Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • What A Cartoon Movie! - The Muppet Christmas Carol.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

After their successful late '70s/early '80s movie trilogy, The Muppets took a decade-long break from the silver screen, only to return with an adaptation of perhaps the best-known story to the English-speaking world. In their first post-Jim Henson cinematic outing, The Muppet Christmas Carol pairs the familiar cast of felt characters with veteran actor Michael Caine, and the resulting 85 minutes amounts to what could be the best adaptation of Dickens' original story to date. This month on What A Cartoon Movie, join us many, many sleeps before Christmas as we discuss and celebrate this beloved holiday film! 

Files

Comments

Jeffrey Allred

Yay! The reason why I finally became a Patreon. Can’t wait to listen!

Athyrium

No cheeses for us meeces

Giovanni

Not a perfect Christmas Carol adaptation but the Muppets did a solid job. Just goes to show you how likable and entertaining these characters can be when all you have to do is put them in any type of situation and they'll carry the show or movie in this case!

Seth

I was born in 90 so I was probably three the first time I saw Muppet Christmas Carol. The scene of the door knocker turning into Marley was very creepy for me as a little kid.

Blake R.

Was excited to listen to this one as this has to be in my top 3 Christmas movies. Loved hearing the discussion and still find myself laughing (and perhaps welling up) as I hear the clips. I saw a 35mm print in Chicago last December and that cemented it as an all-time holiday favorite for me. After a lifetime of home video viewings, what a difference it made to see it in a full house with adults and families alike all laughing along and appreciating it in a way that it likely wasn't upon its initial release. And yes, there were some collective sniffles heard across the crowd in the third act. Time has been good to this movie and I think it will only continue to age as one of if not the best Christmas Carol adaptations. And it's warmed my heart to see recent interviews from Caine where he still has so much love for being in this movie.

Mangoappreciator

I'm interested to hear Bob's description of old novels as similar to japanese light novels in the need to explain their entire plot in the title. Maybe this will make more people interested in such modern classics as "Hello, I am a Witch and my Crush Wants me to Make a Love Potion!"

Giovanni

I had first heard of When Love Is Gone when I watched the Nostalgia Critic's review of The Muppets Christmas Carol. I really enjoyed that song listening to it on Disney Plus

Steve Watts

I absolutely love this movie so I was excited to hear that you guys love it too. Usually I slowly digest the WACM episodes slowly over the course of a month but I dived right into this one and I'll probably finish it before November is even over. One observation I just have to share is the repeated musical motif of the Christmas carol Good King Wenceslas. It's part of the overture, and more pointedly, it's the carol that Bean Bunny is singing when Scrooge chucks a wreath at him. If you're not familiar, it's a story about a kind king who sees a poor man freezing in the snow on the Feast of Stevens (December 26) and immediately goes to provide him with warmth and food. The song concludes: Therefore Christian men be sure, Rank or wealth possessing Ye, who now will bless the poor Shall yourselves find blessing It's a perfect carol to reference because at different points in the story it shows a contrast with Scrooge's treatment of the poor, and then by the end, it's a direct parallel to the new, changed Scrooge.

No It Doesn't

Absolutely amazing episode as always, especially as the Christmas WAC movie to help us transition from Thanksgiving into December. I really enjoyed this one and loved hearing Bob's history analysis on things I wouldn't have picked up on (like novels being a relatively new concept at the time of Dickens). As cruel as Scrooge's joke towards Bob Cratchet is is at the end of the story, it did remind me of Conan O'Brien's joke style of the mean, crazy boss who berates and interrogates his employee only for him in the end to say he is 100% on board with their employee's decision or idea lol

LuvMyNES

Wow! I've been listening to Talking Simpsons/What a Cartoon since day one and I've never commented, but I needed to thank you for covering this film and the 5+ hours of commentary that had me glued to my phone. I'm a lifelong Muppet fan and this is one of my favorite films. The death of Jim Henson shattered me when I was 9 years old and I still watch Jim's Memorial when I need a good cry ("Just One Person" and "Being Green" are tough to get through). I didn't see the movie in theaters, but begged my parents for the VHS tape and I watched it over and over again, especially at Christmas time. I didn't realize until its release on DVD that the theatrical release did not include "When Love is Gone" and I always assumed it was part of the film. I was the rare child that absolutely adored this song and I'm so glad that they were able to add it to the special features portion on Disney+. I could go on and on as I was taking notes like I was prepping for a podcast, but I really appreciate all of the work you put into this podcast and I honestly got teary-eyed during a few parts of the podcast--that's how much this film (and the Muppets) means to me. As you mentioned, I would highly suggest that everyone take the time to read Brian Jay Jones' biography on Jim Henson and there are a lot of videos and documentaries available on YouTube as well. I wish that Disney would do more with the Muppets. Bob--come to Orlando!! I promise it's not as bad as the rest of the state and the Muppets 3-D is a lot of fun! Henry--I was so glad to hear you mention Paul Williams' other Muppet songs, especially, "I'm Going to Go Back There Someday" and "When the River Meets the Sea"...two of my favorites! Sorry for the long comment, but I loved this Podcast and thank you, again, for doing a great job with this film!!

