Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Adding Q&A to the Patreon. Post your comments and questions below and I will read them in the next episode.

Files

Comments

Scott Cunningham

Aaron, why do western surface ships only have a tiny number of small lightweight torpedoes to attack sub contacts? Are those torps, and the ability to deliver via Asroc or anti submarine helicopters render them unnecessary? You would figure that the ability to employ a MK-48 ADCAP would significantly expand the area a surface ship would be able to threaten a sub

Scott Cunningham

Have you head any plans to use unmanned sub vehicles as covert mine laying platforms ? Also, what’s the current status of western mine technologies. Are they simply laid in place like in the old days, or can we now use a CAPTOR type approach when we shoot them in and then they shut down, go passive, and then attack targets when the conditions exist.

Anigai

We never did get the streams of you working out and talking about it you've mentioned a few times on some Cold Waters Twitch streams. Any plans around that?

Anigai

Here's another one, how do armorys work on a submarine? I get that you aren't exactly expecting to have the crew storm the beaches of Normandy with machine guns and bayonets but surely there must be some stuff for emergencies or something?

Paul D Berkebile

With all of the saber rattling going on in the world, I feel like the NAVY has a number of problems that decrease our readiness for war; like recruiting/retention, shipyard backlogs, new construction delays, supply chain issues... Question 1: Is this a good time to be decommissioning assets faster than new ships/boats are being built. Question 2: In light of the expressed desire to build new USN frigates from an existing design and then have the % commonality drop from 85% to just 15% for the Constellation Class(FREMM) frigates. What in the world are our leaders doing?

Paul D Berkebile

Low flying aircraft can be picked up on a surface search radar, but what bothered me the most was how fast this target could close on you. You might only get 2-3 radar sweeps from initial contact to it being right on top of you. Makes you want to go hug your CIWS!

gh0st313

The US Navy still uses the Phalanx CIWS for close in defense. Other NATO countries have started switching to larger caliber guns like the OTO Melara 76 mm + special ammunition, which we have already seen it been effective on the Red Sea. China seems to follow the US, using a small caliber gatling gun with a lot barrels (too comical extend). While the US, China approach provides lots of rounds, with (relative) little cost per round ( https://www.twz.com/sea/phalanx-ciws-costs-3500-per-second-in-ammo-to-fire ), there is the issue of the limited range the magazine depth of the CIWS and the need for above deck reloading. In contrast the 76mm or similar offer greater range, much cleverer ammunition for various uses and the ability to reload under the deck. The negatives are higher cost per round and far fewer rounds on target during the engagement period. In your opinion, given the different targets that modern CIWS are expected to engage (subsonic, supersonic and hypersonic missiles, low and high end drones, speed boats, etc...) which of the two options is better in practice (including acquisition cost, operational cost, impact on supply lines during combat and of course combat capabilities)?

Scott Cunningham

That isn’t a Styx on the RIB. The actual Styx missile is the size of a MiG-15. It looks like they just pulled the warhead out and mounted it. At 1000lbs, it’s a big heavy item all by itself.

Aaron Amick

Great questions Scott. I will address all of these in the next Q&A.

Chronus

This is a good idea, thanks Jive! My Question for Q&A: A few years back Lexus had a commercial in which they showed a car in a loud environment and a quiet interior. They said they used microphones on the outside and speakers on the inside to broadcast the opposite waveform of the sound outside to cancel it out and make the interior quiet. Is this sort of sound canceling system used on submarines to cancel out sounds being broadcast from the ship into the surrounding waters?

Aaron Amick

good call, it is just the warhead, not the whole kit.

Phoa Yew Hui

There are ships carrying HWTs. Not many. In particular, there's this logistics ship that carries 150 km-range HWTs, allegedly for targeting enemy subs in port.

Andrew DeVries

Hey Aaron, just a fun hypothetical question for ya. If you were able to go back in time and start your Navy career over, would you still go into sonar and follow the same path, or would you go do something else?