Best of Friends 58 - Messing Around (Patreon)
Content
A few days passed, and while it still didn’t feel completely real, Rachel did what she could to accept that she and Noah were over. Her mother was supportive in her own way, but her sister helped the most. She was there every night, not once leaving Rachel’s side. And Jack must have heard from someone, because he’d been keeping his distance ever since the breakup. Only ever offering a kind word or a gentle smile when they’d see each other. The same was true for Jack’s mother.
Rachel tried to shake it off. She tried to pretend everything was fine. They all went to the airshow together and sat in folding chairs under a picnic umbrella as jets flew overhead. But Rachel barely paid attention. She stared off at the waterfront, losing herself in the horizon as flashes of memories popped into her mind.
The most invasive was Allison’s video.
She’d stared at the video thumbnail for a long time. Rachel didn't want to play it, but she couldn't stop her morbid curiosity.
Late at night, when Jackeline was alone, Rachel snuck into the bathroom with headphones in and pressed play. It was surreal seeing Mike with another woman, making the same faces he’d made for her. Allison's moans were so obnoxiously fake that Rachel had to mute the video, but even then, she could only stomach a few seconds before shutting it off.
She looked away, feeling sick. Allison had him. She had HIM. And Rachel knew she had no right to care. She knew that the last thing she should be upset about was what Mike was doing with his free time.
And yet. She was.
Her guilt dragged like a heavy mallet across the skin. And with it came waves of invasive thoughts.
She wondered if Noah was seeing Allison also. Perhaps that was why he wanted to tell her. Maybe they were messing around in her apartment right now. Rachel’s anxiety swelled. More than once, she was tempted to call Noah. To warn him, of course. And maybe make sure he wasn’t bringing anyone over to her place.
But he wouldn’t do that. Right?
She just wanted to make sure he was ok. That’s all. It wasn’t weird for her to call. They still had so many things to talk about. Rachel wondered what he was doing. She wondered if he was missing her as much as she missed him. She checked his socials more than once. And as usual, found there were no new posts.
But he'd taken their pictures down.
That made her curl up into a ball and collapse into oblivion. Fortunately, her sister found her and stayed with her again. Stroking her hair as she switched between their favorite reality TV shows.
And with a few more days. With a little more time. Rachel convinced herself she was fine. She bounced back. She became her chipper self. Even more than before. Her mother was pleased to see it. Her sister, less so. But she didn't say a word. Because life was good, and life was only getting better, and what was in the past was in the past, and Rachel couldn't care less about who Noah was seeing or what he was doing.
So when her mother told her she and Jack would have the place to themselves that evening because they were going into town, Rachel embraced it.
"Sounds great," she said.
Her mother was elated. "I'm so glad to hear it, darling! You see, I told you it would all be alright."
And when her mother went to convince Jackeline to leave as well, Jackeline made the obligatory check-in that afternoon.
“Mom says you and Jack want alone time,” she said.
Rachel laughed. “Of course she’d frame it like that.”
"I can always stay if you want,” Jackeline said.
Rachel smiled weakly.
"I'll be fine," she said absently.
"You're sure?"
"Totally."
"Rachel…”
Rachel shook her head. "I think I need this."
The words came out before she could process them. Words she never would have said before coming to Godfrey. They were colder. More knowing. More calculated. And her sister seemed to understand completely.
"Well, alright. But feel free to call me if you need to, ok?”
“Don’t worry, I will,” Rachel said.
And so, she and Jack were left alone once again. Only this time, Rachel had a plan. She deliberately put on the skimpiest bikini she could find, grabbed a wine bucket, stuffed it with three bottles, and went into the hot tub.
Waiting for Jack to show up and keep everything numb.
Not that she needed it, of course. Rachel was fine. She wasn't even going to do anything with Jack, probably. She was just going to have a drink and enjoy a fun, relaxing night with a friend. That was it. Because she was fine, and what was done was done. She was single. She was allowed to have fun. Mike and Noah were, obviously. Not like that mattered. She didn’t even care about what they were doing or who they were doing it with.
Rachel took a swig of her wine and looked into the living room windows of the house. She made sure she faced them. She made sure her cleavage was above the water, and her hair was in a perfect messy bun.
She hadn’t done her makeup, though. At least, not fully. Because she didn't care, and tonight was about having fun.
