Best of Friends 54 - Transition (Patreon)
Content
Rachel awoke with a headache and spinning thoughts. She enjoyed the briefest moment of peace as she absently gazed around her white room. Then the memories from the night before found her.
It hit all at once in a beautiful, terrible flash.
She remembered being on Jack’s lap. Clutching tufts of his hair as he buried his face in between her breasts. She could still feel his tongue slide against her skin before it twirled around her nipple.
She remembered the passion she saw in his eyes as he rested his weight on top of her, pressing his lips against hers as they shared a mixture of chemistry entirely their own.
It was frightening.
And perfect.
It was memories Rachel knew she would never forget, both good and bad.
She rolled onto her back and rubbed her eyes with a soft groan, then glanced at her phone. She couldn’t bear to pick it up just yet. At least not until she'd had some time to process everything that had happened. So instead, Rachel got herself up and slowly wandered into her private bathroom. She entered her walk-in shower, turned on the water, and let it run down her body as she leaned against the blue tile wall.
She let out a slow, painful sigh. She processed the memories and feelings as they came, steadying her breath with each one.
She tried to think of something else, anything else besides how much her heart was leaping in her chest.
But all she could think about was Jack. And how much guilt she felt about Noah.
She shut off the water and stepped out absently, and as she wrapped her towel around her body, she heard her bedroom door crack open.
Jack stepped into the center of the room. Rachel saw him before he saw her. She marveled for a moment.
“Rachel?” he called, before looking up and straight into the open bathroom door. Straight at Rachel, who clung to her towel with both arms to her chest.
They froze as lightning found them again.
“Sorry, I can go,” Jack said, beginning to turn.
“It’s fine,” Rachel blurted out. Jack stopped and froze. He turned back, but kept his eyes averted.
“Do you want to get dressed?”
She did. She didn’t. Whatever spark she felt kept her there, because she wanted him to see.
“I have a towel,” Rachel said. “What is it?”
Jack slowly glanced back over at her. “I uh… I guess I wanted to talk about last night.”
Rachel nodded, resting one leg up on the bathroom sink.
“Alright.”
“I guess I wanted to apologize. If I… I don’t know… gave the wrong impression.”
“You didn’t,” Rachel said. “I should be the one saying sorry. I tried to push things after you told me you weren’t comfortable doing it.”
“That’s actually what I wanted to talk about,” Jack said quickly.
Rachel breathed in as she tempered her nerves. “A-alright.”
“When we… were together last night…”
“Yeah?”
“Did you…” Jack laughed and shook his head. “Did you… feel something? And I don’t mean being turned on, I mean more than that. Did you feel what I felt?”
Rachel smiled, looking away as she pushed her wet hair behind her ears.
“You felt it too?” she said.
Jack took a step towards her, but stopped himself just outside the bathroom threshold.
“I did,” he confirmed.
Rachel laughed softly and shook her head.
“Jesus…” She covered her mouth with her palm. “Jack, I’m not sure what is happening between us… but—”
“It’s ok,” Jack said. “I… I’m not looking for you to give me more than that. I just needed to know.”
Rachel couldn’t bear to look at him, not yet.
“I think I did too,” she said.
Jack let out a long, deep breath.
“Well… obviously there’s a lot to think about.”
“Of course,” Rachel chimed in.
“I’ll give you your space. But Rachel?”
“Yeah?”
She finally found the courage to look at him.
“I think I’d like to feel what I felt last night for the rest of my life.” He paused. “If that’s what you wanted also.”
The magnitude of those words stunned her into silence. Jack didn’t wait for her to answer. He smiled and turned, leaving her alone with her thoughts.
She didn’t remember coming down the stairs. Or sitting down at the kitchen island as her mother glanced back with a knowing smile.
“Goooood morning, my sweet angel,” she said.
"Morning, Mom…" Rachel said absently. “When did you guys get in?”
“Oh, around nine this morning. We tried our best to be quiet and give you your rest.” Her mother turned with freshly cooked turkey sausages still in a frying pan. "I saw that the movie theatre room was used last night…"
Rachel blushed at her mother’s sheepishly excited grin, reaching for a cup of coffee that was already waiting for her. Her mother then leaned in while glancing side to side.
