I Knew You Were Trouble - Part 24 (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
Let's finish up our day in court...
Part Twenty-Four
Maya had never before wished she’d pursued law right out of finishing law school.
But she’d give just about anything to have more experience, because she would give anything to try to figure out how this was going.
Then again, that was a paradox, wasn’t it? Because if she’d gone into practicing law, would she ever have crossed paths with Autumn? She’d probably never be here, feeling Autumn sitting next to her – so tense, like she was ready to crack wide open – experiencing the world’s shittiest sensation, like her own heart was on the line.
Apparently, that was her destiny with Autumn, wasn’t it? To feel like her heart was on a highwire, teetering back and forth.
First, when it came to their sexual relationship turning romantic, and now with this whole situation with the twins.
She’d listened to both of Autumn’s parents give their own testimonials, answering questions by their lawyer and Jillian, which made her feel fucking sick. Particularly Autumn’s father.
The thing that Maya had to admit was that the notorious Pastor Alton really knew how to orate. She supposed it wasn’t surprising, given who he was. But, fuck, all the man needed was more access, and he could be a hit televangelist.
The only person she found even more sickening was Seth.
Who’d sat up there, staring more at Autumn than the twins or the lawyers or the judge, like he was starved for the sight of her. Really rich, considering he was wearing a wedding ring, and Maya was positive he had multiple children at home with his wife.
It took everything she had in her not to hop up and rush him on the stand, after what Autumn had shared with her about their relationship.
But all that would do – all any confrontation, at this point would do – was make her, and therefore Autumn, look unstably emotional. Standing up in the court room to face down Autumn’s sexual abuser was what Maya wished she could do. It wasn’t what Autumn wanted or needed.
“I’ve known Honor and Haven since they… well, since they were born. I’d been in a relationship with their sister – with Autumn – for years. I spent quite a bit of time at the Alton house, as well as the church and the volunteer programs they run. Pastor Alton has never shown himself to be anything less than an upstanding, righteous man. He cares about his kids and his congregation and any other lost soul who comes to him. You’d mentioned before that I’m his protégé, and yes ma’am, that’s true. But the only thing that I’m unsure of in my future is knowing I’ll have the capacity to care about as many people, to help as many people, as he does.”
Maya had wanted to scratch his goddamn eyes right out.
The only thing that kept her still was Autumn sitting firmly next to her, hip to shoulder, still as a stone. She’d had a fire in her eyes when Seth had spoken, her hands curled into tight fists in her lap.
Autumn’s mother, during her time on the stand, seemed like a dutifully trained – and completely broken – person. In so many other circumstances, Maya would likely feel bad for a woman in her position.
But this was the woman who’d allowed Autumn – and her sisters – to be treated like chattel.
Maya was sure that her tears were likely real, because she seemed one moment away from a complete breakdown as she stared across at Autumn, Honor, and Haven. But particularly at Autumn.
No, neither Honor nor Haven had ever expressed unhappiness at home, she’d sworn, her voice wobbling. No, they never asked to live with Autumn. We haven’t even had contact with her since she – she left.
That statement, at least, had given Jillian the established proof she’d needed to verify that there was no possible way Autumn had any contact with the twins prior to running away, absolving Autumn of any wrongdoing, here. Thankfully.
While Pastor Alton hadn’t gone into full performance mode, as Maya was sure he could. He obviously wasn’t a stupid person by any means. He didn’t dial up any theatrics like he was giving a sermon, but he spoke in that same tone.
Delivering a performance.
“I won’t sit here and tell you that Honor and Haven – or any of my children – weren’t encouraged to understand and, at times, write about scripture. Isn’t it my job, not as a pastor, but as a father, to shepherd my children into the warmth of God? I’d argue, in fact, that it’s my highest calling. But the notion of what is being said: being locked in a cage? Confined and then forced into religious compliance? None of my children have ever experienced that treatment. The joy and satisfaction I receive in being a father comes from my children following in my path – our paths – as they find their own footholds in the world.”
Maya had never felt the need to call her parents and tell them she loved them as much as she did today, in this courtroom.
Needless to say, the morning had been grueling. Four hours of interviewing and testimony from Honor and Haven first, then both of their parents, Seth, and two other witnesses to act in defense for Autumn’s parents. And none of it made Maya feel even close to certain.
At one, after the testimony of Mrs. Corbin, a very kind looking – looking being a key word there, clearly – older woman, who’d been a congregant of the church for decades, Judge Ackland cleared his throat.
His expression gave nothing away, no indication of emotion or where his thoughts may be, which made sense but she also hated it. Maya truly hoped was as even-keeled and insightful as he seemed to be, as articles that wrote about him online purported him to be.
Even his voice was the definition of emotionless, as he announced, “The Court is adjourned for lunch. We will reconvene at one-thirty.”
With that, Honor and Haven were whisked back with Rhea for their own lunch break. They both gave Maya and Autumn a long, wide-eyed look that belied their own nerves, and it twisted Maya up inside.
And even after everyone else had filtered out, Autumn remained seated, exactly where she was. Staring out ahead of her, a blank stare that was more than mildly concerning.
