Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Monthly Poll - What Comes Next?

  • Lavender Haze 228
  • Death by A Thousand Cuts 238
  • Guilty as Sin 248
  • 2024-08-03
  • 714 votes
{'title': 'Monthly Poll - What Comes Next?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Lavender Haze', 'votes': 228}, {'text': 'Death by A Thousand Cuts', 'votes': 238}, {'text': 'Guilty as Sin', 'votes': 248}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 8, 3, 15, 11, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 714}

Content

So... it has recently come to my attention that people would like a bit of warning before the official end of Midnight Rain - and this is the warning.

August will mark the official last chapter of MR, and in September there will be an epilogue. After that, I will continue MR in the same way I continue other stories (in bonus content).

This is marking the end of an era in the HCLU Patreon world... but as the saying goes: the end of an era, the start of an age.

And in the start of our new age (coming this October, which will also mark the 3 year anniversary of this patreon!) will be a brand new Sutton/Charlotte AU!

The fun of this one is that: you get to pick which one it is!

>>> let me tell you - all of these will be written eventually. What you are determining is the one that will be written first!

Sutton/Charlotte AUs -

Lavender Haze - (completely alternate universe - Sutton and Charlotte never met on sapphicspark)

Sutton Spencer is in the midst of a brutal divorce from Layla, is a professor at NYU, and the primary parent to an adorably precocious 2 year old daughter, Lucy. Trying to figure out the status quo in her life, she moves into her new home - a beautiful brownstone... with newly elected Senator Charlotte Thompson as her neighbor.

ft:

Sutton and Charlotte are in their 30s

Charlotte is a closeted senator who has never fallen in love or had her heart broken

Sutton being thrilled that this senator is willing to be a guest speaker in her classes

Charlotte shocked at how much she is able to feel for her single-mom neighbor

Neither are looking for anything serious...

Death by A Thousand Cuts - (Those Who Wait-universe, post-TWW au, a la Midnight Rain)

Charlotte never comes out in her interview and sweeps Sutton off her feet at her brother's wedding.

Instead, Sutton goes to Rome for her internship and works to get over Charlotte, while Charlotte becomes a congresswoman. Everything is going according to plan.

What isn't according to plan, though, is coming home to find that her two best friends are now deeply, madly in love. While Sutton is happy for Regan and Emma, she hadn't realized what it would feel like - once being the glue that held this group together, she is suddenly the third wheel.

While she escapes her apartment (the love nest), Sutton bumps into Charlotte. Charlotte, who asks Sutton if she'd like to have a coffee as a friend, sometime.

Sutton knows it might not be a good idea. But... she's worked to get over Charlotte for over six months. And, for better or worse, she likes Charlotte's personality, and she could really use a friend in her corner right now (a friend that isn't in the middle of a fresh relationship). Maybe a friendship with Charlotte could work out...

ft.

Charlotte being delusional that she and Sutton can "just be friends"

Sutton being delusional that she's over Charlotte less than 1 year post heartbreak

Jealousy is real

*Monica really wants me to do this one next

Guilty as Sin - (totally au - they have never met before!)

Sutton Spencer has finally finished her graduate degree, and - for the first time in her adult life - is out of school. She thinks that her next step is going to be getting her PhD, but... she's going to put that off for a year, take a little bit of time off. Unfortunately, that means she needs to find a job in the meantime.

Fortunately, freshly minted congresswoman Charlotte Thompson is looking for an assistant.

ft.

Charlotte being Sutton's boss

Charlotte in the closet

Charlotte "I've made a horrible hiring mistake" Thompson, as she stares at Sutton

Comments

Angelica

Oh. My. Word. 😍😍😍😍😍😍 I love all of these options. Excited that we still get more of them 😭🥰 through different AUs to come

Monica McCallan

As someone who listened and workshopped Death By A Thousand Cuts with Haley FOR FIVE HOURS in the car yesterday, I am humbly asking everyone to help me help that one succeed (because it's, personally, the one I'd love to read most right now)

Erica

Ohhh I can't vote yet because I'm torn between lavender haze and guilty as sin. I think I'm leaning more towards guilty as sin.

Angelica CK

Such a hard choice! I’m excited for whatever comes next💛 I did vote for Death by a thousand cuts though

Kayla

Death by a thousand cuts will absolutely ruin me…. I’m in

Dianna Norman

This one is so hard to choose. I love them all!

kassandra gravel

Omg. This is a hard decision I must say. But I'm glad we'll get all of those eventually, so It makes it a bit easier. Number 2 it is I love angst 🙏

Erica

I'm extremely excited for all 3 but I think I'm going to go with guilty as sin as it's the most different of the au's so far for Charlotte and Sutton!

Kathryn Crowley

Death by a thousand cuts sounds so GOOD… but Charlotte being Suttons boss is something i would kill to see

Jen Fernandez

It was hard to pick one, they all sound amazing!