“I also saw Jack coming down the stairs from your room just now?”
Rachel glanced up at her. She seemed so excited. It was the same look she’d given Rachel at her graduation. The same look she gave when Rachel had been accepted to Godfrey.
It was the look of a mother who was so happy for their daughter.
"I take it you both had a good night?" she asked eagerly.
Rachel groaned. "Mom…"
"Ohhhh, don't worry, sweetheart. Your secret is safe with me," she said with a wink, dropping several sausages on her plate before kissing Rachel’s forehead.
And while she meant well, the words stung deeply.
Rachel was beginning to feel the gravity of what she’d actually done. Her mother seemed to notice, and softened her tone.
"He's a good man, Rachel,” she said.
Rachel stared at her plate. "I know." She buried her face into her hands as a wave of shame ran through her.
“Oh darling…” Her mother rubbed her shoulder. Rachel shook her head as she fought back the tears. “It’s ok, my angel…”
“Mom…” Rachel could barely fight through the words. “Noah…”
“Oh, sweetheart, I know, I know. But it’s ok. These things happen, my love. You are young.”
Rachel shook her head as her mother moved promptly to the other side of the kitchen island and embraced her.
“Oh, you have such a big heart,” she said gently.
Rachel started to break out into soft sobs.
“I don’t want to hurt him,” she said between shaking breaths.
Her mother answered by kissing the top of her head and holding her close.
“It’s alright,” she said, caressing her back.
Rachel rode through the painful wave, eventually landing into the gentle embrace of her mother.
“Heeeey!” she heard Jackeline call as she stepped into the kitchen from behind them.
“Not now, darling. Your sister is having a moment,” her mother said softly. “Come back in thirty?”
“Ok…” Jackeline said.
Then, her mother knelt beside Rachel and wiped the tears from her eyes.
“You starting to feel better?” she asked her, fixing her hair.
“I don’t know what to do, Mom.”
“You will,” her mother said, looking her in the eyes. “You will.”
As Rachel’s lips began to tremble, her mother placed her hands on her cheeks.
“Oh no, no more of that. You are so strong, Rachel,” she spoke with enough confidence for them both. Rachel nodded as she took a very deep breath. At once, her nerves began to ease.
Her mother’s fingers trailed through her hair as she marveled at her daughter's beauty.
“You are so very strong…” she said. “I am so proud of you.”
Rachel scoffed. “Mom…”
“I mean it. I know your father and I haven’t been the best parents. But for all of our faults, you have made up for them more than double. Which is why I know you are strong enough for this.”
Rachel sniffed, pouting comically. “Is this when you try to convince me to be with Jack?”
Her mother laughed warmly. “You know how I feel. There is no need to say more. But do you know what I want more than that?”
“What?”
Her mother leaned close enough for Rachel to smell the familiar scent of her perfume.
“I want you to be happy.”
It made Rachel’s eyes water as she nodded.
“Do you mean that?”
“Of course I do. Which is why I will only say one more thing on the matter.”
“What?”
For the first time in Rachel’s adult life, she saw the strong face her mother always wore melt away. Beneath it was a more tired, more vulnerable woman that Rachel didn’t recognize.
“If you truly feel something real, wherever it might lie, you should chase it. It is ok to discover it at the wrong time, but that doesn’t mean you need to ignore it.” She looked into her daughter’s eyes sadly. “Don’t stay in something so empty like I did.”
She’d never heard her mom say that out loud. It suddenly made all her plights seem so small.
“Oh mom…”
“No no, my days to cry are behind me. I made my decision, and it brought me a happy life and two wonderful daughters.” There was only a glint of wetness to her eyes. “But if I were able to keep my daughters from the same fate, I would.”
She rubbed the last tear from Rachel’s cheek before kissing her on the head once more.
And like a mother should, she eased the burden from her daughter's shoulders, and left her a little lighter.
“I love you, Mom,” Rachel said.
