Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Noah took a fry from his plate as he stared absently out of the restaurant street window. It was a nicer place closer to the city. A chain restaurant that tried to keep itself from looking like a chain by using quartz countertops and designer wooden chairs. But the cheesesteak and fries were good. Things had been difficult since running into Allison. Noah had decided to stay away from Rachel’s place for the time being, and since that meant he was dealing with Fred again, Noah found himself going out a lot more.

He glanced at his phone, looking at the message Mel had sent him after taking Allison away.

Mel: Hope ur doing ok, sorry about all that :/

Noah didn't really understand why she was apologizing. It wasn't her fault that Allison pushed boundaries. She did it with everyone she met. But her apology made him smile all the same.

It had been one silver lining as he returned to his dorm. When Noah unlocked the door and stepped into his place, Fred jumped and promptly minimized a video screen on his computer before covering himself with a blanket.

“Jesus! Could you knock next time?!” Fred shouted.

Noah tiredly forced a smile, “Sorry about that.”

Fred eyed him for a moment as he struggled with his shorts beneath the blanket.

"What the fuck are you doing back so soon?" he asked.

"Change of plans,” Noah said with a sigh. He tossed his bag onto his bed before falling beside it.

"What, is Rachel back?"

"Nope."

Fred scoffed. "So she kicked you out, huh?"

"She didn't kick me out, Fred," Noah said shortly.

"Whatever you say…" he returned to his computer for a moment, clicking without aim at an empty desktop screen. Noah prayed he'd keep his mouth shut and leave him alone. Fred did not. "So when am I getting my turn with her?"

"Drop it, Fred."

Fred scoffed again, louder this time as he turned on a game and began angrily clacking against his keyboard.

"You do realize she is way out of your league, right?" he said.

Noah ignored him. At his silence, Fred laughed loudly.

"She's probably cheating on you right now."

"She is not," Noah said sharply.

"Ohhhh right. Sorry, I forgot you get cucked, so it’s not technically ‘cheating.’”

“Fred.” Noah’s voice grew stern.

“I’m just saying facts! But she IS out of your league. If she hasn't tried something by now, she will." Fred chuckled as he slammed down on his keyboard maniacally. It was the same rhetoric Noah always seemed to run into. The same lines. The same story. Only now, it was becoming more grating than ever.

Before Fred managed to say another word, Noah jumped up from his bed.

“Heading out already?” Fred asked.

“Got things to do,” Noah said shortly.

“Yeah yeah… just make sure to KNOCK next time, alright?”

Noah didn’t answer. He slammed the door behind himself and headed out to clear his head.

Now, here he sat. Doing what he knew was best for his mental health, but not feeling much better. Because whenever Noah was alone, he began to realize just how empty he felt. When there wasn't chaos to contend with, it was as if his body turned on him.

It became a roaring tidal wave that threatened to consume his soul.

But he didn’t need to face it for long.

As he tapped through his social feed, Rachel's name appeared.

He stared at it for a moment, surprised to find that it brought up mixed feelings. Noah put in his earphones and answered.

"Hey," he said, watching as several couples passed on the sidewalk outside.

"Hey!" Rachel replied. "What are you up to?"

"I actually went downtown to get lunch."

"What?! Really?! No way! I’m so glad you got out of the house for a little bit."

Noah smiled. "Yeah. How’s… Colorado?"

Rachel paused for only a moment.

"Good! We've been having so much fun. Actually, we just got back from a hike not too long ago."

"Oh yeah? Let me guess, Jackie’s idea?"

Rachel laughed. "Who else, right?"

Noah breathed in through his nose as he swirled a fry in ketchup.

"And how's Jack been?" he asked.

"Well… that's actually why I am calling," she said nervously.

Noah already knew it was coming. He had known for some time. But that didn’t change how he felt inside. A swirling pain mixed with boiling frustration. A series of compiling feelings that had been unaddressed and left festering. Noah tried to work through it all as Rachel continued.

"I kind of wanted to see if… you know…"

Noah felt his blood run cold and his thoughts turn blank.

"Wanted to see if…?" he asked.

"Well, you know. I figured since we're here, I might try exploring it a little bit? If the opportunity arises, of course."

Noah found himself nodding as he struggled with what he was hearing.

"I thought…. I guess I thought this trip was going to be a break from all of this?" he said.

"Right…" Rachel paused. "And it was, but Jack’s here now, and I don't know, I thought it might be fun. Plus you said we are at the stage where you don't always have to be there, so I thought it could be good."

Noah heard Fred in his head. He saw Allison and Brian in foggy memories. He remembered Rachel's father, and felt a whirlwind of emotions swell through him. And for the first time, Noah found himself growing tired of it.

He took a deep breath and forced himself to speak his truth.

"Rachel, I have to be honest, I feel pretty insecure about it," he said.

"Oh…" Rachel paused. "Well, does that mean you don't want me to do it?"

That was strange. She usually offered not to do something outright. Why was she phrasing it differently now? Noah’s mind raced to the worst reasons.

"You want to though, right?" he asked.

