Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

A few days had passed since Rachel had started to settle in at their Colorado home. And while she had been nervous about the dynamic Jack would bring to her family getaway. He had been, surprisingly… fun.

So much fun, in fact, that it helped remind Rachel why she liked him so much in the first place. Jack was funny, kind, and laid back. He made it easy for her to relax, too. They’d grown apart so much over the last few months that Rachel forgot just how great a guy he really was.

When they first sat down for dinner together, Rachel had anticipated some pressure from him. Perhaps him pushing boundaries or making a move. Instead, he was polite, calm, and confident. He’d even made a point to sit on the opposite side of the large table, far away from Rachel and her sister.

Surprisingly, he was more well-behaved than her own mother, who wasted no time trying to play matchmaker between them both.

“Oh, Jack, you are so far away from us. Why don’t you sit next to Rachel so we can hear you better?”

“Oh, that’s alright, I prefer my space.” Jack took a drink of white wine as he winked at Rachel.

“Well, alright, if that’s what you prefer,” Rachel’s mother said with disappointment. She gracefully picked up a bowl of colorful roasted potatoes and passed it to Jackeline. “It is lovely being here all together though, isn’t it?”

"I couldn't agree more," Laura chimed in, looking at Rachel and Jackeline brightly. "I was actually just talking to your mother about how much you have all grown! We were swapping pictures of when you were all babies. Ugh, breaks my heart…”

Laura spoke as if she were a character from a Hallmark movie. But that was Laura. Incredibly positive, overly kind, truly optimistic. Had it been anyone else, Rachel might have thought they were faking it. But Jack's mom was anything but fake. She clearly had a good heart, and seemed to see the better parts of life every day.

Rachel found that quality refreshing.

Jackeline, however, did not seem to share Rachel’s sentiment. She nudged Rachel’s shoulder, giving her a sarcastic smile as she passed Laura the bowl, who took it delicately and promptly passed it to her son.

“Oh, Jack, you are actually pretty far away. At least sit closer to me. I can barely reach you,” Laura exaggeratedly reached out for her son.

Jack smiled sheepishly and scooted closer and took the bowl from her.

“Better, Mom?”

“Yes, much better, thank you,” Laura said happily.

Rachel’s mother smiled at Jack for a moment before glancing at Rachel with a calculated smile.

"So tell me, Jack, how has Godfrey been going for you?" she asked.

Jack plucked a few potatoes from the bowl and dropped them onto his plate.

"It's fine," he said. "It's been busy, of course, but that’s to be expected."

"Oh well, I can only imagine. A young ambitious man like yourself must keep a very busy schedule.”

Jack looked over at Rachel with a knowing, apologetic smile.

“Well, I wouldn’t say all that…”

“Oh Mary, you’re making him blush,” Laura said cheerfully, taking the bowl from her son and placing it next to the roasted chicken thighs and glazed carrots.

Rachel’s mother, Mary, laughed warmly like she was in a rehearsed play.

“Remind me again, weren't you planning on starting your own business after school?" she said, cutting her chicken neatly into thin slices.

"I've actually already started the business," Jack said. "It's been a little challenging with school, but I think it will be worth it."

"Oh, how splendid! And what is the business?" Mary said excitedly.

Jack sighed. "It’s kind of boring if I’m being honest. I got into property ownership."

Mary leaned in with overly eager interest. "Really?"

"Yes, there are a few areas on the city outskirts that had practically no investors, so we purchased the places for next to nothing and have been renovating them into affordable storefronts for small businesses.”

"And you're making money despite them being… affordable?” Mary spoke of the concept as if it were a foreign language. It made Jack chuckle.

"Surprisingly, yeah, it’s working. Obviously, we’re not making as much as those that jack up the rent, but we believe in keeping the costs affordable. It helps small businesses get started, and it’s been good for the local economy. I really believe in it."

Jack had never told Rachel any of this. Then again, Rachel had never bothered to ask. And he spoke with such passion. It was… well… Rachel was impressed.

"Oh! Another idealist! Rachel, did you hear? Jack is also an idealist," Mary said excitedly.

"I heard, mother," Rachel said politely, plucking a piece of chicken and putting it into her mouth.

"Rachel, are you also interested in humanitarian work?” Laura asked sweetly. Rachel, slightly embarrassed, cleared her throat and nodded.

"Y-yes, I really want to help poverty-stricken areas through lawmaking,” she said.

