Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Remember last year when we, like, semi-accepted Tyler the Creator for being gay?

I felt like we as a culture didn't really deal with the fact that the rapper with one of THE most homophobic lyrics in the past decade, was actually gay himself.

I remember when Odd Future first came out. They took college campuses by storm, (at least, the artsy fartsy one that I went to) and at first, I wanted to go along with them.

But I couldn't.

And I feel like a big reason was my experience listening to Eminem, and feeling a bit guilty about enjoying his music when I was younger, not realizing that I had been sidestepping any of his critics who got on him about his flippant homophobia.

So you can understand why I wasn’t rushing to listen to Goblin, an album that was infamous for using the (other) F-word 213 times.

Maybe if I hadn’t had so much time to think about Eminem’s homophobic lyrics and their impact, I would have been more willing to listen to him, but by that point, I had really started to pay attention to the fact that I hadn’t previously considered how those types of lyrics might make gay teens feel.

On top of that, I didn’t think about how those types of lyric might teach teens (who are *already* around other homophobic people) how to treat gay people.

Another thing I didn’t realize: that gay kid, and that homophobic kid? They’re sometimes the same person.

Enter Tyler, the creator.

His was a type of f-word flinging in an age where… honestly, it felt like we were beyond, at this point.

And I don't mean we were BETTER than that. God knows people are still homophobic and whatnot.

But I mean, by 2009, you could NOT be a super homophobic rapper in your lyrics all the time and have hit records.

And I don't mean “I don't vibe with queers” types of lines. Eminem didn’t just “not vibe” with queers. He said stuff like:

“whether you're a f*g or lez

Or a homosex, hermaph or a trans-a-vest

Pants or dress: Hate f*gs? The answer's yes”

He did THAT, and still managed to have hits records like it didn't even matter.

And the fact that you can't do that anymore is good! It means things definitely ARE changing, if slowly.

So, for me, by the time I saw Odd Future specifically making a name for themselves off of shock rap, which by nature is about crossing people’s psychological boundaries and taboos, I kinda tuned out, because as I got older, offending people for the sake of offending them just felt empty to me.

So I didn't bother to listen, figuring all they were was the newest rap group dissing the same old targets: gay people and women.

But then, I heard that a member of the crew was a lesbian.

...

Well, that threw me off.

And then, Frank Ocean came out as bisexual.

…

Well, shit...

These revelations made people start asking Tyler some questions. Why were you ok with saying homophobic shit knowing that you have a COUPLE of LGBT friends? How is this acceptable to them?

But then, Tyler came out as gay himself.

And I feel like the culture didn't really come to grips with that.

And I don't mean “we didn't accept him as gay.”

I mean, “we didn't reckon with the fact that all that blatant, unabashed derogatory and cruel lyricism at the expense of gay people was actually a roundabout expression of self hate.”

Dude didn't TURN gay last year, he was gay ALL throughout those horrible, demeaning lyrics.

So, when he came out, the conversation was, “Does the gay community “accept” Tyler.”

But I'd argue, that's not what we should be discussing, because I completely understand if gay people don't want to accept the music of a man who's always sounded so flippantly unconcerned about their issues in his music.

My concern is that the loudest guy in the room of Hiphop’s modern homophobia turned out to be the gayest guy in the room of Hiphop’s modern homophobia.

And I’m not dissing him for being a hypocrite. I mean, we ALL know that the “super homophobic preacher turns out to be gay” is a trope for a reason; because it happens in real life.

This isn't a bug; it's a feature of any society that made it normal for decades to shame and insult people for loving someone of the same sex.

Now, forgive me if I haven't seen an article really breaking down the reality of this revelation (and if you have, please link me to it), but, well, I didn't need to be in the trans community or give a shit about the Kardashians to know who Caitlyn Jenner was.

I KNOW who Tyler is, and I read hiphop editorials all the time. And the fact that a homophobic rapper turned out to be gay? That just BARELY hit my radar.

Funny thing is, Tyler has even said on his twitter that he tried to come out MANY times, but either no one believed him, or they just weren't paying attention.

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/tyler-the-creator-gay-bisexual-coming-out-scum-fuck-flower-boy-lyrics-i-aint-got-time-twitter-garden-a7834751.html

And when he DID come out… what even happened?

Was he seen at a pride rally? Did he start working more closely with artists in the gay community? Was he even *accepted* by the gay community? Did he apologize for his years of perpetuating the language of bigots? Did anyone reach out to him for that to even happen?

No, there didn't seem to be a big, loving moment like when Ellen Page came out. Hell, there was even some support for Frank Ocean (after it was clear that he could make hit records for people, of course…). However, there was no huge wave of support for Tyler, there was just… an awkward situation that everyone sorta poked their stick at before moving on.

