Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey, just wanted to let everyone know I've been doing some serious re-evaluating of Violet Memoir over these last couple of weeks and realized that I've been approaching the story in a rather flawed way. While I don't regret it, there's a lot of fluff in my story which has really bloated things up and I realized that with the way the story is going, I would essentially be another 4 years away from finishing, which just doesn't seem reasonable on anybody (and that's under the assumption I would do 20-30k updates which is double my workload).

I'm wanting to ask you guys what you think would be best about this. The easiest (and likely ideal) solution would be to cut and streamline very hard. That means the story's pace is likely going to pick up immensely and the romance will lose a lot of its filler. I still plan on finishing each character's arc but there likely won't be any dates or anything like that. Some of that romance will have to be left on the cutting room floor. A lot of the romance will be scenes that directly tie into the plot.

This is a pretty radical change and would remove essentially a third of the game as I did intend to go to 21 days each initially but I figured out that even if I cut down the size of each of those days to the size of an update. It would still take me nearly 4 years to do unless I released multiple days at once, which would require me heavily increasing my workload or massively reduce the size of the days (which would cut fluff anyway).

Even with this change, it would still likely take me a little over 2 years to finish Violet Memoir, which is still a decent commitment but not 4 years long. This would, however, mean that Leigh and Oscar's routes are basically a third done already, and Lucas is just under halfway. Which is still plenty of time to do their whole stories.

The only other solution I could really think of, that didn't require me abusing the hell out of myself by increasing the workload, would be switching Violet Memoir back into being a singular story instead of diverging routes. This was actually how Violet Memoir was in its initial conception where we would jump between everyone's nightmare sequences but I scrapped that early in favor of a route-diverging system, something I very heavily regret now. The main issue with this is that it would require such extensive rewrites and still basically just be route-based just with a lot of shared scenes.

Please, I'd love any and all kinds of feedback for this. This is a pretty radical decision that will be determining Violet Memoir's future.

Comments

Allowingsoup99

You do what you want but my suggestion is split it up into 2 or 3 novels so you can take a break in between novels so your not killing yourself over this

Allowingsoup99

Like you said it would be another 4 years you could shorten it a little bit but you could make smaller novels every year and still take a break

MissingKeys

The main problem with this is that there would need to be points for the story to stop, which there really isn't. Violet Memoir was never meant to be a large story. I don't think it's a story that would work flowing across novels.

Mihiji_GreenWah

Holy cow, I had assumed the story was more then half over, I had no idea you had so much more in mind. :O While I would love to see this story exactly as you imagined it, 4 years is a huge commitment, especially if violet memoir was never intended to be a long term project. My suggestion would be to maybe add the dates in afterwards (similar to the bonus scenes in echo) that way you can wrap up the main story then take your time adding those in later.

MissingKeys

Initially, I had planned for us to be around the halfway point but then I started really planning out the story and I had so much fluff written down because I wanted to have my cake and eat it too by trying to turn Violet Memoir into what it never was, which was a slice of life story. I was trying to stretch the romance and the thriller into equal parts when I should really have the romance occur as part of the thriller plot.

Tirosu

Maybe have some timeskips, describing in loose detail what happened on the "skipped" days vs actually having the events happen closer together chronologically.

MrUndercity's

I have to completely honest and say I'm more here for the romance than the overarching plot

MissingKeys

The romance will still be there! It just won't have a lot of cute fluff like dates or anything. I'm cutting none of the main story beats I was planning on with the romance, just all the additional content.

MissingKeys

I don't think time skips will really work once the stakes get going. It's the main reason I'm avoiding those, alongside them not being needed for each story.

MrUndercity's

Hm in that case I can't really judge beforehand, the romance now feels really nice and cute and I guess I'd have to see how it feels with less side content to it

Mihiji_GreenWah

Hmmm... I think the smart choice here would be to cut the fluff and try to finish the character routes in the most satisfying way possible. While that might be the safest choice, it might not be the best choice for you if you feel passionate about the these scenes and developing the characters romances in the slower fashion you envisioned. Personally I feel the relationships pacing to this point have been great, but I could easily see the game heading into its climax with where each of the routes is atm. That being said, this is your game, and I think the most important thing here is to allow your story to be told the way you want it to be told. I plan on seeing this story through to the end Regardless of it taking 2 years or 4

Trevor Sizzle

I'd be willing to wait four years, but that is probably just me.

omndragon

I really enjoy the novel as it focuses on the characters. I feel that if you try to take that out a lot of the charm of the vn would be lost. I have no problem waiting on this vn for a few years.

MattKlo

Honeslty, as a reader (and definitely not a writer), part of me is excited to read that there's so much more content left, I really like this "fluff" you're writing, seriously. Sure, it may be filler for the main plot, but in my opinion it helps build the story, the characters and the whole world around them since it adds a ton of small details that makes them feel more "real" or "alive". It also allows for the characters and romance to develop more naturally, as in slowly paced, if you take advantage of it (which I think you are doing great). Yeah, this type of development takes time (I've been following other VNs that have been in development for 4 years+, which is mindboggling to me), and it takes a lot of commitment and perseverance from you the writer and us the readers. At the end of the day, of course, it's your proyect and writing, if you decide on going back and focus on what Violet Memoir was supposed to be at first (quicken the pace, focus on the plot, romance on the main story, as I've understood), we'll be still here to support and read your story :)

Lith Eaon

For me out of the two, I would prefer shortened routes. I think it allows for better flow to focus on one character for both the horror and romance sections rather than splitting them with half-routes and split focus. Also means you can focus on progressing the story rather than editing it which unless you really like editing would probably be more enjoyable for you. Overall, I am fine with it taking longer but do what's better for you.

MissingKeys

It will still focus on the characters. Their arcs will still be completed. There just will be less fluff moments where you're just enjoying the atmosphere and the banter of the characters.

This_One

I really like the route-based nature of the novel so far, but I understand it means about thrice the work. I would prefer shorter routes, with a de-emphasis on fluff and more focus on the story. An example of a visual novel that does this well is Echo. Though that did take a long time to develop (6 years I believe), it does have more routes. But, more importantly it does a similar thing to what you're considering. The start of each of the routes is primarily fluff, with character development and slow-burn stuff, and then partway through, things switch to being more story and horror focused. It does leave a lingering feeling of loss, of wanting more of those sweet moments, even if you are enjoying where the story goes. But that's part of the experience, wondering what simple romance stuff these characters could've done IF there weren't supernatural shenanigans demanding their attention. I'd love it if you took a similar path, with fluff-heavy starts that quickly get derailed by story events.

Oni

If I have to be completely honest, waiting longer for such a great story to be finished doesn’t bother me at all personally. I prefer stories with a slower burn and more small details added in to really flush it out. I’ve waited much longer for other VN’s that I love so only 4 years actually seems very reasonable to me. I have to agree with other sentiments here that hearing that there is “so much more” ahead than anticipated is really exciting. It simply means that there is even more that I could get to see from this story and these characters that I love so much. Though I can perfectly understand if the time frame is something that you being a writer just don’t feel comfortable or satisfied committing to. But as far as I’m concerned you’ll hear no objections from me regarding a longer wait.

omndragon

I honestly think the atmosphere and the banter are the best part. I always laugh. I feel this is something that really sets this vn apart from others. Don't get me wrong. I feel this vn would be still be good without it, but it would lack that charm that I find endearing.