Laura's eyes softened as she touched her chest delicately with her hand.

"Oh Rachel, that is so wonderful," she said.

Her kindness was foreign, but a welcome change of pace from the scrutiny Rachel often faced from her own parents.

"I mean, I don't have it all figured out like Jack, but…"

"You don't need to have it all figured out, sweety, that's what college is for.” Laura let the words hang for a moment as she took a sip of crisp cold wine. “And you never know… you might find someone who can help you along the way…”

Mary couldn't help but chime in.

"Oh yes! Perhaps someone who is helping small businesses get their footing."

Rachel’s mother was never one for subtlety.

Jackeline began to laugh as she took a piece of cornbread from the center of the table.

"Rachel, wasn't Noah working on something pretty cool also?" she asked, reveling in her mother’s disapproving stare.

Rachel nodded. "Oh, yes, well… he's planning on going into computer engineering. He's pretty good at it too! He's even made a few programs himself. He actually has this one where you can click on a button, and it makes this rabbit fart a lot…"

Jackeline and Jack both laughed with Rachel. Laura and Mary, however, glanced at one another with grave concern.

“Oh, a fart program,” Laura said, forcing a polite smile. “How very creative.”

"Yes, well…” Mary chimed in, “as nice as that is, it’s exciting to see all of you doing so well in your fields.”

“Except for me though, right?” Jackeline said dully.

“Oh darling, stop! You are already well established in your career. You don’t see Laura and I talking about our ventures, do you?”

“Mary, don’t be so harsh,” Laura said gently, turning to Jackeline. “Is law going well for you, sweetheart?”

“Very,” Jackeline said, glancing at her mother. “Working hard and hopefully making my parents proud.”

“Ohhh, we are very proud,” Mary said defensively.

As Jackeline and her mother began to bicker, Jack glanced over at Rachel apologetically. She smiled back at him, finding some solace in the fact that he felt the same as she did.

Rachel felt her phone buzz in her pocket. She pulled it out and checked it beneath the table, surprised to see that it was a text from Mel.

Mel: Hey, we need to talk.

Rachel scoffed under her breath. Mel was the last woman on earth she wanted to talk to. She stared at the screen blankly for a moment as she decided what to do next, and felt her sister tap on her shoulder.

"Hey," she whispered. "Is something wrong?"

"Hmmm, oh no, it's nothing," Rachel said with a smile, turning off her phone and returning her attention to dinner.

The conversation meandered between old stories of childhood, new prospects for each family, gossip about aunts and nieces, and ended on a surprisingly pleasant note.

As dinner came to a close, Jack stood and began to gather their dishes. When he reached for Rachel's, she pulled it from him instinctively.

"I can handle it," she said.

"Please, it's not a big deal. Besides, we wouldn’t want to give them any ideas," Jack said, looking back at their mothers, who were now preoccupying themselves with a lively conversation about Laura’s latest custom ring.

"Fair point," Rachel said with a smile as Jack took her plate.

She and Jackeline moved to the living room, relaxing on the oversized, pillowy couch as they talked absently about nothing in particular. The laughter of their mothers echoed off the vaulted ceilings every so often as the sun slowly set.

Rachel glanced at Jack every so often as he cleaned the dishes alone in the kitchen.

A towel over his broad shoulder. His dark hair slicked back. He stopped every so often to gaze out at the mountains surrounding them.

He looked so at ease.

And he only glanced at her once.

Their eyes caught. He smiled.

Rachel smiled with him.

It was… nice.

That, at least, made her texts to Noah a bit easier to bear later in the evening. She sat on her bed, deciding the best way to break the news to him. At first, she thought about calling, but feared it might be too much. She didn’t want to catastrophize the situation, and certainly didn’t want Noah to have another panic episode. And so decided a simple text might be best.

Rachel: Hey :) So I figured I should probably tell you… My mom invited Jack and his mom out here with us 😬

Noah read the message almost instantly, and promptly responded.

Noah: Wait, really?

Rachel: Yes! I had no idea, I swear.

Noah: Has he tried anything?

Rachel: No! He’s actually been really respectful. Plus with everyone here it'd be pretty hard anyway. We're sleeping on separate sides of the house, his idea.

Noah typed for a long while.

Noah: He knew you'd be there tho…

Rachel bit her lip.

Rachel: Yeah… but he did say he wasn’t sure. I think his mom made it seem like it’d be just them up here?