"Well, yes. I do, actually," Rachel said. There was a sharpness to her voice that cut across Noah’s ears.

"Wow," he said.

"What?"

"I don't know, I guess…" Noah stopped himself. He already knew what this meant. Of course she would want to explore things with Jack. Of course she was having an amazing time with him. Everyone could see what was obvious except for them.

Noah was tired of fighting against it.

"We're supposed to be exploring, right?" he said.

"Well, we are exploring because we both WANT to, right?" Rachel almost sounded annoyed. Like Noah wasn't saying something right. It sent him back to a familiar dark place. One he had often shared with Allison long ago.

Noah took a deep breath. "Well, you said we should be getting it out of our systems. So I think you should."

Rachel let out a sigh. "Noah…"

"What?" Noah sounded annoyed. He could hear it in his voice.

"That's not… you DO want to explore too, right?"

"Of course I do," Noah said, doing his best to keep calm.

"Alright, I'm just making sure you know what you want."

"I know what I want," Noah snapped.

"Ok… I'm just asking." Rachel was definitely annoyed now.

There was a wellspring of anger pooling inside Noah, consuming his pain and using it like fuel.

"Just make sure you text me before you guys do it, ok? I want to be mentally prepared," he said.

"Alright. I can do that." Rachel paused. "And you're absolutely sure this is what you want, right?"

It was the way she said it that brought his anger to a boiling point, and it gave Noah the strength to finally ask the question he'd been too afraid to.

"I am, but… I wanted to ask something else too."

Rachel went silent.

"Ok."

Noah cleared his throat. "I think I'd actually like to explore something also."

Noah could sense the energy shift between them instantly. Guilt followed.

"Oh… oh yeah ok… yeah no…" Rachel fumbled over her words as she processed what she just heard. "I mean I'm here doing… so yeah that… ok…"

Noah's heart softened instantly as he heard the woman he loved struggling.

"Listen, I just want to explore. Like we said. I can have boundaries if that would make things–"

"No! Nope, that's not… You don't have to have boundaries. I literally just asked you to see Jack so… I mean that's not fair…"

"Alright…"

A painful silence built between them. And even though Rachel was saying she was ok with it, it certainly didn't feel that way. Her tone was colder. But Noah faced it and continued.

"Do you want to know who it is?" he asked.

"No," Rachel said quickly. "Fuck ew… no just… no."

She was growing agitated. Noah could feel it.

"I'm sorry,” he said.

He heard Rachel scoff.

"Don't apologize, you're making me feel bad," she said.

And in that moment, Noah felt anger towards Rachel for the first time.

"Hey, I'm not trying to make you feel bad," he said defensively.

"No, I know it's just, when you say sorry like that all the time, it's kind of, I don't know. It just sort of–"

"Sorry all the time?"

"Well, I mean, I'm just saying you do say it a lot," Rachel was beginning to sound nervous. And annoyed. And angry.

Noah honestly didn't know. It was getting harder and harder to think.

"Fine, I won't say sorry," he said shortly.

"That’s not what I meant, Noah…"

More annoyance.

Noah couldn't contain the wellspring inside him.

"It's just that I'm literally doing exactly what you said was ok. You have told me countless times that I should be allowed to explore things too. And now that I want to, you're clearly getting upset. So is it ok or not?"

Noah didn't mean to sound as angry as he did. It wasn't even all at Rachel, either. It was at Allison. At his mother. At all the ways he'd been taken advantage of, and all the years he had buried it away. Now that he'd opened up the doors a little bit, it all came pouring out, consuming him in ways he couldn't understand.

"Noah…" Rachel sounded equal parts hurt and disturbed, and it broke Noah's heart.

He wasn't used to standing up for himself like this. In truth, he wasn't even sure if this was what standing up for himself looked like.

"I'm… I'm sorry." He immediately regretted saying that. Noah bit his tongue and glanced around the restaurant. When he saw a couple staring, it dawned on him just how loud he had been. Noah stood and promptly walked out the front door.

"Are you mad at me?" Rachel said. Noah could hear her voice quaking.

He was. He wasn't.

He walked to the side of the restaurant and leaned against its old brick siding.

"I'm just frustrated, I guess."

"But I'm just trying to talk to you."

"And I'm trying to talk to you. But it seems like you're saying one thing but mean something else.”

“Oh, I’m saying one thing and meaning something else?!” Rachel’s voice grew angry. It fed into Noah.

“Yes! And now you're making me feel guilty wanting to do the same thing that you've been doing!"

"I'VE been doing?" Rachel said defensively.

"Uh yeah? What you've been doing."

"Ok, first of all, WE have been doing it," Rachel said flatly.

"Oh my god, you know what I mean, Rachel."

"No, seriously. WE have been doing this together. Because YOU liked it. And honestly, I really don't appreciate how you aren’t giving me breathing room to process when this entire time, you have been constantly going back and forth. Like seriously, one day you’re ok with it, and the next day you’re having a nervous breakdown!"

Her tone was growing sharper, and it cut Noah to pieces. He knew she was right. Her father was right. He was too broken for this.

It took every ounce of willpower Noah had to keep himself focused.