As she began pouring her third glass of wine, Jack came out through the back sliding door and approached the tub with a friendly wave. He wore black slides, black swim trunks, and a striped blue-and-white shirt. It was unbuttoned, with the sleeves rolled halfway up his forearms, and nothing underneath.
"Hey," Rachel said flirtatiously, though it sounded slightly forced.
“Hey,” Jack replied, eyes glancing down to her chest before bouncing back up. “Is it alright if I join you?”
"Sure," Rachel said, letting her feet breach the water as she took another sip of wine. She watched hungrily as Jack took off his shirt and slipped into the hot tub.
To her disappointment, he sat opposite her.
“Really nice night out, huh?” he said.
“Oh… yeah,” Rachel replied dully. “Do you want a drink?”
"Sure," Jack said. Rachel reached for the bottle and the extra glass she'd brought, then swam over to his side, leaning in close as she poured him a glass.
"Here," she said.
Jack eyed her cautiously, then took the glass delicately from her hand.
"Thanks," he said, taking a deep drink while looking her in the eye.
"You're welcome," Rachel replied, staying by his side. She made sure her thigh was touching his. But only for fun.
Jack moved away slightly.
"How are you holding up?" he asked gently.
Rachel felt her insides squirm as she pushed the feelings down.
"Fine, it is what it is," she said absently.
Jack nodded. "Jackeline was saying you were taking it pretty hard.”
Rachel’s jaw clenched. “I was, but now I’m not.”
Jack didn’t seem convinced.
”Listen, it’s alright if—”
"I'm fine. We don't need to talk about it," Rachel said coldly. Jack nodded.
“Alright,” he said. He set his glass down and ran his fingers through his hair.
Rachel glanced down at his body, watching as droplets of water trickled down his defined lats and chest.
“You look really good,” she said.
“You ready to head back to school?” Jack replied, not acknowledging the compliment.
Rachel clenched her fists nervously.
"Of course I am. Are you?" she asked defensively, catching herself after asking the question. Jack took another long drink, then refilled his glass.
"Yeah, I think so. Can't believe summer semester is right around the corner."
Rachel sighed. “Neither can I.”
"You going anywhere for the summer?" he asked.
She was supposed to go on a vacation with Noah. They'd talked about it more than once.
"Don't know what I'm doing yet," she said, downing the rest of her glass and pouring another.
The buzz felt good. Looking at Jack felt good too. He said more. She was sure of it. But she wasn't listening. She was admiring how cut his jaw looked in the glow of the hot tub lights. How broad his shoulders were, and how big his biceps looked when he flexed.
"You're so cute," she said with a smile, interrupting him mid-sentence. Jack paused, smiling back weakly as he shook his head.
"And you're drunk," he replied.
Rachel laughed far too loudly. "So are you!"
"Not as much as you are right now," Jack teased, a certain unease in his voice.
"Coooome on…" Rachel slid into him. She wrapped her arm around his neck while still holding her glass delicately in her free hand. "We're supposed to be having fun, right? It's a vacation."
Jack looked up and down for a moment, his hand hovering inches from her waist.
“It’s alright to take a moment and think about how you might feel tomorrow, though,” he said.
Rachel rolled her eyes. “I’m not that drunk.”
“I’m just saying.”
“Since when did you get so boring?”
Jack’s eyes softened. “There’s nothing wrong with thinking ahead a little bit.”
“Yeah, well, maybe I don’t want to,” Rachel said passively. Taking another drink.
“Maybe you should slow down?” he said.
Rachel raised an eyebrow. “What are you, my dad?”
Jack laughed. “Of course not. But I care about you.”
Tenderness. Just like Noah.
Rachel looked away and reset herself, trying to shake away a flood of old feelings.
“I care about you, Rach, you know that, right?”
“Yeah, I know,” she said with a sigh. Looking back at him. “I… care about you too.”
Jack nodded. “I know.”
He looked so fucking hot.
“I just want to fucking kiss you…” she said.
“Listen, Rach, I—”
Rachel leaned in and stole a quick kiss, laughing. He opened his mouth to speak, but nothing came out. He simply sat still, looking at her, mesmerized.
Noah would look at her like that sometimes.
But she pushed that memory out and kissed Jack again. A quick peck and another laugh. Then again.