She wasn't sure why she felt the need to defend Jack.

Noah: Ok, well… I guess let me know if anything happens?

Rachel: Of course! It's just family time, but I wanted you to know.

Noah: Thanks.

No heart, no smiley face. Nothing. Rachel’s heart began to race as she quickly typed a reply.

Rachel: You having a good time?

Noah took a while to respond.

Noah: Everything is great. Just keeping busy.

Rachel: Alright, well, I'll talk to you later.

Noah: Sounds good.

Rachel: I love you.

Rachel watched as Noah slowly thumbed a response.

Noah: Love u 2 :)

A wave of relief found Rachel, and that wave carried her into the week.

Without even trying, she found herself enjoying Jack’s company. He had a wonderful charm about him. A clever sense of humor and timing that always landed at the perfect moment. When they had all decided to visit downtown, he took it upon himself to plan the day and drive them all. He’d found an eclectic sushi restaurant for lunch, encouraged Rachel’s mother to try raw fish for the first time, and found a large thrift store for them to get lost in. And when they stopped in a park to get ice cream, Jack ushered his mom towards the store’s polar bear statue for a picture.

"Oh, Jack, I look terrible!" Laura said.

"No you don’t, Mom. You look beautiful as always," Jack said, handing Mary his phone before stepping to the side of his mother.

"Oh, you two look wonderful!" Mary said sweetly, struggling with Jack's phone for a moment. "Now how do I… oh, it's zooming in, what do I do?"

"I'll do it," Rachel said, politely taking the phone from her mother. She looked at Jack through the screen. She smiled as Laura glanced up at her son proudly while Rachel began snapping several shots.

"Do they look alright?" Laura asked, fixing her wide-brimmed hat.

"Oh, they are coming out lovely, Laura!" Mary called as she peered over Rachel’s shoulder.

"Do you want a picture with your daughters, Mary?" Laura asked.

Rachel closed her eyes and grimaced when she heard her mother's eager cry.

"Oh, of course! Come along, my chikitis! It’s family picture time.”

Rachel and Jackeline followed their mother with a knowing gaze, standing on either side of her as she posed underneath the polar bear statue.

Rachel’s mother wrapped her arms around them both, pulling them tightly towards her.

Just like she used to when they were young.

Rachel couldn’t help but smile at that.

Jack held up his phone and took several shots. Rachel swore he was looking at her the entire time he did.

Their mother playfully made several other poses, including one where she pretended the bear was attacking them. Jackeline and Rachel were inclined to participate.

And then, of course, came the dreaded question Rachel knew was coming.

"Oh! And how about one with Rachel and Jack?!" Laura suggested all too innocently.

"That's a splendid idea! Jack, won't you come over here?" Mary said, stepping out of the way with Jackeline. Rachel couldn’t help but roll her eyes.

"Jackie too," she said.

"Oh, but darling…" Mary started.

"If it's going to be a shot of the kids, it should be all of us,” Rachel said. Before her mother could protest, Jack stepped forward.

"No, she's right," he said, ushering Jackeline back under the bear. “Jackie deserves to be in the shot too.”

“Ohhh, alright,” Mary said, stepping to Laura’s side as she began to pluck her finger against Jack’s phone.

“Ok you three, give us some smiles!” Laura said happily.

As their mothers shot the pictures, Rachel leaned close to Jack.

"Thanks," she said softly.

"No worries, Rach," he replied.

It was the first time he'd used a nickname for her like that, and it was nice.

He was nice.

And stable.

And kind.

He was always thoughtful. Always had something clever to say. He never apologized. He never seemed uncertain. And he was smart, too. So smart. Laid back. Willing to do things. Athletic, also.

She really noticed that when they went to play pickleball.

He wore a perfectly fitting pair of black shorts and a white sleeveless shirt. It showed off his toned body so well. And what started as a friendly game between him and Jackeline quickly turned into a rally, which attracted a group of onlookers.

Their movements were smooth, and as the game went on, their intensity increased.

Jack started to let out these grunts every time he hit the ball. Rachel found her chest racing every time she heard them.

And after, when he suggested they all go to a sports bar to catch the game, he was so relaxed.

There was no anxiety to worry about, no bad habits to call out. Rachel could simply be there with him and know things were taken care of.

Rachel hadn’t realized how nice that truly was.

She slept soundly that night. Only to be woken by a pillow landing on her face the following morning.

