Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

(#946, 28th December 2002)

  

Looked at one way, this had to happen. Reality TV pop shows weren’t going away. Lightning had struck for Hear’Say, then again for Liberty X, then so often for Pop Idol that you’d think Zeus had the ITV voting lines on speed dial. The maths of it was simple enough: the audience mobilised for reality shows was multiples larger than the crowds pop could normally draw for a new release. Anything a winner released would get to number one. Simon Cowell (and gang) had hacked the charts.

But in doing so they’d also surrendered control. If winning a reality show was the golden ticket, and what you released after didn’t matter, then the winners’ single could get away with far more drama and delight than Cowell’s starchy definition of pop allowed. Critics, me included, who gasped in excited shock when they heard “Sound Of The Underground” – it’s reality TV pop, but good – hadn’t twigged that this outcome was always a possibility. Once you shatter the link between quality – however conservatively measured – and results, you create an opportunity for anything, great or touch-my-bum awful, that’s blocked by the usual filters.

You can make too much of this idea – “Sound Of The Underground” is a superb pop record, but it’s not a revolution. From another angle, it’s cynically 2002. Puretone’s “Addicted To Bass”, which shares Dick Dale-goes-Drum’n’Bass chimera DNA with “Sound”, had got to Number 2 in January. Songwriters Xenomania – Brian Higgins and Miranda Cooper - were picked because they’d already had a Number 1 with Sugababes’ “Round Round”.

And yet “Sound” clearly improves on both those tracks. “Addicted To Bass” is breakneck fun, but it’s all concept and attitude and not much song once the dust clears – Xenomania borrow its ideas and use them to soup up what was already a sprightly, hooky tune. “Round Round”’s intrigue lay in its mantric chorus and circular structure but also in the job it did to establish the Sugababes as a brand – its aura of distanced cool means it can’t be as eager to please and surprise as “Sound Of The Underground” is.

“Sound Of The Underground” does, in fact, establish the Girls Aloud brand, though that wasn’t clear right away. Its immediate job was to win the competition within a competition that ended Popstars: The Rivals, by beating boyband One True Voice’s “Sacred Trust” to Number 1. The ‘Battle Of The Sexes’ gimmick could easily have been an experiment in proving every feminist dictum about male mediocrity and undeserved success. “Sacred Trust” is an affable, mid-paced blob of a song, by lads whose happy-to-be-here vibe crumpled to injured bafflement when it became obvious how badly they’d been outclassed. “Sound” wasn’t just good because it could be; it had to be.

Even then, what were the girls really going to win? A few weeks into Popstars: The Rivals, Hear’Say announced a split, citing “abuse from the public” and with their label cooling on them. Their magnesium-flare career set a boundary on any reality TV group’s ambition – whoever won the Rivals, it would be a short victory, however beautiful.

Most reality TV winners have followed the precedent. Girls Aloud did not. Here we are looking with hindsight at one of the most beloved and successful pop groups of their decade, and “Sound Of The Underground” isn’t just a pop song, it’s the First Girls Aloud Song.

What does that mean? The band, Higgins remembered, were politely sceptical when he and Cooper played them their winning song – they “liked their R&B and Mariah ballads”, and expected something along those lines. As their career continued, and Xenomania took on full songwriting and production duties, the relationship became far closer – the group became Cooper and Higgins’ muses, and both band and songwriters quickly and jointly evolved their ideas about what a Girls Aloud song might do.

A Girls Aloud song might suddenly shift style and dynamics mid-song (“Biology”); it might feel like a layer-cakes of part-finished tracks (“Sexy! No No No”). It might spring left into pastiche (“Love Machine”). It might play structural games – delaying the chorus until halfway (“Biology” again), or letting two of them fight it out (“The Show”). The lyrics would be just as elliptical, jumping trains of thought, dodging narrative, pouring out feelings but remaining somehow elusive. Mixed-up signs, as “Sound Of The Underground” put it first.

What held it all together was a promise, mostly kept, that every new single would try something different, and the girls themselves. Cheryl, Nicola, Sarah, Nadine and Kimberley’s performing, enacting, inhabiting of the songs was the guarantee that this wasn’t some aloof exercise in game-playing pop-craft, but a method for making vignettes of 21st century life and love, in all its oblique, keenly felt, confusion. The surface inventiveness would beckon you in to where a half-line could make you shiver or blush.

On “Sound Of The Underground”, for me that line is “into the overflow / where the girls get down to the sound of the radio”, an evocation of some Morlock subterranea where girls (the band, their friends, their voters, all girls anywhere) go to listen, dance, hang out. It drags the Underground metaphor out of the realm of taste and knowledge and into the world of secret bonds and dens and communions. Girls, Allowed. It appears when the track is past its punchy verses, with their crisply sung lines and karate-chop drum breaks, and into the rolling release of the chorus, a thrilling mine-train descent into this secret world.

If this was all there had been, it would still be a coup. As it was, there was so much more. But to go back to the idea that winning a reality TV show was a license to innovate – one few took – the sad truth is that for most of their career Girls Aloud were an exception, not an example. “Sound” is the only one of their most famously inventive singles to hit Number 1, and we’ll meet their best work in the comments, as sharply enjoyable rebukes to the less imaginative music which outsold them. 

