Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

When Don Bluth set out to show up his former employer in the early '80s, The Secret of NIMH got absolutely wrecked by E.T. at the box office—as most things were. Little did he know, the father of that wrinkled alien would contact him a few years later with the opportunity to collaborate on an animated feature backed by the prestige of the Spielberg brand. This month on What A Cartoon movie, listen in as we explore An American Tail: the film that saved Don Bluth's feature film efforts and kicked off Steven Spielberg's decades-long dabblings with animation.

Files

Comments

Dylan (batmanboy11) Freitag

I was extremely lukewarm on this movie (even borderline bored for a good chunk of it) but I know there's certain sects of animation fans who still talk this movie & its sequel up, so I wasn't sure if I'm just seeing this too late (having never seen it before). Thankfully early on Bob affirmed my feelings on it, so I'm glad it wasn't just me. Some of it looks really good, but overall the really half-assed plot and world, and all over the place voice acting really sinks the ship, as it were. Only time will tell, but I think The Secret of NIMH might end up being a little more memorable to me, even if it's a worse movie ultimately. I think the only other Don Bluth movie I've actually seen is Titan A.E., but I have next to no memory of what actually happens in it, and if I've seen Anastasia, it left even less of an impact on me.

Blake R.

Bob's Henry the Pigeon voice is an all-timer bit for me on WAC movie. Bluth definitely a fascinating figure for animation. Disney had needed that kick in the pants to get out of its dark days but I've always felt he was the wrong man for the right moment. His filmography of Thumbelina, Troll in Central Park, Rock a Doodle, and The Pebble and the Penguin back to back feels like a career suicide run few filmmakers ever experience. I definitely felt for the guy when he was having to make the rounds in Nostaglia Critic reviews to promote his crowdfunding campaign for a Dragon's Lair movie that never materialized. I've always found An American Tail itself to be too driftless and downbeat even as a child. Amblimation is a fascinating blip in Spielberg's career but it's easy to see why he lost interest once Dreamworks was beginning to materialize and would give him a much more lucrative sandbox to supervise.

Jonathon

Was not expecting such a vicious shot at Hook lol. I love that movie. It has excellent performances and also contains John Williams' best score. That's right, best. Yes I will die on this hill.

Ian Stratton

You cut out my favorite part of the Siskel and Ebert review: Ebert says he doesn't like the song "There Are No Cats in America" to which Siskel replies "What about all the people named Katz?"

Tricia

Bob, don’t apologize for your goofy accents, it’s what I pay for. I’ll admit I enjoyed this movie more than you guys but I saw the flaws just as clearly watching as an adult; in some ways nostalgia makes me grade Bluth on a curve, but in other ways I still appreciate him for the ways he broke the kid movie mold back then. Something he kind of shared with Spielberg is that he had his main characters suffer, only Bluth always gave you a happy ending when Spielberg let you sit with the characters and the trauma they experienced, a “you can’t go home again” feeling All that said, still fun to hear you guys rag on Bluth, you should probably wait on All Dogs Go to Heaven, there’s more of the stuff you took issue with here

Sean Ryan

On Michael Jackson's Moonwalker, apparently there's a blu ray release in Europe. I imported it a few years back; not cuz I'm a big fan, but cuz I remember a lot of interesting things from that movie, like some sweet Will Vinton animated sequences. Plus Michael's dead now, so fuck it. I will say the video quality of that release is some of the best I've ever seen on home video, so I'd say it may be worth looking into.

Jeffrey Allred

The Irish Mouse gave me Bob vibes. Anyone else?

Marty

Mott Street is in Manhattan's Chinatown now, but it used to be part of Little Italy. It's not far from Hester Street. The former Barnum Museum would be a 20 minute walk from both. The movie is actually kind of accurate with its New York geography.

David Louis

Ehhhhhhh yeah baby! Giving the Don some due love. 🙂 Thanks guys!

Erin Hardy

I rewatched All Dogs Go to Heaven for the first time in 25-30 years, and I am eager awaiting its inevitable WAC entry.

goonichiwa

I haven’t watched this movie in probably over 10+ years so I was listening to this, thinking oh I’m confusing it with different scenes from other Don Bluth movies that I watch way more often with my nieces and nephews (Thumbelina and Troll in Central Park) Like in Thumbelina, there’s a French bird who sings to Thumbelina nothing is impossible which is basically another type of never say never vibe and they have some cutesy girl birds as backup singers / dancers . And in Troll in Central Park Dom DeLuise plays a troll that’s ✨not like the other trolls✨ and he’s nice compared to the bad and mean trolls - so basically the troll version of Tiger. Like how did I not see it before ? I used to watch a lot of his movies as a kid (and I was basically glued to the tv so I knew all the movies I did watch by heart) i should have been able to tell they were all made by the same guy lol

Matt

I was only 3 when this movie came out, so I definitely don’t remember seeing it in the theater. However, I did occasionally watch it as a kid on VHS and I vividly remember seeing the sequel, Fivel Goes West, in the theater and the Pizza Hut promotion. Pat Musick was also the voice of Fluffy and Uranus on Duckman.

Matt

An American Tale just happens to take place in a particular time period and is about the experience of one particular group in America (in this case, Jewish immigrants). I don’t see how that’s a problem. I think the idea that a movie is somehow obligated to represent the experience of every single immigrant or marginalized group, as Henry seemed to suggest, is unfair and unrealistic.