AlsoNamedB0rt

I have a couple of great reads if you are interested in A Christmas Carol/Xmas/Dickens. First is Stephen Nissenbaum’s “The Battle for Christmas.” No, not the war on Christmas, which of course I wage all year long. Insightful, elegant and well written, it answers a million questions you have about Christmas. There’s also George Orwell’s essay “Charles Dickens,” which discusses Dickens in general including A Christmas Carol. Free on the internet, but pick up his collected essays if you see it in a Little Library. Also you left out Paul Williams’ career apex which was obviously Little Enos in Smokey and the Bandit.

Gayest Episode Ever

From listening to the Evolution of Horror podcast, which is like Talking Simpsons but about specific horror subgenres, I have learned that the tradition of Christmas Eve ghost stories is alive and well in the UK, in the form of these weird, stark BBC short films that aired that night but often aren't Christmas-themed. They are actually quite horrifying, in the way that certain made-for-TV movies from the 70s were, and there's a whole generation of people who have shared pop culture trauma from some special that aired on Christmas Eve. I don't know why we don't have that here.

Joe Hodgson

As a kid, I first saw Mickey's Christmas Carol in 1987 via the NBC broadcast which my mother would record for future viewings and is something I still have. I was always really confused how Mickey was referred to as Cratchit, Donald as Fred, and Daisy as Isabelle while Scrooge, who I knew from DuckTales, was just Scrooge! Naturally, I caught on to what was going on with having the characters play the roles of the novel so when the Muppets did it I wasn't at all confused. Plus, I was very familiar with the characters from Muppet Babies, A Muppet Family Christmas (also on that same beloved VHS as Mickey), and the Nickelodeon reruns of classic Muppets. This is one I saw on VHS too, and I hate that Katzenberg was right, but the song he cut was always the point in the film I would drift away. This was a movie I would get through maybe once a year, though my sister would put it on probably more than that. It probably hurt that I'd watch the Mickey version, which was much, much, shorter, many times each holiday season which is no fault of the film. As a result, I definitely have more attachment to the Mickey version, even while acknowledging that this one is a better, more thorough, re-telling of A Christmas Carol. And frankly, we should have placed a moratorium on all future adaptations after this one. I definitely didn't need to see CG Jim Carrey as Scrooge.

Jonathan Mitchell

I rarely comment but needed to say that Bob singing “Shinzo Abe” to the tune of “Marley and Marley” had me howling on my walk to work.

Thad Komorowski

This one really hit me in the feels during a lowly holiday season for me, so thank you both. If you do a Summer of Muppets, I think you'll get ZERO complaints, and I urge you to let me help if you do The Great Muppet Caper (I agree with Bob that it's the best one, and it probably shaped my taste and sense of humor more than any other single film).

Camille Walters

A certified holiday classic! So happy you guys covered this film so in depth.

JoshuaMartian

Wanted to leave a comment on behalf of the Millennial Muppet fans who don't consider this a holiday favourite. I've always preferred the earlier vaudeville/variety show style energy to this movies gloomy and gothic Victorian flavour. I can respect the reverence for the source material and not making obvious choices like having Muppets play the ghosts but it's really a better adaption of Dickens than it is a Muppet movie. This also began the trend of Muppet movies focusing on human leads who have to deal with the Muppets who are relegated to supporting roles and for many characters, silent cameos. 'Muppets from Space' and 'Muppets Most Wanted are the two exceptions since Jim Hensons death. I swear I'm not just being a contrarian but I side with Katzenberg on the 'When Love is Gone' song. I'm glad the work of the performer and songwriter have been rediscovered but I don't watch a Muppet movie to listen to human grownups sing slow sad breakup songs.

Alfredo Goves

A lot of Christian themes in this movie. Believe it or not its not bad to be Christian and not all Christians are like the ones you see on fox news

Harry Boucher

As a younger British Millenial, I can distinctly remember seeing this as a child (perhaps as part of some weird right-of-passage for English kids). Marley and Marley never scared me, but the Ghost of Christmas Past sure as Hell did! My stupid child brain couldn’t work out whether she was a muppet herself, or a real, strangely diaphanous child. However, like all English people, I am a glutton for punishment and so child-me trained myself to watch the film over and over until it no longer scared me, and now I consider it a holiday classic. On a side-note, I’ve visited Dickens’ childhood home in Portsmouth several times (not too far from where I live) and was disappointed to find no mention of the Muppets in any of the historic information in the museum. My friend decided to rage against the system and ended up leaving a tiny plush Kermit in one of the rooms 🤘🏼 I’m sure it didn’t confuse any of the geriatric visitors who usually frequented the place.

Michael Bentley

Having read a recent book on the history of Christmas, Bob's comment about being a young millennial atheist sneering that Christmas wasn't even when Jesus was born was something Puritans were doing in New England in the 18th century. Well into the 19th century, Scrooge wouldn't have been alone in keeping his business open on Christmas. Many Protestant churches didn't even offer services. This eventually changed, not just with Dickens but with American authors like Washington Irving.

nina matsumoto

This story didn't help popularize turkeys over geese as a Christmas tradition. Eating turkey on Christmas was already a popular thing to do by the time Dickens wrote this

David’s Stuff

If you're ever in Atlanta, GA I would highly recommend visiting the Center for Puppetry Arts. It's a fantastic museum dedicated to all types of puppetry, including stop motion. Almost half of the museum is dedicated just to Jim Henson and they regularly rotate the puppets on display.