Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

"My beloved is napping in the many folds of my Spider-Man t-shirt. As for me, I am popping kettle corn." - Comic Book Guy

After eight years, the Skinner/Krabappel pairing comes to an abrupt end when Seymour gets cold feet, causing Edna to leave him at the altar. And when Comic Book Guy comes along to pick up the pieces of this shattered relationship, we're all left wondering if this episode was written backwards from the title.

Our guest: Stephen Sajdak from We Hate Movies

Files

Comments

Langdon Alger

I hope you bring up that Jeff Albertson also hooked up with agnes skinner

Alex Irish

This episode so bad Henry forgot to say “oh boy, Bobby!” in the news segment

Dylan (batmanboy11) Freitag

While I do dislike that this did away with Seymour x Edna for good (as far as I know anyway), and think even temporarily putting Edna with Comic Book Guy makes NO SENSE (other than her having a thing for losers, I guess), I don't HATE this episode with the seething passion I once had. Its execution is pretty poor, but I do think there is SOMETHING to Edna's concerns about Seymour and his Norman Bates issues. Regardless of that, him and Edna have had such a good dynamic in past episodes (especially Grade School Confidential, of course) that dumping it out for nothing is a waste, and all of Al Jean's resets in this era are unnecessary and piss me off as a fan of the Bill & Josh era (especially). It is ALSO lame to get into Homer and Marge's problems so late in the show and then solving it just as fast with 1 romantic gesture, when we've seen this many times before and will see it many times after. -- Morbid side note: do we think Matt Groening was wearing the Simpsons jacket he's drawn in here when he was on an Epstein flight?

marathedemon

To comment on something not related at all to the actual simpsons episode: I like to call myself a second generation weeb, my boomer parents were way into all of the Japanese media coming into the US in the 60s and 70s and Gigantor was huge for them. Unlike Kimba, Speed Racer and Ultraman, which I occassionally see nostalgia for from other people I have never seen anyone give a shit about Gigantor. Stephen’s account of Gigantor references in at least 3 movies makes me realize my parents weren’t just making it up I guess.

Joe Hodgson

I think you guys did a good job of illustrating why this episode is bad. I don't have a problem with breaking up Edna and Seymour, but I do think this episode did a terrible job of it. It feels reversed. Skinner is a dork and for him to land someone like Edna it just makes no sense to me that he'd be the one with cold feet. I always felt he should be written as the one eager to make things official and it's Edna who should be having second thoughts because there isn't much in Seymour's personality that seems appealing. The many marriage jokes feel hacky and the episode has nothing new or interesting to say on the subject. The ending with Homer and Marge renewing their vows feels very tacked on and the shoehorning of Marge and Homer's marital woes into the plot feels inappropriate. Like you pointed out, we've done this before! Homer being put in charge of the bachelor party and Marge hosting Edna's bachelorette also makes no sense other than we need the Simpsons involved since it's their show. They could have come up with a funny excuse for the setting, but they just don't even bother. It's a bad episode and it makes me feel bad.

Michael Recon

Oooff not Skinner and Bart do a version of “Lion Sleeps Tonight” - this is bad

Jeremy Mele

Skinner should have remembered the Bi-Mon-sci-fi-con because he was there to see Mark Hamil request a volunteer from the audience to play Obi-Wan (“Kenobi?”)

PurpleComet

What annoys me about this episode is that they start off with just saying Skinner has cold feet and feels pressured into the marriage, but we're never given a reason WHY he has cold feet. Maybe the things that drew him to Edna in the first place started to grate on his nerves or something. But we never hear that, he just wants out because OF COURSE a woman would force a guy into marriage before he's ready. Marge showing up at school to check on Edna was jarring. Homer and Marge usually only interact with Skinner and Edna when it relates to Bart and Lisa (usually Bart), but suddenly they're deeply invested in their personal lives. "Grade School Confidential" wasn't the funniest episode, but it felt grounded and believable whereas this episode shoehorns most of the cast into scenes where they don't fit. The line "Let's go home so I can yell at you" sounds similar to "When we get back home, we're going to have a long, boring talk about our relationship" in "The Cryonic Woman". Just go to therapy, Simpsons writers. I did think Lion Sleeps Tonight parody was cute and laughed at a few jokes.

nina matsumoto

Bob I was not a "cat person" in FF14; I was a dragon girl! An Au Ra! How dare you forget your in-game wife who you fought alongside for so many hours Henry, I don't think a "pickleback shot" is meant to be a sexual innuendo (pickleback is the name of the shot and some bars may add "shot" as a descriptor but it's usually just listed as "pickleback". And a "back" means a chaser. No, not THAT kind of chaser)

Christian Kiddle

I tried to direct a community theater production of Harvey when I was 18 (long story short it didn' work out lol). I love the play and the movie a lot. I'm not as fond of the 1996 Leslie Nielsen remake though. Loved seeing the reference as a kid but this episode as a whole ticked me off, I distinctly remember it as the first time I felt like a tv show was making fun of me for watching it at all

Dylan Sludge

Whoever was in charge of drawing Selma at the party..... by god that is my exact type of woman

SilkiePJ

Think this episode is even worse than "Co-Dependence Day." While what happened to Homer/Marge was bad, it was always limited by status quo to be fixed? However, Edna/Seymour break apart because of Marge and Homer being actively awful and complaining nonstop. It sells out the characters a lot without good pay off to gags or jokes. This is why everyone under 40 hates "I hate my wife" comedy.

André Da-Silva-Pereira

Henry, do I understand you play MTG, judging from your MagicCon appearance? I wonder what you think of the latest FF set and the upcoming Spiderman set.

James Babbo

I find it interesting that Bob states this causes "a huge amount of damage" to Skinner's character when the podcast went to great lengths to defend "The Principal & the Pauper," an episode that many felt not only ruined Skinner but caused the show to "jump the shark." Talking Simpsons may disagree but it cannot be denied that many felt this to be true. Count me as one of them. BUT since we're all pitching ideas to fix this episode, I really think a little Armin Tamzarian could've gone a long way to helping the ending without even mentioning him. Skinner could've gone to his storage locker to reflect on his past life choices, looked at his motorcycle, & used it to drive up and scoop up Edna declaring "I've made a lot of bad decisions in my life. It's time to make the right one." And marries Edna. Not only would this make a satisfying ending to their character arcs, it would've gone a long way to smoothing over the criticism of "Principal & the Pauper." But as I felt towards that episode & now this one, if the writers don't care about these characters, why should I?