Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Elijah struggled with his key, then shoved his apartment door open and dropped his bag beside a set of shoes. With a sigh, he slowly walked into the living room and spotted Ryan sitting on the couch alone, watching the latest Crusador series on low volume.

“Hey man,” Elijah said tiredly as he walked into the kitchen.

Ryan glanced back a thim. "Damn, you were out late.”

"It's not that late," Elijah opened the fridge and grabbed a jug of orange juice and a dirty glass from the sink.

"It's one in the morning," Ryan said. Elijah froze and glanced at the clock.

"No shit…" he poured his juice and walked over to the couch and sat down, then did a double take when he noticed the hickies covering Ryan's neck. When Ryan tried to cover them up, Elijah laughed.

"What?!" Ryan said.

"I take it you two had a good time?" Elijah replied, casually taking a sip of his juice.

Ryan’s cheeks flashed crimson as he fought to contain a smile.

"She was dressed as a fucking vampire dude…"

Elijah's eyes perked up. "A vampire?!"

"Bro! It was a whole goth outfit, and she did a whole roleplaying thing!"

"Holy shit… well, that explains the hickies." Elijah’s voice trailed off as he finished his drink and set the glass aside.

"It was mind blowing,” Ryan said absently.

Elijah had no doubt about that.

"Is she still here?" he asked.

"Yeah, sleeping in your room," Ryan said. Elijah nodded as he melted into the couch.

"And how are you feeling after all that?" he asked.

Ryan thought for a moment, then shrugged. "I don't know… a little weird? Do you feel that at all?"

"Kinda, yeah," Elijah admitted.

Ryan let out a relieved sigh. "Thank god it's not just me. I've never done something like this before.”

“You haven’t done anything before,” Elijah said.

Ryan laughed. “Fair point... Have you… you know… been in a situation like this?"

"Only once, but not quite like this," Elijah admitted. "And look, it clearly works for Ev and me, but I want you to know that if it ever gets to be too much for you, just say so. The last thing I’d want you thinking is that you need to be a part of this thing since we live together.”

“Thanks, Elijah. It’s working for now, but if that changes, I’ll let you know.” Ryan paused for a moment. “Can I ask you something though?”

“Sure.”

“So are we… like… a throuple, or whatever?”

Elijah rested his hands behind his head. “Good question… I don’t think throuple is the right word. I’d say it’s more like a casual situationship between you and us.”

“Oh…”

Elijah glanced over curiously. “Are you ok with that?”

“Hm? Oh yeah, to be honest I prefer it that way. I was actually getting more nervous that you wanted to be a throuple.”

“What, you don’t want to be a throuple with us?” Elijah said with a smile.

“Listen, you guys are great, but I want to keep myself open for… well… my own thing…”

Elijah nodded. “I’m just messing around. And I’m sure Ev feels the same way. But if anything changes, we’ll talk.”

“That works.”

They watched the show for a little while.

“Man, they really got Sweeny’s character down, didn’t they?” Elijah said.

“Dude, this show is so fucking cool. You have to watch it.”

“I’ll put it on the list.”

Another pause.

“So your own thing, huh?” Elijah said.

Ryan blushed. “I mean, some day yeah… I know I’m not like, the hottest but—”

“No, I didn’t mean it like that. I’m happy for you! You should go for it.”

“You really think I could?” Ryan said.

“Get a girlfriend? Yeah, of course,” Elijah replied. “No doubt in my mind.”

Ryan smiled faintly. “Thanks, man.”

“Don’t mention it.” Elijah stood and slapped Ryan on the shoulder. "I'm going to turn in. Don't stay up too late."

"I won't," Ryan said.

Elijah gave him a wave as he walked into his bedroom. There, he found Evelyn on his bed, curled tightly into a little ball. He closed the door carefully behind himself, watching her for a moment as she shifted slightly and pulled at the light throw blanket wrapped around her waist. Her bare chest and smooth legs were exposed, her plain black underwear barely visible as she shifted slightly. Elijah glanced over and saw her latex outfit thrown onto his chair along with her coat, and envied that Ryan had gotten a chance to see her in it. He took off his shirt and pants and climbed into bed, cuddling up behind her and pulling her into his chest.

