The Rules We Break 17 - Dinner Date (Patreon)
Content
Jeremy sat on the patio outside with the rest of the group, watching the setting sun as they picked away at the club salad Sage had haphazardly put together for them. The light meal was preferred, however, since it allowed fewer glasses of wine to feel a buzz, which they all happily embraced.
"So, you guys ready to head back tomorrow?" Jeremy asked. Ryan looked up from his salad.
"Hmm? Oh. I guess I am. Or maybe I'm not. I don't know." Ryan glanced over at Amy. "What about you, toots?"
"I guess I'm ready for the real world again…" Amy swirled her wine, passively looking over at David's backyard as she spoke. Sage followed her eyes to David's living room window, but said nothing.
"I heard you got the gig sorted. What’s the venue like?" Ryan asked Jeremy.
“Oh right, the show! I totally forgot about it,” Jeremy said, leaning back in his chair.
“Considering everything, that’s understandable,” Sage chimed in, pulling her eyes from David’s window. “How big of a show do you think it will be?”
“Well, the venue is just a bar. So it will be smaller for sure,” Jeremy answered calmly.
"How many people do you think will come?" Amy asked.
Jeremy shrugged. "I don’t know. The bar can only hold maybe fifty people? So probably less than that. It’s on a Wednesday night, too.”
“Well, you never know! It could be big,” Sage said encouragingly. Jeremy smiled as he refilled his wine glass.
“Thanks, babe,” he said sweetly.
"You getting nervous yet?" Ryan asked.
"Not yet. The nerves usually don’t get to me till the morning of," he said.
"And what about you, Sage?" Ryan asked.
Sage jumped. “Oh, me? No, I’m not nervous. Why would we be nervous?!”
Ryan chuckled and shook his head. “No, what’s in the works for you after this little vacation?”
Sage blushed bright red and laughed uncomfortably.
"Oh well… you know, I'm sure I'll find something to keep me busy," she said passively. And as if on cue, all four looked at David's home.
Jeremy watched as Sage fixed her hair nervously when they did.
"Ok," Amy said, finishing her third glass of wine. “I don't know if it's appropriate to ask this… but I’m dying to know, how does it work with him?”
"Thank god you said it," Ryan chimed in.
“Oh god…” Sage said. “Jeremy, do you want to explain?”
Jeremy spun his fork for a minute, unable to contain a smile as he glanced between Amy and Ryan.
“So you two little perverts want the dirt, huh?” he teased.
“Oh, stop!” Amy said. “We just learned you guys are swingers! Obviously, we’re gonna want to know what that means!”
“For the record, I never said we were swingers,” Sage interjected.
“Well, what else would you call it?” Ryan asked.
“I don’t know!” Sage looked over at Jeremy expectantly.
“Wait, why are you looking at me?!” he said.
“You’re the wild guy. Don’t you know the terms?” she said.
“No! What, just because I play music, I’m the wild guy now?!”
“Jeremy, you have always been the wild guy,” Ryan said.
“Agreed,” Amy added, looking at Jeremy with an overly long gaze.
The temperature dialed up. Jeremy promptly threw his napkin on the table and looked away.
"Look, what we have going on with David isn’t all that deep, alright? It just happened," he said.
"Oh yeah, fucking the neighbor, just sorta happens!” Ryan said with a deep, humorous voice. The group laughed. “Didn’t you two used to do this kind of stuff before, though?”
Sage and Jeremy spoke simultaneously.
“No, we haven’t,” she said promptly.
“I guess you’re right,” Jeremy said. Sage went bright red as she slowly turned to face him.
“Excuuuse me?”
Jeremy took a deep swig of his wine. “Oh, come on, you’re really going to sit there and say we didn’t get a little crazy back in college?”
"So you two DID do things like this before!" Ryan chimed in.
"No, we did not!" Sage said, emphasizing every syllable.
"What are you talking about?! We did all kinds of stuff when I was touring. Especially when we went to bars,” Jeremy said.
"Ooook, first of all, that was JUST flirting," Sage corrected, promptly grabbing the bottle of wine on the table and pouring the remainder of its contents into her glass.
"What about that one guy, what was his name… John?" Jeremy said.
"Really? You're going to tell them about John now?" Sage replied, bobbing her head as she downed half her glass in one gulp.
"Who's John?" Amy asked eagerly. She laughed wildly when Sage gave her a side glare. "What?!"
Sage shook her head as she finished the rest of her wine.
