Animated Style or 'Realistic'? (Patreon)
Content
So I've been playing around with GenAI for making an animated prelude to Silver Wings. Wrote the script a few years ago when there was some interest in doing a show/film based on it, but it never went anywhere... so now I'm going to use it to learn how the GenAI systems function and whether they're worth bothering with on this level.
This isn't a new full time project, my writing will remain focused on Bastion for the summer or until it's done. But I figure I can make a 20-25 minute episode over the run of a couple weeks, working an hour or two a day, based on the animation I just posted.
My Question for this post is... would you prefer a more realistic look, or a clearly animated look?
Both have advantages and disadvantages but neither have much of an edge over the other in terms of approachability. So it's purely what would you guys think vibes best with the source material.
For example, a young Sorilla Aida, aboard the Los Angeles :
The realistic option tends to lean softer than I'd prefer for Sorilla, I expect because the images it was trained on were mostly models, actresses, etc... Still good, still a good look for Sorilla that hits all the right points... but the vibe may be a little different than you'd get in the books. Which is par for the course when it comes to film casting I suppose. I would not complain if Silver Wings got a TV or Movie and this was the casting, but I would note the differences.
Now, the animated version, same character concept, same basic prompting.
Here you can see we get a harder look, it feels more muscular, more defined. I'm not certain that it's exactly Sorilla... but honestly I think that's more cause I tend to leave the characters kinda nebulous in my own head so that I have room to make adjustments if I come up with a cool concept later.
I like both concepts, I like both animated and realistic styles, personally. I think I'd prefer the realistic style if the systems were more consistent... then I thought maybe animated, but honestly that look MIGHT make the inconsistencies stand out even more somehow. Not sure.
What do you guys think?