Rules 46 - Open Doors (Patreon)
Content
Moving did more for David than he thought. Even a few hours away, it gave him a chance to reset. To leave behind arguably the strangest fucking time in his life and try to start something more normal. And for the most part, that was what happened. But he hadn’t expected nagging guilt to continue festering beneath his skin. More than once, he'd dreamt of being in a room with Sage and Jeremy. It was much like their final together. He and Sage would scream at each other so loud that it made his throat bleed, and all the while, Jeremy sat in a corner like a lifeless puppet. When David finally looked at him, Sage spoke.
“You should be happy,” Sage said, her face hollowing out as she spoke. “This is what you wanted, right?”
The dream would shift and weave, their faces elongating as she screamed louder and louder.
And those screams turned to wails of pain.
He’d wake up in a cold sweat every time.
And during the day, David would replay their final fuck. But it came with an increasing amount of sickness. The desperation in her eyes became clearer every time he remembered. He could see how badly she wanted him to stay. And realized that, in her greatest moment of need, he’d turned it into a fucking game.
That was what he struggled with most. Well, that and how defeated Jeremy looked in the end.
In the dark of night, alone in his apartment, David’s shame and self-hatred flooded over him as he realized that he was responsible for destroying two lives.
A third if you counted his.
Things were normal, yes. But only on the outside. More and more, his thoughts became a labyrinth of the memories that he couldn’t escape. He thought about Sage almost constantly. He had fake conversations with her. Fake arguments about why it was her fault and not his. He’d do it so long that he’d forget where he was.
And then he would fall asleep and be greeted by ever-worsening nightmares.
Regret, exhaustion, desperation.
David felt pathetic. Why did any of this matter? It was done and over with. Finished. Sage was the little whore who played with fire. They were the ones who roped him into it. And they all got what they wanted. It wasn’t his fault. David could be done. He could move, just like Theo had.
Only, Theo hadn't really moved on either.
He'd called David while drunk, rambling endlessly about all the shit they'd done to him. And as Theo began to sob, David really took in just how fucked up the whole situation had been, and that maybe he would never find peace again.
So he drank. But drinking only went so far.
Then he tried deleting the videos and pictures so he wouldn't be tempted to look at any of them.
But all that did was encourage him to ruminate endlessly, making the nightmares worse. And when he finally couldn’t sleep soundly for an entire week, he did something he never thought he would.
David decided to go to therapy. Stupid. Fucking. Therapy.
He sat on a colorful couch, and he talked about it. About his feelings, about what happened, about the nightmares. But mainly the guilt. About how he had betrayed Theo, someone he truly saw as a friend. About how he had tried to blackmail Sage. About how he emailed her boss and ruined her life and marriage. The more he talked, the more he wondered if he deserved peace.
They talked about that, too.
About who he was before all this, and why his wife had left him in the first place.
For months, it spilled out of him. David didn't really know if it helped. But hey, the meds they gave him helped him sleep better, and some days he didn’t even think about Sage.
That seemed fitting considering the final closing on his house was right around the corner. With just a few dotted lines, he could leave that part of his life behind for good.
And that would have stayed the plan if he hadn't gotten another text from Sage with a video attached.
It happened just as he’d stepped outside his therapy office. David looked at his phone blankly, then shut it off and stared ahead at the strip mall across the street. The blood in his lips pulsed as his chest tightened. As the sun set behind decaying buildings, he let out a long, defeated sigh. David already knew he would watch the video. There was no fucking way he couldn't. But… he was also hungry. So, using a new trick his therapist would have been proud of, he walked across the street and grabbed a burrito. He ate it slowly by the restaurant windows as night came, then drove to his apartment. He sat down on his new, untainted couch, looked up at the ceiling, and closed his eyes as he slowly pulled out his phone.
He played the video.
Sage was in his old house. The place was mostly empty, save for a few boxes and odd pieces of furniture. Including the couch they’d spent so much time on. She had set up her phone in an old, familiar way.
