Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This one's for the poll heads.

One thing the planned move of the polls from Twitter to my own site lets me do is break out of the rigid 4-options 1-choice format Twitter imposes. There's a lot that's good about this format and I am sure I'll stick to it initially, or only make minor tweaks.

But it is allowing me the luxury of dreaming up entirely NEW pop poll game formats. This one combines the basics of pop polling (picking a favourite track) with the planned-picking format of Twitter pop challenges - thanks to Arron Wright, the challenge master, for inspiration here - and the "managerial" element of the old Pop World Cup games.

I call this... the Catalogue Crunch. The numbers are arbitrary - 40+ players is probably too many, I think it would need at least 20 to work well though.

41 players each pick an artist. The only fixed stipulation - they must have released at least 40 tracks.

The players submit 5 tracks at a time, to be played one per round, in the order submitted. In round 1, 41 tracks - one for each player/artist - are available to be voted on over the course of several days. The artist (and player) with the lowest votes is eliminated.

Repeat on a weekly basis. So by week 11, for instance, 31 tracks would be voted on, and we'd be on the 11th track of each remaining artist. The final week would see two remaining players submitting their 40th song.

I feel like this would be a good way to explore artists with deeper catalogues through a frame that isn't just "albums", and allow for a bit of strategy: when do you play your strongest songs if you're one of the big boys? How do you stay in as long as you can and pick up momentum if you're not?

This format would be more at the "fun" end of polling than the "discovery" end, though there would be SOME discovery involved of obscure gems within catalogues, and ways to tweak it. Limit it to a particular decade, put arbitary limits on how many hit singles you're allowed per artist, and so on. One other obvious tweak would be to eliminate several players at once on the basis of cumulative scores, so an unlucky first pick wouldn't finish some poor sod. Finally there might be arbitrary exclusions of the most absolutely obvious acts - The Beatles, Bowie, etc.

Will I ever do this? Who knows. It depends on workload and how well the new poll widgets work. But it's an idea so I thought I'd write it down and get it out in the world.

Comments

Arron Wright

I rather like this idea! Is there a jump of 10 somewhere though? Can’t work out why week 11 is 21 songs not 31.

Tom Ewing

Oh that's easy - I wrote it as 30, switched to 40 and forgot to change some of the numbers - glad you like it!