Until finally, Jack put down his glass and pulled her in aggressively. He kissed desperately as his eyes searched for Rachel’s, but she avoided them as she slipped into his lap and grabbed handfuls of his thick hair.
It felt good being against his large body. It felt good to feel his hands slide up her back as his lips trailed along her neck. She slowly undid her top and threw it to the side as she pulled Jack’s head into her breasts, moaning loudly as his lips latched around her nipple. She grabbed his hand and placed it on the other, pushing her weight down against his cock as he played with her.
Rocking back and forth. Stealing kisses from him desperately as she chased that intoxicating spark between them and forgot everything else.
They kissed tenderly as he squeezed both her breasts together. Then he bucked up, causing her to gasp, and met her eyes.
“I really like you, Rach,” he said.
She was sure he'd said more. She barely registered it over the loud tub jets and racing thoughts.
So she laughed, kissing him again as she trailed her hand down his abs.
"You’re fun,” she said, tugging at his swim trunks.
"Hey, why don’t we…"
"It's fine, we're just messing around," Rachel said. Her hands moved as Jack continued to search for her eyes. Continued to plant tender kisses.
She pulled the trunks down to his thighs.
Then delicately moved her bikini to the side and pressed her sex onto his throbbing cock.
And it was all fine. Because she was over Noah, and this was just for fun. Because she was single.
She was single.
She rubbed against Jack, kissing him aggressively, bringing his hands to her breasts as she grabbed his cock tightly and squeezed his girth.
As she did, Jack laughed nervously, pushing Rachel off his lap and stepping out of the pool.
She looked up at him as her head swayed. “Everything good?”
"Oh yeah, just getting a little too hot for me,” he said, running a hand through his hair.
“You look hot,” Rachel said, glancing down at his very full, pulsing, reddening cock. The heat of the water had made his round balls drop. They looked so swollen.
“Yeah, well… I mean, you're really beautiful yourself, Rach.” Jack glanced away for a moment. “Did you maybe want to take a break or—”
He talked more. Rachel didn’t listen. She just watched the pulse of his cock.
"Wait," she said, pulling at his legs and bringing him to the edge of the tub.
Then she slowly stood, smiling at him as she wrapped her hands around his shaft and slowly kissed the tip.
“Rachel…” Jack started.
“It’s alright,” she replied. “Let’s have fun.”
Jack said nothing. She felt him swell in her hands as she teased him with her lips and swirled her tongue around his cockhead. She watched his abs flex with pleasure, and his face contort with ecstasy.
Mike made a similar face when she’d blow him. Rachel looked away and licked the bottom of his shaft before sucking on his balls.
“Jesus Rach—”
“Sit down for me,” she said. Pulling Jack down by the hand and moving between his legs.
Placing his juicy cock between her rosy tits.
She pushed them tightly together with the palms of her hands, pumping with a steady rhythm she knew Noah and Mike both liked.
They also liked it when she’d open her mouth and suck on the tip of their cocks as they slid between her soft tits. And when she would moan and gasp between breaths.
Jack seemed to like it too.
"You're really good at that," he said nervously. "I’ve never had someone do this before…"
Rachel smiled at him weakly, giving his cock a final swallow before stepping out of the tub. Jack stood with her, and she pressed her naked body into his, stroking him with her hand as they kissed.
Then she slid him between her thighs as Jack squeezed her ass.
Mike really loved doing that to her also.
Maybe he was doing it to Allison.
Or maybe Noah was.
She kissed Jack harder. And he kissed back eagerly.
"I've always wanted you," he said.
Rachel smiled. They continued to kiss.
”I really like you, Rachel,” Jack said again tenderly. She looked down at his cock and gave it a gentle squeeze before meeting his eyes.
Those eager, innocent eyes.
"Then you should take me," she said.
Jack paused.
"Are you sure?" he said.
Rachel smiled. "We’re just messing around, right?”
Jack’s eyes dimmed ever so slightly.
“I mean, tonight, yeah.”
Rachel’s heart tensed.
“Yeah, tonight.”
“Then we got tomorrow, right?”
“Right.”
Jack sniffed when he saw Rachel look away.
“Let’s just focus on tonight,” he said.
“Sounds good,” Rachel replied.
Then Jack picked her up.
Just like Mike did.
Then brought her in for a tender kiss.
Like Noah always used to.
Rachel laughed as he carried her upstairs to his bedroom.