Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

 

Kendrick Lamar messed up.

About a few weeks ago, this happened:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WfwzK2kHGxU

Now, let’s break this down.

Kendrick Lamar invited a white woman on stage to perform “maad city”. And in her performance, she said “nigga”.

And since nothing takes place in a vaccuum, let’s put this in context.

Kendrick: *cutting the music* Wait, wait, my man Rohan knew the rules...

Her: [trying to hopefully side-step the issue] “It was really cool *bro* ya gotta work with me!”

Kendrick: You gotta bleep ONE word!

Girl: [with what I personally interpreted as belligerent sarcasm] Oh, I’m *sorry*... [sudden switch in vocal tone to innocent voice] Did I do it?

Kendrick: Should we keep her up here?

Girl: [Trying to save face] I’m used to singing it like Rohan [the white guy who came up before her], I promise!

Now, listen back to the first time the word was said. She edited herself. But the second, third, and forth time she didn’t.

She knew damn well that something in her was telling her not to say it.

But hold on: maybe I’m wrong!

Maybe this was what was going through her head:

Kendrick: *cutting the music* Wait, wait, my man Rohan knew the rules...

Her: [nervous in front of one of her favorite rappers ever, and trying to be cool by over-acting her coolness] “It was really cool *bro* ya gotta work with me!”

Kendrick: You gotta bleep ONE word!

Girl: [Not understanding the weight of the situation] Oh, I’m *sorry*... [sudden switch in vocal tone, because she just realized that she actually did say it] Did I do it?

Kendrick: Should we keep her up here?

Girl: [Honest plea] I’m used to singing it like Rohan, I promise!

With those brackets, the interaction is recontextualized now, right?

And here’s the thing: I personally don’t know her heart. Maybe she truly is an innocent babe who just doesn’t understand anything about the history of black people in America, and how there are still neo nazis in this country TODAY who use that word, and in their hearts wish to do Black people harm.

However, I don’t entirely blame this woman for saying it.

In this specific context, I blame her AND Kendrick. But in the grand scheme of things, I blame America’s legacy of slavery and it’s constant refusal to understand and truly teach to their children the history of WHY a black person would have a problem with this word based on that legacy.

But, you have to admit, in this context, Kendrick sent mixed messages.

He called her up on stage and put her in that scenario. And as far as the video shows, he did not introduce any limitations beforehand.

So, you invited a white woman on stage to sing the lyrics to your song (in fact, I think the point was to play a game of “do you know the lyrics?”) and THEN he got mad at her for saying them.

That was a mistake on his part.

And while it was definitely short-sighted, and I don’t think he had some bigger goal other than “make a fan feel special for a few minutes”, I do like that he ended up forcing people to have the conversation of white people saying the n word at rap concerts.

And to give credit where it’s due, Amine did a more intentional version for set at Coachella, to hilarious effect:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kEOiNHQbYlo&t=1m2s

(I mean, come on, let’s not act like, when rappers are on stage singing their songs, that the most-likely-majority-white concert-goers are ALL censoring themselves when the word comes up.)

But because of Kendrick’s short-sightedness, we’re now having the discussion again of “Can white people say the n word?”

And as a black person, my answer is:

There was never a time when they COULDN’T say it, so why are they acting like they need some sort of approval NOW?

And the anwer to THAT question is: white people didn’t have to consider how a black person might feel about them saying it, and now they do.

White people, you were never *actually* banned from using the n word. There’s no lock on your mouth that prevents you from saying it. You could say it right now, and you won’t go to jail, and you won’t be fined. There is literally nothing legally preventing you from using it.

No, if a dominating group of people with real power over you wanted you to stop doing something, they’d burn down your town, like Tulsa Oklahoma. They’d lynch you, like they did to those who are commemorated in this monument: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/11/a-national-monument-to-america-s-known-victims-of-lynching/540663/

They’d keep you from high-paying jobs. They’d draw red lines around where you live and say, “don’t give loans to these people”. They’d defund school primarily attended by black and latino kids. They’d make it dam near systemic to put you in prisons and take away your right to vote.

But what did Kendrick, a man with WAY more power and influence than this particular white girl, do?

Did he burn her town down? Did he lynch her? Hell, did he even forcefully kick her off the stage?

No. He basically said, “please don’t say that”.

That’s not censorship, or whatever these “free speech” advocates might argue.

That’s asking you to show respect to someone who’s experience isn’t your own.

And when you look at the reasons WHY black folk might be tight about you using that word as a white person, and your response is still:

“I wanna use this word without Black people making me *feel bad* for using it!”

I have no choice but to wonder what *your* position is on that racial history.

I want to use an analogy that an awesome youtuber named Jay Smooth said:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4yDMd9g1oSA&t=1m14s

For those who can’t watch:

“If I’m sitting at the bar with my date, and I call them ‘Honey’, it won’t be awkward, but if YOU came up to the bar and put your arm around my date and called them Honey’, it *will* be awkward.”

To that end, you could just be an overly friendly person, and no one explained to you why you shouldn’t do that, OR you’re a jackass who’s trying to take my girl. In that moment, I have no idea which one you are, so I’m going to naturally assume the worst.

Similarly, you could *absolutely* be a great guy without a racist bone in your body, and you grew up mainly around black people, and you just wanted to sing along!

Or, you’re a neo nazi asshole who just wants to shove that word in my face but then play innocent, and you’re using the fact that you have one or two black friends as a shield from any criticism.

As I said earlier, life is all about context, and in this specific context, she’s in a concert on stage where no one here knows her personally enough to be able to make that distinction.

So yeah, instead of pouting that you can’t say one word (that you actually can say, literally, at any time), maybe focus on *why* a black person would take issue with it. Maybe ask them, and start a dialogue, and listen to their experience.

I can tell you right now that the best white friends I have are the ones are willing to understand boundaries. And if the n word is one of those boundaries, and they respect that, I’m so much more willing to hang out with them.

But if the first thing you think is, “That’s a stupid boundary, it’s just a word!”

You’ve already lost me.

I want to end this with a quote from a white friend of mine:

"My momma always told me that the words I chose defined who I was to other people. Some people are gonna be fine with certain words, and some people won't be. And when you use those words around people, they're gonna know what kind of person you are. If they are kind enough to give you a chance and the benefit of the doubt by explaining why they dislike the word, well then, you have a chance to show what kind of person you are by respecting their reasons."

Comments

No comments found for this post.