Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this patreon exclusive, Breht lays out a possible new direction for Rev Left and asks for listener feedback, reflects on a handful of books he has read (or listened to) recently and what he got out of them, ponders what social media and smart phone addiction robs from us all and how we can resist it, analyzes what the Tik Tok Ban is really all about (with leaked audio from Jonathan Greenblatt from the ADL giving the game away), highlights the abject inhumanity and casual sociopathy of Zionists, and more!

Files

Comments

Angleton

So I have just finished reading the entire Oxford History of the US and I was wondering if you could tell us the books you are reading for your advanced level US History courses?

Angleton

Also more Dialects Deep Dive

Ben

Hey Breht! I’ve been a listener since mid-2020, and in my opinion, I don’t feel as though the interviews have become over-saturated. I really like the variety of views they bring in, and it’s cool hearing from experts, especially on historical topics (like the ongoing modern Chinese history conversation on GH. That said, I don’t listen to a lot of other podcasts, and none with interviews heavily featured, so other folks may feel differently. I really do love your monologues, and they’re a big reason why I subscribed to the Patreon, so if the show went more in that direction, I certainly wouldn’t be disappointed.

Gabriel Alvarado

Breht O’Shea famous quotes, “It fucks their little baby brains up”😂

Gabriel Alvarado

On a serious note, do you. The way you took the risk of quitting your shitty soul sucking job to pursue something you are passionate about. Take the risk of moving RevLeft in a different direction if that is where your heart/soul desire. That’s honestly why I subscribe to you. The show is genuine, it’s raw, it’s passionate. That’s really all I can personally ask for.

Brett

I don’t know how much weight you should give my opinion since I’ve only been a communist and listener since 2021 (though I’ve immensely enjoyed enjoyed listening through the backlog). However, I would say that I have found your show to be a vital source of connectivity for the far left and the interview format seems like a key part of that. Part of the reason I’ve become aware of the wide variety and impacts of left belief structures (and how various groups use theory/praxis) has been because you talked to someone from a group/tendency I’d never even heard of. Since I belief that left solidarity is the most important (short-term) goal in our lifetime, that aspect of your show has been something I have really treasured. Take the show in whatever direction you feel is best, but don’t do it for sake of personal popularity or because you think that’s what the mainstream listener wants. You are a vital cog in the left ecosystem that we need no matter how you decide to fulfill your role.

Beefdrip

Still working through the episode, but my preliminary feedback so far: 1). I think most people come to RevLeftRadio for Breht (and Alyson for Red Menace), myself included. I don't really care what format you do, since listening to your experience is a treat, I trust your judgement on the podcast's direction. The interviews are great, you shooting the shit with Dave is great, and the theory is great. I think it's a real achievement that you've made a podcast that is so academic while still being entertaining/accessible. As someone who formerly made content, I felt the burnout after a while and ultimately quit, so if the interviews are tiring you and you want to change, go for it! But please don't change because of trends. I don't think Logan Paul or Joe Rogan are talking to guests about dialectical materialism, lol. 2). For social media, I've definitely been cutting back on my usage. I got addicted to discord during COVID, so my compromise is keeping it to my desktop, like you do with Instagram. Getting back into reading has been hard (due to that constant dopamine hit you've been talking about), but it's been rewarding to pick up Parenti again and to discover new sources like Ilan Pappe or bell hooks. Another thing that helps out is making stuff, especially with my own hands, has been very rewarding and boosts my self esteem. No longer am I arguing with some random assholes on Twitter or Reddit, but I'm building furniture or cooking dishes that reconnect with my heritage. I think for the phone aspect of it, I use a long passphrase, so that even if I wanted to get that 30 second dopamine hit, I wouldn't have the time to pull out and unlock my phone. It forces me to be more intentional on when I want to pull out my phone, especially in social circles. I still notice people whipping out those machines instead of sitting with their thoughts and observing their environments, lol. Board games have been great for conversation and social interaction, as you have common goals to work towards, and you're thinking instead of pulling out a phone. 3). As for books and specifically the topic of casual sex, have you read bell hooks? I find that her discussion on feminism and her insight into men and how patriarchy has robbed them of emotion to be fascinating. 4). The TikTok ban is quite transparent, as you've said, but I think it's too late for congress to change the narrative. Pandora's box has been opened and we still see protests for Palestine to this day. This "problem" hasn't gone away for the Biden regime and co. and has only intensified, i'd say. So long as people continue to see this genocide in real time, which will happen with or without TikTok, no amount of spin or toothless non-binding "ceasefires" (i.e. not a permanent end to the slaughter) will placate most of us.