Evelyn moaned softly as Elijah wrapped his arms around her. He smelt her hair as she pressed herself into his embrace, taking in that beautiful, flowery scent he never wanted to forget. As he did, he felt her nails trail up his forearm.

"I tried to stay up," she whispered sleepily. "But you were out so late."

"I know, I got caught up finalizing the products for the new marketing campaign," he stroked her arm as he spoke.

"Ooooh, sounds fun. The girls will be excited."

"Val and Jackie are already ecstatic."

Evelyn rolled to face him and smiled. "I'm so happy to hear that."

"And how was work for you?" Elijah asked. Evelyn groaned. "Oh no, what is it?"

"Ugh…” Evelyn buried her face in Elijah’s chest. “We have to have a talk, Elijah.”

"Oooh shit. What about?" Elijah asked, still more playful than serious. Evelyn looked him in the eyes before gently tapping on his chest.

"We have beef."

Elijah furrowed his brow. "Wait, we do?"

"Mhmmm, I'm kinda fucking pissed if I'm being honest."

Elijah's playfulness quickly disappeared, replaced by a steady and calm demeanor.

"Alright, tell me what’s going on. Am I going to need to buy a dog house?" he asked. Evelyn got a little closer, pressing her nose up to his.

"This is serious stuff."

"Ok, I’m all ears,” he said gently.

Evelyn clenched her jaw, a tinge of fear flashing in her eyes before she spoke.

"Fuck!" She buried her head in his chest again.

"Come on, you can tell me, Ev."

Evelyn took a very long, deep breath.

"Ivan says he asked you if you wanted to listen that one night. He said you knew he was going to call you and that it was your choice to listen." She looked back into his eyes. "Please tell me that isn't true."

Elijah grew somber. "Well, it wasn't exactly like that. But, yes, he did call me, and I did know."

Elijah saw the light leave Evelyn’s eyes as she pushed herself off his chest. He immediately let her go and watched as she rolled onto her back. She said nothing, and Elijah gave her a moment to process before continuing.

"I need to make it clear. We weren't talking about it like it was some secret plan. I wasn’t trying to do something behind your back. He kept pushing, and I kept telling him it was your job and not my business."

"But you still listened in, right? Couldn’t pass that up?" Evelyn said matter of factly, not removing her eyes from the ceiling.

Elijah rolled onto his back too, rubbing his face with a heavy sigh.

"Fuck, this is embarrassing… I'm not trying to make excuses, but when I said yes, I wasn’t trying to do something sneaky."

"Then why didn't you tell me that's what happened?" Evelyn countered.

"Because I was embarrassed."

Evelyn shook her head and glanced over at him, annoyed.

"Embarrassed? You fucking lied to me because you were fucking embarrassed?"

"Yeah, I guess I did," Elijah admitted calmly.

"Jesus, Elijah… Is this your way of telling me you're a fucking coward?"

"No!" Elijah said, sitting up. "Look, I clearly fucked up, alright? You can rake me over the coals for that. I deserve it. But listen, Ivan was being a total piece of shit, and I didn't want you thinking he was getting into my head. He started doing this fucking mind game, and he wouldn’t fucking leave it alone! He just kept prodding and prodding. He even suggested he would end things if I didn’t agree. And I guess I felt like he was trying to set us up to fail. So I decided not to play into it. I wanted him to shut the fuck up, and I wanted him to know he couldn’t fuck with us. So yeah, I said yes. But I said in like a 'please leave us the fuck alone' kinda way."

Evelyn stared at the ceiling for a little while longer. "Buuuut you still HAD to listen, right?”

“Yeah… ok… fair point.”

Evelyn scoffed as she shook her head in disgust. “There is no way in fuck you're getting lucky tonight."

"Also fair."

He heard Evelyn swear under her breath.

"It’s really fucking gross you fucking did that, Elijah,” she said.

"Also very fair."