Monica McCallan

In this essay (of bullet points) I will... wholeheartedly campaign for Death By A Thousand Cuts - Sutton and Charlotte less than a year out from cannon TWW - THE ANGST. THE ANGSTTTTTTT. - New relationship Regan and Emma - Regan when she finds out that Sutton is friends with Charlotte again (it will be dramatique) - Sutton and Charlotte bonding over both being third wheels with their co-workers and sibling/best friends - Caleb and Dean! - Sutton / Catherine Spencer writing collab - Jealous Charlotte! as she has to watch Sutton move on from her (spoiler: Sutton won't)

Angelica

Haley…happy wife happy life 😂

Flavia

My Pisces heart is bursting with this patreon and with the knowing that all three stories will be written! ❤️

Haley Cass

omg i know, i might have to skirt the poll results bc I'm really hearing it rn!

Liz Hendrick

This essay made me change my vote to Death by A Thousand Cuts.

Jess Bullock

This is the one I want!! So much delicious angst!!!

Kayla

I <3 jealous Charlotte Thompson

Jess Bullock

Death by a thousand cuts sounds so super angsty I need it!

Gabby

Lavender haze sounds new and different 😍 death by a thousand cuts is also a top but I like the idea of something completely new!

Jess Bullock

You have the most sway in this decision! But I will happily make petition signs with you

E.L.Fechner

I would love to read one where they are together and in the White House. I like the idea of seeing how Sutton and Charlotte handle the pressures of being there while raising a family.

Sonia

YOU HAVE MY VOTE!

Sonia

Also, now that I’m obsessed with TSE, I selfishly want to see more of Emma/Regan. And Sutton finding out. 😆

Sonia

I need this. Monica, fix the vote.

Dani

I’m devastated MR is coming to an end but knowing we’ll get bonus content AND 3 more AUs?! This patreon might be the best investment I’ve ever made 😅 Monica I’m sorry, I’m going lavender haze on this one!!!

K. Travels

Yes, please. Long term lesbian domesticity expressed through established relationships is sadly missing in sapphic lit. If anyone can do it and make it sexy, it’s Haley Cass and these two characters.

Robin M Lee

Happy Wife = Happy Life I'm work Monica - Death By A Thousand Cuts

Lauren

I'm sold - this sounds epic (esp the angst!)

Lauren

I was thinking the same - loving Emma/Regan :)

kimberlys323

Lavender haze won out for me too but DBATC would be a great option too.

sandrakb

Haha loving the campaigning

sandrakb

As much as I’d love to see the story continue a la TWW universe, Lavender Haze sounds sooo good. I read the synopsis and immediately forgot about my grief with MR ending

Jamie

Again, where is the “all of the above” option?

Cristy Kuhn

There are no bad choices!!! We are here for it all 🙏🏼🙌🏼🤓

Tina M

D. ALL OF THE (DAMN) ABOVE!! And rather than a poll, let us rank order the choices!...But if I have to choose: I defer to Monica's choice!

Tina M

1000% here for Regan's "ride or die", "I will cut a b$%^&", "help you hide the body" snark!!

Misty

Nearly impossible to pick between Death by Thousand Cuts and Guilty as Sin

Misty

Went with Guilty because it’s the most different from the original story!

Meri Kay Hodges

If you’re going to write all of them then best to go with your wife’s choice. Trust me, I’ve been married for years!

Lisa Tillery

As a wife, I will do anything to make my wife happy. Therefore, I will vote to make your wife happy. *teacher/mom look to literally everyone that hasn’t voted*

Lisa Tillery

Monica and Haley, for the sake of your marriage….as someone that has been married twice…I say we choose DBATC and then change the vote to something WYLEI related, possibly a story with Abbie. I have zero ulterior motives or deeply held soft spots for those three whatsoever. This is purely about y’all. Obviously.

Jessica Woodcock

I’ve gone for Guilty as Sin because I do love a boss/assistant romance! But Death by a thousand cuts sounds so good too! Plus, more Remma!!! Yes please

Chris

I picked Guilty as Sin because, well, it instantly made me smile thinking about the scenario. I think MR made me realize that I’d read these 2 falling in love a thousand times over. Although since Monica has a vote ( and probably some other persuasion techniques) we should assume DBATC will be first, after all Monica is moving to NE!

Kaslo

Do you plan to officially publish Midnight Rain? I would love a physical copy!!

Kim Bond

I trust both you and Monica... Thank you so much for these AUs! Love these two, and the wider cast, and it's great getting to spend time with them in different situations and variations

Noelle

👀 I picked number 3 but I stand by Monica. Happy Wife Happy Life! You can sway the vote Haley!

Libby

I chose Guilty as Sin because I love a workplace setting but I do love a jealous Charlotte. Hardest choice of the day!