Maya looked up and met Charlotte’s gaze, as she’d been sitting on Autumn’s other side. Charlotte, who Maya had never been so happy to see as she’d been this morning. Not only because of the power that Charlotte had and that she represented, but also because she knew how much it would mean, emotionally, for Autumn.
Maybe Autumn couldn’t process it right now, but when this was all over, she would feel that. She would feel it, deep in her bones, that Charlotte Thompson had cleared time in her schedule to come to Ohio and support her.
And, in this moment, Maya loved Charlotte for that.
She also, admittedly, found it a little amusing – at least, as amusing as she could find anything right now – how deeply lost Charlotte seemed, as she glanced back to Autumn. Like she was out of her own emotional depth, unsure of what to say.
Because Charlotte wasn’t someone who would offer platitudes or false assurances, and that made things needlessly clearer to Maya: they truly didn’t know how this was going to play out.
Maya might not come close to having Charlotte’s power or charisma or pedigree, and she didn’t have Autumn’s intensity or iron will, but she realized that at this moment, her skill came from her ability to be a chatterbox.
Charlotte cleared her throat, garnering both of their attentions as she stood. “I’m going to meet with Jillian.”
Autumn tore her gaze from where she’d been staring out into space, nodding sharply. “Yes. That’s – I’ll come, too.”
Maya caught the way Charlotte hesitated, looking like she wanted to encourage Autumn to do otherwise, but like she didn’t know how to handle saying that in a delicate way. “Will you do me a favor, instead? I’m feeling kind of lightheaded – probably from not having had anything to eat this morning.”
Autumn wasn’t the only one whose stomach had been in knots all morning.
“I thought we could grab a sandwich from the vendor downstairs and sit outside for a few minutes, before going to meet with Jillian. Just five minutes,” she tacked on.
“It would probably be a good idea to get some fresh air,” Charlotte murmured in agreement.
Autumn reached up and rubbed her temples, but acquiesced with a sigh, “Maybe you’re right.”
***
She and Autumn sat side by side on the steps outside of the courthouse a few minutes later, both of them holding halves of a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. The only thing Maya had trusted at all from the vending options.
Though, she was reasonably sure neither of them wanted to eat it. But she also wanted Autumn to eat something, even if it was only a bite, so she gamely brought her half up and bit a big piece out of it. “Mmm, what an incredible sandwich this is. Gourmet, really.”
Autumn gave her a sidelong look, her lips twitching up in a way that made Maya’s heart sing to see. Just the littlest give into something lighter. And she let out another deep sigh, before she took a small bite of her own sandwich.
After she swallowed it, Autumn muttered, “We can’t run away together. With the twins,” she tacked on, as if Maya had proposed multiple scenarios of them running away together instead of just the one. “It wouldn’t – we can’t do that.”
There was a deep crease between her eyebrows, like she’d genuinely been giving it thought.
… fair, because Maya hadn’t been kidding.
She hadn’t seen any other way. She still didn’t see any other option if Honor and Haven were ordered to go back to their parents.
Honor and Haven, those two ridiculously sweet and naïve teenage girls that made Maya care about them so deeply in the last few months, would go back to an abusive, religious cult? Where their own parents were attempting to marry them off, like livestock?
She didn’t have the relationship with the twins that Autumn did, and it made Maya feel like all of her seams were frayed. Like she needed to rail at all of the injustice in the fucking world.
And, beyond Honor and Haven as the biggest victims in that scenario, there was Autumn.
This beautiful, brilliant, strong, capable woman who’d already been put through the wringer so many times in her life. She’d already had to build herself up, to create a world in which she could feel somewhat secure in.
Honor and Haven coming back into her life only to be ripped away – and ripped away to go back to Circle of Mercy, at that – would destroy her.
“It just doesn’t make any sense,” Autumn continued, her voice hoarse, as she stared down at her sandwich, like she’d never seen PB&J before in her life. “We can’t really do that. They need stability, and we need to work, and… I’d never let you throw away your life like that.”
“I wouldn’t be throwing anything away,” she immediately refuted, curling her leg up under her to turn and look more directly at Autumn. Tracing her eyes over the sharp, beautiful lines of her profile.
So achingly beautiful.
“If it kept you – and Honor and Haven – safe and happy, it wouldn’t be throwing anything away,” she elaborated, her heart in her throat. She knew she sounded crazy, but… she meant it.
She’d never loved someone the way she loved Autumn. This intense, soul-grabbing, life-changing sort of feeling. Where she’d give anything to make her feel loved and secure.
“And I meant it when I said that I think things would get sorted out, eventually. It wouldn’t have to be forever.”
Autumn huffed out a quiet breath, shaking her head. She didn’t look back at Maya, though, just stared across the street as she asked, “Are you sure you want to do this as your job? Do what Jillian does? Work these sort of cases, all of the time?”
She sounded utterly incredulous. Like the very idea of Maya wanting to do this was incomprehensible to her.
Maya supposed she understood that. Even so, “Yes.” She looked down at her sandwich half with a thoughtful frown. “Even though it doesn’t make me feel good, I feel… like it matters.”
It mattered in a way that managing Charlotte’s scheduling and organization didn’t. At least, not in an enriching, fulfilling way.