The others followed her lead, their words collectively slurring without anyone noticing.
"John… was a very handsome older man at a bar in Nashville. It was the last stop on Jeremy’s tour, and I was very, very drunk. And Jeremy had seen him flirting with me for a while, so we talked between his sets and agreed that I could… keep flirting.”
"Yeah… and?" Ryan said, refilling both his and Amy’s glasses.
Sage looked over at Jeremy sheepishly. “Oh my god… I cannot believe we’re telling this story."
"You don't have to tell them if you don't want to," Jeremy said playfully.
"No, you definitely don't," Amy said, drinking deeply from her glass. Then, with a smirk, she continued. "But also…"
"Oh my god! Fine!” Sage said loudly, words meshing together as she nudged her glass towards Ryan, who happily filled it for her. “While Jeremy was on stage, I made out with John in a booth."
Amy's jaw dropped. "You did?!" She looked over at Jeremy. "And could you see it?"
"I saw the whole thing," Jeremy replied. "And it was very hot."
"God damn!" Ryan’s cheeks and nose were permanently red now, and his already jolly demeanor only doubled.
"I know, we are so gross," Sage said.
"No one's saying that," Ryan said, taking another swig before continuing. "I mean… if I'm being honest…" he looked at Sage. "I've thought about it."
Amy let out an overly dramatic scoff. "Ryan!"
"What?! I'm just saying. It seems like it'd be… really exciting."
“To mess around with other women?!”
“IF YOU WANTED ME TO, like themmmm,” Ryan said, pointing between Jeremy and Sage. Amy leaned in toward her husband and grabbed his jaw with one hand.
“I oughta smack you right now,” she said playfully.
“Yeah, I BET you wanna smack me right now.” Ryan then glanced over at Jeremy. “Maybe you wanna smack HIM too.”
The comment seemed to strike home. Sage’s jaw dropped in surprise as Amy’s face went bright red.
“Stoop!” Amy hissed, shoving Ryan away before taking another long drink.
"I’m jookin’” Ryan said. “Obviously, we wouldn’t do anything unless we BOTH wanted to. I’m just saying that, with the right people…” his eyes trailed to Sage.
Then down her chest.
“It could be… fun.” As he finished, Sage found his eyes, and Amy found Jeremy’s.
At once, a new energy danced between them all.
Ryan stood up promptly and wobbled to the sliding patio door.
"I need another drink, do you guys want–"
"Yes!" They all shouted, standing in unison and following Ryan inside. Jeremy and Sage sat beside each other, and Amy sat on the opposite end of the couch. As they got comfortable, Ryan came out of the kitchen with two bottles of white wine.
"Oh, Ryan, no,” Sage said, wagging her finger in the air as she spoke through slurs. “Not those. Vaude Chateu is for special occasionnnsss and waaay too nice for how drunk we are. Get the boxed."
"The boxed wine?" Ryan said with disappointment.
"We are too. fucking. drunk.” Sage said again, pointing to the pantry. "Get the boxed."
Ryan grumbled as he sauntered back into the kitchen before returning with two large boxes of white wine. He sat on the loveseat facing Sage, Jeremy, and Amy.
The group shared a few more glasses.
They started and finished off-ended conversations with loud laughs and bright smiles.
They took a few more drinks between off-color jokes while eyeing one another with racing hearts.
Jeremy could sense the tension in every sentence and every breath. It was the same energy he had shared with Sage years ago. Only now, it was right here in their living room with some of their closest friends.
“So, have you two ever wanted to explore things?” Jeremy asked.
Amy’s eyes perked up as she nervously set down her wine glass on the coffee table. Sage promptly grabbed a coaster and placed it underneath it without a second thought.
"I mean… we’ve never talked about it formally,” Amy said, seeking her husband's eyes as she spoke.
“Riiiight…” Ryan looked back at Sage, eyes locking onto her cleavage. “Never formally…”
“And would you two, you know, ever do something like that?” Sage asked softly, glancing at Jeremy only for a second.
“I mean… we’ve never really had the opportunity to…” Amy glanced over at Jeremy, her eyes dropping to his groin before moving back up to meet his gaze. “I guess with the right people it could work.”
Silence filled the room, all waiting for someone to finally suggest it.
Jeremy took the leap of faith.
“Sage,” he said.
“Yeah?”
“Why don’t you go sit by Ryan and see how that feels.”
