Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

https://inkshield.io/p/proj_qngwK0oX72Z0Hq17E5Rk6DZd

Used ai to generate. Premise, dialogue, shots, blocking, pacing, everything else me. Testing out a much faster but slightly lower quality model to generate parts of this, as well as a bunch of other new workflow tweaks. Wouldn't call it as polished as backyard slug - still experimenting.

The poll basically had 50% of people saying "keep doing a bit of ai at least" and the other half "nah none of that." Here's some for now. My alternative is to just post ai stuff on deviantart only, which requires me making it paid and actually investing time there vs here. still considering, but this is done now. sharing here.

That said, considering this a success, it took an order of magnitude less time to make it and I actually figured dialogue, swallowing, etc as well as a ton of tiny other things. All made locally.

Files

Comments

belovedskull

Normally I would just ignore this; I've made my stance clear, and I wish not to engage or cause arguments, but I do wish to correct something: the poll is not 50/50. As of writing this, it was 21% “keep going on AI,” 53% “stick to 3D renders like before,” and 26% “do a mix.” You can combine the 21% and 26% and say that 47% of people voted for an option that allows AI in some capacity, but that's a different way of interpreting the poll, not what the poll actually showed. The “mix” option was deliberately separate, and we don't know how much AI those 26% actually wanted. So if we're talking about the actual results, it was 53% for sticking with 3D renders, 21% for the AI approach, and 26% wanting a mix. Calling that roughly 50/50 is technically possible as a broad reinterpretation, but it isn't what the original poll actually said.

andy g

I took a good look at it and wanted to share my thoughts with you. First of all, thank you for the work that went into it — I really appreciate the effort. With AI, things can definitely be created much faster, which opens up the chance to build more complex stories without needing tons of extra time. That could lead to more new stories overall, which I think is a great opportunity. The storyline itself could be expanded a bit more — similar to the older comics that had 50+ pages/images. I’d love to ask whether a more complex comic could be created in an AI‑based version, using the same characters, dialogues, and plot. Having a direct comparison would be super helpful and would probably convince a lot of people that the AI approach is a real option for the future. I’d be really happy to see this idea come to life. Wishing you lots of success going forward — keep up the great work.

SimpleGreenBag

i can upload an attempted comic animation + raws so you could try. there is a strict 'instruction budget' so i dont think ill be able to do that + dialogue. but you will see that turning pics into videos is actually hard (on low vram). there is a lot of implicit behavior and priors to account for. starting and sticking with just 3d renders doesnt quite work even good iray ones. need a "copnvert to photorealistic" step in between, then a ton if itewration experimentation. that said when you get a thing once its then easy to repeat

SimpleGreenBag

for "yes/no" ai signal its fine to combine "some ai" with "do more ai" as "ai is ok". for strict preferences you are right the 50% original comics doesnt account for anti-ai preferences. maybe worth a followup poll? the thing i still havent heard from anti ai crowd is how this patreon survives when getting a personalized sgb comic for pennies becomes a thing. if 95%+ said 'no ai keep giving me comics' great done deal. but basically half are saying 'im ok with it' and i would bet 80%+ would stop sub if they could get my comics at same or higher quality in more quantity for cheaper is it better for me to be the one profiting off those, or someone else?

SimpleGreenBag

i get you dont like ai. i know you're feeling like "wtf hes not even listening." but would rather see this patreon end than me use ai? should i base the continued existence of this patreons future off your personal preferences? will your preferences actually stay the same? especially when ai becomes indistinguishable? is it then ok if some other company becomes the place that gets the reward from making work like mine? i wanna keep doing this and i know what people actually do (by the data) not what they *say* they will do. i get a small window to get out front because this is niche/nsfw. then its over. this is a hard topic and im a little frustrated. i dont think people are actually aware of what ai can do right now, or thinking through incentives at play, ways this could play out, etc.

SimpleGreenBag

but yes id love to have longer videos instead of comics with more intricate storylines etc

Tyson Dix

Maybe instead of posting to DA you can make different tiers for your Patreon if possible. Then you could set it so that people could pick just comics, or comics and Ai, or just Ai.

SimpleGreenBag

luckily for me this patreon is expendable. i am successful outside this so i can drop at any point without worry it just means i cant purchase more 3d assets from people and not pay for other production stuff. but not a lot of other indie artists nsfw and otherwise are in that spot and i feel deep worry for them. i think a bunch of audiences are about to wipe out the indie artists they say they want to protect.

SimpleGreenBag

hm. ill keep it off patreon and do it somewhere else. wip ai stuff is kind of noise here

