Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • Episode 252 - BRETT WROTE A BOOK.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

Let's explore a very interesting synthesis between multiple schools of thought as we dive into Breht's new project.

CHECK OUT REVLEFT: https://revleftradio.com/

Files

Comments

Dracip

I saw the word Buddhism and immediately knew Breht had to be the guest

Dahlia

Okay but if nobody talks about Laos this episode my bust of lenin is gonna cry tears of blood.

Jack

Same, so damn excited for this one. Love Breht

Sophie 🏳️‍⚧️

Can't tell if I'm disappointed or relieved Hakim isn't on this episode...

Rens Victor

This was so good, thanks for letting him rant

Dahlia

It's all over the carpet..

Paddy League

I love Breht’s perspective… thanks for having him on again! So stoked about the book

Sophie 🏳️‍⚧️

I know nothing about the politics of Laos, other than they're at least nominally a communist state. Would be very interested to learn

Dahlia

Yep they're a socialist state led by a communist party, the socialism of Laos is also quite influenced by Buddhist ideas and principles

Michi

taning is skin cancermaxxing

Kenny

I'm from the northwestern US and when someone goes to a warm beach place in the winter we also make the same tan comments.

CM

I agree we shouldn’t dog pile on the conference and I don’t agree with the leftist content creators who made reactionary videos about it either. That said, in an attempt to do a dialectics critique, the conference has the biggest platform out there in global north and is using the word ‘socialism’ so I do think we should point out narratives that can be harmful to the movement. What bothers about that ‘being fit’ discourse is that it seems to lack a material basics. Is there an endemic issue at the organizing spaces at the ground? Are people leaving organizing because they were told they need to exercise? Or they are alienated en mass because they don’t look like Butchware? If im someone who is new to socialism im going to be discouraged from organizing because of what is implied here. That is like saying ‘ hey socialists shouldn’t eat children, it’s fascism! ’ (okay extreme example but you get the idea) But I agree with Berht that we shouldn’t concede these spaces :)

Alex Isaac

The YouTube version at 1h:20 loops to the start....

Babel2GK

Gonna shill for Breht a little bit but check out REVLEFT's patreon for their full back catalogue. I've been a listener and (seldom) commenter since all the way back around 2018 or so

Danny Boy

YAY BREHT IS BACK!

Michael Xin

I support too many red podcasts with my meager wage

Hamish Bradley

YAYYYY DEPROGRAM AND BREHT LETS GOOOOO

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

I love Breht and Rev Left Radio for many reasons, but primarily because he is incredibly open and transparent with listeners about his own lived experience in a way that informs his politics. Amazing episode, cannot wait to read his book when he comes out, and encourage any Deprogram comrades to become patrons for Rev Left if you aren’t already (and have the means to do so)!

Shami Carroll

Incredible conversation, had to listen to it twice

Sadie

Disabled and immunocompromised comrades who chose to stay covid safe out of their own necessity have actually been largely excluded from many spaces, including organizing spaces, because they just simply aren’t accessible or safe enough. Rae has discussed this on Proles pod. I would encourage anyone, out of curiosity, to ask more questions and maybe pay attention to what disabled people are saying instead of automatically assuming this has no material basis - we’ve been living through a mass disabling event for 6+ years now as covid continues to rip through the global population unmitigated. The point of this is that we are all pre-disabled if not already disabled, and people will continue to be disabled by covid infections as time goes on - like we don’t have the 40 years to correct this shit like we apparently did with convincing doctors to wash their hands after procedures, or stopping smoking in hospitals - it’s that bad, most people are just ignoring it and assuming public health is fine. But millions of previously healthy people, including many of your comrades out in the world who you might not know yet, as well as my comrades, have been permanently disabled and given chronic illnesses by this virus - which, like Bea and Da’Shaun both discuss, is relevant. Fascism and health fascism typically accelerate after pandemics - happened with the 1918 flu pandemic as well. There’s a certain irony and grief in seeing people do their best to maintain what they’ve been told is healthy under capitalism while being repeatedly infected with a neuroinvasive vascular disease, you know? I think for many people, the “lack of material basis” is simply a lack of context on their part (this isn’t a jab, just encouragement to learn about this.) Also, I would encourage you, like Breht said, to listen to Bea’s entire speech because Bea and Da’Shaun actually do go into a diamat historical analysis of the history of fascist metrics of “health” in this country. If someone is “new to socialism” and this is the first thing they see but their gut reaction is to run, maybe it’s not for them or it’s not the right time? The “discourse” isn’t about being fit, again, it’s about the history of fascist metrics and standards of health in this country. People really need to be engaging with curiosity more when they don’t understand something is my point. Our assumptions aren’t always correct and we need to be looking at things from other perspectives when possible. TLDR; definitely give the full episode a listen on death panel, it’s labeled as socialism conference 2026.