Sage and Jeremy watched Amy and Ryan look at one another, doing their best to hide their excited shock.
“What do you think?” Ryan said under his breath.
“We could…” Amy’s voice trailed off into mumbles.
“Yeah, but…” Ryan didn’t need to finish his sentence. It seemed like Amy knew what he would say.
“Well, if we just…”
“Yeah… but…”
“Ohhh, we’re overthinking it!” Amy finally said, looking at Sage. “Go sit by him.”
Jeremy and Sage shared a glance, and it was all they needed to know this was exactly what they wanted. She squeezed his leg and slowly stood. Jeremy watched her drop beside Ryan close enough that her leg touched his. His back shot upright as his already red nose turned maroon.
"Well… how are we feeling?" Sage asked, glancing between everyone.
“So far so good,” Amy replied with a nod, glancing at Jeremy. Sage was quick to catch it.
“In that case, why don’t you go sit by Jeremy,” Sage said to Amy.
And Amy moved quicker than Jeremy had anticipated. With a nervously eager laugh, she downed her glass and promptly scooted close to his side.
And again, the group waited, laughing excitedly as they all took a moment to see if anyone was going to end it. When none of them did, Amy cautiously placed her hand on Jeremy's thigh and gave it a gentle squeeze.
The dam broke.
Laughter rang out as the excitement overtook them. Ryan quickly followed his wife’s lead by putting his hand around Sage’s waist. And Sage, in turn, reached over his lap for his other hand and interlocked her fingers with his, smiling at Jeremy while she did.
"You two look like a great couple," Amy said with a slurred laugh, glancing over at Jeremy.
"You two don't look half bad yourself," Sage replied, watching as Jeremy wrapped his arm around Amy's shoulder.
They stayed that way for a moment, continuing to drink and chat in the embrace of their friend’s partners while they waited for the adrenaline to settle.
“Did you ever think we’d be here like this?” Amy finally asked.
“Not in a million years,” Ryan replied, squeezing Sage’s side. Amy watched as her hand trailed up Jeremy’s leg.
“So… should we like… try making out and see how that feels?” she asked.
"Amy!" Sage said with an expressive amount of shock.
"What?! You already did it with the neighbor?! Why not do it with friends?" While Amy tried to sound certain, Jeremy could sense the unease in her voice. That didn’t stop her hand from scooting closer to his hardening cock, however.
Sage let out a giggle as Ryan’s hand slipped down to her hip.
"No, I know. It’s just, hearing someone say it out loud is weird," Sage said, looking up at Ryan. He seemed just as nervous as she was, and even started to loosen his grip around her.
"We definitely don't have to!” Amy said. “I just thought since we’re here… we could give it a shot, right?"
Jeremy weighed the group’s uncertainty against their excitement and made a decision.
“I vote we give it a shot,” he said confidently, pulling Amy closer. She gasped at his touch before looking up at him excitedly.
"Of course you'd say that," Sage shot back.
“Am I sensing jealousy?” Jeremy replied. Sage narrowed her eyes as she leaned forward.
“You’re going to make them nervous,” she said.
“Is this part of your guys' kink?!” Amy interjected.
The group laughed again, dancing around the growing curiosity they all shared. Each sentence inching them closer to a line most would never step over.
The drinks certainly helped.
"I mean… I'm down," Ryan said, pulling Sage closer to himself as his hand slid up her waist and pushed her top, exposing her olive skin.
"Ooook, don't be TOO eager," Amy said. Jeremy was thankful to see them both laugh afterward, but knew better than to let the group continue without saying something.
"Ok, look. If we actually want to do this, we should make some rules," he said.
"Isn't that Sage's department?" Ryan said, nodding to Sage.
"Heeeey!" Sage said, slapping his burly chest. He laughed warmly as his hand rubbed against her exposed ribs. She leaned into him, her drunken state making her more confident than usual. “I like how small you make me feel…” she whispered.
Ryan, a bit star-struck, cleared his throat with a nod. “Joking aside, Jeremy's right.”
“Agreed.” Amy chimed in. “What do you two usually recommend?"
Jeremy watched as Ryan’s arm coiled around Sage like a snake as that familiar, hungry look appeared in her eyes.
"Sage?" he said.
"I’ll only make the rules if you all admit that I’m the best planner in the world and promise to never tease me about it again, deal?" she said.
“Oh Sage, you are the best planner to ever live!” Amy said quickly.
“Truly. Amazing.” Jeremy added.