“I love you too, my angel.” Her mother made her way back over to the kitchen and began to cook as if nothing had happened. “Now, we have business to discuss.”
Rachel laughed. “Business?”
“Family. Business.” Her mother said pointedly. “Oh, Jackie! You can come out of the guest room. We’re finished,” she shouted.
Jackie peered sheepishly from around the corner with an exaggerated pout, eyes furrowed in mock concern.
“Are you ok, seeester?” She approached Rachel with her arms wide open. Rachel opened her own and embraced her.
“Yesss, I’m ok,” Rachel said flatly.
“Are you sure?” Jackeline asked sweetly.
“Yes…”
“Alright,” Jackeline sat down next to Rachel with a final rub of her back.
“Do you want some sausage, Jackie?” their mother asked.
“Yeah, I’ll take a few. Did you talk to Rachel about the plan yet?”
Their mother turned and placed several sausages onto Jackeline’s plate.
“It was just about to,” she said.
Rachel looked at them both suspiciously. “What plan?” she asked.
Her mother looked at Jackeline. “Why don’t you tell her, darling?”
“Tell me what, Jackie?” Rachel asked.
Jackeline picked up a sausage and took a bite out of it.
“Mom convinced me to stay for another week.”
“Oh, don’t make it sound like I twisted your arm. I offered, and you said yes,” their mother countered.
“Uh huh… so why are you staying?” Rachel asked. Their mother chimed in.
"There's a special air show going on, and she wanted to catch it before we all part ways." Their mother waved a spatula in the air. "Plus, I'd like to think she is enjoying time with her dear sister and mother."
Jackeline nodded as she took another bite. “I mean, that too.”
Rachel laughed softly. "So is this where you ask me if I want to stay to?"
Her mother glanced back. "Am I so obvious?"
"Always, Mom."
"I never did learn your father's subtlety, did I?"
Rachel had no idea what her mom was talking about.
"Would you consider staying?" her mother asked. Returning with a stack of waffles, of which Jackeline promptly took several. Rachel stared at them for a moment as she contemplated the prospect.
"Would… Jack be staying too?" she asked.
Jackeline and her mother looked at one another with suppressed smiles.
"I'm sure he could be persuaded," her mother said sweetly.
Rachel was surprised at how excited that made her feel.
"Alright, it does sound nice."
"Oh, how wonderful! Don't you worry about a thing. I will speak with Laura and Jack. I'm sure they'd be elated to stay for another week."
Rachel's heart leaped as she did her best to avoid Jackeline’s searching eyes.
"Where are they, by the way?" she asked.
"Oh, they went out for a few little errands and sightseeing, Jack's idea. He’s such a wonderful son."
Rachel smiled. He really was.
"You think Dad will be mad?" she asked.
Her mother sat on the opposite side of the island with a plate of greens, sliced meats, and cut fruit. "Oh, most certainly."
Rachel laughed as her phone went off. She looked down at it, heart dropping when she saw it was Noah.
Her mother spotted it and glanced up at Rachel.
"Well, you better answer that,” she said.
Jackeline looked between them, confused, until her eyes also caught the phone.
“Ahhhh, yeah, you should,” Jackeline tried to find her sister’s once more, but when she couldn’t, she stood with her cup of coffee. “I’m gonna chill by the pool. Mom, you want to join me?”
“That sounds lovely. Rachel, you're welcome to join us after,” she said, standing and following Jackeling out the back sliding door. As she passed Rachel, she squeezed her shoulder gently.
“You will be alright,” she whispered.
Rachel smiled without a word, waiting till they had left.
Rachel stared at her phone, a part of her seeming to know something was coming.
She still didn't know how she felt about that, even when she answered the call.
–
Noah stared outside his dorm window as the phone rang, grateful he had the dorm to himself. When Rachel answered, his heart stilled.
"Hey," she said.
"Hey," Noah replied, sensing the tension between them both.
"How are you doing?" she asked.
"Good, actually. I wanted to call because, well… I went on a date, and I wanted you to know."
Silence fell on the line.
"Oh,” she said.
Noah didn't crumble when he heard her discomfort. Instead, he took a deep breath. "Yeah, I just wanted to let you know."