Rachel bolted upright and found Jack standing a good distance away from her bed.

“Good morning,” he said.

"What are you doing?!" Rachel asked as she slowly gathered her senses.

"Sorry, I was trying to call to you, but you weren't waking up," Jack said apologetically.

Rachel’s eyes focused on him. He wore a baggy red shirt and a pair of grey cotton shorts. And when he smiled, Rachel became all too aware of how frumpy she looked in her matching fish-patterned pajama set. She quickly covered herself with a blanket.

"Why are you waking me up?" she said tiredly.

"Jackie sent me up here, said you needed to wake up and come down for breakfast."

Rachel groaned and fell back onto her pillow.

"Ok, well, I'm up," Rachel said flatly.

"Cool, but are you going to fall back asleep?"

Rachel’s head slowly turned to him as she glared. "You can go now."

Jack laughed as he raised his hands. "Fine, but only if you promise to come downstairs and eat breakfast with us."

"And who is us?"

"Your sister and me? She made a whole thing for you."

Rachel blinked. “Jackie never makes breakfast.”

“Well, she did so…”

“Why?”

“I guess you’ll have to come down and see,” Jack said playfully.

Rachel closed her eyes and sighed.

"Fine, I'll be down in a minute, now go please?"

"You got it," Jack said, turning to leave. "Oh, and Rachel?"

"Yeah?"

"You snore."

It was said so perfectly, Rachel couldn't help but laugh.

"Ok? And?!"

"I don't know, might be sleep apnea or something."

"Sleep apnea?! You're telling me I have sleep apnea?"

Jack shrugged as he exited the room, not looking back. "Might be worth looking at!" he shouted before disappearing.

Rachel scoffed and got herself out of bed, heading to her private bathroom. She sat on the toilet and checked her phone, surprised to see that there weren't any texts from Noah. It wasn't in their habit to text daily, but considering everything going on, she thought he might.

Or rather, she wished he would. While nothing was happening with Jack, it felt like everything was. Already in a hurry, Rachel put it out of her mind. She threw on her sweatpants, picked up a baggy shirt, placed her hair in a messy bun, then headed downstairs.

There, in the kitchen, Jackeline and Jack stood around the island eating their breakfast. Between them were several plates of French toast, scrambled eggs, bacon, and sausage. Jackeline was the first to see Rachel. She smiled brightly as she poured her sister a glass of orange juice and pushed it towards a plate already prepared for her.

“The sleepyhead appears,” Jackeline said playfully.

“It’s not even that late,” Rachel said dully.

“Well, it is if we want to get out to the hiking trail at a reasonable hour,” Jackeline said. Rachel lazily took a bite of a sausage as she looked between them.

“You guys want to go hiking?”

“Oh my god, I told you she would act this way!” Jackeline said to Jack with a laugh.

“I should have known the two athletes would want to take me out on the trail,” Rachel said.

“Well, last I heard, you’ve been pretty athletic yourself these days,” Jackeline teased, but when she saw Jack and Rachel freeze, she promptly cleared her throat and changed the subject. “I just thought it’d be nice to get some air. It will be an easy trail, I promise.”

Rachel, eager to stay very clear of any banter related to her extracurriculars, happily focused on the new topic.

“I’ll see it when I believe it,” she said, glancing around for a moment. “Where’s Mom and Laura?” she asked.

“They decided to do a shopping day, so it will be just us,” Jack said, finishing off his plate and promptly cleaning it up.

“Well, alright,” Rachel said reluctantly, “But if I get tired, we’re turning back.”

“I promise to carry you if that happens,” Jackeline said.

Rachel rolled her eyes and felt her phone buzz. Hoping it was Noah, she promptly unlocked it, only to find it was Mel calling her. With a grimace, she promptly hung up and looked back at her sister.

“I’m holding you to that.”

—

The trail was not easy. Already two hours in, Rachel thought she was going to die. Jack and Jackeline both seemed completely unfazed, however. Jack especially so.

“If you guys don’t mind, I think I’m going to pull ahead a little bit,” he said.

“No worries,” Jackeline said, taking a swig from her water bottle. “I’ll stay here with the little one. We’ll see you at the summit.”

“Sounds good!” Jack said. Rachel’s eyes dropped to his butt as he began striding up a steep slope. He’d taken his shirt off long ago, and now his back glistened with sweat.

“God, he really is hot, isn’t he?” Jackeline whispered as he pulled away.