She sighed and shook her head. "Fuck!" She rolled out of bed and began to pace back and forth. Elijah watched calmly, letting her do what she needed to do. She glanced at him.

“Don’t fucking look at me right now!” she snapped.

Elijah nodded. “Alright, I won’t. You want to get dressed?”

“No! I’m not getting dressed so you can look wherever the fuck you want! Fucking look away!”

“Ok,” Elijah said gently. He let her pace for a while longer, keeping his eyes on the ceiling.

"So like is that what I am to you?" she said.

"What do you mean, Ev?"

"Am I just a fucking whore?! Is that why you’re dating me?! Just a fuck doll you can pawn out to all your friends and any fucking creep who will let you have a show?"

"No, Ev," Elijah said calmly.

"And what about Ryan? Did you have him call you so you could listen in on that too? Or maybe that’s why Henry conveniently showed up tonight?!"

“Wait, you saw Henry tonight?” Elijah glanced over at her.

“OOOH, you didn’t know?! And don’t fucking look at me!”

"Ev!" Elijah raised his voice for a moment, but when he saw the fury in Evelyn's eyes spark, he closed his own and took a deep breath. "You have every right to be angry right now."

"Thanks for telling me," she said flatly.

"But I promise you, I am not doing stuff like that to you. Ivan caught me off balance, and I fucked up. I swear, I will NEVER do it again."

He opened his eyes and met hers. He could see her shell drop for an instant, just for a small second, before it flared back up again as she stormed to his chair and sat down with a hard drop. It slid back on its rollers slightly as she crossed her legs, glaring at Elijah.

"I want to believe you," she said coldly.

"You don't have to right now if you don't want to," Elijah said.

"I feel like you're fucking playing me," her voice began to shake.

She was afraid. Elijah could see it. He turned to the edge of the bed and looked at her with love and remorse.

"I promise, I'm not. It was super fucked up. I should NEVER have said yes. I should NEVER have entertained his fucking creepy little games. And I should NEVER have listened in on you two. I should have told him to fuck off, I should have told you what was happening, and I should have hung up when he called."

Evelyn’s eyes reddened as she looked away to hide them.

"You fucking used me, Elijah…" she said softly. Elijah looked down at the floor.

"When you put it that way, it really helps me realize how fucked up it is."

He watched and waited. No matter what happened next, she deserved his undivided attention. She took another deep breath as she gazed cautiously into his eyes.

"Do you really like me for me?" she asked.

"Of course I do."

"So if I stopped fucking your little friend group, and stopped letting you see me fuck men, and banned you from all my accounts, and didn’t you with your business, and became boring, poor, ugly, and fat, you'd still love me?"

Elijah leaned forward, heart racing in his chest as he built up the courage to tell the truth.

"I want to spend the rest of my life with you, Ev. No matter what you decide to do or not do."

Evelyn's eyes softened. Elijah cautiously smiled.

"I love everything about you. It was never just about your job or our dynamic”

Her body shook as she curled into a tight ball and stared at him in terror.

"Do you really mean that?" she said.

"Yes."

She paused. "I'm still really fucking mad at you."

"That's ok, you can be mad as long as you want.”

Then, after examining him for what felt like ages, Evelyn let out another groan as she looked up at the ceiling. "You are SO fucking lucky this happened after I fucking fell in love with you. Like for real. I would have dumped your ass so fast."

Elijah let out a deep breath as his shoulders relaxed. "And you would have had every right to, just like you do now."

Evelyn glared at him again, then looked back up at the ceiling.

"So are you going to come over here and fucking hug me or not?"

Elijah stood at once and walked over to her. As he did, Evelyn stood, moving quickly into his open embrace as he wrapped his arms around her tightly. Then, after a while, Elijah felt Evelyn slowly hug him back.

"I love you so much, Ev," Elijah said gently.

She held him tightly, equal parts comforted and terrified.

"I love you too," she said. Then, on impulse, as if required and rehearsed, she reached for his cock and squeezed it. Not wanting to, not even desiring that kind of touch. It was just what she thought she needed to do.

