Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Benjamin Studebaker and Douglas Lain discuss the riots in France (and Europe) in today's context and compare what is happening now with what happened in 1968.

Comments

John Hoggett

My retired Troskyist friend thought the riots in France and Spain were the revival of the left. I didn't like to dissapoint him...

Dave

Why can’t Ben say that the people are fighting, or rioting?

Abgesang

While i would argue that the analysis here is really messy and at times wrong i think it may be boiled to the fact that "massification" didnt killed the university as the side of the production of ruling casts but thst the change in powerrelations after ww2 rendered university inadequat for the task. Like the material reality of social organizing changed what edjucation was good for, not the other way around. The depressing truth is that the fight for the future of how power would be exercised - after the pre WW2 Elited became useless and inefficient - was lost in 68 because liberal democratic forced where to weak. And this shows now, that the existence of elite networks which have no functional constructive effwct but to syphon of wealth becomes a hard roadblock to the development of peoductive forces.

John Hoggett

"The people are not united We were defeated long ago The struggle does not continue. " From a book I was working on.

Carlos

Studebaker has criticized Cutrone’s critique of the Millennial Left as moralistic. I’ve been confused by that (meaning that I don’t see that as being the case whatsoever). But here Studebaker, discussing the failures of ‘68, appears to make clear his own position: political failures are moral ones because the political is a realm of virtues. This seems to me as useful as “the personal is political”, which is to say not very useful at all.

Dave

I agree. Not sure why he can’t call a riot political? There have been riots for over 200 years. Like, why can’t people be doing what they say they’re doing? My hunch is his opinions might degrade the personal brand he’s cultivating.

Maria

I know very little about the student protest in Nanterre and some about Paris, but I know plenty about the US student protests in the 1960s. I think this history went missing in the discussion. First of all, the Free Speech Movement was in the early 1960s, mainly 1964. Paris was in 1968--'68 was worlds away from the early 60s politically. Free Speechers and SDS were not hippies and their protest was NOT about the quality of their university education (their disappointment about not getting a real elite university experience, as BS claimed). They were NOT protesting for their sexual freedom- not in the early 1960s!! And they were not protesting against the soul-crushing white collar jobs they imagined in their future. They were not disaffected and despondant Benjamin Braddocks a la The Graduate. Both FSM's and SDS's main target was America's Cold War illiberalism- its bureaucratization, its militarization, and its authoritarian ever-expanding state. (A state that had a few short years prior killed Ethel and Julius Rosenberg.) What Savio was objecting to in the "Operation of the Machine" speech was Berkeley's crack down on student speech and the college administrations imperioius control of campus politics. He was arguing for his liberal rights! His expectation of political and civic self-development (for him the real gift and promise of a University education) was being quashed by the increasingly illiberal tendencies of American society. Savio was a first gen student when he came to Cal. He grew up in Queens in a Italian speaking devout Catholic immigrant family. He considered becoming a priest at one point in his life. As a first gen student, Savio would not have presumptions about the university, that Studebaker assumed he would. He would not have thought Berkeley intellectually inferior or below the threshold of a university education in the early 20th century. And in fact, I'm not entirely convinced that higher ed's decline had already begun in the mid 1960s. Berkeley, I believe, was a very highbrow serious institution in 1964. The summer before the Sproul Hall speech, Savio had joined protests against the San Franciso Hotel association for its refusal to hire black workers. He was arrested; while in the holding cell he met a guy who was involved in the Mississippi Freedom Summer. Once out of jail Savio went to Miss. to join the Freedom Summer. His activism in Fall 1964 was inspired by his work in Mississippi. Tom Hayden (the primary author of SDS's Port Huron Statement) also went to Mississippi that summer. As did various other figures in the early student movement. Both Savio and Hayden's Civil Rights activism generated and formed their mid 60s politics--not their disappointment about future jobs as managers and functionaries or their disappoinment with their university experience. Their involvement in the Civil Rights movement connected them to older leftist and socialist political actors, organizations, and sensibilities. I think that is enough from me.

Dave

I agree. I’ve never heard the 60s spoken about as disappointment in the job market. I’m sure it existed, but it never seemed like a central thing the way civil rights did.

Dave

And I would also say that Salvio is expressing his inexpressible need to fight the system in that clip. That can be criticized, but in practice it’s very common. Not quite the same as a party meeting with Lenin into the night.

Maria

You did, Doug. I just wanted to draw some things out more clearly. I know that it's easier to offer post-pod commentary than to actually play the game.