“The broadsheets were amazing”, Higgins reflected later, but radio kept its suspicion of his TV stars turned critics’ darlings, which limited their airplay. More fool the playlisters, you might say, but in a funny way they were right. What let Girls Aloud stay fresh was the way Xenomania helped keep faith with one original promise of reality TV shows – that it was a way to see what happened when ordinary people were pushed into an outlandish adventure. The group stayed ordinary, the songs offered new adventures every time, the results were electrifying.

9 out of 10

Files

Previews only

Comments

Holiday Kirk

As an American that had to go and seek this stuff out I was pretty floored like six years ago when I got their greatest hits.

ThePensmith

My most immediate memory when I'm asked to recall 'Sound of the Underground' is that of my school bus c. late November/early December 2002. There were a group of girls in my sister's year, who were Year 11 at this point - two of whom were twins - who worshipped at the altar of Westlife and Blue. As far as they were concerned, like the producers of Popstars: The Rivals assumed, it was a done deal. It was widely accepted that how the voting usually played out on these sort of shows, where the watching and voting audience were mainly girls and young women, was that the boys - sorry, Pete Waterman, male vocal harmony group - were going to win on account of being well...boys. And thus better in their eyes. I can still picture the looks on the Year 11 girls' faces now, that morning that our local radio station, from our driver's in-bus system (long since bought out by Global/Heart) played first One True Voice's 'Sacred Trust' for the first time, and then 'Sound of the Underground'. Talk about famous last words. I also recall looking around and seeing more than a few mutterings or head nods to the effect of 'this is actually properly good', and, in contrast, the universal whispers of 'This is a bit shit' about One True Voice. Certainly the moment I heard it I knew Girls Aloud had potential way beyond the show they came from. You place the two videos and songs side by side and there's no contest. One True Voice looked and sounded like a bunch of lucky winners come pound shop Westlife, which pop and boybands were already moving away from. Girls Aloud look like the sort of pop group that could be launched minus reality TV stabilizers. They're in a cage in the video for Christ's sake. It wasn't another 'Evergreen' or 'A Moment Like This'. It felt like and it indeed was the sound of pure British pop for that next decade. I mentioned this back on the entry for 'Round Round' about Miranda Cooper's interview for The Telegraph's 'Story Behind the Song' podcast from 2017 (https://www.telegraph.co.uk/music/artists/story-behind-girls-alouds-sound-underground-inspired-wheels), but it's particularly relevant companion listening for this entry, as the genesis of 'Sound of the Underground' was an interesting one. Her and Niara Scarlett (another of Xenomania's many co-writers who subsequently ended up with Giselle Sommerville as part of their short lived vanity project Mania - they had just one top 30 hit, the brilliant if slightly too clever for its own good 'Looking For A Place' in 2004) came up with the chorus melody, and sang 'The wheels on the bus go round' to it in early demos when it was being projected for Orchid, a girl group Brian Higgins was putting together at that time for pitching to Polydor (they ultimately put Orchid on the back burner, and it was rumoured at one point that it was meant to go to another Louis Walsh charge in the shape of Samantha Mumba, who had not long released a fast disappearing top 5 hit 'I'm Right Here' off a never released second album before she was quietly dropped). When the final 10 girls were selected, they all recorded the song (and some, as you mentioned Tom, were none too impressed, expecting a big Mariah Carey style ballad. Needless to say those girls didn't make it into the final group) so that week by week as they were voted off, Brian and Miranda could delete their vocal contributions before piecing together the final mix. However, interestingly, they did speculative mixes with all possible combinations of members, but none without Javine Hylton in the line up who everyone thought was a dead cert to win. It meant that Sarah Harding had to hastily re-record all of Javine's lines before their video shoot the Monday after they made the final lineup. The B-side was a cover of East 17's 'Stay Another Day', and at one point it was billed to be a double-A-side before it was apparent there was no such need to do so, but they still performed it on TV a handful of times. The girls also interestingly recorded a version of 'Sacred Trust' as I believe the Popstars producers were initially pushing, in another twist, for both bands to release the same song. Thank God Polydor put their foot down on that one. No one knew about this until their version was released as a rarity on the bonus disc for their 2006 best of album 'The Sound of Girls Aloud', and proved you literally can't polish a dud. Needless to say Brian and Miranda had no part in their version whatsoever. Given we've got a while before we discuss GA next on Popular - there's a hell of a lot of #2 watches for them between now and then - I think my commentary on what happened next will be coming at each of those instances in turn (largely because I don't care for/will have much to say in favour of any of the records that beat them). But this was and will always remain a classic pop single and worthy chart topper. And Nicola Roberts' side ponytail on the single artwork was iconic. 10. Enough said. #2 watch - a returning Cheeky Girls for its second and third weeks, thus ensuring both they and GA outsold One True Voice in the long run. On its fourth and final week, it was the debut of short lived comedy rock outfit Electric Six with 'Danger! High Voltage'. It's possibly their single after that one ('Gay Bar') that they are more remembered for, mind. And by remembered, I mean stumbled upon only at instances like these and reminded of how dated they made themselves even at the time.

Ed Still

Re: Danger! High Voltage. It was used to brilliant effect in the Soulwax /2manydjs As Heard on album. Appropriate given what a breakout year for MashUps 2002 had been.