Autumn didn’t respond to that, not for several moments. Which was okay. Sitting in silence with Autumn was something Maya had gotten used to right from the beginning of their working together. And especially in these last few weeks, as she’d gotten lost in her thoughts…
All that Maya could do in these moments was sit with her.
Which was why she was surprised when Autumn suddenly did turn to face her, eyes searching. “Can you tell me something that has nothing to do with this?”
“Did you know that cats have free floating collarbones? So they can essentially squeeze through any area they can fit their head through.” It was the first thing that came to her mind.
Autumn seemed thrown for a loop, eyebrows furrowing together as she spluttered, “What? Why – that’s not what I meant.”
“You said something that has nothing to do with this,” Maya defended.
Autumn smiled, though, and that was the ultimate goal. Still, she rolled her eyes. “Something else. Tell me… tell me… tell me something about you or me or us, but take me away from here.”
Ah, that made more sense, then. Kind of. For someone else, it made sense. She’d never known Autumn to want to get lost in thoughts of them, but Maya couldn’t say she didn’t like it.
“Okay. I imagine that even if I went right into practicing law, we’d still find our way to one another.”
Autumn’s eyes narrowed slightly. “How do you figure?”
“I think I’d have liked to work for Jillian, no matter what. I figure I’d have gotten to that point, eventually. And then we would have met.”
“And how do you think things would go, if that’s how we met?”
“I’d probably have asked you out pretty early on, if we didn’t work together,” Maya had no problem answering. Because she knew exactly how she responded to Autumn, and how that would be true in every iteration of them.
Autumn scoffed softly, but didn’t disagree. “And… how do you think that would have gone?”
“Well, I think you would have been devastatingly attracted to me. As evidence supports that theory.” She fluttered her eyelashes toward Autumn.
Autumn hummed in response, but couldn’t disagree, so Maya counted that as a win.
“And you would have found me annoyingly charming.”
“Emphasis on the annoying part, if we’re thinking about when we first met,” Autumn drawled.
Maya snorted out a laugh. “Yes, that’s why I said it.” She sobered, searching Autumn’s eyes with her own. “And I think you wouldn’t have accepted my asking you out, even though we didn’t work together. But I have to imagine you’d have been more than tempted to take me up on an offer of not-dating.”
Autumn’s gaze was intense, as she ran it down Maya’s face, lingering on her lips, before she moved it back up. “Your imagination is not wrong.”
“Therefore, we’d have found our way here, no matter what,” Maya came full-circle, breathing the words out, as her heart fluttered at the look in Autumn’s eyes.
Eyes that Autumn squeezed closed for a few seconds, before she leaned in and pressed her lips to Maya’s. The kiss was soft, achingly soft, and Maya ached with it.
Her eyes were still closed when Autumn pulled back and murmured, “About what I said… what I said… this morning…”
“That you love me,” Maya supplied, blinking her eyes open, but staying leaned in, wanting to stay close.
She could feel Autumn’s deep exhale, even before she watched her nod. “Yes. That I… love you.”
And then, she paused.
Did it make Maya feel good? Uh, absolutely not. In fact, it made her feel like her heart was squeezed too tight by some foreign source outside of her own body.
But did Maya understand?
Yes, which was why she hadn’t really allowed herself to revel in Autumn’s proclamation.
Well, that and the fact that Autumn had said it to her at literally the worst time. How could Maya really feel happy – because the biggest part of her wanted to be elated. The woman she was so in love with, the woman her soul fucking yearned for, the woman she’d craved for long before they’d started sleeping together was in love with her! – when they were on the verge of Autumn’s life falling to shambles?
It was the best thing she’d ever heard, no matter what the circumstance. Because she’d thought for months that it was an impossibility, that it would never happen.
But…
“Autumn, while I am someone who has a lot of hopes, I’m also a realist,” she murmured, reaching out to take Autumn’s hand in hers, hoping the touch would be reciprocated.
She gently stroked her fingertips down the back of Autumn’s hand, over her knuckles, testing the waters. Seeing if Autumn was receptive to her touch.
Autumn looked directly at her, lifting her eyebrows in that no-nonsense way that always made Maya want to smile. “I don’t enjoy when you approach me like you’re approaching a feral cat.”
Maya paused, a grin flashing across her face. “But… you’ve gotta admit, you have a lot of startling similarities.”
Autumn rolled her eyes, but Maya knew she saw the edges of her lips twitch up, even if it was only for a second. That second of lightness right now, though, meant everything.
It meant even more when Autumn turned her hand over and firmly clasped Maya’s, lacing their fingers together tightly. Like she not only was allowing Maya to hold her hand, but like she wanted it.
“There’s nothing wrong with being a feral cat in human form, you know,” she murmured, stroking her thumb over the back of Autumn’s hand, caressing her knuckles. “I have a wonderful track record when it comes to that, in fact.”
Autumn rolled her lips and shook her head rather than respond. And when she did speak, Maya didn’t expect what came out of her mouth: “As you were saying – you’re a realist?”
She blinked, her smile fading slightly. “Right. I’m a realist. Which means…” She trailed off, taking in a deep exhale, holding it for long moments, before expelling it. Self-soothing for what she was about to say, as a realist. “I know that you said you love me when you were in a really vulnerable moment. And if you aren’t ready to keep saying it, then, I get it.”