It faced the couch.
She was standing.
She was bent over.
Between two men.
They must have been the movers, and they were clumsy as shit.
One of the fucking bozos thrust violently into her from behind. His belly out, pants drooped halfway down his thighs, and shirt half pulled up as he pumped haphazardly. He had to stop every few seconds to catch his breath and keep from losing it. The other idiot was using her mouth like a fuck toy, grabbing onto the back of her head and pumping his little dick in between her lips while groaning loudly.
David was ashamed that he didn’t stop the video. He watched the mover fucking her mouth push deep inside her throat and cum. And continued watching as the other man pulled her upright and pumped wildly into her pussy before finally cumming deep inside her.
But where there might have been jealousy before, David found pain instead.
He watched as Sage haphazardly wiped dripping cum from her mouth and scrambled towards the phone.
The video ended. Frozen on Sage.
Silence followed.
She didn't look well. Her eyes were sunken in, and she'd lost so much weight. Her hair was matted and thin. Her eyes frantic and desperate.
Like she was coming undone.
David shut off the phone, unable to bear the image.
Wondering if that woman was a product of him.
He carefully read the message she’d sent after the video.
Sage: Thanks for letting me borrow the house. Too bad it's not u.
It at least explained the calls and texts from the movers he’d chosen to ignore.
And thank god he hadn’t. David wasn’t sure he could forgive himself if he had.
And yet, even now, he wanted to answer.
It’s why his fingers hovered over his phone, aching to message back.
-
"Ladies and gentlemen, we are proud to announce that the first-ever downtown music festival is now open!" Ralph clipped the ribbon with giant scissors as locals and music travelers clapped ing and strolled into the center square with bright laughter.
Jeremy was surprised the festival had been so well received. The whole sleepy town had come to life with excitement, and local bands had come out of the woodwork for a chance to play.
It felt good to be part of something like this, and it felt even better to have Erin by his side. They had been seeing each other steadily for a few weeks now. They'd been taking it slow, and only recently started sleeping together again.
But they still hadn't defined anything, and Jeremy was okay waiting.
"What a crowd, huh?” Erin said.
Jeremy smiled. “Right? I can’t believe the turnout.”
“Shall we walk in?" she asked.
"Let's do it," Jeremy said, offering his hand. They passed down a local vendor alley, inspecting a booth filled with vintage odds and ends before stumbling into another selling records. They browsed through them as Erin swayed to a folk band playing on stage.
"I got to hand it to you, this idea of yours really did pan out," she said.
Jeremy pulled out a record to inspect closely before glancing at her with a smirk. "So I take you changed your mind about this festival killing the small-town vibe?"
Erin rolled her eyes. "I was afraid ok? But I can admit when I was wrong."
"Well, if I'm being honest, I was afraid too," Jeremy said. He looked out at the crowds crossing the courtyard pathways, watching children run with sparklers in hand as attendees gathered around the main performance stage.
"Hey," Erin said.
Jeremy looked at her. "Yeah?"
"I'm proud of you."
"Thanks. But Ralph was the one who pulled all the strings."
"Yeah, but you had the idea. He never would’ve done it without you. You should be proud of that."
Jeremy’s eyes softened as he looked away. "It does feel good having a fresh start."
“I’m sure it does,” Erin replied. The two looked through records for a moment before she continued. “So… you wanna talk about us?”
"If you're ready.”
"I might be," Erin said. "But there are some things I wanted to cover before we start getting more serious.”
Jeremy spoke reactively. "Look, I know my past was messy. I did some crazy things. But I want you to know that I am ok leaving that all in the past and closing that chapter of my life.”
Erin’s eyebrow raised with intrigue.
"Oooh? And what chapter would that be exactly?" she spoke with a surprisingly playful inflection.
A group passed them, laughing loudly. Jeremy and Erin stepped aside with polite smiles before looking at each other.