"Look, I get that. But you're twisting my words,” he said.

"No I'm not."

"Yes, you ARE," Noah shot back. An old man passed him. Noah smiled politely and waited for him to be out of earshot before he continued. "Obviously we have been exploring things together. But YOU are the one who has ACTUALLY slept with other guys. I haven’t done anything with ANYONE. And every time I even come close to it, you REALLY get upset. Not only that, you are the one who is always moving things forward without even bothering to talk to me first!"

"But you said–" Rachel spoke in a small voice.

"Oh my god, Rachel. There are so many times you pushed the boundaries!"

The line went dead.

"You said… you said over and over… that you liked it…" she said weakly.

Noah's voice softened. "I do… I did…"

"You did?"

"I still do," Noah said.

"Ok… I'm trusting your word," Rachel said. Noah was confused why she was even saying that. It felt like a kind of trap Allison would set up.

Noah wasn’t going to fall for it this time.

"Ok, so can I explore things, or not?" Noah asked.

He heard Rachel take a very deep breath.

"I… understand… that you want to explore too. And you should. It's just… hard for me."

Noah closed his eyes in frustration. It felt like they were spinning in circles.

"I know that, which is why I'm asking if it's ok or not." He slumped against the side of the restaurant as he heard Rachel let out a deep breath.

"I think we just need a break."

Noah's heart went cold.

"What?"

"Not like… not like a break break. I mean, let's just take a minute and come back together, alright?"

Noah pushed a hand through his hair.

"Ok, so does that mean we're going to take a break from the other stuff too?"

Rachel paused.

"I'm ok with you doing your thing, and you're ok with me doing my thing. That's what we said. So I think we should use our best judgment."

Noah never thought Rachel could say something as hurtful as that.

"Use our judgment…" he repeated.

"Yeah."

He sniffed and shook his head in disbelief.

"Yeah, alright. Sure."

"Are you mad?"

"I'll let you use your judgment on that one," Noah said coldly. Regretting every word.

"Ok…" Rachel's voice was weak and defeated. She sounded like her father had just reprimanded her.

Noah fell silent. He wanted to say sorry, but immediately caught himself.

"I shouldn't have said that," he said.

"It's fine."

Noah knew it wasn't. He waited and hoped Rachel would say the words he desperately needed to hear at that moment.

But they didn't come.

"I'll… talk to you later," Rachel said.

Broken and eyes reddening, Noah sniffed and nodded. "Yeah, talk to you later."

The line went dead, and silence followed.

–

Rachel hung up the phone and stared blankly. They had just had a fight. A bad fight. She and Noah had never fought like that before. While Rachel was still trying to process what just happened, Jackeline appeared at her door, as if summoned.

"Heeeey seeester," she said.

"Hey," Rachel said weakly.

At the sight of her sister's face, Jackeline's smile faded into concern.

"Uh oh… did the talk with Noah not go well?" she asked.

Rachel shook her head defeatedly.

"We ended up having an argument."

"Oh my god, what happened?" Jackeline asked, rushing to Rachel's side.

"I don't know, it got heated so fast! I did what you said. I really tried to communicate what I wanted, and also made it clear that Noah had to know what he wanted. But I don't know, he got so mad."

"Was he mad about you seeing Jack?" Jackeline whispered.

"No… well, he was weird about it for a second. Like always. And then he did his thing where he said it was fine. I don't know, I got a little bit annoyed with him. Maybe I shouldn't have," Rachel shook her head. "I also told him not to apologize so much. I feel terrible for saying it."

Jackeline nodded slowly.

"But does he apologize a lot?" she asked.

"Is that really such a bad thing?" Rachel said.

"It can be," Jackeline answered.

Rachel wasn't ready to confront that truth yet.

"Well, that isn't even where things went wrong, it was when he asked to… to see someone."

Jackeline's eyes widened. "Wait, he's seeing someone?"

"Not yet, but he did finally ask."

Jackeline took a deep breath.

"Ohhh man," she said it playfully enough to make Rachel laugh as she fell back into her bed.

"I knooooow…"

"Ok, hang on," Jackeline stood and walked to Rachel's bedroom door and closed it, latching the privacy lock. "Alright, so… Noah has finally asked you to see someone."

Rachel nodded slowly as she closed her eyes.

"And you're ok with it?"

"Yes?"

"Rachel," Jackeline spoke with the kind inflection of a caring parent. "Did we not just talk about vocalizing how we feel? You have to do the same for him."

"I did!" Rachel said, sitting up. "We've already talked about it so many times. I TOLD him he could. Just because I'm getting nervous now doesn't mean he shouldn't. That would be… wrong."

"You're halfway right," Jackeline sighed as she sat beside her sister. "But now we get into the other part of it."

Rachel looked at her worried. "What's that?"

"Well, now you're going to see if him being with other women is something you actually want," Jackeline said.

Rachel felt her blood run cold. They were running against the truth she'd been avoiding this entire time.

"I have to be ok with it though. I mean, after everything I've done? How can I not be? It would be so unfair."