“I don’t want to talk about that right now. I’m dying,” Rachel said, forcing one foot in front of the other.

“How mad would you be if I said I tried to make a move on him last night?” Jackeline asked. Rachel immediately perked up, eyes wide.

“You did what?!”

Jackeline laughed.

“When you went to bed, we were hanging out beside the pool together, and we had a few drinks… so you know… feeling inspired…” Jackeline’s eyes trailed back to him. “I kind of made a pass.”

Rachel’s jaw dropped.

“I cannot believe you did that!”

“Are you mad?”

“What?! No! It’s just… I don’t know. I never thought of you being that kind of girl!”

“Me either! But you had me inspired!” Jackeline began to laugh as her face turned bright red.

“Well, what did he say?” Rachel asked.

“He passed over it like it didn’t even happen,” Jackeline replied defeatedly.

“Ok, but what did you actually say?” Rachel repeated, more curious than ever.

“It’s so embarrassing! I haven’t done something like that in so long,” Jackeline wiped the sweat from her brow as she continued to walk.

“I promise I won’t laugh.”

Jackeline closed her eyes and shook her head as she stared up into the sky.

“HE said it was a great view. And then I said, You’re a great view… especially with that shirt off. And he didn’t even acknowledge it! I wanted to die!”

Rachel laughed with her sister.

“Maybe he didn’t get that you were making a pass at him? Maybe he thought you were complimenting him.”

Jackeline scoffed. “No, that’s not it. I’m pretty sure I know why he didn’t respond.”

“Why?” Rachel asked, breathing heavy as they crested over a steep incline.

“Because he has eyes for someone else.”

Rachel blushed and didn’t say a word.

“So… are YOU going to ask him?” Jackeline teased.

“Ohhh, I don’t know,” Rachel said nervously.

“What, why not?!”

“I don’t know. It just… it feels wrong?” Rachel said. Jackeline looked over at her with some concern.

“Wait, why? Are you and Noah not open anymore?” she asked.

“No, we are. It’s just… I don’t know.”

“Hmmmm.”

“What?”

“Well, I guess I’m trying to understand why you’re feeling guilty if you guys are open.”

Rachel sighed. “Noah can be… tough to read sometimes.”

“Mhmmm,” Jackeline, as always, made no attempt to interrupt Rachel. She walked steadily beside her sister, patiently waiting for Rachel to open up.

“To be honest, it can be really, really difficult to know what he’s thinking. He’ll say one thing, but then in an instant, he will change his mind and get really upset. Then I’ll see that he’s really upset, and calm him down, and even tell him that we don’t have to do anything, because we don’t. But then, he will say it’s fine. But then also be distant? Like he won’t say what he’s thinking. And it’s really confusing. It’s a lot of back and forth… all the time… I don’t know.”

They hiked in silence for a moment.

“Hey, Rachel?” Jackeline said.

“Yeah?”

Her older sister smiled at her with gentle eyes. “Can I be real for a second?”

“Sure.”

“It’s not your job to read Noah’s mind. And it’s not your job to police yourself to keep him happy. If Noah says he’s ok with you guys being open, then you have to be able to believe him. And if he’s not ok with it, it’s up to HIM to say that. And not only that, HE has to be able to hold his OWN boundaries, not leave it up to you to figure out what those boundaries are.”

“No, I know…”

“I’m serious. The real question you need to be asking yourself is, do YOU like exploring this stuff?”

Rachel blushed. “I do.”

“And Noah said he’s into it too, right?”

“He did.”

“And did Noah say he’s ok with you possibly exploring things with Jack?”

“He did, he did…” Rachel said timidly.

“Well… if that’s the case. Then you have to trust him at his word, right?”

“You’re right,” Rachel said with a deep breath. “But what if he gets upset again?”

Jackeline went quiet for a moment as they neared the peak.

“If he keeps getting upset after he says it's ok, then that is his problem. Not your problem. You’re not his caretaker, Rachel. You’re his girlfriend.”

Rachel felt the words hit home. As she processed them, her phone buzzed in her leggings. She opened it and saw it was Mel once more. Annoyed and flustered, she promptly blocked the number and put her phone away.

“You’re right,” Rachel said. “He did say it was ok. Just to tell him before it happens.”

“Then that is exactly what you do. And you don’t clarify. You don’t say ‘are you sure?’ You ask him and let HIM tell you. Because if you can’t trust his word, then you can’t really trust him, right?”