She didn’t have to like it, but she understood it.
The fact of the matter was that she loved Autumn, and, in turn, she knew Autumn.
“It’s not… that’s not what I’m saying. I just want you to know that it – even if this afternoon doesn’t go well, I still feel that way. Even if I’m not able to really show it properly. Even if I pull away. I don’t know. I just want you to know it’s still true.”
Those butterflies, the ones that felt so incongruous with where they were and what was going on around them today, sprang to life. And even as she felt them, her throat felt so tight, at the strained emotion in Autumn’s voice.
“I know. I’ve known it for a while. And I’ll keep knowing it. Okay? You don’t have to worry about me, about that, right now,” she whispered back, hoping Autumn knew Maya the way Maya knew Autumn.
She wouldn’t turn and run away if there were a few more bumps on this road. Bumps that we, unfortunately, very understandable.
Autumn let out a shuddering breath. “Okay.”
***
When Autumn went inside to meet with Jillian, Maya stayed outside for just another minute. Needing to get out some of this restless energy that had taken up space inside of her, pacing around the sidewalk. Trying to think of something to do, anything to do. Especially since it seemed that Autumn wasn’t on board with the running away idea.
She didn’t want to sit idly by, being a passive bystander in whatever was going to play out today. She wanted to do something. She wanted to make a damn citizen’s arrest on both of Autumn’s awful parents.
It felt ludicrous that this was even something they had to do. Like, how could they have to be in court, arguing against two innocent teenage girls going back to a fucking cult?
It –
She paused, tilting her head in question when she saw the back of a woman’s head, the same pale blonde hair as Autumn, quickly disappear around a shop across the street, several buildings down.
That couldn’t be Autumn; she’d just watched her go into the courthouse.
And it couldn’t be Honor or Haven, right? They should be with Rhea. Unless they’d snuck away and were trying to pull some sort of disappearing act.
Which, actually, wasn’t that crazy, when Maya thought about it. After all, the twins had broken all of the rules they’d ever been taught, had rebelled in the biggest way – literally risking their physical safety – to get out of here, once.
Maya’s stomach sank as she hurried across the street and down the sidewalk. She could only imagine what kind of plan Honor and Haven might have hatched this time, and this time, they had nowhere else to go. No other relatives they knew the way they knew Autumn. And the world would eat those two kids alive.
She picked up the pace into a run, needing to make sure she didn’t completely lose them.
Concern pounding through her veins, she turned around the corner of the small store she’d seen them disappear behind, finding herself in a small alleyway.
“Okay, runaways, I get it, but–” Her words completely fell away into silence when she actually got a good look at the woman.
The single person standing here, so definitely not the twins.
And she did have the same shade of blonde hair that the twins and Autumn had.
She had the same blue eyes, the same face shape; the resemblance shared between all of the Altons – at least, all that Maya had encountered – was crazy. She and her sisters shared some similarities, but nothing like this.
The mystery Alton froze, going still as a statue.
Honestly, she looked as frightened as if Maya had pulled out a weapon and told her give me your purse. Especially when she jerked the large purse she was carrying up to her chest and cradled it closely in a death grip.
Maya held both of her hands up, switching gears immediately. Showing Mystery Alton that she didn’t have anything with her, and that she wasn’t a threat. She didn’t step closer, either.
And she had the errant thought about Autumn’s feral cat comment.
Maybe people didn’t like being treated like feral cats, but the Altons all acted exactly like feral cats. And Maya did have a great track record. With both feral cats and Altons.
“I didn’t mean to scare you,” she spoke softly, giving her a small smile.
She wore the same kind of clothing Honor and Haven had on the day she’d met them. A floor-length skirt or dress – Maya couldn’t be positive, because she also had a black jacket buttoned up all the way to her throat. Her hair was tugged back in a neat chignon, and she looked so tense, like she could crack at any second.
Just like Autumn, her mind supplied, and… it made Maya feel so soft for this woman.
Even if she was here to support their parents, which she realized was a jarring possibility. Actually, it was more a probability than anything, and while her stomach sank at the thought, she found she couldn’t quite harbor any negative feelings toward her.
If Autumn hadn’t had the strongest constitution known to humankind, this could have been her. If only a few parts of Autumn had been tweaked, this could be her. Or the twins.
“I thought you were Honor or Haven,” Maya added, trying to test the waters. Gauge what Mystery Alton’s response would be.
Her eyes widened and her lips parted on a surprised inhale, before she darted her eyes over Maya’s shoulder. Still, though, she didn’t say anything.
Which only made Maya more alarmed.
Lowering her hands slowly, she asked, “Are you all right?”
Mystery Alton exhaled, long and measured, before she nodded. The briefest, most uncertain nod… before she cut it off, like she couldn’t say for sure that she was, indeed, all right.
“I’m Maya. Lindsay. Maya Lindsay.” She breathed out a laugh at how she’d said that, trying to keep the mood light. “Not trying to be James Bond or anything.”