Elijah gently reached for her hand and brought it up to his waist. Then caressed the side of her face.

"Why don't we just hold each other tonight?" he said.

At once, Evelyn melted. She pressed against him as silent tears streamed down her face.

As Elijah squeezed her tightly.

So very tightly.

Like a strong wind might take her away if he didn’t.

Playing with her hair as they rocked back and forth. As he took them back to the bed, and let her rest on his chest as he lay back.

Long enough for her to calm down.

Long enough for her to think clearly again.

Long enough for her to realize what kind of man he was, and what they could become.

"Promise me one thing," Evelyn said.

"Anything," Elijah replied.

She pulled away from his chest and looked him squarely in the eyes, pointing at him.

"From now on, I want the WHOLE truth. Got it? No more embarrassed bullshit. No more bitch moves, either. If Ivan, or ANYONE tries to fuck with us, have the fucking balls to push back, got it? And don't EVER lie to me again."

"I promise, Ev," Elijah said somberly.

"I fucking MEAN it, Elijah."

"I promise," he said again.

Then, at once, her voice softened. "Alright."

And pain followed. Betrayal perhaps. She thought Elijah was different. And he was. And he wasn't. She didn't know. But she loved him.

"I blew him, by the way," Evelyn said.

"Who?" Elijah asked.

"Ryan."

Elijah couldn't help but chuckle. "Oh, ok."

"Don't laugh!" Evelyn said as she joined him. "It's supposed to be sexy."

"It is! It is… I wasn’t expecting that transition.”

“And what were you expecting?”

“More of a lashing, honestly.”

"Mmmm, and you'd deserve it, too," Evelyn said, pressing her forehead against his. "So anyway, I sucked him off."

They laughed so hard it hurt their sides.

"He’d mentioned something about a vampire outfit?” Elijah said.

"Ooooh, he told you about that, huh?" Evelyn said sweetly.

"You should have heard him, Ev. You made his night."

"Awwee, that makes me so happy. I had it on for a while. I wanted you to see it too, but I got tired and wanted to shower before sleeping."

"My loss, I guess," Elijah said.

She caressed the side of his cheek, then kissed it lightly before burying her head into his neck. "I will do it for you too one day, I swear."

"I can't wait," he said, kissing her again. Her smile dimmed for a moment, a rift of emotions coming back.

"And you're REALLY ok with me doing what I did?"

"What with Ryan?"

"Yes."

"Of course I am, and I promise. It's not all about that."

A pause.

"I've never met someone who's actually ok with that," she said with suspicion. Elijah could sense her newfound distrust, and he had earned it. Instead of growing worried or defensive, he squeezed her tight.

"Well, I've never met someone like you, but I'm really glad I did," he replied.

"Guess that makes us the perfect little pair…"

"Guess so."

Evelyn traced her nail on his chest.

"There's more tea," she said.

"Between you and me?"

"Noo, you're off the hook. For now."

"Thank god. But let me guess, about Ivan?"

"And Henry," Evelyn said.

"Oh right, Henry!”

"Which do you want first?" Evelyn asked.

Elijah sighed. "Well, let's start with Henry."

"Oooook. So. He was at the club tonight."

"Was he?"

"Yup."

"And what happened?"

"I took all his fucking money, that's what happened."

"Wait, what?! Did you mess with him?!" Elijah asked. This time, he pulled away.

Evelyn's eyes widened when he did. "Ok… I can see how this is kind of hypocritical on my part… but there was a good reason."

Elijah's face went deadpan. "Oh really?"

"Yes, really! He wanted to cheat Elijah! Behind your fucking back!"

Elijah sighed. “And did he?”

“No! Well… kind of? Shit… ok shit… are you mad?” Evelyn asked. Elijah shook his head and waved her off.

"Nah… I mean, yeah, a little. But all things considered… you didn’t fuck him, right?”

“God no! I just fucked with his head.”

Elijah nodded. “Alright, but maybe talk to me first when it's my friend next time?”

Evelyn tried to move towards him, but then stopped herself. “And here I was giving you shit, huh?”

