The Fifty Best Songs Ever (DVD Commentary Disc 1) (Patreon)
Content
I am going to make the original post public so here is the list reprinted with REASONS or at least the first 25 of them.
50. Toots & The Maytals - "54-46 Was My Number" (1969)
One of a few songs here I was introduced to by Dave Marsh’s 1001 Singles book, a bigger driver for my taste than a lot of more fashionable books cos it told a coherent story which was almost entirely different from the one I was weaned on by UK music mags. Marsh IIRC emphasises the prison narrative elements of 54-46 but it’s also a rock hard piece of dance music.
49. Charli XCX - "You (Ha Ha Ha)" (2013)
I like the perversity of forging a pop track, even a very barbed and spiked one, out of an IDM piece like Gold Panda’s “You”. Also a fantastic kiss-off track, the coughing robot HA HA HA HAs make a great hook.
48. Rachel Stevens - "Some Girls" (2004)
This is an unpleasant track in some ways but I think X’s cold production telegraphs and makes use of that. The greatest song of the British Poptimist Wave.
47. Cutty Ranks - "Limb By Limb" (1995)
Also maybe I was just in an unpleasant mood. “Kill dem”.
46. Octo Octa - "Can You See Me?" (2019)
The most recent thing on the list I think, from Octo Octa’s stellar Resonant Body, marrying blissful trancey house with big blocky gorgeous breakbeats; its vocal loop “I know exactly how you feel” seeming like a one-line manifesto for empathy in a bad winter.
45. Rosanne Cash - "Seven Year Ache" (1981)
TOKEN COUNTRY song I guess, this has one of the best and best-delivered choruses I’ve ever heard.
44. Wham! - "Wham Rap! (Enjoy What You Do?)" (1982)
I think this is the most Andrew of all Wham! songs, the sparkiest and cheekiest and most stupidly quotable, “Hey everybody take a look at me / I got street credibility”
43. A Flock Of Seagulls - "Wishing (If I Had a Photograph of You) (12" version) (1983)
Absolutely has to be the 12” version, which is like the New Romantics reimagined by Tony Conrad or Klaus Schultze, wave upon wave of that synth riff.
42. Bikini Kill - "Rebel Girl" (1991)
I was way too shy/blobby/afraid to do more than press my nose up against the world of zines and the kids who made them, which made them easy to romanticise of course.
41. The Prodigy - "Out Of Space" (1992)
I almost had “Chase The Devil” AND “Out Of Space” in here and both are magnificent, but Max Romeo doesn’t have chipmunks on his record. Shout out to selector Pete B.
40. John Cale - "Paris 1919" (1973)
Oh I just did a Twitter thread on this. It’s two linked sort-of-narratives about the temptation and hubris of imagining you can impose order on something, and it’s one of the prettiest songs ever recorded too!
39. The Four Tops - "Baby I Need Your Loving" (1964)
It’s embarrassing to admit but this was the record where I received the startling revelation that sixties soul could be - get this - as painfully apposite to my life and emotions as, say, The Wedding Present. “Cos lately I been losin’ sleep”
38. Mobb Deep - "Shook Ones, Pt. II" (1996)
I had never heard of them and it sounded so old and cruel that I assumed it must be old and by older men, then I realised it had been recorded that year by kids younger than me. Bloody hell.
37. PJ Harvey - "The Words That Maketh Murder" (2011)
I love songs that quote other songs, especially when they work both as a theft of the fire of 50s pop and a curse on the century that produced it.
36. Britney Spears - "Oops!...I Did It Again" (2000)
I realised it should probably be “Get Naked (I Got A Plan)” but the mad, cynical and brilliant Titanic interpolation nicks it for “Oops” anyway.
35. The Human League - "The Black Hit Of Space" (1980)
Honestly makes me grin every time I hear it, a new wave SF parable about a bad record, and those synth drones are pure filth.
34. Joe Smooth - "Promised Land" (1987)
This was held in so much reverence by early house heads I was nearly put off as a dilettante come lately but it really is all that, one of house’s purest and most beautiful prayers.
33. Diana Ross - "Love Hangover" (1976)
Paired with its not-so-secret twin, The Associates’ feverish, sweaty-palmed cover version, but the extended mix of the original is still what all smooth disco tracks aspire to.
32. Origin Unknown - "Valley of the Shadows" (1993)
I was wavering on this or another jungle track (“Terrorist” or “Renegade Snares” maybe) and then I realised I’d forgotten the payoff closing line and knew it had to be this.
31. Sugababes - "Freak Like Me" (2002)
I've said quite enough about this!
30. Adam & The Ants - "Stand and Deliver" (1981)
I feel like there’s a lot of ground to cover with Adam and I hope someone covers it one day, for me I am just delighted that I was an 8 year old boy at the time the most 8 year old boy friendly pop star ever to exist was in his Imperial Phase.
29. Public Enemy - "Black Steel In The Hour Of Chaos" (1988)
PE at their most exciting, their most incisive, also their most kitsch, shifting modes continuously between a critique of the carceral system and an unmakeable 80s action movie.
28. Broadcast - "Echo's Answer" (1999)
I’m attracted to bands at their most themselves, even when the results aren’t necessarily immediate or don’t particularly make sense. There is no Broadcast track more Broadcast-ish, more luminous and inscrutable than “Echo’s Answer”, which I played a lot in the dead of winter in an unsettled year.
27. M.I.A. - "BirdFlu" (2007)
Similarly this is MIA at her most MIA, with a rhythm and soundworld it took me half a dozen delightedly horrified plays to get my head around and a mid-apocalyptic scenario of the revenge of the hot repressed. Credentials ARE boring, a fact we all learned since.
26. Clarence Carter - "Making Love (At the Dark End of the Street)" (1969)
Ending this first chunk with another great song I heard of in the Dave Marsh book, though in this case I can’t remember exactly what Marsh made of it, beyond what’s there on the record, a Hayes-style spoken word intro to a fragment of cover which turns the transition between intro and song into the heavens parting and judgement coming down.
to be continued...