Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I see this rhetoric a lot, usually under videos when someone disagrees with my rating for the album of that week.

(And by what I'm sure is also sheer coincidence, I never happen to see this rhetoric when we review an album that the commenter agrees with.

No one ever says, "Hey, I agree with your opinion on this album, too! But then I remembered that you gave Pac a lower rating than Cardi B, so unfortunately YOUR OPINION OF *THIS* ARTIST [that is in line with mine] IS NULL AND VOID".)

Unless it's a rap battle, or you're comparing the greats purely for the sport of a "Who, among these great artists, is better?" thing, I don't see the point of this, other than purely discrediting someone for not having the "right" opinion so you can feel better about having yours.

And either way, I don't analyze art by blanket praise for an artist just because they are loved by many. They are all mortal humans who make subjectively good and bad decisions like every other artist in existence, so unfortunately, not every single album, song, lyric, or recorded utterance in a classic artist's discography is preordained to be the very manifestation of perfection in my mind. And if that means sometimes, a newer artist can get a higher rating from me on a song or album than an older artist, well, I figure the fans of a critic would appreciate the specificity of my opinions, and would take care to hear out exactly *why* this or that rating is lower or higher, and would appreciate that honesty and detail.

Then again, I *could* just have arbitrary guidelines for "who is allowed have an album with the same rating as another artist".

But I figure you're here for MY thoughts on a piece of art, and not to hear me simply regurgitate pre-selected opinions.

And lemme be clear: I'm absolutely fine with people disagreeing with my opinion of a piece of art.

But this "RC doesn't like A album and B album, but *I* like A album, so therefore his opinion on B album MUST be wrong" line of thinking, in and of itself, is flawed, *especially* if you ALSO agree with my opinion on C album and D album and E album.

Maybe sometimes, *sometimes*, we just have a difference of opinion.

And that's okay. Judge each album by their own merits, not by some weird, complicated hierarchy of EVERY album being compared to each other. 

Different albums do different things. Respect their differences.

Comments

No comments found for this post.