Jackeline smiled sympathetically. "You're a good person, Rachel. But sometimes, it's not about being fair. It's about fitting one another."

"What do you mean?"

Jackeline turned from her sister and sighed. "I don't know if you're ready to hear this right now."

"No, I am! Please, I need help. I'm so confused," Rachel spoke playfully.

"Alright, are you sure?"

"I am."

Jackeline took Rachel's hand.

"Rachel, just because your partner is ok with something doesn't mean you will be."

"What do you mean?" she asked.

"So, it's pretty obvious that right now, you like exploring things with other men, yes?"

"I do," Rachel admitted.

"But… If you're being honest with yourself, do you like the idea of Noah exploring things with other women?"

Rachel grimaced.

"No… I mean, no initially. I guess… I don't know…" she said shamefully.

"And that isn't necessarily a bad thing, you know that, right?"

"But–"

"No, don't say it's not fair. There isn't such a thing as 'fair' with this kind of stuff. Your brain wants it to be that simple, but it isn't. It seems like Noah does actually enjoy seeing you sleep with other men. But you might not be able to get there like he could. This isn’t about making sure there is an equal exchange. It's about what you need and what he needs, and whether those things are compatible. Does that make sense?"

Rachel nodded slowly.

"So… are you telling me that–"

"I'm not telling you anything, ok? This is something you have to figure out. But what I am saying is just because Noah is ok with you exploring stuff with other men, doesn't mean you have to be ok with him exploring things with other women. You're going to have to be honest with yourself and… well… be honest with him. And then be strong enough to accept whatever comes after."

Rachel sat back and took her sister's words in. She was, of course, right. But another part of her pushed against what she was hearing. Because it meant that if she and Noah couldn't solve this…

"Listen, I can see that look on your face. You don't have to make any decisions today, alright?" Jackeline said.

“I know, I know.” Rachel shook her head. “Why does it have to be so complicated?”

Jackeline rubbed her shoulder gently.

“Well, you DID pick one of the hardest relationship types,” she said teasingly.

Like a pressure valve releasing, Rachel burst out into laughter. Jackeline continued.

“But you’re going to figure it out, I promise. Do you want to do something to get your mind off it?”

"No, I think I just need some time to process," Rachel said.

"Alright," Jackeline hugged her sister tightly. "Just be true to yourself, ok?"

"Ok.”

“Hollar if you need me.”

“I will, seester,” Rachel said with a smile.

Jackeline left Rachel alone with her thoughts. And while there were many, the one she couldn’t let go of was how things had ended with her and Noah just moments ago. After calming down, she pulled out her phone and texted him.

Rachel: I'm sorry :(

He replied almost instantly.

Noah: I am too.

Rachel: I don't know why it's been so hard lately :///

Noah typed for a long while.

Noah: I don't know either.

Rachel slumped back in her bed in her all white bed.

Rachel: I was wrong to get upset

Noah: I was wrong to get mad like that. You were just trying to talk to me.

Rachel: It's ok. I forgive :)

Noah: I forgive too 🙂

Rachel smiled as a tear formed in her eye. She didn't know why, but part of her knew something was coming.

Rachel: How far were you planning on going with this person?

Noah typed, then stopped. Ten minutes passed. Agonizing minutes. He typed again.

Noah: I wasn't really sure? I'm so new to this, I'll probably go with the flow. Don't even know if I will.

Rachel closed her eyes, the pain in her heart lurching.

Rachel: No. You should.

Noah: I don't have to.

Rachel: Please, you should.

Noah: Alright.

Rachel's lips quivered as she slowly typed her last response.

Rachel: I love you.

Noah: I love you too :)

Rachel threw her phone to the side as tears ran down her face.

She stayed there for a while, fighting a terrible sense within her.

That a clock was ticking down.

That a timer was running out.

She stayed there till she lost track of time, only appearing from her room when her stomach began to growl. She made her way into the large, open kitchen, surprised to find it empty. The setting sun bled through the windows and across the floor. She began to walk through the first floor, finding no one in sight.

She then checked her phone and saw that her mother had texted her a few hours ago.

Mom: Darling, Jackie let us know you weren't feeling well. So we decided to let you rest. Laura and I have taken your sister out for dinner to catch up. We promise to bring you back dessert. We will be staying at a hotel in the city. The place is yours for the evening.

All my love, my angel.

Mom: PS. Please don't hesitate to call if you need anything. And ignore your father if he tries to text you. He's been hounding me, and I'm ignoring him for the time being.

Rachel couldn't help but laugh. She hearted her mother's first message.

Rachel: Sounds good, Mom. Love you.

At once, her mother responded.

Mom: Heart Reaction!

She always typed it out, no matter how many times Rachel or Jackeline tried to explain how to react to a message.

Rachel wandered back into the kitchen and inspected the fridge. Not seeing anything to her liking, she decided to head outside and get some air.

She went out the four bay garage and took the walkway that led to the large patio in their backyard. As she approached, she caught the scent of delicious barbecue.

And there, by the pool, she found Jack tending to the grill.