“It’s fine.”

“You can give me shit back,” she said pleadingly. Elijah shook his head and laughed.

“Not really my thing. I do need a minute though. Just tell me what happened.”

“Ok, listen. He came into the club. Acting like a piece of shit, and then he started making moves on me. So, I got pissed and decided to make a game out of it.”

“And that game was…?”

Evelyn looked away shamefully. “It was giving him a lap dance. It wasn’t private though!”

“Oh, thank god it wasn’t private,” The pain was tempered, but it was there. Evelyn frowned.

“I’m sorry…”

Elijah sighed. "It’s fine. I know you, I know it was business.”

“Oh, absolutely! And I had every intention of telling you tonight.”

“I know.”

“Is it ok if we keep cuddling?”

“Of course,” Elijah said gently.

Evelyn moved back to his chest as Elijah stared at the ceiling.

“Man… Henry,” he said absently. “I guess I can't say I'm surprised."

“Was he always a scumbag?" Evelyn asked.

"No. It's only the last few years that he's decided to be this new person. Kinda sad, really."

"So are you going to unfriend him?" Evelyn asked.

Elijah shook his head. “I don’t know…”

"Are you giving him a pass right now?" Evelyn sounded more intrigued than concerned.

"I've known him since he was a kid. I know somewhere in there he is a good guy. I think he’s just gotten a little lost.”

"Well, that doesn’t excuse it. But… if we’re giving him a pass…” There was a playfulness to Evelyn’s voice. It caught Elijah’s attention.

"I'm listening,” he said.

She perched her chin on her hands and began swaying her legs playfully. "I kind of want to make a game out of it now."

Elijah smiled. “I can’t wait to hear this one.”

“Are you judging me?!”

Elijah squeezed her. “Never.”

She rolled off him and covered her face.

“I know, after everything I just said, right? We shouldn’t be playing mind games with your friends.”

“True, but like you said, he did try to go behind my back so…”

Evelyn closed her eyes and sighed. "Ok, I’m not saying we HAVE to. But let’s look at the facts.” She sat up and began counting on her fingers. “One, Henry was alone at a strip club. That’s a yellow flag. Two, he happily went behind your back for a lap dance. That’s messed up.”

“Agreed,” Elijah confirmed.

“Three, on the ride home, he really thought he was making moves with me.”

“He gave you a ride home?”

“Of course he gave me a ride home. How else would he have had the chance to make a move?”

“Man, you’re good at this,” Elijah said.

“Almost like it could be my job!”

Elijah laughed softly. “So how was he making moves?”

“Oh, you know, sweet talking, trying to be mysterious, suggesting he fucks like nobody else, flaunting his wealth, the usual. He wants to steal me away, or at least wants a pass. He even asked me to keep our dance a secret when I said I was going to tell you.”

“And I’m assuming you told him you would?”

“Oh, of course! I didn’t want him to start doing damage control.”

“Ok, you made your points, so what is this game?”

Evelyn leaned in with a bright smile. “I want to see how far he’s actually willing to go, and how much money he’d be willing to spend to get there.”

Elijah looked away pensively. "Ok… let’s say we do it. And he goes all the way.”

“Yeah?”

“Wouldn’t we be setting up to be a cheater? Isn’t that entrapment?”

“I’m not saying we have to!”

"I know. But if we did, we'd definitely have to think of the implications," Elijah said.

"Oh, most definitely." Evelyn agreed, both of them sharing a knowing glance before Elijah continued.

"Because if he went through with it, it could be pretty bad… it could mean he’s kicked out of the friend group. Or the end of the friend group itself."

"Well… I thought it'd be more like you guys humiliate him for a little while, then go back to being friends," Evelyn said, rather surprised by Elijah’s remark.

Elijah chuckled. "Ryan might go for that. But that's because Ryan knows what we are. But if Lucas or Juan heard what we were doing? Or heard what Henry had done? It’d be a very different story. Most people don’t see cheating as a game."

Evelyn’s smirk dimmed. "Ooooh, right. Jesus… yeah sorry. I can be fucked up sometimes.”