“Are you…” Mystery Alton trailed off, swallowing thickly. She continued to hold her purse against her chest like Maya was going to dart out and rip it from her at any moment. “You’re with Autumn.”
Surprise filtered through Maya, her lips tugging into a considering frown. Okay, so Mystery Alton definitely knew something. Not that she’d believed she was here by coincidence, that simply wasn’t possible. Suspicion ate through Maya, but she had to keep it buttoned up, especially if Mystery Alton was willing to talk to her in some way.
“I am,” she confirmed, wondering if Mystery Alton knew just how with Autumn Maya was. “We work together.”
Mystery Alton’s eyebrows furrowed deeply, obviously suspicious as well. “But… you’re also… you and Autumn are also…”
Well, damn. So, Mystery Alton did know how with Autumn Maya was. She was desperate to know how, especially since it seemed she struggled to voice the truth of their relationship, despite knowing it. But it wouldn’t do her any good to deny it; it would just make Mystery Alton see her as a liar.
“Autumn and I are also in a relationship, yes,” she supplied, keeping her voice light and easy. Thinking about how Honor and Haven had seemed so unsure about queerness and queer relationships, and she had to imagine Mystery Alton was the same.
“Yeah, our – my father,” she stumbled over the word, like she was unsure of how to assign ownership of their parents, given Autumn’s excommunication. “Has – he’s spoken about it. A lot. In the last couple of months.”
Everything she said was hesitant and stilted, and Maya’s curiosity was piqued.
If Mystery Alton was here to support their parents, why wouldn’t she be up at the courthouse? Why was she lurking two blocks over, in an alleyway?
“I hadn’t gotten the impression that your parents spoke about Autumn much,” Maya kept the conversation going, trying to glean anything she could.
Mystery Alton immediately shook her head. “Oh, they don’t. Well, they – they didn’t. Until the twins… and this…” She glanced around them, as if encapsulating the situation the Altons were embroiled in by that single word.
“Do you mind my asking what your name is? Since I already know you’re an Alton and all,” Maya tacked on, hoping to allay some of her concerns. After all, the woman had already confirmed she was an Alton. What was the harm in specifying?
Still, she was quiet for several long beats, staring at Maya with wide, uncertain eyes.
Long enough that Maya decided the best thing to do was reel it back. “You don’t have to–”
“I’m Florence Miller. Well – Alton. But, Miller, now.”
Florence… Maya was assisted by the alphabetical nature of the Alton names, but in going over all of the details of the case with Autumn and the twins, she’d memorized all of the ages of their other siblings. So, she knew that Florence was a very newly turned twenty-one.
And Maya knew, obviously, that anyone could be married over eighteen, and people did make that decision, themselves. But… she knew that wasn’t Florence’s situation. She knew it wasn’t really her choice. She’d become a Miller at nineteen, after having been properly engaged – per their father’s choice of “suitor” – at eighteen.
“Florence… nice to meet you,” she tested the waters, offering a friendly face, not expecting Florence to return the sentiment.
She didn’t.
She looked like she was ready to bolt at any moment, so Maya kept things moving.
“Do you maybe want to talk about why you’re here? Even if it’s to see your parents, I can let you know where to go.”
It was the last thing she wanted to do, but Maya was getting a little desperate to know what the fuck was going on, and she needed to get back to the courthouse, herself.
Florence’s eyes went so wide, they were practically saucers, and she jerked backwards, shaking her head vehemently. “No! No, I’m – don’t – don’t tell them that I’m here. You can’t.”
Well, then. This was really fascinating.
Maya didn’t let her interest show, for fear of scaring her off. Feral cat rules.
“I promise you, I won’t be conversing with your parents,” she swore.
As much as she’d love to tell them off, Jillian and given Autumn – and Maya had been included in the conversation – not to engage any further. It wasn’t good for their case to get into anything personal with them.
“Is there another reason you’re here?” She gently prompted.
Florence’s hands tightened on her bag until her knuckles turned a bright white, and her breathing came so quickly, Maya was concerned she might hyperventilate.
“I…” Florence started, then stopped, biting at her bottom lip. “I… I don’t know what to do,” she confessed, her voice an anguished whisper.
Maya couldn’t help herself from taking another step closer, moving slowly, approaching Florence as carefully as possible. “Why don’t you just let me know what’s going on? Do you want to see Autumn?”
If not their parents, Autumn seemed like the right person to bring up, next.
Florence didn’t have the same terrified response to that the way she had their parents. In fact, the look in her eyes seemed brighter, almost like she hadn’t considered that as a real possibility.
Maya thought about how Honor and Haven viewed Autumn. As their safe space, even after they hadn’t seen her in years, and it was so clear Florence shared that sort of residual, lasting love for Autumn.
But Florence shook her head. “No, I can’t. That’s not what – I can’t.” She took a deep, bracing breath. “Autumn… she – she always took care of us.” A fleeting smile toyed at Florence’s mouth. Both melancholic and light, simultaneously, and it made Maya ache for her. “And life was so much worse when she left. And – and I don’t want Honor and Haven to come back to that. I don’t want them to have to…” She trailed off, clenching her jaw tightly, regrouping. “I want Autumn to take care of them, again. They’ll be better off with her.”