He wore no shirt. The purple and gold skies behind him illuminated his olive skin and red cotton shorts. He wore a thin gold necklace around his neck, and athletic slides on his feet.

As soon as she approached, he turned and looked at her.

"Hey," he said. "Your mom was saying you felt sick."

"Just a rough day," Rachel replied, walking over to the table next to him and sitting.

Jack nodded. "Have you eaten?"

"No."

"You hungry?"

"What are you cooking?"

"Half-cut barbecue chickens. The sides are corn on the cob and mashed potatoes."

"Why are you cooking all that?" she said. Jack's subtle smirk acknowledged the angle of her question, but he still shrugged casually.

"Was hungry, felt like it."

"And you just had to make two chickens, huh?"

"Well, when you cut a chicken in half, you get two pieces," Jack said. He flipped the chicken halves onto two plates, then carefully placed a half-cut corn cob and a scoop of mashed potatoes on each.

He walked to the table and set one plate in front of Rachel.

"Do you like to add anything to your corn cob?" he asked.

"I really hate corn, to be honest," Rachel said.

Jack offered her a set of silverware. Rachel took it delicately from his hands.

"I do too," he said, giving her a playful wink before turning and walking to the outdoor fridge underneath the grill countertop.

"You want something?" he asked.

"Sparkling water is fine," Rachel said.

He returned with one and a beer for himself. Rachel eyed it as he snapped off the cap and took a long swig. Their eyes caught. Jack offered her the beer.

"Here," he said. She hesitated a moment before taking it from him.

"Thanks.”

"No problem.” He went and grabbed another, cracking off its cap as he stared out at the setting sun cresting the mountains.

“It’s beautiful out here, isn’t it?” he said.

Rachel admired the view with him.

“It is,” she said.

Jack sat beside her and began cutting his chicken. Rachel watched him for a moment. But when she found her eyes trailing down his chest, she promptly began to eat.

Jack pulled a paper towel from the table and cleaned his mouth.

"So," he said, "why are you looking so glum?"

Rachel blushed. "I'm not glum."

Jack smirked as he took a swig of his beer.

"I've known you long enough to know that's not true."

Rachel sighed.

"It's dating troubles,” she admitted.

Jack raised his eyebrows with an unsuprised look as he took another swig of beer. Rachel glared at him.

"What?!" she said.

"Oh nothing," he said playfully. "It's just… you know…"

"Yeeeeah?"

"Doing what you're doing… It's inevitably going to cause some problems, Rach," Jack said.

Rachel closed her eyes and sank into her chair. "I guess I don't want to believe that."

Jack nodded. "So what’s giving you two trouble?”

Rachel’s heart began to race. She looked back at him, admiring the cut of his jawline as she wondered if it would be wise to tell him.

But somewhere deep inside herself, she wanted him to know.

"I… asked… to do something… while I'm here."

Jack chuckled as he took a large bite of chicken.

"You don't say."

Rachel rolled her eyes and shook her head.

“Whatever…”

They ate in silence for a moment.

"With me?" Jack asked.

"Yes…" Rachel said bashfully.

"Wooooow… very presumptuous of you."

"What?! I was going to ask you. It’s not like you HAD to say yes."

“But you assumed I would, right?”

Rachel blushed so hard her ears felt hot. Jack nodded triumphantly.

"Thought so… and is this your way of asking me?"

Rachel could feel sweat forming on her brow. "Maybe… I don't know…"

"You don't seem confident."

"I'm not," Rachel said truthfully.

Jack sighed, putting down his fork before looking back out at the mountains.

"Rachel… you have to know by now that I like you."

"I know," Rachel whispered.

"Our parents think we'd be great together."

Rachel groaned. "I know…"

"And, for me, being with you, it would mean something."

Rachel stared at him till he stared back.

"You understand why I can't go there, right?" he said.

Rachel had never felt more embarrassed in her life. He was saying no. To her. It was the first guy to ever say no to her. She hadn’t expected this to be a possibility.

She didn't want to feel hurt by the rejection, but she did. It stunned her into silence.

But… the more she thought about it. Why wouldn't he?

After finally getting a chance to be with him, she was really beginning to see who he actually was. The parties, their fooling around, all of that was only a fraction of who he was. Jack was a good man. A man who clearly wanted a normal, stable relationship.

Rachel was never going to be the kind of girl a guy like him would want.

Or any guy should want.

"Hey, I'm sorry. I didn't mean that in a disrespectful way," Jack said.

"No! No… don't be I…" she laughed weakly. "God… obviously yeah… I don't know why I thought…"

She buried her hands into her face as she let out a comical groan.

“I just don’t know what I’m even doing anymore…” she admitted.

"Hey…" Jack said. “You don’t need to beat yourself up about it.”

“But I’m serious, Jack!”

“You like what you’re doing though, right?”

Rachel shook her head.

“I don’t know. It’s exciting. Sometimes it’s fun. But it’s also scary, and a lot of times I’m not even sure if it’s healthy. I… I’m not sure if I should say more.”

“It’s ok, you’re safe here,” Jack said.

Rachel glanced at him, feeling more exposed than ever.