“You’re right.”

“So communicate, say what’s going on and what you want to do and then… you know…” she looked back over at Jack and bit her lips. “Have some fun…”

“Oh my god,” Rachel blushed, pushing her sister playfully as the two began to laugh.

But Jackeline was right, and Rachel knew it.

She had to hold Noah to his word.

She couldn’t police him anymore.

She needed to know she could trust him.

That he was stable.

That he was safe.

And as they neared Jack on the summit. Rachel decided she would ask for permission that night.

Files

Comments

Banana23

Every Rachel-focused chapter reinforces my belief that not only will she and Noah eventually break-up, it would be better for them to do so. I actually side with Jackie's opinion about Noah when looking at him from an outside perspective and no awareness of his trauma and issues. But since we are presented with Noah's issues, it makes me feel like Rachel is not equipped to help Noah deal with his problems and everyone around Rachel will only be looking out for her and guide her into decisions that could exacerbate Noah's issues. I can't even fault Mary or Jackie for acting they way they do since they only want what's best for Rachel. It also doesn't help that Rachel is written to have so much chemistry with Jack and Mike that her scenes with Noah seems bland in comparison.

NaughtiWolf

There's quite a bit to unpack in this chapter. Rachel blocking Mel is gonna come back to bite her in the ass because I think this happens after Mel and Allison's day out in the previous chapter. Mel's actually trying to do the right thing by warning Rachel but because of Mel's previous actions and attitude, Rachel isn't going to extend any trust. Rachel's chemistry with Jack has always been there from the beginning, so this chapter isn't a revelation so much as a continuation and escalation. I like that Jack is clearly respectful and warm with Rachel, even going so far as to recognize the blatant attempts from Mary and Laura. It was inevitable once the reveal of Jack joining the "family" vacation that Jack and Rachel were going to hook up. Jackeline's advice is solid. “It’s not your job to read Noah’s mind. And it’s not your job to police yourself to keep him happy. If Noah says he’s ok with you guys being open, then you have to be able to believe him. And if he’s not ok with it, it’s up to HIM to say that. And not only that, HE has to be able to hold his OWN boundaries, not leave it up to you to figure out what those boundaries are.” It is up to Noah to talk to Rachel, to set boundaries, to say I'm not okay with this or that, and figure out compromises that work for both him and Rachel. It isn't Rachel's job to modify her behavior to provide emotional regulation for Noah. This is one of those things that polyamorous or ENM people struggle with as well. Jealousy is normal and expected. Not feeling like the "special" one in the relationship is normal. Questioning why your partner stays with you when there are clearly "better" options available is normal. Unfortunately, as we have become privy to over the last 15 chapters, Noah is so deeply traumatized by his mother and Allison that he doesn't have the backbone necessary to openly discuss his traumas and what he actually needs. For lack of a better term, he's a people pleaser for the worst reasons. Honestly, Noah should not be in an open relationship. At this point, I don't think he should be in any kind of romantic relationship. He needs therapy to process his trauma, process how he bonds with people, stop his people pleaser tendencies, and decide if he really likes being in an open relationship or if his trauma is the reason he thinks he deserves to be treated as less than by his partner. I have a feeling that we've been slowly entering a tragic story arc for this series and the tragedy is about to start piling up.

NaughtiWolf

Rachel is not equipped to handle Noah's trauma. Period. Honestly, no one in this story is equipped to help with that kind of trauma outside of an actual therapist. Either Rachel and Noah need to break up so he can focus on dealing with his trauma or the two of them need to have a long, frank conversation about everything and set proper boundaries. Mary is clearly dismissive of Rachel's actual desires and prefers to meddle because she believes she knows best. She is a mirror for Rachel's father.

Tombstone23

Yeah I’m often wondering why she’s with Noah anymore when their chemistry falls pretty flat compared to Jack and Mike at this point. I think I’ve officially given up on Noah and Rachel working, this chapter and how she decided to be with Mike instead of Noah before her trip sealed the deal for me. I get Jackie’s point, especially since she’s not aware of Noah’s trauma like you said. But if I had to guess it seems like it will be a license for Rachel to just be even more selfish rather than actually trying to talk to Noah and show that she cares about him and has noticed how he’s been struggling. Neither of them are willing to start that convo to address things, so it makes her look like she doesn’t care like she says and makes Noah look like he actually believes what her dad told him however many chapters ago that happened.