Funny thing is, Tyler’s coming out was hard to handle, but in a way, it's his fault: Tyler is so well known as being a troll and a joker that being serious didn't really make sense.

In fact, one example many point to is his interview here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ahLZnxzER_Q

He admits to liking boys (in particular, *white* boys, which is… it’s own can of worms we don’t have time to get into here…), but then, he immediately says that he’s also sexually attracted to literal vans, with the same lackadaisical delivery, obscuring the ability to take either claim seriously.

But who's to say that that mask, that trolling persona, is put up so THAT he could tell us his truths without it feeling like it would hurt?

‘Cause let's take a step back and understand that society at large (and hiphop in general) has been breathtakingly homophobic since time immemorable. So, when someone IS gay in a space where you could be beaten up for not only being gay, but coming OFF as gay? What does that do to someone?

Shit, we were all bullied at one point or another, but I'm pretty sure it's one thing to be picked on for “acting gay” when you're not, and another to be picked on for “acting gay” when you ARE, and in this confrontational interaction, you're basically being called out and ridiculed for your identity.

As well, there doesn’t seem to be any real open celebration when a gay rapper comes out. There's just this tacit sense of, “Okay, fine, you're gay, just shut up about it, and we'll be cool”.

Same with Young MA, same with Dej Loaf, same with ILOVEMAKONNEN (whose homosexuality only even became a hot topic after Migos said something about it).

And I hate this.

I hate that we see artists come out in other forms of art, and they are accepted and loved, but for hiphop, we just do a collective nod, and go, “Aight, yeah, whatever”.

And that may seem progressive to some (I mean, hey, SHOULDN’T we eventually reach a point where coming out as gay doesn't matter?), but to me, something feels… off.

By which I mean, where WAS Tyler during all of pride month? Where’s Dej Loaf? Where are all these artists being open and celebrating their love, and more importantly their COURAGE to come out in a world that, as much as we like to think is super progressive, fucking isn't.

And let's be absolutely clear about this: the Supreme Court JUST ruled, ONLY THREE YEARS AGO, that same sex marriage is LEGAL in all 50 states.

I ask you, honestly: do ya think everyone accepts gay people now? 

You think all those churches and politicians who pushed against this for literally decades were just like, “Oh, OKAY, you win, we’ll stop being homophobic now...”

And yes, we *do* have more gay and lesbian representation in the media.

But, you ever notice it's only blatantly presented in *certain* places?

And in other, more mainstream spaces, gay characters either just don't exist, or are barely ever presented as loving someone of the same gender?

Think about how many films in the past couple year have tried to “have it both ways” by giving SIGNIFIERS to queerness without ACTUALLY showing it?

(For real, does anyone ever get sick of that shit? Not because I want to push some “gay agenda” or that I want to make characters gay that aren't written to be gay in the first place. I just hate when people insult my intelligence. You know, like with the recent Solo movie where “oh-ho-ho! Landon is (maybe) PANSEXUAL! Or Dumbeldore is GAY, but, like, he NEVER does ANYTHING to show that he is. ((Just sayin, if Harry went the whole series without doing many magic, what would be the point of Hagrid telling him he's a wizard?) Okay, side-rant over.)

I say all that to say, the fact that this is even a possible discussion means that the higher-ups at these companies are telling people to not put queerness *so* upfront in *certain* venues, that gay people can be here, but when you’re over *here*, eh, don't be so loud about it, so our culture doesn't have to finally look at itself and how it constantly forced gay folks to hate part of who they are in order to fit in.

And THAT, I think, should be how we go forward when the next rapper comes out. Let's really have a discussion about not just tolerance, but acceptance; not just superficial signifying, but true representation; and most importantly, let's really look at the factors that cause our society to turn a guy like Tyler, the Creator into a gay man who makes homophobic music.

Or, as Tyler might say, “a fucking walking paradox”.

And as my last article ended with a quote, I’d now like to quote Frank Ocean, from his GQ interview:

Interviewer: Did you worry [coming out] would derail your career?

Frank: I had those fears. In black music, we've got so many leaps and bounds to make with acceptance and tolerance in regard to that issue. It reflects something just ingrained, you know. When I was growing up, there was nobody in my family—not even my mother—who I could look to and be like, "I know you've never said anything homophobic." So, you know, you worry about people in the business who you've heard talk that way. Some of my heroes coming up talk recklessly like that. It's tempting to give those views and words—that ignorance—more attention than they deserve. Very tempting.

https://www.gq.com/story/frank-ocean-interview-gq-december-2012


Comments

No comments found for this post.