Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This is a list of options for volume 4 of Thresholder. Each volume of Thresholder has a different setting, and volume 4 is going to be no different. This is a non-voting list of options, with the vote coming in a week or so. Volume 1 was 28 chapters, Volume 2 was 37 chapters, and I'm hoping that Volume 3 is somewhere between those. With eight chapters done so far, that means that Volume 3 won't conclude for at least another two months, maybe more, but I would like as much lead time as possible for Volume 4 so that 1) I can do work ahead of time 2) I can let the ideas marinate ahead of time 3) I can do any setup in Volume 3 (this is or should be minimal).

Voting might be in two weeks, idk. It'll also probably be weighted by tier, though since we're not doing voting now, I'll do it later. Descriptions are a fraction of total planning for each world, which all have skeletal outlines and descriptions for my own benefit (to make sure each is something that I would actually want to write). Descriptions are minimal in order to preserve surprises. Most of this lead time is for discussion, and in theory, this list might change based on feedback. I will not be answering questions at this time, unless somehow the community gets some idea that's totally out of line with what I'm thinking.

I encourage discussion on Discord, though note that it (and this post) are both open to the public, so no spoilers for stuff from Volume 3. If I mention an established property, it'll have the serial numbers filed off and be used as a jumping off point or a touchstone for the genre. Any details listed here are vibes-based and might not actually show up.

Oh geez, I nearly forgot: why am I doing this? Mostly, I thought it would be fun, and don't have super strong feelings about what Volume 4 looks like on the setting level. I don't normally do this sort of thing, but Thresholder seems uniquely suited for it. Maybe I'm wrong, and I'll find it unfun for some reason, but each of these are ones that I have plans for and think I would enjoy writing.

1. Magical Accessories World (guild of hats, cabal of rings, the duality of earrings)

2. Mad Max World (post apocalypse scavenger clans)

3. Capes* (superheroes and supervillains)

4. Magical Masks (spies and intrigue)

5. Dreamscape (dreams within dreams)

6. Weird West (occult gunslingers, gothic trains, oneric mines)

7. Isekai World (industrialization of summoned heroes)

8. Palimpsest (the constantly rewritten world)

9. Fantasy Solarpunk (STEM wizards using green technology, optimistic utopian solutions)

10. Tournament Arc (set matches against opponents with either secret or public powers)**

*Capes is the only one I'm on the fence about, and that's mostly because I think it's a genre with a lot of weight of expectations on it, way more than anything else. People are very particular about their superheroes, and it's a genre that's been torn apart and rebuilt to the point that it's hard to do something truly "new" with it. I've written unreleased superhero stuff and DMed some Mutants & Masterminds, but ... I don't know, it's the only one I feel some hesitance about, mostly because of audience stuff.

**This has been updated, since people were (wrongly) thinking that I was implying bringing back a bunch of old characters. It's way too early for that, and would represent a substantial shark-jumping.

Comments

Mr. Mister

Mmm, I’m torn between Palimsest because it sounds like it’d be fun how offended March would get and at logging errors, and Maskerave because March would trivialize a lot of it (pre-internet cold war-ish era?)

patreonizing

2 already got mentioned (Xiyan's tales?), 3 I kinda never wanna read again after Worm (this is not praise), 4 would rhyme with Teaguewater, 7 would feel like certain popular glowfics, 10 is...more or less where Maya ended up, mechanically. 1 and 5 could be right out of the Aerb Exclusions book, 6 sounds incredible even if Vol 1 was goth-y already, 8 and 9 have the benefit of more-virgin territory. At least compared to fantasy I'm familiar with.

Kyle

Many of these are super interesting! Personally, I would love to see how you handle the dream world.

Lewis

The dreamworld, Fantasy Solarpunk, and Weird West are particularly interesting to me. Unexpected angles in worldbuilding mean a lot, compared to the relatively expected reactions of Marsh and Perry. Will look forward to any voting options that might arise, but also interested in how you plan to close out this sort of story, so there's no bad options!

Darryl Greensill

Weird West. I want to see your take on Deadlands.

Davin Stewart

You do such a good job at worldbuilding I feel like you'd do any of these justice but 8. Pampliset really stands out to me because I have no idea how you'd do that.

Martin Raunkjær Andersen

I'm most particular to 9, I think. I really enjoy your takes on "optimal" / utopia society from the end of WtC, I don't think there is anything quite like it on the internet. And I love a good magical sci-fi.

Thomas Downing

I’m thinking 9 since it’s the most likely one to be able to repair March fully and maybe that will let Perry move his wolf vessel back into his body and have a complete circuit again. This would let him be able to take the time to explore more about his Tier 2 body and abilities and start making the push to Tier 3!

Philippe Ad Astra

I will probably like any of those worlds if you write them, but from your list I think I would prefer one among 1, 4, 5, 7, 8 and 9 since they seems more unique. I know there is a lot of Isekai World (7), but industrialization of summon hero to the meat grinder of war seems more unique. The only story I can think about in that vein (if I understand correctly the plot) is The Gilded Hero on RR (it was not finished) but with the twist of Thresholder it can be pretty unique.

Philippe Ad Astra

I am not sure if you are open to other world settings, but I thought of 3 other options that could be pretty interesting and unique (but the most important part is if you would like to write them). 1. (my preferred world settings) A magic world where people are more focused on body enhancement such as body (blood, flesh/muscle, bone)/mind/soul mages, transmutation/rune mages and artificer for artifact crafting. The rune mage could be in the form of rune tattoos on the skin, rune engraving directly into bones or scar tissue inside the flesh. Those disciplines together could also create an endoskeleton (like exoskeleton but inside your body, probably inside the bones with electromagnetic or magic movement control at the joint). The potential main issue is that the benefit/power for Perry might be a bit too much like second sphere stuff and his power armor but would be a power easily transferred between worlds since it is essentially his body. 2. A hell type world or heavenly or both (if only one of those worlds, it would be internal conflict and intrigue, but if both it would probably be with conflict between those two). The main potential issue I see would be with the power scaling and hell/heaven implication for the overall story. 3. A DnD type world. This one is not specifically unique, but the setting is so vast that you can make a unique story within. This world might be a bit like Seraphinus but as a reader we have never "seen" it. 4. A world were people enter into symbiotic relationships with parasitic entities. One such example could be a young blood elemental (an hybrid elemental plane from water and life?) that bond with someone and enable to control blood internally and externally (blood claw, lasso and weapons). Maybe to balance this you make it hard to control someone else blood (living) because you need to subvert there innate will? Another strong example would be metal elementals.

Cam X

Hahah, the benefit of 'thresholding' is that if you find a world isn't working out as you'd hoped, you can always write it off and hit the next one and have it be a learning experience for Perry. He hasn't had some of the near-instant/didn't get any powers losses that other thresholders have described. Would be an interesting thing to struggle/make peace with/have influence next worlds. (Getting a vibe from 1. of missing the worlds of worth the candle/used to be dungeons?)

Christopher Roberts

Weird West, Isekai, and magic items are all interesting to me. Weird West because it's dripping with flavor, magic items because might help the character with magic, and Isekai because he could start understanding the thresholder system and the power to Isekai people to a world combines very strongly with the power to jump to worlds

waldvolllauterbaeume

Several of these sound really great and I'm indifferent between them. Would it be possible to do approval voting instead of single choice?

Alexander Wales

Yes, the vote will be approval voting, as I'm 90% sure that Patreon allows that as an option.