“I think Autumn would love to see you. I can go get her, really quickly. You don’t even have to come to the courthouse–”
“No,” Florence’s voice was firm and unyielding. “I can’t. I – my parents can’t know I’m here. Aaron, m-my husband, he doesn’t know I’m here. He thinks I’m with Cindy. And I have to get back, soon.”
Her comments were disjointed, obviously getting worked up, nervous.
“All right. That’s okay. What can I do? Why did you come here?” Maya pushed a little harder, feeling a certainty that Florence could flee at any given moment.
“Here. I – can you get this to Autumn? To the lawyer? The judge?” Without hesitation, Florence tugged the strap of her bag over her head and shoved it into Maya’s arms.
The move was so unexpected, Maya nearly dropped it. She managed to secure it, holding it as carefully as if she were holding a living baby. “What’s in here?”
“It’s… you’ll see. But you didn’t get it from me,” Florence stated, and there was a strength there that Maya recognized, the same kind of backbone Autumn had. It was lurking there, just under the surface. “My life would be over if my parents or Aaron or anyone at church knew. Promise me. Please.”
There was a fear that was laced through her words, one that told Maya she wasn’t being hyperbolic. She was genuinely terrified.
So, Maya said the only thing she could: “I promise.”
Florence’s exhale shuddered out. “I have to go. I need to make sure I’m back before…” She trailed off, shaking her head.
Maya carefully shifted the bag, swinging the strap over her shoulder, as she reached out a hand. She didn’t touch Florence, but reached out enough to gesture for her to stop. “Wait. Do you have a phone?”
Florence hesitated, clearly suspicious, before she nodded. “Yes.”
“And you have it with you? Like… you don’t keep it locked away?”
“No, not since I left my parents’ house.” Florence’s hand went to her jacket pocket, protectively.
“Let me give you Autumn’s number,” Maya was this close to pleading, but she couldn’t help it. The idea of letting Autumn’s sister go back to their community without a lifeline… she couldn’t stomach it, and she couldn’t look Autumn in the eye and tell her she hadn’t tried to help.
Florence’s fingers twitched, but she didn’t reject the idea right away.
Which told Maya everything she needed to know, so she leaned into it. “Save her name as something else, something safe. Something your husband wouldn’t look twice at. And you never have to use it. But, this way, you have it if you ever want or need to.”
She waited, her heart pounding in the silence between them, waiting for Florence to react. To either run away or allow herself the lifeline.
Maya could have melted in relief when Florence slid her phone from her pocket, hesitating for a moment, before she unlocked it and handed it to her.
Maya leaned in slightly, wanting Florence to watch her, wanting her to see that Maya wasn’t doing anything she needed to be concerned about, as she entered Autumn’s number, but left the name blank for Florence to fill in. Then she handed it back, feeling a sliver of hope.
Florence accepted her phone back gingerly, like she was touching a loaded gun – and Autumn’s information was the ammunition. “Thank you.”
“You’re welcome. And – I mean it – Autumn would want you to use that number. Any time, any day.” Maya didn’t need to ask Autumn to know that was true.
Florence nodded again, sharply, before she looked around them, and started down the alleyway where her car was parked, without another word.
Maya was pretty sure this was the most clandestine thing she’d ever done, and she wondered if there would ever come a day where she could appreciate it, in an objective sense. At the moment, she simply felt filled with urgency.
She, too, looked around, making sure there was no one else here, before she knelt to the ground, and unzipped the bag.
It was neatly organized, but she wasn’t shocked by that. Florence was Autumn’s sister, after all.
On the top was – was that a burner phone? Who’d taught Florence about burner phones?!
She reached in and pulled it out, tapping on the screen. It didn’t demand any sort of passkey, simply opened to the home screen. And the only app currently on that home screen was the camera roll.
Maya’s blood was rushing through her ears, and she held her breath as she clicked play on the video.
There was no audio; she was sure that Florence had taken great care not to say anything. She’d also, very clearly, been careful not to capture herself in any reflections, which was brilliant.
But she made a point of capturing the address – Maya was sure it was Autumn’s parents’ house – as well as moving close to a calendar to verify the date, even though it would be verified on the metadata. Still, good thinking.
She moved through the house, before reaching the basement door, where she reached out a trembling, gloved hand – smart – to unlock the door, with a key she’d found stashed in a nearby cabinet.
Maya held her own breath as the view went down the stairs, and…
Sure enough, there it was.
A literal fucking cage with a school desk and a chair inside of it. The gate went from floor to ceiling, and was reinforced, drilled into the house fixtures. Florence made a point of showing that on the video, as well as the heavy-duty lock that was on the gate.
Maya felt sick to her stomach. She felt like she wanted to cry. Like she wanted to murder Autumn’s fucking parents with her bare hands.
Still, she watched as Florence then moved toward a large cabinet on the other side of the basement, using another key to open it.
There were so many journals stacked on top of one another. There had to be hundreds. And the shelves were all labeled, with all of the names of the Alton children.
She grabbed some of Honor and Haven’s journals –
Maya looked down, noting that Florence had taken the risk of putting several of them here in the bag.