“You’re ok Ev, we’re just talking.”

“They’d probably see it very differently… and they'd see me differently also, right?" Evelyn said.  

Elijah nodded. "Probably. To what degree, I’m not sure. But even if Henry were technically in the wrong, we’d still have been the ones who set him up. It's a risk, that's all I'm saying."

"That's fair," Evelyn contemplated for a moment.

"But on the other hand…” Elijah said with a smirk.

“Yeeeees?” Evelyn chimed in.

“IF we did it, AND we kept it to ourselves and Henry, it COULD be a little game where if he does slip, we could hold it over his head for the rest of our lives. And who knows, maybe it would finally help him grow up.”

Evelyn let out an overly dramatic cackle. "So you can be as ruthless as me.”

"I can be. Especially when my friend tries to fuck my girl behind my back."

"Ahhh, so you ARE jealous." Evelyn slowly crawled on top of Elijah with a bright smile.

"Oh, you like that?" he said.

"I REALLY do actually… you're always so nonchalant when I fuck other guys."

"I thought that's what you wanted."

"Well yeah, but SOMETIMES it's nice to know you're a little territorial over me."

Elijah grabbed her neck and pulled her lips close to his. "You have no fucking idea."

Evelyn drew closer. "I don't?"

Elijah went in for a kiss, but Evelyn put a finger to his lips. "Ooooh no, I'm not letting you have me just yet."

Elijah grabbed her hand and kissed it tenderly. "Alright."

She looked at him longingly for a moment.

"So what am I doing with Henry?" Evelyn asked.

"For now, I will leave it in your hands… don’t mess with him yet, though. See what he does and keep me in the loop. We can circle back after this marketing campaign.”

"Deal," Evelyn offered her hand.

"Deal." Elijah shook it playfully. "Now tell me about this Ivan situation."

"Oh my god, that mother fucker. Well, he was there too. Being an asshole like usual. He spotted me with Henry. I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing."

"Probably a bad thing," Elijah said.

"Probably…" Evelyn sighed. "Little fucker…"

“Which one?”

“Both,” Evelyn said flatly.

They shared a laugh at that.

“Did you two talk about that month coming up?” Elijah asked.

"We did,” Evelyn confirmed.

“And are you going to do it?”

"I am," Evelyn said with a long sigh. "But no fucking overnights. And Ivan should NOT be contacting you anymore. If he does, the deal is fucking off."

"Absolutely. So what does the deal actually include?”

Evelyn leaned her head against his shoulder. "Since we’re not doing overnights, he wants me to come to a lot of day events. So it will be a very busy month."

“And is there anything you need from me, outside of not talking to Ivan?”

Evelyn shook her head. “Just be there for me, like always.”

“That I can do.”

Evelyn closed her eyes and wrapped her arm around his.

"You're too good to me," she whispered.

He wanted to tell her that he felt the same. That he was amazed by how patient she was with him, and how much she’d already helped him grow.

But instead, he decided to say the words he felt she needed to hear the most.

"You deserve it, Ev," Elijah said.

Evelyn didn’t say anything. Instead, she curled tightly next to him and pulled him deeper into bed.

Files

Comments

Brent Duvall

Maybe the most realistic argument I've seen written out into a story. Every chapter has been better than the last

NaughtiWolf

Yet another great chapter for this story. Jakobs, this is probably the best argument scene you've written for any of your stories. Both Evelyn and Elijah felt like real people in the scene. They both had solid points but Elijah stepping up and admitting fault was the right thing to do. I feel there will still be stumbling blocks as the story progresses but I like where this is going. Well done.

northdrop

It’s so refreshing to see characters in a story like this have a REAL conversation and use it to deepen the ties in the relationship. There are definitely some double standards here and there, but they saw them when it came up and addressed it. Like adults. This context in their relationship, this depth, makes the filthy parts hit so much harder and i absolutely love it:)

NaughtiWolf

Speaking of real conversations that deepen ties... ::cough:: Noah and Rachel ::cough:: Sorry. Internet chats can be so dusty...