NaughtiWolf

15 chapters since the conversation with Rachel's dad. It goes back to what many of us have said over and over again: The drama for this series relies almost entirely on people being too afraid to have the difficult conversations you need to have when a relationship is opened up.

ToSch

Man... I've reached the point where I find reading Rachel chapters... emotionally taxing? Exhausting? Yeah, I think that's the right word for it. I think I feel that way because she doesn't do any real introspection, questions why Noah is acting the way he is, or shows any real emotional empathy as a girlfriend. While I can see where Jackeline is coming from, lacking the proper context, I'm surprised that her only comment seems to be that Noah just needs to toughen up, especially after her earlier speech on the phone. Really? Is that what she's boiled it down to? That's a rather weak cop-out for her character arc, if you ask me. However, Rachel's instant acceptance doesn't surprise me anymore. For the longest time, she has more or less been focused on where HER next emotional or physical gratification will come from. Not theirs, as in Noah and Rachel, but only hers. Is Noah his own worst enemy? Sure, no doubt about it. But at this point, Rachel really just doesn't give a shit. She tries to convince herself that she does, perhaps out of habit, but she really doesn't. At this point I'm actually quite morbidly interested in how Allison's vile plans will impact Rachel. Which kinda worries me, to be honest. :D Will it lead to her having some empathy or pity for Noah's position? Or will it just end in an epic crash-out because someone dared to interrupt her perfect little world of bulls at her beck and call and her browbeaten cuck always waiting for her at home, his feelings be damned? What about Noah and Rachel as a couple though? I don't see a way anymore that doesn't end in a breakup. Maybe Mel can give Noah a proper, loving relationship despite her initial mistakes. But the current Rachel? No chance. She cares too much about herself and not enough about him.

northdrop

I mean, Jackie isn’t wrong; she’s stating the obvious. People in relationships need to communicate with each other and trust that what is said is true. Rachel has been open about enjoying this exploration and Noah has been open about saying he likes it. If Noah were ALSO open about his past traumas, it would inform Rachel’s behavior with the kink THEY share. As far as she knows, he’s enjoying this as much as her, even if he seems to be wishy-washy at times. That said, if I were in this situation, I would try to force my partner to tell me what they are really feeling because not knowing exactly what’s going on would drive me insane and fill me with anxiety. It’s unfair, however, for me to put my expectations on others (Rachel, in this case). As for the Mel communication, as Jackie already knows what’s going on, if Rachel doesn’t want to talk to Mel but is curious about what’s going on, she should have Jackie text or call her to screen the communication. The Noah and Rachel not communicating every day blows my mind. I’ve been with my partner for fourteen years and we talk every day. She’s my best friend. If Rachel has any sense, she aught to call Noah and have a real connective talk about asking about Jack.

Tombstone23

Yeah them not texting or talking daily is a huge red flag, at least in my eyes. I don’t think I’ve met a couple in the last seven years that doesn’t keep daily communication with their SO

Tombstone23

Well said, and I agree. Especially about the emotional empathy. I think Rachel loves the idea of Noah, the memories he has with him. But how she immediately took her sister’s advice to heart without expressing more concern for how Noah is, the lack of attempts to really connect with him when he shows he’s struggling, but at the end of the day she seems to take what justifications she can to have sex with Mike and Ethan over anything else with minimal guilt. Actions show she doesn’t care for him as much as she claims. I’m also hoping Allison comes in and seriously ruffles feathers. I don’t want to see Noah get hurt, but I’m very interested in seeing Rachels reaction to Allison’s games in how she wants to hook up with Mike and the others. That’s probably what I’m most interested in now that I don’t have any hop for Noah and Rachel, though I there’s still some lingering hope it’s a biiig wake up call for Rachel

