Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Talking Simpsons' final Disney Renaissance Summer is here on Patreon, and we're starting with the beloved Mulan from 1998. Starring the first Asian Disney Princess, we discuss the thousands of years of history for this fable, how it ended up at Disney in the '90s, and why it was seen as the most important film animated in an Orlando theme park. After exploring its creation, we delve into this tale of militarism meets gender, covering every song, battle, and bad joke by Mushu in fun detail. So grab your luckiest cricket and listen along!

Files

Comments

Alistair Shand aka Bongo

As a long time subscriber - that duck comic strip is not in Viz have you ever read it ? It’s very funny bit it might be to “British” but I recommend a read

Michael Hoffmann

Think black and white is a reference to a police car

Giovanni

Mushu really is Donkey light. He's the Coke Zero of Eddie Murphy characters. Donkey plays more to Eddie Murphy's strengths and being able to be more risque. And in the sequel he's 100% the villain with his horrible actions in that movie.

Andy H-D

I'm a $10 per month "Stonecutter" again today after stopping Patreon for a while. Before, I found the link to add the Patreon-only episodes to my podcast player (I use Overcast). I can't find it today. Can anybody help me out?

nina matsumoto

Important correction for Bob, co-host of Retronauts: Ryu Hayabusa is from Ninja Gaiden, not Street Fighter! SF Ryu doesn't have a last name Also yes, I had seen Mulan twice before I saw it for a 3rd time with you. Bored to tears all three times. Never liked this film

F Shackleford

Re: Bob's question about Shan Yu's motivations for conquering China, you may be amused to know that the Han dynasty, the one which lent its name to the entire Han Chinese ethnic group and Mandarin language (Han Zi or "Han words"), was founded by a prison transport guard whose prisoners escaped en route one day. Because the punishment for letting this happen was death, this dude decided to go for broke, freed the rest of his prisoners, joined them in starting a local militant band, and eventually ended up as the emperor of China. In Mandarin Pinyin romanization, the long A sound (as in 'rain') is not asssociated with the letter A, so the A in Li Shang sounds like "Shahng" (rhymes with long). However, the way they pronounce the villain's name as "Shahn" Yu seems to suggest it should be romanized as "Shang Yu", because without the G, the letter A in Shan typically rhymes with the the English pronunciation of "fan". I guess this is all to say that foreign pronunciations are not easy. On another note, something I noticed that was most likely unintentional was the way Mulan's relationship with her family seems to reflect the 90s in China being in the aftermath of the One Child Policy. Mulan is an only child, so her family spends a lot of time and energy worrying about whether she can become a functional enough adult member of society to thrive on her own and care for them in their old age, since she is their only horse in the race. Mulan meanwhile has the entire burden of her family's expectation on her. As a result she goes on a crazy adventure at great personal risk that in a roundabout way ends up more or less allaying her family & ancestors' worries. The last thing I want to add, part of the reason that marriage is important in Chinese society is that regardless of the sex of your child, as an adult you have likely already spent years attending the weddings of friends and relatives and giving them courtesy gifts of significcant monetary value (it's usually gifts of money in contrast to the American tradition of the wedding registry) so your own childrens' weddings represents your turn to recoup those favors. This is in addition to the traditional dowry stuff we usually think of for medieval weddings. I'm glad to finally see Mulan covered in the TS format, and thanks guys for bringing some genuine criticism to this film, in 1998 I was too young and too excited for the movie to leave anything but a very deep impression on me (as you can probably tell by this excessively long comment).

Giovanni

I always laugh whenever James Hong's character screams when the panda eats his slippers!

JoshuaMartian

The animation studio I work for (Mukpuddy) animated a series based on VeggieTales co-creator Mike Nawrocki's book series 'The Dead Sea Squirrels' and Tom Bancroft was namedropped as being involved in some capacity. The show is about a pair of talking squirrels, preserved since Biblical times awakening in the present day. It takes place in a world where some animals can talk and others can't for no given reason. The show teaches general Christian principles (honour thy parents, thou shalt not take moochers into thy hut) and seems deliberately inoffensive to secular audiences. It wasn't a favourite of mine to work on because it's mostly characters doing a lot of talking and there are rarely fewer than five characters onscreen. We had to laugh when in the series' final scene, a character wakes up in hospital and almost every character is waiting to greet them.

Joe Hodgson

Mulan is a pretty unremarkable Disney film that I only remember because I did visit Disney's MGM Studios during its production. It was nearly complete and I can recall taking the tour and seeing some of the production art, though they were still keeping a lot of it secret. I mostly recall the maquettes for artist reference which were pretty cool looking. I was well into my teens by then so when the film came out I didn't pay much attention. I think my family rented it eventually as I don't recall seeing it in theaters. My takeaway is similar to yours in that this is a bad fit for a G rated film. It can't go far enough in depicting how terrible war is and instead it's mostly happy-fun-time antics with an annoying dragon. The final act feels so out of place and is not rewarding at all. Because of my criticisms of the film, it did make me curious if this is the one animated "classic" from Disney that might benefit from a redo in live-action, but despite that thought I have yet to bother with the live-action version and I have no plans to see it. Returning to my post to add that the Hostess Honey Bun was the god-tier lunchtime snack when I was in middle school. A lot of folks would basically hover around the snack cart, which didn't open at the start of lunch because it sold junk food, until it did indeed open and the Honey Bun was the first to sell out. And, honestly, it might have been the best of what was there, but it was pretty poor when compared to a good, fresh, sticky bun or bear claw. For some reason, it was always wet out of the foil. Nevertheless, my Nana insisted they were "delicious" and would eat them as part of her regular diet of cookies, Sprite, and cheese pizza at the end of her life. And she made it to 91 so maybe there's something in those horrible, pre-packaged, pastries that contributes to longevity.