Maybe it wasn’t ideal evidence of physical abuse, but it was certainly fucked up, and that was undeniable. It was absolutely corroborative of an unhealthy environment, she was sure as hell of that.
Quickly, she placed the phone back in the bag and securely zipped it back up, energy surging through her. She had to get this back, now.
Her rush to the courthouse was a blur, and she burst into the room acting as Jillian’s on-site office, out of breath, her hair most certainly a mess after having ran back here at full speed. She slammed the door closed, and everyone jumped, including herself.
“Didn’t realize how loud that would be,” she wheezed out. “This place could use some updating.”
Autumn, Charlotte, and Jillian all stared back at her with differing expressions.
Jillian in disdain – fair, given Maya’s abrupt entrance, though she was aware this was not a good look for her with her future employer – Charlotte with curiosity, and Autumn with a deep concern.
“Are you okay? Why were you running?” Autumn asked.
Well, more like demanded, as she stepped closer to Maya, reaching out for her. Which, Maya had the presence of mind to think, was objectively really nice. If this had been months ago, she didn’t think Autumn would reach for her like this, especially so openly.
But – not the time to think about that.
“I…” Maya trailed off, looking away from Autumn to Jillian and Charlotte, and – fuck.
She was, of course, going to tell Autumn the full story about her sister. But Florence was petrified about whatever she’d given Maya, and Maya had promised her anonymity. There could be consequences that Maya couldn’t even imagine for her, if anything about Florence’s involvement became public.
And she didn’t think Autumn would ever want Maya to sacrifice her sister’s safety, even if it was a trade off for – potentially – Honor and Haven’s custody case.
So, she had to make a split-second decision. In this moment, Florence was her client, and there was confidentiality she couldn’t breach.
“I found this bag outside.” She tugged it over her shoulder. “There’s a video from the Alton house, showing the cage. And there are the journals that Honor and Haven talked about.”
Everyone gathered around, the feeling in the room immediately shifting. Notching into something buzzy and light. Maya could feel it with every breath she took.
Still, Jillian leaned back, arching her a look. “A random bag of unverifiable items isn’t exactly a smoking gun.”
Maya nodded. “Yeah, I know that. But that video can be confirmed – the date and location? And the journals,” she felt invigorated, the realization shooting through her, as she snapped her fingers. Genuinely, feeling like a lightbulb went off. “Ohio’s Rule of Evidence nine-oh-one, subsection B, paragraph two,” Maya recited. “Allowing a nonexpert witness to testify about the legitimacy of handwriting. They introduced Mrs. Corbin this morning.”
She’d not only served as a character witness, but she’d also served to confirm Honor and Haven’s handwriting, as she’d overseen them in their youth group bible studies for years. Autumn’s parents had submitted written pieces from the twins about how fulfilling they found their lives, especially within the church.
Which Maya thought was utter bullshit; of course, they’d say that when they knew that everything they wrote would be passed on to their dad.
But now, in light of the journals, this was actually fucking great.
She hit play on the video after tugging the phone out of the bag, and they all watched. She could hear Autumn’s breath hitch where she stood next to her, when the cage came into view, and the urgency in the room shifted even more tangibly.
“Honor and Haven’s handwriting has already been verified, so we can introduce the journals to reinforce their testimony,” Maya continued, feeling like she was firing on all cylinders.
Because all they’d had before were Honor, Haven, and Autumn’s word. They didn’t have any of these physical belongings to prove the hours and hours they’d been forced to copy scripture, in said cage.
“I know it’s not perfect, but it’s pretty damning, all things considered. It’s not like we have to convince a jury; this isn’t a criminal hearing. No one’s being sentenced, we don’t have to prove guilt beyond a shadow of a doubt.”
They just needed the judge to be able to consider all of the pieces he was presented with in order to make an informed decision. To make the right decision.
Maya looked around the room, meeting everyone’s eyes again.
Well, not Autumn’s. Because Autumn was staring down at the phone, watching the video on replay, her expression completely shuddered.
But Charlotte – yes, Charlotte fucking Thompson – looked genuinely impressed, the corner of her lips tugged into a small, approving smile. All right, Maya would give it to Autumn. It did feel good to be on the receiving end of that.
And Jillian looked pretty damn similar. Less proud and more thoughtful, like the cogs in her head were turning. But the air around her seemed a lot lighter than it had earlier, less skeptical.
Jillian quickly stood, glancing down at her watch. “I need to take that bag to Judge Ackland before we reconvene.”
Maya wasted no time in handing it over. “I think it is also interesting to note that the local police reported that they’d done a preliminary visit to the house and didn’t report seeing anything in the basement… when it’s clear that cage is a pretty permanent fixture.”
Autumn had seethed about that, but hadn’t been surprised when they’d gotten that information. Millstead had a police chief, she’d informed Maya, but he was a locally appointed official in their town. And every town official was a congregant of Circle of Mercy.
Jillian paused, flicking her eyes back to Maya’s. “Indeed. Very interesting.”
Even though Maya knew this wasn’t a criminal hearing for the Altons, she hoped this was the first step toward it.
Charlotte walked past them, pausing to rest her hand on Maya’s shoulder, giving her a warm squeeze. “I’m going to join Jillian. My presence can sometimes be… useful. Even if I’m not officially working on the case.”