“There are times where I feel like a slut… and there are times when I don’t, and I’m just having fun. And there are times when I love the idea of being a slut… but I don’t mean that in a gross way! Ugh…”

“You’re fine,” Jack said. “It’s not a bad thing, you know. What you’re doing.”

“I know, everyone says that. But then you do it, and people still make you feel like it is. But that’s… That’s just part of it. It’s not even the part I’m struggling with.”

“What part are you struggling with?”

Rachel sighed as she played with her fork. “Noah wants to start exploring things too…”

“Oh,” Jack sounded somber.

“Yeah.”

“And he hasn’t been up to now?”

Rachel shook her head. “No.”

“Huh.”

“What?”

“Oh, nothing. I just thought he had been.”

That hit Rachel especially hard. “It makes me a bad person, doesn’t it?”

“I didn’t say that,” Jack said. “But if I’m being honest, I don’t envy either of you.”

Rachel rolled her head as she laughed. “Gee, thanks.”

“I’m just saying!”

“No, I get it. Someone like you wouldn’t be into stuff like that.”

“I mean, I tried,” Jack said.

“I remember,” Rachel replied. Jack looked over at her.

“It was a fun night.”

“It was.” Rachel paused. “So you really feel something for me?”

“I do,” Jack admitted. “But I also know what I would need.”

Rachel nodded. “And what would that be?”

“Oh, you know. Just the boring traditional stuff. A girlfriend. Exclusivity. Dreams for the future. Fun adventures. Getting married someday. Nothing you’d be interested in.” Jack’s teasing cadence was as sweet as honey. Rachel pushed his shoulder playfully.

“I happen to want those things too! I just… I don’t know… It’s college! Now’s the time to be having fun.”

“No, I can see that.”

“But you don’t want to?”

Jack shrugged. “I never said that.” He looked longingly into her eyes. “But I also know there are certain people I would hang it all up for.”

Those words were terribly frightening, because Rachel knew exactly what he meant.

She looked away, her heart leaping in ways she had never felt before.

Thankfully, Jack broke the silence for them.

"Listen, I know things have been crazy for you lately, and I also know that our parents haven’t been making it any easier.”

Rachel let out a loud laugh. “I know! Can you believe this?”

Jack laughed as he finished his beer.

“I know they were REALLY hoping you and I would seal the deal tonight. But how about we watch a movie instead?"

His words were sincere, and that’s what made them so dangerous.

Rachel was afraid of what would happen if she was alone in the movie room with him. Jack seemed to sense her hesitation.

"It can just be a movie," he said gently.

"You sure?" she said.

Jack hesitated.

"I'm sure," he replied.

Rachel thought about it for only a second longer, but didn’t need to. She had made her decision long ago. She just didn’t know it yet.

Rachel smiled. "Alright."

Files

Comments

northdrop

Holy dick. That was a HUGE step in Rachel and Noah’s relationship and I hope it actually goes somewhere; Noah needs to be more assertive and forthright with what he’s feeling and I’m glad to see Rachel responding in kind. They could absolutely make this a wonderful thing if they maintain that level of honesty going forward. Both of them could be having way more fun with all this if they were open from the start. If Noah is going to explore something with another person, the most obvious is Mel….but the real brain-melter would be Allison lol that would blow up HARD.

ToSch

Not sure if I would agree with this. This seems like two steps forward and two steps back. Yes, they talked, but they seemingly agreed to things they are both uncomfortable with. I'll have to think about this some more and reread it later in the day, when I have more time, to decide if it's actually an improvement or if the car is just picking up speed before going straight over the cliff.

Banana23

This is one of my favorite chapters in BOF so far. I also see a small ray of hope for Rachel and Noah, but it still doesn't change my prediction that they'll end up separating sometime in the story. Here we see them actually trying to communicate which is great for their relationship, but we are also starting to see signs that their needs and wants are fundamentally incompatible. Looking forward to the next chapters!

JRockk

Well an argument was bound to happen between Rachel and Noah. After the last couple of chapters it seemed to be heading this way. Noah should be more assertive and tell Rachel that at times he feels so alone in this relationship while she's exploring and Rachel is right that he should say exactly what he means while they're exploring. If they had better communicate their feelings it wouldn't be so bad between them. It feels like the rift is just growing more and more and Kudos to Jack for being honest about how he feels about Rachel and what type of relationship he would want from her and not judging her for the decisions she's made.

northdrop

I agree that it is both positive and negative. Positive in that they were both honest with each other…negative in that the honesty didn’t necessarily leave them in a better place. They have been teetering on the edge of a fight for a while, now, and I’m glad there has been movement! Noah could end all of the madness by simply saying, “I doubt myself and have self esteem issues. your father told me you were too good for me and that I should let you go. As a result, watching you with other men is both arousing and terrifying because whilst it brings me joy to see you so happy, it also reinforces my fear that you will leave me for someone better.” Is he ready to have that conversation? Probably not. I think Noah would be a lot happier if Rachel said the obvious, too, “I love you and will never leave you. Sex with other men is fun, yes, but you fulfill me in all the ways that matter. No matter how good the sex is with them, it will never replace the joy and satisfaction I feel from being YOUR girl.” And is Rachel actually feeling that? I think so…but she won’t say it. Or maybe she doesn’t know that’s what she’s feeling , yet. We will just have to see :) in any case, I’m so stoked with how this story is developing

