Noah and Mel's conversations are real, honest and down to earth because that's who they really are. With the others, including Rachel, Noah is calculating his responses to cause the least ripples. Rachel's Father, although a slime ball, is aware of the real difference between these groups and is at least honest with Noah about what's going on (much as it's distasteful). Noah recognises this too and so does Mel. Rachel has no clue at all despite her love for Noah. She's incapable of that level of self reflection because she's never had to deal with reality and recognise her culpability. Noah understands the pathology of these dynamics and knows that all he can do is ride them out as best he can. Hopefully he will get Mel in the end and Rachel will learn that in order to gain something important we need to lose something first.