Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Casting Call : Eric Weston

  • Option 1 44
  • Option 2 10
  • Option 3 9
  • Option 4 11
  • Option 5 6
  • None of the above 16
  • 2026-05-12
  • —2026-05-19
  • 96 votes
{'title': 'Casting Call : Eric Weston', 'choices': [{'text': 'Option 1', 'votes': 44}, {'text': 'Option 2', 'votes': 10}, {'text': 'Option 3', 'votes': 9}, {'text': 'Option 4', 'votes': 11}, {'text': 'Option 5', 'votes': 6}, {'text': 'None of the above', 'votes': 16}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 5, 19, 22, 12, 38, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 5, 12, 22, 10, 24, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 96}

Content

Have some options and we're gonna a poll. Comment as much as you like, I'll read em all, but votes are what counts for the winner here. I will put a "None of the Above" slot, if that wins... then we chat about what you guys think Eric needs that I'm missing. You can ignore clothing, we're just looking at the face for now.

Option 1

Option 2

Option 3

Option 4

Option 5

Files

Comments

mark lacy

I feel that Eric Weston has been through hell and back. The weight of decisions should show on him. The stress of everything takes a toll on your body. I might say he should look even more worn

Evan Currie

Really? Some of these guys look like they've been through it more than I want to think about. Well, vote None then, and we'll see if others agree. Might have to "crowd fund" descriptions from you guys in that case. lol

mark lacy

Think about what Weston has been through and try to imagine what that does to the body. The decisions leave visible results on you. I may be older than you and wear my time more than you so it hits home a bit more. How would you look 500 years after the fall of earth and the realization that you had a part in it? I can very easily be wrong.

Alejandro Hurtado

He can be young in age, but being in WWIII leaves a mark

John Huzinec

Aren’t they all the same guy 😂

Evan Currie

They're all similar because they're all based on Eric's description in universe. I could change the details, I guess. If you don't like them, pick none and we can go from there. Or maybe I should cast the net wider and just not worry about the book description?

Anna Stofsky

Eric Weston is hot. At least the way you describe him. Option 1 is the hottest. It may be reductive, but here it is...

Andy

Always pictured him as looking more like Alexander Skarsgard

Dallas Eden

Having spent a large portion of my adult life in the US Navy, and much of that in the company of Marines, he should be clean shaven per regulations. With the exception of SEALS who generally go a little native, facial hair is severely frowned upon.

Edward Poole

He needs to be older even though he took Nantes it’s been 5 centuries. Maybe a very fit up yo.

Brion

I actually have a vision of someone more clean cut and disciplined looking. Someone who has demonstrated control at almost every turn. I personally didn’t see facial hair. Was that in the story? If so , I don’t remember it.

Edward Poole

Sorry for chopped up comment, he needs to a fit, scared, 70 y0. Say a captain who can still bench 225 lbs

Brion

Love the idea of exploring these visuals though. I’ve read most, but not all your work. Just getting into Thermals now

David Jones

Went with 3 but 1 is good too. It was pretty much a draw between them.

Nallus

He's been through hell and back, but he's not weighing himself down with past decisions, and he's determined to be resilient.

Eric Kaulfuss

I think one pretty well nailed it. Certainly the closest of the group. Boyish but weathered by life - the guilt of having led the Empire to EARTH / even if the Bloc would have done it themselves eventually.

Randy

Went with 3, I liked opt 1 also, but was a bit too young looking I thought.

Evan Currie

No, no, that's actually fair. The character we get through the books is going to be regulation... or mostly regulation. He's not a martinet, but he holds himself to a standard. I might be looking at a second poll here.

Evan Currie

Honestly not what I was going for, but that's good to know. lol

Bill McHugh

Option 1 has the “look” (slight smirk) but looks too young. It’s the only one that has the “nice guy” look that could still be a bad ass.

John Huzinec

Yeah. I caught that. I was more saying that a picture of serious me and less serious me is still a picture of me. It’s like 5 pictures of him with different emotions. Not that I think the rendering is bad. I like it. I was just saying it’s not really 5 different options.

David Andrews

Option 1 is probably closest for me. 4 and 5 look a bit miserable and I've always seen Eric as a "happy warrior," if you like.

Krister

For me number 2 but as Stephanos, I would rather see someone like Eric Danes character in the Last Ship(Captain Tom Chandler) as Eric

Adrian Burchell

I voted for No.1, but he should be clean shaven.

Palmyra1

The is IMO something calming about #1. So called calm and collective under fire. #2 I could live with but not always looking over his shoulder. The others look beat down as such would I follow any of them to the gates of Hell???

Hugh Blair

I think Eric wouldn’t have facial hair. He’s an old line marine and all of those selections are not in line

Jeffrey Dekosky

I think it should be a clean shaven Brad Pitt or Matt Damien who should play Eric Weston! I also agree with comments below, someone who looks like Robert Conrad! I also think a young William Shatner, Captain Kirk look!

Andrew Heard

I would agree some look like they’ve been through the s*** but I think Weston is somewhere between 1 and 4. 2 is possibly a good look but he’s too bland for me. 1 is too handsome and I think Eric Weston is a little more shrewd and weathered than 1. 4 has the cold eyes that have seen that 1000 yard stare more than once, both in the mirror and in his friends and subordinates. Look up Admiral Kieth Davids. That’s who I’ve always pictured as I read your amazing stories. I’ll try to post a pic of my old commander

Steven S

Understand about the facial hair, was Air Force myself, but we need a look of experience without it being too harsh. A look that can both pierce your soul and still make you feel understood and not too uncomfortable, unless that was his intent. Hence option 3, I think, fits that characterization.

Brion

Regulation perhaps from a dress code standard, but not a by-the-book guy by any means from my perspective. He's simply very decisive and confident in following through with his decisions. But I did see him as more of a statesman, if in a less-than-conventional way. He has presence that sets a standard for all those around him. This depiction looks a bit more like an aged Stephen Michaels (perhaps from "Harvest"?

Charles Craig

Eric I don't believe is as devil may care as Michaels is, but he's affable and approachable, nice guy that will make the hard call