Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Just some things before I announce the winner below and their prize. It has been spoiled, but I figured I would give everyone the full breakdown.

I graded all guesses based on these four criteria and read through every guess in full. I was as generous as I could in interpreting guesses. Even the ‘its just Mana’ guess got some credit for that for that guess in the most applicable criteria. So even something fairly vague would still give credit to that category and I was looking at the guesses in the best possible light. Lots of credit, if it was even close. No one scored zero. I won’t share the scoring individual people got. You can compare your guess and the others to what has happened and what is listed below.

FOUR CRITERIA
1. Impassable terrain from the surface into the Dungeon that is disrupting communications.
-This is the Abyss of No Return. A remnant of a battle long ago, that cut deep into the Dungeon and created an oceanic water obstacle. Some kind of imbalance between the continents was a common guess and got credit here and for criteria 3. Also why the Ocean Empire and fishman don’t bother/know in most cases.

2 A monster beyond reckoning, waiting
-It is coming…run. Also, the art posted on discord and on the summary page for the story show it. So, there was a hidden clue there for people. I didn’t just put up the art for no reason. I am shocked how few people guessed this. A true super boss, has to have sub-bosses. That is practically a rule for this genre. Well I guess RR has cultivators, not monsters. But you have to beat the ‘young masters’, then the ‘clan’, then the ‘sect’, then the ‘ancestors’ kind of trope. I will let you guess where this monster falls on that list. Also, why I said nothing stronger than Elena in the contest, another clue that I guess I hid a bit too well. Also, why the announcement is now, rather than when the Abyss of No Return first showed up, if you wanted to think of a guess in super meta terms. The Beast was a clue shown in the past as well for this category of monster, the reading list from the College.

3 Spatial loops on either side of the impassable terrain
-This was shown before and lots of guesses got credit for both this and criteria 1 since there is overlap. But it really is a distinct obstacle and one that has been shown before in the story. Very few people even considered spatial looping. Surprised this one wasn’t more popular either, since it is a clear obstacle one can face in the Dungeon.

4 Surface conditions/monsters/governments that create extreme difficulties on the other continents.
-I was also quite lenient on this criteria as well. And that is why I included the part from Xanatos and the Eternal Emperor. Otherwise, it would be impossible to guess. Social skills aren’t just for combat or the Seraphim, but other cultures. While one could guess it, it is truly the only thing without a clue so far in the story. For the fourth continent I have some general ideas like the overall political/social structure, and the third continent is set. The politics….I weep for my past and future self for having to sort out the politics and schemes. The worst part are schemes changing in response to actions, which then change other actions and schemes.

By the System it is complex, so mentally prepare if you want to work through the nonsense. I might have to make a diagram or something now that I think about it, so you all aren’t lost. I am trying to not get lost in the sauce as well and make things clear, but even Justin is going to get confused at points trying to work out motivations and goals. This is what happens when I don’t have brain fog. I am going for a well thought out political arc. But anything that could be possible, got credit. I won’t spoil things here, but these continents are messed up in unique and interesting ways.

HONORABLE MENTIONS

Honorable mention to Bookworm bibliophile for their insight into the Eternal Emperor. It wasn’t a guess, but they phrased things very well and made me happy about how I am doing the world building.

Honorable mention to Collateral (Discord guess). They were the next closest and I reread their guess and the winner’s multiple times. They had a very impressive and lengthy technical analysis but picked everything for the other continents I didn’t go with. Like temporal stuff and dungeon gradients. A single mention of environmental conditions, cultural issues, or something similar would have made the decision much harder and possibly a tie. They literally mentioned everything else. Also, the only one trying for the social route. You are all thankfully spared from bestiality yoai between Justin and Ozy written in the style of Twilight as the final outcome of this contest. Since he wanted everyone to suffer like Xanatos or more since he started up the Darker Cabal. -_-

The winner has been decided. No appeals allowed. I did double check all guesses against the winner at the end and can say it was the most accurate one out of 28 guesses plus 2 additional guesses. I triple checked the closet guesses in score from my first pass again, quadruple checked second place, just to be sure I didn’t miss anything. Took way too long, but this is very subjective, and I wanted to pick the objectively best answer based on what the actual criteria were.