Lana

I enjoy the interviews but I really enjoy a Breht riff lol always here for that! The monologue analysis idea sounds great. Something I often find myself enjoying in other podcasts are interviews but...more off the cuff type of interviews. Kinda like two people shootin' the shit on a few topics. Similar to what you did with BRG in your recent episode. I personally love that structure of interview and find it very personable and accessible. Your perspective on social media really resonated with me. As a fellow late 80s baby, I'm so glad I had a childhood without phones and social media. I'm introverted and shy to begin with so socializing digitally was like a dream for me at first but damn, it's gotten so out of hand now. I have been reading Stolen Focus by Johann Hari, which sounds similar to Digital Minimalism, and it's so eye opening. You mentioned what it does to children and those dopamine hits they get constantly, and as an elementary art teacher I see the results of this of my students in their art making too. Children give up at the slightest hint of struggle. Very little perseverance, very little creative problem solving, very little creative effort, because they aren't getting that instant gratification when they have to actually WORK at something to produce a result. As for me, I've started putting my phone in another room lately and any time I get the urge to scroll, I reach for a book or my sketchbook instead. It's such a double edged sword too because on the one hand, I feel like social media has done a lot for the masses in terms of education, ya know? Like, we no longer get our information and news from top down sources like corporate owned media but we can get it from each other now. But on the other hand, are we meant to be this connected ALL the time? Are we meant to have this much knowledge all the time? Are we meant to be this aware of what is happening in the world ALL the time? I dunno. Ugh, what a mess.

Lana

Well said on number 1!

cj7700

I don't listen to RevLeft for the guests although I think you do bring on brilliant people. I think as the crisis develops in this country there would be a lot of value in conversations between you and organizations who are dealing with the crisis on the ground, but I agree that interviews shouldn't be the bulk of your content. Lending your very tall soapbox to groups like Black Alliance for Peace has been really informative and valuable to me (and probably very valuable to them as an org as well) and I'd hate to see that disappear but I think an interview once every month would be plenty. Idk if the interview market is saturated because honestly the only media I have time to digest is your work and that dude Sisyphus on YT but I do think that becoming an interviewer is a skill that is pretty easily developed compared to the knowledge and perspective that you've cultivated over years of learning and personal growth. What draws me to this podcast is a superior analysis of current events, your superior analysis of the human condition, and the political education I can glean from your excellent conversations with Alyson. I'd be thrilled to see you shift your attention to a more formal long-form monologue but frankly I think that regardless of which direction you go with this podcast you'll continue to produce content at a very high level. Definitely going to check Digital Minimalism too

cj7700

Cal Newport

Z

Listener since 2019 when I began a warehouse job - thank god for rev left, proles pod, and the deprogram because I would have lost my mind without you guys in the 3 years I worked there - I think more off-the-cuff/free flow content would be great. The interviews you’ve done are fantastic, but as you mentioned, you have a massive archive of interviews, and you can still make time for more when good opportunities arise. It also seems that, even without pursuing your masters in education, you have a pretty substantial workload, so it only makes sense health-wise to pursue a direction with the pod that ultimately nourishes your mind. Thanks for all you do! Also, totally random side note, what’s your workout routine like lately? I just started back up after a 6-8 month hiatus and I really enjoy legs/push/pull/legs, and sometimes I’ll give shoulders their own day instead of trying to jam that into push day.

Saya Clarke

Breht I think what has made the show so successful and what most people here on Patreon love about the show is your warm compassionate personality, brutal honesty, fearless display of emotion and integrity. It’s inspiring and cathardic and has moved me to tears many times over the years. And of course the fabulous group of comrades you’ve surrounded yourself with. Truly Alyson is another person that I admire so much and feel emboldened by. Personally I haven’t much thought about the interview style as being any kind of liability as far as growth goes but I trust your judgement that the show needs to stay fresh and exciting. I think experimenting with a style that more closely resembles your Marxism x Buddhism speech or your Red Hot Shots would work well and your regulars would maybe appreciate a change of pace. The political climate is escalating, as you’ve demonstrated here so maybe it’s time to turn up the heat on your commentary accordingly. I only speak for myself of course but I’m in it for the long haul. As long as I don’t wake up one day and see an episode entitled “MAGA Communism: Why I’ve Come Around” I will likely keep finding value in your shows. Thanks for all you do. Happy to support the work. Solidarity!