B

this is the hardest decision of my life guilty as sin is giving josh/donna from the west wing which feels like its fate considering it has the same abbreviation tww ……

Hanna Baptist

Ooh, I want to read all three, obviously, but voted DBATC because I fucking love Regan and Emma and I feel like it makes sense to read that one first because it's Midnight Rain ish. Guilty As Sin is very intriguing, though, so I'd enjoy it too. Lavender Haze is also great, though the whole Sutton having a nasty break up thing makes me sad because she is so wholesome and lovely in the cannon universe.

Alex L

This is suuuuuch a difficult question, but thank you for preventing me from an endless loop of agonizing over my decision by telling us they will all be written. I’m a sucker for workplace romance so guilty as sin it is.

Angelica

THISSSSSSS!!! All of these point but a jealous Charlotte….❤️❤️❤️❤️

Betsy Walker

So hard to choose between 2&3. I’m happy with any of them

Kayla B.

Honestly I was going to vote for Guilty As Sin but your essay of bullet points and the fact that you have more intimate knowledge of these AUs caused me to vote DBATC. I trust you Monica!! LFG! ❤️

Kayla B.

Also it does seem like the AU would make sense to read along with The Snowball Effect

Kayla B.

You convinced me!

Melanie Reber

Pardon the language, but, holy fuck. The choices. Choice 2 really pulls on the heart strings and there's so much potential for angst, and I'm a huge sucker for angst. But, choice 3 could be really hot. Like, smokin. Gah! The agony.

MC

I am absolutely heartbroken that MR is coming to an end but I am also absolutely elated about all the other story lines in the pipeline. All that matters is that we are getting more of Sutton and Charlotte. Can never have enough. This Patreon is the gift that keeps on giving…thank you!!!!

MC

I second this

Taylor Eddleston

I’m stuck between 1 and 3!!!! Not a big fan of number two with all the angst and lack of communication and ability to feel your feelings.

Katie

Wow I sure am a sucker for a neighbors AU!!! This list is insane though 🤪

Stacey Thurston-Woods

I want them all but have been swayed by Monica to vote DBATC! Loving the titles btw, these acronyms come very naturally to me 😅

Dianne

Lavender Haze or Death By A Thousand Cuts 🙏

Nicola Lewis

3 years 🤯. Look at what you have grown and achieved!

Dianne

I voted Lavender Haze and immediately changed my mind to Death By A Thousand Cuts 😅

Mary Ann Bosworth

Tough choice, but glad these will all eventually be written. You rock!

kimberlys323

Would lavender haze mean Charlotte is presumed straight and we see her response to questions of romantic partners and Sutton offering to set her up with a coworker? Would be hilarious. Haha

Haley Cass

Sutton DOES presume her to be straight! It causes... some confusion

kimberlys323

I can see this playing out with awkward confusion from both parties.

Dakota Pruiss

Haley. ALL OF THE ABOVE. For the love of all things Spencer/Thompson

Kelly

the emotions! the angst! no. 2 is a need not a want 🧎🏻‍♀️

Dalila Ribeiro

I am voting for Death By a thousand cuts and I think this one should get extra 10 votes because it is Monica’s choice and she should have power 😝

montserrat

I like the version of them in their 30s cause that's when Elizabeth would be more insistent on putting sense into Charlotte and I would love to see more of her

AF

The way I keep coming back here to peek at the poll progress 😂 come on lavender haze!!!

Lauren

I check all the time too 😂 but come on DBATC!!!

nicole

Excuse me? Why is Death by Thousand Cuts losing?!?! WE ALL NEED THE ANGST 😭 and jealous Charlotte will always be my favorite side of her.

Lauren

I know 😭 I want jealous Charlotte I want more Regan and Emma too. It sounds so good 😞

Dianne

I really want this story! Even while reading Midnight Rain I was wondering how would it have played out if they'd bumped into each other sooner.

Lucía

Delusion and Charlotte jealous?! No doubt DBATC! I'm here for the angst ❤️‍🔥

Megan Z , [sapphic_graphics_and_reviews]

I’d even love the other side of like Charlotte being president and how her and Sutton navigate that and once she’s not in office .. or like another series as the girls older reflecting on their time in the White House and having 2 moms

M P

Not #2 feels overdone. I don't know why since you've never done it. But I'd like something AU

Spanglish sapphic

I love the idea of workplace/forbidden love romances swoon BUT the neighbors-lavender haze will deliver on the friends to lovers/ hot sexy time and Sutton being a young mom- which I loved in MR. Also on #3 which is winning- would Sutton work for a member of congress given her Dad was or is an elected official? Senator?

Trinity

Way too hard to choose Need all of it

Sarah-Maude Godbout

Well…I think that we have spoken…WE WANT THEM ALL!! ;)

AAM

All of them. Please and thank you.

Kenzi Rose

PLS do death by a thousand cuts next 😭