"So… how did it go?" Rachel's voice was cold and stiff.
"Good, actually. It was nice,” Noah found himself smiling as he spoke.
Another pause.
"Did you…?"
"No, we didn't sleep together. We did kiss though," he said.
"Oh." Rachel sounded like she was miles away. Present but gone. “Did you do anything else, like mess around or anything?”
“Not really, just talked, hung out, and ended with a kiss.”
“Oh,” Rachel said again.
Noah fought the urge to apologize, to search for a reason which explained why this was all his fault, to take on Rachel's discomfort as his own. Instead, he sat patiently and waited for her to process.
"So, is that it?" she asked.
"Yeah," Noah said.
"That's why you called?" She almost sounded disappointed. But Noah stopped himself from reading into it.
"Well, I mean, it felt important to let you know right away. Plus, I wanted to check in. We haven’t been talking much."
Again, the line went silent. At this point, Noah already knew what that meant.
"How did your night go?" he asked.
"Uhm, well…" Rachel let out an uncomfortable laugh. "It was good. A good night… I was home alone with Jack, and we hung out…"
Noah closed his eyes and shook his head. She'd done it again. After all this time and all these talks, she did the same thing she always managed to do. And somehow, Noah knew she would. He took a deep breath.
"Did you guys do something?" he asked. Already knowing the answer.
Rachel laughed again, as if it were a joke.
"Things got a little steamy…" she admitted.
"I asked you to text first, remember?” he said.
“I mean… yes but—”
“Why didn't you text first, Rachel?" Noah asked.
"It happened so fast, we weren't even going to–"
"But you did."
Rachel paused. "W-we did."
"So you could have texted," Noah said flatly.
"Y-you're right…" she was stumbling.
And as she stumbled, a wave of comfort and certainty hit Noah. A snap, perhaps. An epiphany. A change. Perhaps all of it.
"I mean, I could give you the details. It's not like I want to hide it from you," Rachel tried to meet him in the middle, tried to throw a bridge across a gap that had grown too far.
But something in her voice betrayed her. Her offer felt like a formality rather than something authentic.
"That's alright, I actually don't really want to hear the details anymore," Noah said.
Rachel couldn't muster a response. It was only stutters for a long while. Noah was stunned himself. It’d been the first time he’d ever said something like that, and he wasn't certain what would happen next.
"You heading home soon?" he asked.
"Well, actually… my mom convinced me to stay here a little longer."
Another fracture, another step towards certainty. And strangely, Noah was relieved to hear it.
"Alright,” he said calmly.
"You're ok with it?" she asked, surprised.
"Yeah, it’s fine," he said.
"Ok, well, I will definitely be sure to tell you if Jack and I decide to–"
"Honestly Rachel, don't worry about it," Noah said.
The heart flexes only so much before it breaks. When it does, it can't come back.
"Alright…" Rachel said.
"I'm probably going to go on another date," Noah said.
"With… with the same person?" Rachel asked.
"Yes."
She laughed, but it was nervous now. It was broken now.
"Ok." She sounded so innocent and lost.
"I guess we'll talk later?" he said.
"I guess so."
"Alright."
A pause. Noah usually would have waited for those words he always longed to hear. Words that had been said before, but now wouldn’t feel real. Perhaps it was because of him, perhaps it was because of her. Noah wasn’t sure it really mattered.
"I'll talk to you later, Rach," he said.
"Ok, Noah… talk to you later."
Noah hung up and watched the clouds pass as he thought in silence, certain one of them looked like a giraffe.
He smiled.
There is no ceremony when something becomes final. It simply does.
He looked back down at his phone and called Rachel’s number again.
“Hello?” she said, confused.
“Hey, so, there’s actually one more thing I wanted to say. I wasn’t sure if I should wait a little longer, or until your back, but now feels like the right time.”
“Ok…” Rachel sounded worried. Noah didn’t blame her. He was barely able to think as adrenaline flooded his brain.
But for all the worry he felt, one thing was very different.
Noah was finally able to face it.
“I think we should break up.”