Seany G

Lots to comment on, as others have attested. My initial thoughts before I lose them.... 1) it is true that social media CAN be a black hole, but it can also be a source for connecting with others about IMPORTANT topics, not just inane ones. Someone mentioned Palestine in a comment ; where would the resistance to Israeli atrocities be if not for alternative voices and perspectives exchanged on social media? How could they be as affective at organizing protests and other actions of they weren't on social media? The trick, in my opinion, is to learn to use it as a productive tool. Imagine how the Bolsheviks would have used it if it had been around at the time... Besides, when I get bored, it is true that I DO reach for my phone, but it's to listen to Rev Left Radio.... :) 2) As for interview saturation, it is true that interviews can be restrictive for the host and uninformative for the listener, but it could also be highly interesting to get a new perspective on a topic, or to hear someone who has a deeper understanding of a topic than you do. It always depends : on who you interview, and HOW you interview her/him/them. Whatever frequency you feel comfortable with is the way to go. As Oscar Wilde said, "everything in moderation (including moderation)." 3) this segues into a possible new direction of your show: I think that you do theory VERY well - your analysis and understanding of topics, issues, and concepts is deep. No doubt about that. One area I have felt you could expand more on, however, is praxis. You have mentioned, I believe, that Lenin or someone said that theory without practice is useless and practice without theory is unprincipled (or something like that). With that in mind, I think that you could use the once-per-month interview to highlight people who are actually organizing with others. This could be union leaders, student activists, specific solidarity groups. This would show the real-life application of why we are communists. There's a point to it all, and it's not to win debates among your friends! If you want to make such interviews even more substantive, you could even bring in theory to the topic. Eg. Interview someone from Jewish Voice for Peace, or Not in Our Name, and then discuss the concept of Zionism or settler colonialism or Israeli apartheid with them. And I think you could do this a little more even outside of an interview format. Eg. take a topic like Haiti and talk about the solidarity groups that are giving alternative narratives to the "those (black) gangs are just violent b/c they want power" from the mainstream media. You could outline what they are doing, whether a specific campaign or a general orientation, and highlight the good, the bad, and the ugly (plus the contradictions) . 4) the "know your enemy" approach to reading and discussing a topic is a laudable and necessary endeavour. You used to do this more on Rev Left Radio, and I thought it was wonderful. It's not "masochism", it's a logical and beneficial orientation to grounding our own positions. As Norman Finkelstein has said, you can (and usually do) always underestimate the arguments of your ideological opponents. Their voices are the dominant voices in our society, so we need to confront their false narratives constantly to better understand our own ideas. War on Gaza? What's wrong with Ben Shapiro's or Rabbi Schmuli's arguments about "human shields" or the tunnels Hamas has constructed? These straw man arguments have to be taken down. And you can help us learn to this better. (Like you did with Sarah Isgar's outlandish comments on Bill Maher.) OK, that's enough for now. Thanks for reading.

Michael Xin

Breht I think you have an exceptional talent for fiery red hot polemics, but I'm worried too much solo ranting will burn you out. Maybe find some more frequent collaborators you can rant together with

Keelan Swift

But I can’t delete the patreon app… that is an essential function of my phone 😂 Firstly, thank you for all the work you do. I only listen to four podcasts and they are all part of the Rev Left family tree. For half a decade now you have been fundamental in shaping the way I interpret the world. You’re work must mean a great deal to a lot of people. I like the idea of you trying something new and the written monologues sound great. The one you did on the overlap between Buddhism and Marxism worked really well. Personally, I enjoyed some of your more obscure episodes. For example, the guided meditations and your reading of Howard Zinn’s Marx in Soho. Fun little variations like that are fun and refreshing. I also love it when you talk about specific people. Rev Left has made read stuff by people like John Berger and Fyodor Dostoevsky, as well as watching films by Andrei Tarkovsky and listening to music by Nina Simone. It goes without saying that you’ve also turned me towards a lot of political theory! Try not to burn yourself out by doing too much. The monologues sound like a lot of hard work. Regardless of what you do, I’m excited for the future of Rev Left. Hope you’ve recovered from the unfortunate car crash 😂 Love and solidarity!

Andrew Blake

I love everything you do. Don't need it to be freshened but if you're getting bored go for it. imo you should do what makes you happy... I suspect the audience will follow regardless

d

Do your thing breht, the new format sounds like a great idea

Vincent

I think the move away from interviews makes sense personally. I think interviews tend to be very long, which makes it hard to find time to listen to them. Personally, I think there are a lot of topics that you hear a lot about on the Left where it seems everyone has a strong opinion about a given thing but it's hard to find concise information about what that thing is. I really like when you have episodes that give an overview of these kinds of topics and think that would work well with an essay format. I really appreciate all the work you've put out and look forwards to more!

Felisha Buchinger

I look forward to the new chapter of left. Rev left is some of the first Marxist content that had, lightbulbs going off for me, and it’s because of specifically the way you analyze things in a non-academic way, in a way that anybody can understand and relate to. I genuinely look forward to deeper scripted analysis from you..

Tiffani McCoy

Follow your instincts and your heart. I loved this episode and I’m interested in you doing an episode or two on what you are learning from Tucker Carlson and all these other far right folks you educate yourself on. I’d love to know their key points but don’t have the stomach to listen. My own personal turn toward Buddhism, meditation, mindfulness is in part because of your solo shows. I’m deeply thankful for you sharing so much of your life and personal journey with us. Also, hope someday your neighbor acknowledges your existence! 🙃

Rev Left Radio

Thank you very much for this and for your incredibly kind words! I agree that I will never fully jettison interviews, but might make them one type of episode among a couple other types, that way there is a broad spectrum of episode styles! That probably seems better than just reducing the show to any one type of episode structure!