“I don’t know how the world would function without you,” Ryan said.
Sage rolled her eyes, glancing between her husband and the fiery red-haired woman nuzzling into his side.
"Ok, we are friends here, and we need to be friends after this. So talk as we go. Anyone can end it at any time. And if at any point you start thinking, 'oh shit, this might ruin our friendship,' say something. Agreed?"
"Agreed," the group replied.
Another bout of tension followed. It felt like they were on top of a tall diving board looking at a small puddle of water below, waiting for the right moment to jump.
"Ok…" Amy said, biting her lip as she looked at Jeremy. "So… Wanna make out?"
Jeremy glanced over at Sage once more. She nodded and watched as Amy's fingers slid up to his shirt collar and clenched it tightly.
“I’d love to,” he said. Without a moment of hesitation, Amy tugged his head low.
And his lips locked with hers.
Her brilliant, curly hair spilled over her face as they shared a soft, tender kiss. She pressed into Jeremy with so much passion that he glanced over at Sage and Ryan instinctively. To his surprise, they both watched with excitement, looking as hungry as ever.
When Amy and Jeremy parted, she let out a long, quivering sigh as she began to shake her hands frantically.
"Oh. My. God!" she shouted. Looking over at Ryan. "I just did that!” she said with a laugh.
“You did,” Ryan confirmed.
“Are you good?” she asked.
"Oh, I'm very good," Ryan confirmed, his hand now touching the underside of Sage's giant breast. Amy's eyes caught it, and she bit her lip once more.
"So, you gonna make out with her or what?" she asked, playing with the back of Jeremy's hair.
"Jeremy, are you good?" Ryan asked cautiously.
Jeremy looked into Sage’s eyes, smiling as he nodded.
"She’s all yours,” he said, giving his wife a wink. Jeremy never got tired of seeing her light up in moments like this.
"Right, I keep forgetting you two are the pros here," Ryan said as he nervously shifted to face Sage. He was so big that he wasn't able to lean towards her comfortably. And so, with a devious little smile, Sage looked at Jeremy as she slid a leg over Ryan’s lap and mounted his large frame.
Her skirt slid up her legs as she plopped her ass onto the growing bulge beneath his slacks, revealing the underside of her lacy black underwear.
Ryan’s eyes were transfixed on the plunging cleavage inches from his face as his hands hovered over Sage’s ass.
"Honey, you good?" he asked, failing to hide how eager he was to touch his friend’s wife.
"I'm very. Very good," Amy said, her hand digging into Jeremy’s hair as she watched another woman mount her husband.
Ryan didn’t waste a second. His face immediately plunged between Sage’s breasts as his hands latched onto her jiggling ass cheeks. Sage gasped in surprise, looking back at Amy as her husband began to fondle her.
"You sure this is ok?" she asked.
Amy answered by sliding her hand over Jeremy’s hardening cock and giving it an eager squeeze.
"I am very, VERY, into this," she confirmed.
With that answer, Sage’s eyes shifted from Amy to Jeremy, and she slowly began to grind her ass in Ryan’s lap. Then she turned and pressed her lips against his. Jeremy was disappointed he couldn’t see it from where he sat, but he could hear the gentle sounds of their kissing as Ryan’s beefy hands kneaded her ass cheeks together. Then, after a few moments, he wrapped his arms around Sage’s waist and squeezed her tightly against his massive frame.
Amy watched also, her hand gently massaging Jeremy’s cock as Ryan’s fingers slowly pushed Sage’s skirt upwards.
Then she looked over at him, and Jeremy suddenly found himself lost in her brilliant blue eyes framed by freckles. Her lips were lush and red, matching the rosy tint of her cheeks. Her slender neck was as smooth and pale as her exposed chest, which rose and fell quickly.
"Should we join them?" she asked sheepishly.
Jeremy smiled and wrapped his hands around her waist, eyes interlocked with hers as he called to his wife.
"Sage, you good if we move forward?" he said.
Sage pulled herself from Ryan's lips, moaning softly as he buried his face into her cleavage once more.
"Go for it," she said, her voice muffling as Ryan pulled her back in for another kiss.
They disappeared from view as Amy slid onto Jeremy's lap. She was far lighter than Sage, and much shorter, too. Jeremy could feel the fullness of her thighs press into his lap as he trailed his fingers up them.
"You ready?" she said timidly.
"If you are," Jeremy replied gently.