Sadie

And you actually did ask questions and were honest about your critiques which is great, glad I could provide some context. Thanks for being open to discussing and also for refusing to be reactionary 🤝

Wendi Byther

Been thinking a LOT lately about how the right is trying to weaponize empathy as toxic or even suicidal.. This guy’s outlook feels like a good place to start to try and combat that whole shitbag “ideology” (I put it in quotes bc they don’t actually believe in it. Not really. It’s a means to their ends.)

Sadie

Breht and Alyson’s discussions and “rants” always keep my attention! I’m auDHD and am always super engaged listening to them. Agreed 100%.

CM

Thank you for providing context and I def learned more. I guess my question (honestly not trying to antagonize) is whether covid safety is the primary driver of the people not wanting to join organizations and organizing meeting? Whenever I try to get people to come to meeting or events whether this is from strangers online or people I know the main barriers seems to be capacity, immigration status, lack of childcare/ event is not child friendly, the time is inconvenient for parents or people who work, or just a general lack of interest/consciousness. I never get a question about covid safety. Most of these meeting also have online option. This is what I mean material basics. I recognize this is my personal observation so if there is some sort of data out there that would be great. Of course I believe we need to prioritize disability comrades as much as possible, but recognize there are also other barriers such and immigration status and childcare, which doesn’t really get discussed. If we truly want to build a mass movement, as Marxist we should approach this dialectally and identify what is the primary contradiction and maybe perhaps that is disability. Anyways thanks for engaging in comradely debate with me :)

Michi

It is not even a debate. Hakim always has the best takes on topics like this.

Sadie

I gotta give this a better read rather than a skim, but for a lot of the people I’ve engaged with it’s about a lack of airborne precautions and I guess also a general feeling of alienation given the disconnect between people who are taking precautions and people who don’t think they need to if that makes sense? I’ll come back to this though. The thing with disability and a mass disabling event like the ongoing unmitigated spread of SARS-CoV-2 (with no sterilizing vaccine, mind you, so everyone who doesn’t mask is spreading it) is that the people most disproportionately affected by this virus and the other disabling factors of capitalism are the exact marginalized and oppressed demographics you mention - children, immigrants, alongside women, LGBTQ+ people, autistic and ADHD people, and already chronically ill and disabled people. So it’s not so much about one issue being more important than the other, but that disability and the spread of COVID literally has a handle on everyone’s objective material conditions whether they want to acknowledge it or not - it can happen to any of you at any time. And I wouldn’t necessarily call it “prioritizing disabled comrades” but rather people putting on a KN95 in essential public spaces, at meetings, running air purifiers, you know. Pretty simple. Not masking everywhere if they don’t want to but inside public spaces like the doctor, grocery, or where there are workers. I personally don’t know anyone who can afford to be sick off of work or suddenly disabled and catching covid repeatedly is like playing Russian roulette with disability. Engels actually goes over this pretty well in the condition of the working class in England, the concept of social murder, how public health is a collective responsibility, etc. I look at it like this: When we’re taking care of disabled comrades we’re taking care of ourselves too because we will all be disabled or further disabled eventually, and capitalism is disabling in itself. I probably didn’t hit all of your questions - but this was a good discussion and I appreciate you being open minded too :) 💜