CollinB

Any relationship is a compromise. It’s clear that Rachel’s desire to have fun will always clash to some extent with Noah’s desire to be involved and have a voice. Even if they were to talk through all of this with the utmost honesty right now, as if by magic, the potential for conflict wouldn’t be completely eliminated. Rather, they need to figure out whether each of them is worth this compromise to the other. Ultimately, they need to determine if there’s a balance where Rachel is sufficiently satisfied with other men and, at the same time, Noah doesn’t feel crushed. It may well be that such a balance simply doesn’t exist, in which case breaking up is a reasonable solution.

ToSch

Now that I've had time to sit down and read this chapter properly, I think I know what it reminds me of. It feels like one of those summer thunderstorms that we're getting more and more of here in Europe. You yearn for them, hoping they will cool down the air like they used to, but once they're over, you notice that they actually only increased the humidity and you're objectively worse off than you were before. That's what this entire chapter reminds me of. Yes, Noah and Rachel finally had a talk. Or more accurately, they had a fight. They finally snapped at each other about their problems but ultimately both agreed to things they are not comfortable with. Not just a little uncomfortable, either. Noah teeters between anger and depression/self-hatred and Rachel is in tears. That's not the place you want to be after a clarifying talk, is it? So what did they actually achieve? All I see is that they are about to bring two people into the mix (assuming Noah's pick is Mel) who are already known to not be in it for the purely physical side of things. They both even admitted as much to Noah and Rachel. That won't help at all. It will only make the mess they're in worse. As many of you, and I, said in the last chapters, I simply can't see this working in the long term. Rachel and Noah have totally different needs and ideals about what they want from this relationship and its future. Ironically, even though Rachel seems to start daydreaming again about her life with another one of her (not yet) bulls at the end of this chapter, she and Jack wouldn't work out, in my opinion, for the same reason she and Noah won't work out either: She actually seems to enjoy this lifestyle (Or does she? She seems awfully insistent on thinking of herself as the heroine of a fairy tale or a Prince Charming story with whichever guy she's with.). Noah only does because of his trauma-induced fetish and Jack specifically said in this chapter that it's not for him. However, I currently can't see Rachel stopping this lifestyle. She seems fixated on enjoying being a slut, as she put it. She probably won't stop until she hits rock bottom and sees the ruins of her imagined future(s).

NaughtiWolf

Finally, an honest conversation between Rachel and Noah and it went about as well as expected. I have a strong feeling that Rachel and Jack are going to hook up, regardless of Jack's protests to the contrary. Rachel clearly has complicated feelings about Jack, especially given the pressure her mother and father have put on her. Noah finally growing a backbone, even if it is born from anger and resentment, is a good thing. My concern is that he's going to make poor decisions because resentment has been festering for so long. Resentment and bitterness are the two main destroyers of relationships, especially ones that are non-monogamous. I won't say this is the death knell of their relationship but the internal dialogue of Rachel's half of this chapter indicate that could very well be what we see. The recognition of a timer counting down is ominous and deservedly so. Part of me wants to see Noah and Rachel end up together but another part recognizes that it may not be possible for them.

ToSch

To be honest, whenever we see Rachel's internal dialogue, she seems to have "complicated feelings" about most of the male cast. She strikes me as the personification of the "imagining my whole future with the person who just smiled at me on the street" meme. Maybe this is something that could be attributed to her rather cold and calculated upbringing. Or perhaps it is simply because she is spoiled for choice. It's cerainly not the best foundation on which to build a relationship, and, as you noted, it's probably not a good sign for the future of Noah and Rachel.

Eve St. Albert

I think I've come to understand why I despise Ethan. And for that matter, Rachel's father, Rachel's mother, Jackie. They all, in their way, want to control and own Rachel. Their interactions are fundamentally manipulative - they have different approaches, Ethan is just spoiled and demanding, Rachel's father is bullying and cruel, Rachel's mother is machiavellian and Jackie goes for head games. But they're all despicable. Even Jack, who is the best of the bunch, is clearly conditional - 'my way or the highway' he just offers Rachel his terms and the option of saying no. That's why I love Noah so much, his love for Rachel is unconditional. He doesn't make demands, he doesn't try to manipulate or take control. He takes Rachel as she is, and lets her be herself. Herself just happens to be a really promiscuous slut, but Noah is mostly okay with that. Also, she's deeply insecure. I think Mel has has her number, but I like her. I also like Mel. I think the 'fight' such as it was, is a positive thing. Both Rachel and Noah need to come to grips with their insecurities or they won't make it. I think Noah fucking Mel, and Rachel working through her insecurity and accepting Mel would be healthy for her. I'm hoping for a threesome (or a Lesbian encounter) actually - just because I'd love the feeling of tentativeness and uncertainty between Mel and Rachel works for me.