Amy hesitated for a moment, then, with a bashful laugh, she pushed her curly hair behind her ears and leaned forward.
Pressing her full, sweet lips against his.
A few more exploring kisses followed. Then, she began to eagerly rub against him, pressing her pelvis down as her tongue slid into his mouth. She kissed aggressively, digging her nails tightly into Jeremy's shirt. He, in turn, squeezed her round ass beneath her thin maxi skirt. An ass that was far larger than he had anticipated. Amy gasped at his touch, quickly finding the ridge of his bulge and rubbing herself against it.
A series of quiet, eager moans began to leave her as she moved with a pace Jeremy expected from a former D1 athlete.
Jeremy's hands trailed up her body, following the curve of her wide hips to her slim waist. He slid his fingers along her toned abs all the way up to her perky breasts, stopping just beneath them. He kissed her a little while longer as she wrapped her arms around his neck. Then, with a long, passionate kiss, she pulled away from him.
“You can touch them if you want," she whispered shyly.
Jeremy smiled. “Should we ask them?” he said.
Amy laughed as she pushed her overflowing locks back once again and turned.
Ryan’s hands were already out of sight, arms moving eagerly as he played with Sage’s breasts.
Amy turned back to Jeremy. “I think they are way ahead of us.”
They laughed softly together.
“Fair enough,” Jeremy whispered. Amy grabbed his hands and pulled them over her round breasts. He gave them a gentle squeeze, which caused Amy to let out another small, eager moan. Her nipples were more prominent compared to Sage's, but they felt wonderful all the same. And as Amy buried her face into Jeremy's neck, Sage and Ryan came into view over her shoulder.
He watched as Ryan tugged at Sage’s top, exposing her shoulders while he eagerly continued squeezing her massive tits together. Their pace quickened as they made out passionately, and it was clear to Jeremy that Ryan was getting lost in the heat of the moment.
He felt the same from Amy also, who found his lips again as he continued to explore her body, moving her with ease, enjoying the sensation of her full, thick thighs pressing against him as her maxi skirt rode upwards, exposing her smooth skin.
He could have gotten lost in that moment if only he hadn't glanced out the kitchen windows.
And spotted David next door. He sat on his couch, watching with a bottle in hand and fury in his eyes.
Jeremy couldn't help but smile at the sight.
Amy began rocking eagerly, rubbing with all the force she could muster as she trailed her hands up his chest. Sage and Ryan were just as passionate. Her skirt was at her waist now, and if Jeremy let them continue, he was certain her breasts would be out in a few more minutes.
But then he looked back at David and found enough willpower to give everyone a chance to slow down.
"Timeout!" He said loudly, causing everyone to freeze.
Sage looked back with concern as she began fixing one of her top’s straps.
"Is everything ok?" she asked, eyes widening when she saw Amy plunging into Jeremy's neck and kissing it passionately.
Jeremy smiled at her. "Everything's fine, just wondering if we want to take this upstairs, or call it a night."
Everyone caught the implication and settled down.
Amy let out a long breath as she slid off Jeremy and began to fix her hair. Sage did the same. Leaving Ryan frozen in place with a stunned, awe-stricken smile.
He looked over at Amy as she fixed her outfit.
"What do you think?" he said hopefully.
Amy's cheeks flushed bright red against her pale, freckled skin. She looked into Jeremy's eyes, bright excitement swelling as she let out an embarrassed giggle.
"Fuck it. You only live once, right? Let's do this!"
Jeremy was surprised to hear it. And when Ryan made no protest, he turned his attention to Sage.
"What do you think?" he asked her.
Sage covered her mouth with both hands, looking at Ryan and Amy for a moment.
"Oh my god, I can't believe this is happening! Are we sure?!" she said.
"I think so," Jeremy replied, standing up and adjusting himself so his cock didn't press so painfully against his pants. "Ryan, Amy? You guys ready?"
"Don't have to tell me twice," Ryan said, standing quickly and hoisting Sage over his shoulder. She let out a surprised laugh as he began to walk towards the stairs. "Come on! Let's go!"
Amy stood next, stepping past Jeremy as she trailed her fingers along his chest with a hungry gaze.
"Come on," she whispered, following her husband up the stairs.
Jeremy took a step, then stopped, allowing himself one last look out the patio window.
He locked eyes with David, a surge of triumph swelling as he saluted him.
David responded with a middle finger.
“Looks like I win this round,” Jeremy said with a laugh before turning to the stairs.