Sadie

Oh - so regarding Covid safety - I think yes, that is a big thing for Covid conscious and disabled comrades. Online options are an absolutely fantastic for chronically ill folks and disabled folks when it’s just not a great day symptom or chronic-pain wise to attend in person - or if someone just wants to stay home which I get 😂 but there are definitely a good amount of CC (covid conscious) disabled comrades who do attend meetings in person and are typically the only masked one there which can be disheartening given the reality that everyone is vulnerable to long covid, not just disabled people, and it not only is physically putting that comrade at risk even if they’re masked, but it also just feels like a slap in the face if that makes sense. I feel the same way when I’m at the doctor and me and my cardiologist are the only ones in N95s in the building, meanwhile there are 6 people hacking up a lung in the lobby in August - asymptomatic spread is really bad too so people don’t really know when they’re sick. So yes, for some CC people that alienation is difficult to contend with. I wouldn’t say that it’s generally the primary driver of people in general not wanting to join! For me, I know with my auDHD I would go to my ex’s organizing events periodically but never after work because I needed to decompress alone. I think as far as people not joining there are soooo many different variables - I wouldn’t pin it on airborne precautions in a general context, so many factors contributing to it, not unlike the barriers you mentioned, (childcare, crazy work schedules, too much life stuff, mental health) those are very real. I’m not sure if you’re in the U.S. (don’t tell me where you are comrade!) but if you are, you can check and see if you have a local mask bloc maybe? That’s a great way to connect some precautions to your org, they often lend out high powered air purifiers for events and can also help with providing masks at times. (This is also just good for keeping us all healthy in winter and fall, so no one is ending up out of work or very ill.) Actually if you’re interested I’d be happy to link you to instructions for building corsi rosenthal boxes (DIY air purifiers) these are super useful even if no CC people are in your org, they help clean the air of airborne viruses which personally I think Engels would’ve loved lolol. I think like everything it’s contextual - I know for me it has been a difficult balance of caring about other people and not wanting them to be harmed by Covid but also grieving the fact that a lot of people won’t care and we’re all gonna be hurt by it? And it’s hard to reconcile with that cognitive dissonance. I guess my best advice on that front would definitely be to engage with a mask bloc and ask (sensitively) what their thoughts are, like what their ideal meetings would look like. I think we just don’t want everyone getting sick and disabled because Joe Biden said we could for surplus value, ya know. We gotta preserve whatever health we have left to the best of our abilities and I think that solidarity (which takes less effort than it sounds like) and understanding is super important and impactful even just through “hey, we all mask for an hour or two at this meeting, we can take mask breaks in the hallway or outside, and this way the space is inclusive for everyone / we’re not normalizing the spread of a disabling virus in this space”. Disability does effects everything, especially under capitalism, so I think there are ways to combat the spread of COVID in essential spaces at the very least; like hey, if someone wants to be unmasked at the bar or a house party - fine, I can understand that to an extent for sure, but that when we’re locking in to serious community care via public health mode, we put the mask on in public transit, in-person organizing / events, grocery, hospital. And I think the more you learn about it, given that you’re my fellow Marxist, the more connections you’ll make to the ubiquitous nature of disability and pandemics under capitalism in relation to our material conditions 💜 but always feel free to reach out to me if you wanna talk about it more or have questions!! (Also sorry these were so long lol I’m very wordy)

QuantumNoob

I really really miss Hakim in this episode! Besides that he asks the questions that are on my mind, Orwell was mentioned without Hakim reacting.

Web wil

Please, if you see this, don’t just scroll past. Even sharing this could connect us with someone who can help save Liv from continuing to suffer. Liv’s dialysis was turned on, but it was shut back off at 12. She is now without the dialysis she needs, and I am desperately trying to raise enough money to get it turned back on. I need to cover at least half of the dialysis cost, or the full amount if possible, along with the remaining portion of our rent that is due tomorrow. Since her dialysis was shut off, Liv has been having horrible seizures, and I am absolutely terrified for her. I am doing everything I possibly can to keep her safe and get her the care she needs, but I cannot do this alone. I am asking from the bottom of my heart: PLEASE help Liv. If you can donate anything at all, no amount is too small. If you cannot donate, please share this with your family, friends, churches, community groups, or anyone who may be able to help. I am not asking for anything for myself. I just need to get Liv’s dialysis turned back on and keep a roof over our heads. 🙏🏽 PLEASE HELP LIV. 🙏🏽 💔 WE NEED HELP NOW. 💔 cash.app/$DaunderDogg venmo.com/u/Webwil1240 Paypal.me/oriverawilson