The thought of Charlotte standing in the background with her most intimidating expression was deeply appealing.
Only after both Jillian and Charlotte left did Autumn turn her attention to Maya. And it seemed she could see right through her, especially as she asked, “Where did you actually find that?”
Maya looked over Autumn’s shoulder, just to make sure the door was shut, then hesitated. They were in the courthouse; she didn’t trust what was being recorded anywhere. There was a camera in the top right corner, and she had to assume it was on.
So, she leaned in, bringing her lips so close to Autumn, she brushed against the shell of her ear. “Florence.”
Autumn reeled back, her eyebrows high on her forehead. “My sister?”
Maya quickly darted her eyes to the camera, hoping that Autumn realized what she was doing. She leaned in again, this time tugging Autumn into a close hug, something that looked natural.
It felt natural, and for a few seconds, she luxuriated in the feeling of Autumn’s body against hers, especially when Autumn returned the embrace.
“I saw her loitering down the street. We did the craziest back-alley trade that feels like it was in a tv show or something, where she gave me that bag, and I gave her your number,” she whispered, stroking her palm up and down Autumn’s spine. Feeling the tension radiating outward. “She wants the twins to be with you. But she’s also terrified of your parents or anyone finding that out.”
And Maya was pretty positive that if Florence was identified to the Court, she would be called in as a witness after providing this information, so.
She felt Autumn’s hands press tighter against her back, felt her shake her head, before she managed to find some words, “I just… I don’t even know what to say.”
“We don’t have to say anything right now. We just have to see what happens and be grateful that your sisters are brave as hell, just like you are.”
***
The next couple of hours felt less grueling than the morning.
Maya hadn’t known exactly what to expect, she supposed, but Judge Ackland had walked in with Jillian and Peter Wicks, talking in close conference. And Wicks did not look pleased, as he walked back to where Autumn’s parents were seated.
And she took a deep satisfaction at the expression on their faces when Judge Ackland called for Jillian to present the video, as well as the journals. For Mrs. Corbin to nervously have to compare handwriting samples she’d brought in from Honor and Haven’s written pieces, to the journals, and – even though the vein in Pastor Alton’s head had started to become visible – she’d confirmed that they did match, per the best of her ability to determine.
When Judge Ackland moved to making his final declaration, though, Maya wasn’t sure if it was a good or a bad thing that he didn’t take another recess.
Rather, he moved right into announcing, “Having considered the testimony, the evidence presented, the recommendations of the guardian ad litem, and the wishes of the minors involved, the Court finds that returning the Honor and Haven Alton to the parental home at this time would not be in their best interests.”
She felt Autumn’s hand reach for hers, and they locked hands without even looking, and she was positive that Autumn felt the same rush through her body that Maya was experiencing. Like this was so surreal to hear after the last few months.
Judge Ackland continued, “The Court recognizes both of the minors expressed wishes and their concerns regarding returning to their parents’ care. Accordingly, this Court will not order the minors to return to their parents at this time. The minors in question shall remain in their current placement with their sister, Autumn Alton, pending the dispositional hearing later this week.”
Holy fucking shit. Maya shouldn’t be surprised, and she wished she didn’t have to be. But… but life was so absolutely messed up, and Autumn’s hand tightened on hers so hard, her fingers might dislocate, but Maya didn’t care.
“This matter is hereby concluded for purposes of the requested custody determination. A written judgment entry reflecting the Court's findings and orders shall be filed. This concludes the matter before the Court.”
This was concluded. It was done.
They’d done it.
For several seconds after Judge Ackland spoke, there was no response in the room. Like everyone felt the way Maya felt, like they all needed a beat to allow this to sink in.
Autumn’s gasping inhale, like it was the first time she’d been able to breathe all day, was the sound that broke the silent barrier.
Autumn didn’t drop her hand, even when she stood up to meet Honor and Haven, who’d popped out of their seats to rush toward her. Which meant Maya stood with her, and was included in the embrace. She felt Honor’s arm thrown around her waist, her breath knocked out by how they landed against her.
Nothing dimmed the elation buzzing through her veins, though.
And, though the wide smile she couldn’t possibly wipe away from her face, Autumn turned her head to kiss her. Right here, in the middle of it all.
It wasn’t deep or searching; they were both too exhilarated and too aware of their surroundings for that.
But it was the loudest kiss Maya had ever experienced. It was a statement.
She knew the statement was heard loud and clear when Autumn’s father’s voice cut in, “Your Honor, my daughters cannot live with that – that perversion.”
Before Maya, Charlotte, or Autumn could say anything, it was Honor who spoke. Louder than Maya had ever heard her, actually. “It’s not perversion. They’re in love. And we like that.”
Maya’s mouth fell open, impressed and – damn, she loved these kids. She really did.
Judge Ackland was right on her heels. “Pastor Alton, I understand that you strongly disagree with the Court’s decision. However, I will not permit derogatory or discriminatory remarks in my courtroom. If there are any further comments made, you will be removed.”
Autumn didn’t say anything, even though she tossed her parents another look.
What she said was –
She leaned in and kissed Maya again.
.
.
.
.
.
.