RESULT

Congratulations Flipper!

Flipper, the winner asked for specific interludes for Boris, Judy, and Lanner. As well as some maps. You are getting both. I am quoting them verbatim below for their guess and how I judged. Let’s see how they use their ‘meta-point’ on the story. For people who read Systemic Lands, you will get that reference.

GUESS

So these are my predictions:
1) “height of continents” Justin has already experienced this when traveling to and from the beastmen continent, where it was easier to travel ‘down’ to beastman then back ‘up’ towards Eldarin continent. I believe this problem will be greatly exacerbated when trying to travel from the unknown continents back ‘up’ to the Eldarin Continent.
2) “negative effect” I’m guessing that the other continents, while livable will have some sort of negative effect of arrivals from the Eldarin continent. A natural debuff some sort of curse/environmental effect/natural counter will make these continents less hospitable and very dangerous for Justin and any others that have traveled there.
3) “Dungeon shit” some sort of crazy dungeon anomaly, super monster, effect (maybe water related) will be very difficult to cross for Eldarin adventures leaving only the strong and highly skilled (Eternal Emperor and Xanatos) will be able to survive it.
4) “new race/ethnic group” a different species or very different ideological group with a different outlook on the world that it is not worth dealing with, uses some weird ability.

I will explain how I scored specifically for the winning post here. Flipper got 0.5 for criteria (1) and (3) for the first prediction. They were close but not precise enough. No reference to spatial looping, or damage to the dungeon creating a dungeon feature, so partial credit. I was generous with these two criteria in the same way for other people. Got 1.0 for criteria (4) with their second prediction, since there are things they mentioned that do happen, but ‘less hospitable’ could be considered a near perfect response for this criteria. No bonus points however, 1.0 is the max for each criteria. Got 1.0 for criteria (2) with their third prediction. One of the few guesses with super monster, still surprised more people didn’t guess this. But his guess with water, put him over the top to win with criteria (1) getting maxed out at 1.0 instead of 0.5. The fourth guess just got rolled into criteria (4) and would have also given Flipper a 1.0 in this criteria, but scoring capped out at 1.0 per criteria. Flipper got 3.5 points out of 4.0 to take the win.

Guessing water as an obstacle and super monster, were the two main things that pushed Flipper to the top compared to other guesses. Now with great power comes great responsibility. Thankfully they are not a member of the Darker Cabal.

REQUEST

Maps coming out today. They are in-progress, but what I plan to use for the Spellblade game that is being worked on.

An extra chapter that is an interlude also included, so you get 2x today. Nothing changed, what happened to these characters was already planned. Flipper didn’t change the outcome. Thank AI for fixing the numbers and rescheduling everything.

Also, you get a much more complete answer, especially about the newest threats. Since I know people will have questions. This story isn’t meant as mystery. Just that knowledge has been lost to time and certain people not saying anything. Looking at dear old dad with that complaint.

As for him not mentioning anything, the answer is that he made it to the 29th layer, Elena didn't. Some things are better left unknown, since the truth is just too despair inducing. Like climbing a mountain, only to realize it is a hill.

Comments

Fusion

Huh climbing a mountain only to realize it was a hill dang floor 29-30 is another power spike

Kaladin

Is there a reason the obstacle can't be circumnavigated on the surface? Either going the opposite direction around the world or really far along the obstacle?

E

Those are pretty damn good picks for interludes

MisterVii

The Abyss of no Return is very, very long. As for circumnavigation, that is a very good question. The main reason is distance and the turbulence of th Great Ocean. The Eldarin Continent and Continent 3 were once connected by a land bridge. So their distance isn't that far apart.