“I guess what I’m saying is we don’t need to be doing any adventurous stuff. I don’t want you thinking that’s something I need,” Jeremy said. He reached for Erin’s hand and squeezed it. “It can just be us.”
"Yeah… about that," Erin said.
"Yeah?"
Erin tapped her worn nails against a record. "What if… I didn't want to close that door?"
Jeremy's eyes widened. "I'm sorry?"
Erin laughed nervously. “So listen… I’ve been thinking about it a lot. Even before you came back, actually. And the truth is… that night, when we had our fun with that other guy? It… changed something in me.”
Jeremy nodded slowly, still not entirely believing what he was hearing.
"I really liked it,” Erin continued, cheeks red. “So much that I was looking at some… special dating apps before you came back.”
Jeremy let out a surprised laugh. “Wait, really?!”
Erin burst into laughter. “Yes! It really did something to me…” Then, a bit quieter. “I really liked it…”
"I did too,” Jeremy said. “So what does that mean?”
Erin bit her tongue. “Well… what if we tried again?”
Jeremy stared, still processing what he'd heard. “And you’re sure you want that?”
Erin nodded. “I mean, can I be honest?”
“Of course.”
She blushed brighter. “Before you showed up, I literally matched with a married couple and was going to do it again.”
“Stop! Really?!”
“Yes!!” Erin said, glancing around nervously to make sure no one was listening. “But the reason why I wanted to talk to you is because of what you just said. Are YOU sure that it's something you want, or do you want to leave it in the past?”
Jeremy looked out at the crowd again, thinking for a moment. “This whole time I thought it was something you wouldn’t want.”
“Well, that’s why we’re talking.”
“I do like it.”
“I do too.”
He looked at her. “But if we do it, I want it to be clean from the beginning.”
“It will be.”
Jeremy’s heart was racing. “So is your thing married couples now?”
Erin shook her head and snickered. “No! It was who was available. I liked what we were doing. I guess I’m just excited to try all of it.”
“Man… not what I was expecting to hear.”
“I know, it’s crazy! But honestly, when you came back and we started again, I couldn’t believe it. I…” She let out a breathy laugh. “It felt like a dream come true.”
“It does, doesn’t it?” Jeremy said.
“It does.”
They smiled in the warmth they shared.
“Ok… so when do we want to do it?” Jeremy asked.
“Well… that was the other thing I wanted to talk about.” Ering glanced around the festival. “One downside to a small town is that word gets around quickly. But there’s a lot of visitors here today.”
“Are… are you saying you want to try something tonight?”
Erin shrugged playfully. “Only if you want to.”
Jeremy’s eyes brightened as they both scanned the crowd.
“So… let’s say I do. How would we do this?”
“What if I take a look around and see if anyone catches my eye?” Erin suggested.
"Ok… then what?"
"Then… maybe I invite him back to my place, or his, or… that motel down the street. And if everything goes well, we can turn it into something.”
“Are… are you going to let them know I’m showing up?”
Erin bit her lip. “I don’t know yet! Maybe? I wanted to play it by ear and see what happens. The last guy got so weird, so I want to try and ease them into it.”
Jeremy laughed, shaking his head. "Fair enough. And if you’re getting the vibe they’re not into it. We could always do videos too.”
“Or you could watch from a window,” Erin added sheepishly.
The words struck home.
“Ok, I like this,” Jeremy said.
"So we’re doing this?!"
Jeremy smiled. "Go for it."
"Ok!” Erin took one step back, eyes bright with excitement as she looked at Jeremy. “I guess I’ll start looking?”
“I guess. I’ll hang around. Feel free to check in with me.”
“Ok,” Erin said, jumping forward nervously.
“Alright,” Jeremy replied.
She wrapped her arms around him.
“Wish me luck!" she whispered.
“Good luck,” he replied, then gave her a gentle kiss.