belovedskull

To reply to all three comments: 1: I feel like the people specifically saying they wanted the comics to stay the same as they were before are probably the people who were against AI, or at least against making AI a significant part of the comics. Obviously not necessarily all of them, but “stick to 3D renders like before” was the only option for people who specifically didn't want the AI approach. Maybe a better poll would have been something like “yes to AI / no AI / some AI / indifferent,” because the 26% who chose “mix” can't really be classified as either pro- or anti-AI without knowing what kind of mix they actually wanted. You can combine the 21% AI and 26% mix and say 47% were okay with AI being used in some capacity, but that's a different interpretation of the poll. The actual results were 21%, 53%, and 26%, not 50/50. As for the “if people could get my comics at the same or higher quality, in more quantity, for cheaper, they'd leave” argument: I understand the point you're making. But isn't that also one of the concerns people have about AI? It dramatically lowers the time and cost needed to produce this kind of content, which can put creators who don't use it at a disadvantage. 2: I'd rather you continue making comics. I don't want you to stop, and I'm not asking you to take a break. I just don't want AI-generated comics from you. I understand that AI makes the process much faster, but faster doesn't automatically mean better, and it doesn't mean your audience has to prefer the faster method. I'm also aware there are other NSFW artists. That doesn't mean I have to want to replace your work with theirs. I followed you because I liked your comics. 3: As for the indie artists supposedly being “wiped out” by audiences who don't want AI, I don't think that's a fair characterization. Someone choosing not to support AI-generated work isn't necessarily trying to make indie artists disappear. They can dislike AI-generated work and choose not to pay for it. And I don't think “either accept AI or the artist goes out of business” is a fair argument or something the audience should be expected to accept as a moral obligation. If AI changes the economics of making this kind of content, that's a much bigger issue than whether individual fans are okay with AI in the work they support. You were one of the creators I really enjoyed following. I remember posting jokes under your comics because I genuinely enjoyed them and wanted to be funny with you. That's why this change is just disappointing, man. I wasn't trying to start an argument about AI or tell you to stop making comics. I just wanted to point out that the poll results weren't quite 50/50 as you presented them.

Sporf

How does not wanting Ai, wipe out indie artist that don't use ai? I'm not sure I follow you. If I wanted Ai, why would I support an indie artist in the first place?

SimpleGreenBag

when quality becomes indistinguishable, quantity and cost win. why pay an artist $12/mo when you get get double the customized content for less than $2. a large proportion of people only pay here because its the only supply. when something better/cheaper comes along, how does this place compete? a majority of my stuff has been leaked more than enough to train on. i fully believe some small % of people would continue supporting but thats not the majority. the majority is usually silent in comments etc. to listen to them you have to look at data about what they do, what they download, etc to see their preferences. i got a forced sneak preview of what this is like elsewhere. i know that this place needs to adapt or it wont survive. maybe thats ok. but id like it to.

SimpleGreenBag

also @belovedskull thats why im engaging here normally i just post work and shut up and watch what people do. i mentioned elsewhere but ive already seen these market dynamics play out and force big sudden changes in my life. im not making a fundamentally complicated argument: when quality becomes indistinguishable, quantity and cost win. in this case distribution negligible because its digital. also its porn so people want as much as cheaply as they can get. my big edge is niche, some creative storytelling, and mediocre rendering/posing skills. each of these is trivially automated/replaced today, but only frontier models can replicate my manual quality. you might not think ai is there. it is but ok, lets say its not. just wait. how long? nobody knows but the scale is years/months. i probably could today i just cant afford the computer to do it locally. either i adapt or lose my place in the market. what could change my mind is seeing other creators who are trivially replaced survive in a way that isnt heavy audience building or engagement

SimpleGreenBag

i know this is kind of a "Trust me bro" position i dont want to reveal personal info but if i m wrong and ai doesnt displace me then nbd. but if i dont get good at it and it can replace me then im done and this hobby is over

belovedskull

I get the point that if people can get something cheaper and faster while they consider it equivalent in quality, some people will obviously choose that. I'm not really arguing against that. What I do doubt is the assumption that this means most people will automatically choose the cheapest and fastest option once the quality becomes similar. I've seen enough indie artists and their communities to think people don't always treat creative work that way. Humans are obviously self-interested, but we're not only self-interested in the immediate “what gives me the most for the least money?” sense. We get attached to creators, we want to support people whose work we like, and sometimes people will deliberately choose something that isn't the cheapest or most efficient option because they value the person behind it. If someone takes an artist's work, uses AI to make something similar much faster and cheaper, and starts competing with them, I don't think the automatic reaction from everyone is going to be “great, now I can get twice as much for less money.” A lot of people are going to be annoyed specifically because they wanted to support that artist in the first place. You can see some of that sentiment outside specifically AI-focused communities as well. Obviously, you can find people who strongly support AI if you look in communities dedicated to defending it, and you'll find the opposite in communities dedicated to opposing it. So I don't think looking at one particular group tells us what everyone's preferences are. There are plenty of people outside those communities who are still skeptical of or opposed to AI-generated creative work. I see a bit of that with my own stuff too. I make things myself and sell them — not currently because my old account got nuked, but I'll be back in October — and I've seen people doing similar things with AI that they can produce much faster than I can. I still have followers despite that. Obviously that's only my personal experience and isn't proof of what your Patreon audience will do, but it's why I'm skeptical of the idea that cheaper and faster automatically wins once the quality is comparable. Personally, I'd rather spend more time making something myself than have a machine do most of it just because someone else can produce it faster with AI. And I don't think I'm particularly unusual in that respect. I do understand the concern you're talking about with AI potentially becoming good enough to replace parts of what you do. I can understand why you'd want to learn it now rather than wait until you're forced to. I just don't think that necessarily means your audience will value the resulting work in the same way they value what you were making before. And you may be right that AI will become much stronger than it is now. But I don't think that means everyone's opinion will eventually converge around it. Some people will become more comfortable with it, some will remain opposed to it, and plenty of people will probably fall somewhere in between. That's why I don't think you can necessarily assume that once AI reaches a certain quality threshold, the majority of people will simply choose whichever option is cheapest and produces the most content.