Tricia

I have the reverence for Eddie Murphy that you guys have for Jason Alexander so this hurts me Jk I appreciate a perspective on this movie from people who didn’t grow up with it like I did, harsh as it may be. I subscribe to the reading that the Great Stone Dragon is in Mulan and with Mushu along with her this movie is about two awkward dragons trying to prove their worth.

Stacey P

I kept reading crik-ee as crickey, but I am British

Dylan (batmanboy11) Freitag

This was one of (or maybe THE) favourites of mine as a kid, and unlike feeling underwhelmed by returning to Lion King with this podcast, I still did really really enjoy it! Maybe it's because I'm a non-binary bisexual but there's just so much that I love in this movie, which is CRAZY knowing now that it was directed by two uber Christian dudes, though I of course already knew that NONE of the queer subtext people have read into this film was intended by the writers or directors. I'll Make a Man Out Of You is still one of my favourite Disney songs, and while the film's plot is maybe too straightforward and Mulan herself is kind of underdeveloped, I can't help but have a blast with the movie and the smoooth animation. But I know I'm an outlier around these parts since I also do still love Hercules even after revisiting it for the podcast, and am kind of meh on Lion King and the Little Mermaid as an adult (the first half of Lion King slaps though, it just loses me once Simba becomes Matthew Broderick).

Dill Pickle

Thanks for spotting all those cinema sins this week, great episode

Lambda

Kinda appreciated the lightly negative tone here. Mulan is okay on the whole, but there's an undercurrent of weird writing. The impression I got, watching this movie in anticipation of the podcast, was that it felt very "Save the Cat." Big "I haven't actually read that book" disclaimer, but it felt like the reason the events of Mulan happened at the points they happened was because the creative team was adhering to a formula, and were not because characters in the story were making decisions. "Introduce the character as likable and relatable" "big second act battle" "The All Is Lost Moment" "big third act battle." I'm really glad you pointed out that the gigantic, iconic snowy mountain battle sequence was started because Mushu accidentally set off a rocket, because that seems like the most egregious example of the slapdash way the movie gets from one event to another. Great episode! Even if it did make my skin crawl to learn about the evangelical xenophobic stink that's all over this movie.

Tim Regan

I want hot & sour soup now.

Andrew

I’m surprised Henry hadn’t heard of Arroz Caldo when talking about congee. I’d say when Mulan first used her manly voice its extra growly and feels like she’s channeling Tim Allen in Home Improvement. I always also thought from the way that they talk about her dad as “The Fa Zhou” they wanted him as an experienced soldier to help Shang as a new leader

ThePich

Western Pasta is unrelated from Chinese noodles (tho the latter are definitely older by a good 5 millenias), the oldest confirmed proof is for a dish called ittriyya from ancient palestine in the 9th century, which was spread around the Mediterranean by the Arab conquests, and especially in Sicily where other shapes came about by the 12th century. The myth of Marco Polo bringing them back from china was, like most things, made up by an American magazine.

Guy Incognito

Elsa probably has the highest Disney Princess body count, though not intentionally. Plunging an entire kingdom into winter in the middle of summer would likely kill large numbers of people, especially the very young, the very old, and the sick, who wouldn't be prepared at all for the extreme cold. And even though it was only for about three days it would wreak havoc on the country's agriculture. Even with foreign aid her actions would likely lead to food shortages and starvation across the country.

To Boldly Joe... Moore

You guys mentioned the opening to Mrs. Doubtfire. My head-canon for years was that Robin Williams' character was dubbing an older, pre-existing cartoon (from a smoking-friendly era) into English... ...but then I watched the movie recently and the lip-sync is way too exact to be another language... ...so my NEW theory is that he's simply replacing the voice of another actor (e.g., Tim Curry's version of Joker in Batman TAS) So there... movie's perfect now. 😄

David Thomson

I was in the same boat as you guys, where I was in my late teens when it came out and just never saw it until now. Unlike you guys, I quite enjoyed it but I can just let it wash over me, without having to make a 6 hour podcast covering it great detail. One thing Bob mentioned at the end was that it would rank lowly in the Disney Renaissance-era films. I know you guys are against the listicle in general but I'd be interested in both of your top tens for these movies once you've given the all the "What a Cartoon" treatment. Maybe it could be a segment in "Talk to the Audience" and it might entice a few people to upgrade to the $10 tier.

YancySr

just a quick one. I love the Chinese style smoke in this movie, I thought it was a nice touch