NaughtiWolf

One thing to remember is that Rachel's maybe 22 or 23. How many of us got lost in flights of fancy about a cute guy or woman at that age? Let's say the roles were reversed and this was a traditional harem story with Noah at the center and Rachel being one of a bevy of women vying for his affection. Use the same internal dialogue Rachel has in these chapters, just gender-swap the pronouns and focus. Would you have the same criticisms of Noah?

NaughtiWolf

I think Jackie's speaking some good truths to Rachel but because she doesn't have the full context of Noah's trauma, she's making assumptions. One of the problems with Rachel right now is she's so conflicted that she can't get her bearings to make proper decisions. She's rudderless, to use a nautical term. And rather than doing the deep introspection she needs to do, she's about to make a decision that will have further consequences she's probably not going to like.

ToSch

I probably wouldn't have. But that's not because of the gender switch for the character receiving attention. I think most of our disagreements in the last couple of chapters stem from how we perceive this story and in which genre we would place it. You wrote in the past that you think of it as a reverse harem story, right? As you've noted before, I read it more as a core couple experimenting with cuckolding and potentially sharing, but currently failing pretty badly at it. Why? Because, in my opinion, they're going way too fast, involving way too many partners, and are way too close to home in their choices of people, all while having absolutely no guardrails and horrible communication. Having flights of fancy isn't uncommon. You're absolutely right about that. However, acting on them without a basis to fall back on and with no proper communication, as we see in this story, will probably destroy the core relationship on which everything is built.

NaughtiWolf

Eve St. Albert posted this in the comments of the recent "Rules" chapter and I think it fits for BoF as well. There's a tendency in stories like this to automatically blame the woman MC, especially when she's perceived as a "slut". Your agreement that you probably wouldn't be as harsh on Noah if the roles were reversed and he were the one getting to select from a group of willing women kinda points to that double-standard. Best of Friends absolutely started off as a cuckolding/hotwife/sharing situation, with Noah and Rachel as a core couple. The narrative shifted into a Reverse Harem (if you go on MrJakobs website, he has Best of Friends listed as Reverse Harem), which meant the narrative focus has shifted to Rachel figuring out what she really wants and if she really has to "choose" between all of these guys. Obviously, choices have to be made and I agree that they never fully established guardrails and communication. I think the narrative is starting to shift again, with Noah finally starting to speak up, even if its in fits and starts. He's not going to suddenly put his foot down but I think as time goes on, things are going to come to a head. The fight in this chapter feels like a preview for a confrontation that Noah and Rachel will have when she comes back from Colorado and they're able to see each other face to face again.

ToSch

Perhaps I didn't phrase my post correctly, as I certainly didn't intend to come across as sexist. The pitfalls of being a non-native speaker! :D What I was trying to convey is that I wouldn't judge a male character for having these thoughts if I perceived the narrative as a harem one and the same goes for a female character in that narrative. I just don't currently see this story as a harem one. If you say that Mr Jakobs officially labels it as such, then I must be getting the wrong impression. My bad!

Eve St. Albert

That Jackie is speaking 'truths' doesn't mean that she's not manipulating Rachel. She is pushing Rachel into Jack, while at the same time trying to strategically engineer a confrontation between Rachel and Noah under the guise of 'honesty.' She's trying to push Rachel into a situation where she has a big fight with Noah. Mission accomplished. Then she'll sympathetically be 'honest' with Rachel that clearly Noah is not right for her, and that she doesn't know what she wants. Then she'll sympathetically be 'honest' and point out that Jack is right there, he's willing and able, and she likes to get fucked ... so why not. Of course, Jack's rule is monogamy. So there'll be another 'honest' conversation where she points out that monogamy is not so bad, and Jack is really nice, but it's completely up to her. Yeah, I've met 'honest' people speaking 'truths.' They're the worst, ugliest gaslighters of all.

ToSch

I think that interpretation of Jackie's talking points is pretty harsh. Her whole conversation with Rachel just seems to me like her trying to help her sister navigate the complicated relationship that Rachel and Noah are in. She advocated for cool heads, boundaries, and clear communication in her first call with Rachel and it seems to me like she's still trying to help them stay on a healthy course. The stuff that one could potentially classify as bad faith advice stems, in my opinion, from the fact that, as NaughtiWolf pointed out, she's missing some crucial pieces of the puzzle, which Rachel couldn't inform her about because she isn't aware of them either. Looking at their first phone call and this conversation and imagining them knowing about Noah's trauma and PTSD, I'm pretty sure that her advice would look very different. She just doesn't strike me as the controlling gaslighter you seem to perceive her as. The rest of the family? Sure, they seem like a bunch of conniving snakes. But Jackie? I'm not really seeing it.

Eve St. Albert

People can manipulate and gaslight you, even gaslight you with 'manipulative honesty' and think they're doing it for your own good. Jackie can honestly believe that she's letting Rachel live her own life, while at the same time believe that Rachel is fucking up her life and that Jack would be a really good match and positive influence. "I'm only doing it for you." and "I only want the best for you." and so forth comes up all the time.