Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Rose v. Caroline Showdown

  • Rose Elliston 505
  • Caroline Parker 533
  • 2026-03-15
  • 1038 votes
{'title': 'Rose v. Caroline Showdown', 'choices': [{'text': 'Rose Elliston', 'votes': 505}, {'text': 'Caroline Parker', 'votes': 533}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 3, 15, 20, 59, 49, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1038}

Content

To (probably) no one's surprise, Charlotte was the resounding winner.

Honestly, for a couple of days it looked like Rose was giving her a run for her money!

So now it comes to this... Rose vs Caroline. The two women who have stolen the hearts and minds of the Dalton women - which is, actually, kind of fun when you think about it.

(this poll is only open to those on the tiers with access to The Game Plan, so the results will not be skewed by anyone who doesn't know Rose. Whatever happens here is fair and square)

Comments

SJ

🌹🌹🌹

Tina M

Now this is a brutal choice…😳🫣

viviana

rose deserves her moment !!!!

Melissa

Ugh I can’t believe I had to choose, I love both of them 😩

Ramona E

Yayyyy! So excited Rose made it! She has become my fave the more that we get about her

Alex L

This is so though because on so may level I think Caroline, but also Rose!!!

B

Okay but Caroline is a lawyer 🫦

sarrah

🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

Lilisionnach

God, I love both of them, but I gotta go with Rose. Her and Autumn just hold special places in my heart.

Robin

Nasty of you to ask us to choose. They're both amazing people.

Valeria Cabriolu

I will always love Caroline most... But now that we've seen so many new glimpses of Rose I just can't get enough of her 🥹 there's a reason why both of these women stole those precious Dalton's hearts!!

Megan

This is the hardest choice I’ve had to make when voting in the HCLU yet!

Lauren

who can resist rosie posie?

Erin Hubay

Looking at the title I was assuming this was a bonus post conversation between the two haha (in my dreams)

Angelica

I request that a Hamish button be the automatic “I can’t chooseeeeee” option

Jenn Stephens

I love this soooo much. 🥹 "Rose vs Caroline. The two women who have stolen the hearts and minds of the Dalton women - which is, actually, kind of fun when you think about it. "

Kim Bond

Is there a group therapy option for having to make these choices? 😂🧡🧡

Chance

Caroline has had my heart for so long but Rose stole it the moment she knocked the soccer ball out of Abbie’s arms 🤣

Heather

ABSOLUTELY NOT.

Chance

Who will win, biggest simp lol

Rachel

Ok I love all of you. But Rose could not be.... without Caroline. She's the OG. Abbie wouldn't be Abbie without her. That also means she would have never had the impact that she did on rose that planted the seeds for current rose.

Meg Helen

I love Rose and Abbie. LOVE them. But I fell in love with Caroline long ago and well... you just never forget your first 🔥🔥 (HCLU crush, that is)

Linda B

Caroline Parker! ♥️♥️♥️♥️

Iris

For me it was when she kicked the soccer ball in Abbie's dad's face. Knew she was my girl then and there

Lucia G.

This one hurt haha

Jamie B

Omg .....

Meri Kay Hodges

I voted for Caroline because she’s one of favorites. I like Rose and it was tough to choose. I think I will like Rose even more once I see more of her and Abbie and Cassie together.

HRM

Love Caroline, but I’m sorry…it’s gotta be rose

Kayla B.

This was incredibly difficult! Gotta go for my OG knight in shining armor though!

Ange Elson

I only just read Abbie's story. And having been a very, very big Caroline fan, I'm now a Rose convert... switched my vote in this poll. <3

Quilt

Caroline was my introduction to the HCU. My loyalty lies with her, but I love all the Parker’s + Rose by extension ❤️

Anna

I adore Caroline so much still. I'm waiting for Rose tho

Cat H.

Love the way Caroline loves Hannah. Rose will have her moment, she is new to the HCLU, but give it up for Caroline an under appreciated dedicated woman.

Laura McKenna

I love them both but I loved Caroline first 🥰

Linda B

50/50! Love that for them 😂♥️

Kristianna

My step-parents have been every bit of the Caroline every child deserves in a bonus-parent 🥹 Caroline all the for me- and then every 👏🏻 bit 👏🏻 of 👏🏻 Rose 👏🏻