NaughtiWolf

I disagree that Rachel doesn't give a shit. Her internal dialogue in pervious chapters shows that she does love Noah fiercely. Unfortunately, Noah is too traumatized by his past to be completely honest with her. My read on that is that he is deathly afraid that Rachel will leave him for Mike or Ethan or Jack if he objects in any way. Here's something to keep in mind, given I think you've stated your experience is primarily monogamous relationships: Monogamy teaches you that you should be your partner's primary focus and have a special place in their heart. Ethical Non-monogamy has different facets but an open relationship like Noah and Rachel's is shifting away from purely physical relationships into emotional connections. This is why communication is essential. Jealousy, feelings on inadequacy, concerns about whether your partner still loves you and wants you when you see how they are with another partner are all normal. It's the expansion of understanding that you are no longer the center of your partner's romantic and sexual universe. It's frightening as hell at first. Sometimes, that's where ENM relationships end because they can't handle it. But on the other side is the understanding that each person can provide a different experience, a different kind of love. The problem, as we have both agreed repeatedly, is that no one is having the honest, difficult, and frankly painful conversations that need to happen. Noah needs to tell Rachel everything: what Allison did to him, what Bryan did to him, what his mother did to him, what Rachel's father said at the dinner. Rachel needs to articulate to Noah how her feelings for Mike have changed. My hope is that Allison's involvement will force everyone to actually confront what they've been doing.

NaughtiWolf

Noah's isolating himself, as we saw two chapters ago. He's not in a good headspace but he doesn't have a proper support system to help him deal with what's going on. Jackie is on the right track but because she doesn't have the full context, her advice is only half-right. With Mel, it's simply a case of her previous behavior making Rachel completely mistrust her. Mel should honestly not have expected any better given how she's acted. Just wait until Mel finds out Rachel slept with Jack. Remember, all the way back in "Morning After": the one person Mel told Rachel to stay away from was Jack. If Rachel follows through and has sex with Jack, Mel's gonna have an epic crash out and make some poor decisions.

ToSch

Hey Naughti! Yeah, as we've discussed before, I'm not personally familiar with these relationship dynamics. I will defer to your experience there. I'm simply arguing about what I can see and deduce from the story, even though I may be missing the personal experience necessary to properly contextualize some of the dynamics. While I agree that her internal dialogue expresses her feelings for Noah, I don't see much action to confirm it. As I've argued in the last few chapters, I feel that Rachel prioritizes pretty much every other guy in this story over Noah, if she has the option. He's basically only her backup when nothing else is available. Every time she was "forced" to choose in recent chapters, she chose someone other than Noah. - Celebrating the "great" dinner with her dad? She invites and focuses on Mike. - Mike wanting to include Ethan in their fun? She just okays it and only then remembers to even check with Noah if he's fine with it. - Checking on Noah after he left in a hurry or keep on having sex with Mike? Sex with Mike it is. - Leaving the boys alone for a few days? She's getting jealous about Mike potentially "straying", not Noah. Actually, while thinking and writing about this topic, I noticed something. Let me rephrase my point: She's not choosing other guys over Noah. She's actually choosing herself over everyone else. She coerces not just Noah into doing what she wants. Ethan was never really comfortable with the arrangement either, but she pestered him too until he gave in and gave her what she wanted. We see this in this chapter once again. After maybe a two-minute talk with Jackeline, she's all geared up and ready to do what? Finally have the talk that Jackeline advocated for the last time they spoke before she suddenly changed gears in this chapter? Which we all agree is desperately needed? Nope. She decides to put Noah on the spot by telling him that she wants to sleep with another guy after her sister gave her a flimsy excuse for it. That's why I stand by my interpretation that, at this point, Rachel's love for Noah is more or less just lip service. She's currently more in it for herself than for their relationship. And I think we can all agree that, no matter the type of relationship, this is not the way to go.

NaughtiWolf

Fair points but let me offer an alternative perspective. -After the dinner, I believe Noah encouraged Rachel to bring Mike back. - Noah didn't object verbally to Ethan joining and both him and Mike getting to have unprotected sex with Rachel. He gave her a thumbs up, if I remember right. -instead of speaking up about his distress during the second threesome day, Noah fled. He didn't speak up, so how would Mike or Rachel know that there was a problem? -Noah already told Rachel he didn't want anyone else. And Rachel's rather complicated feelings for Mike are becoming romantic. Rachel is making decisions for her own pleasure because she doesn't know what we know: that Noah is struggling. Jackie is right: it's not up to Rachel to intuit Noah's moods and boundaries. I agree she should clarify what the boundaries actually are but Noah is just as responsible for setting boundaries as well. Neither of them are blameless and neither of them are completely at fault.

ToSch

I absolutely see what you're saying, and I certainly agree that Noah is also to blame. There's no doubt about it. However, I think I tend to blame Rachel more than Noah because she's the one who usually initiates all these situations, while Noah's fault is "just" being too passive and spineless for his own good and theirs.

JRockk

Yeah Noah and Rachel are not gonna make it at this rate and it's probably for the best.