Rev Left Radio

1) Thank you for that feedback! I appreciate it and take it to heart! 2) Very smart move wrt cutting back on discord/social media, and you are 10000% correct about using your hands, making stuff, learning stuff, and basically engaging with the physical world, instead of wasting away on the digital one! That shift is precisely what I am advocating!! 3) I am certainly familiar with bell hooks (even did an In Memoriam style episode on her when she passed!). She has some areas that deserve critique, but her overall work is really deep and worthwhile for sure, particularly around those issues you mentioned! 4) Absolutely correct. Their desperation and insecurity and censoriousness can only go so far, the cat is out of the bag, and no matter what they do, they cant put it back. Their heavy handed approach only further alientates them from the youth and continues to dig their ideological graves!

Rev Left Radio

1) Great feedback, and I appreciate that and the kind words! Thats what I love about Alyson eps: its like two friends talking, and not as formal as a normal interview! 2) Totally agree. and your point about instant gratification and the necessity of work, struggle, and perseverance is so on point. Smart phones and their compulsive use is EASY. and anything that is that easy is not worth having. Everything in life worth doing or having comes with difficulty, and demands perseverance, overcoming adversity, failing and trying again, etc. I feel very scared for a generation of kids facing all the problems of this world with the attention spans of a goldfish and the complete lack of any ability to struggle, be disciplined, have deep focus, etc. But for our rulers, having a populace of compulsive, impulsive, scatter-brained, internet addicts is better than having a populace of disciplined, focused, mentally strong, and well-educated citizens! Not that this is a conscious strategy on their part, but it does ultimately seem to be heading in that direction. The fact that the inventors of these apps and phones often make a huge deal about not letting their own children on them is all the proof we need that this shit is toxic and terrible for all of us, especially children and teens. 3) Yea, that is a good point. But I see podcasts, audio books, and even good educational YT content/docs, etc. as better forms of keeping up w the news and information than social media, which comes packed with a bunch of other terrible shit and gives us news largely in the form of hot takes from total strangers. Then you add the data mining, the algorithmic containment, the COINTEL elements, the profiteering by monopolies, etc. and it seems clear that giving social media away in favor of those other long form approaches to news and info is best! IMO at least! Although, i have to admit, there is no better place to be than twitter when some crazy shit pops off. The In-Real-Time and radically uncensored aspects of that platform make it the place to be when huge events erupt!

Rev Left Radio

Damn thank you very, very much. Incredibly kind of you to say all of that and it means a lot to me! Thank you for your feedback, I truly take it to heart! Thank you as well for your support of me and the show. <3

Rev Left Radio

THank you for that feedback!! I appreciate that. As for my work out routine, it shifts depending on the time of year. With volleyball and softball coming up, ill cut back to probably 2-3 days a week of full body (or else it gets too hard to recover and I start getting hurt). In non-sport seasons, I go up to four days, usually a lower-upper split. But I am working toward your idea of Push/Pull/Legs/Rest/Repeat, especially when I start my fall/winter bulk. In addition I have also been getting into cycling to and from the gym, and on rest days as well. Id like to work on getting my cardio for cycling up over time, and maybe start bikepacking at some point!

Rev Left Radio

LMAO well you need not worry about the MAGA communism thing XD. Tho that did give me a good belly laugh, so thank you! As for the rest of your input, Im grateful for your kind words as always. It means so much to me to read that, and inspires me to keep going; and since I have genuinely developed a deep respect and appreciation for you in particular over the years, it means THAT much more! So thank you. I agree with your advice as well regarding episode styles, and the escalating crisis situation calling for some more analysis and commentary on my part. I think the best approach is a mix of interviews, red menace eps, and monologue essay type eps! Ill experiment w that going forward!

Bill

Interviewing for the sake of interviewing is probably a bad model, but certainly a quality interview (and you’ve had many) holds great value and is worth continuing from time to time when the opportunity arises. The podcast doesn’t have to be all or nothing. I would also add that for my aging tired mind, I prefer podcasts that run less than an hour. After working all day I simply don’t have it in me to listen much longer that. Regardless, Rev Left remains one of very few that holds my attention and I thank you for that.

Dakota

Hey Breht! I've been an avid listener since 2017, and I'm always interested to see what new, interesting directions you've taken the show in, over the years. I definitely would appreciate some more essay syle episodes, like of the Buddhism and Marxism lecture. However, I don't think the interview format, when done well neccesarily is oversaturated. What's oversaturated is bad interviews with uninteresting people, and you manage to always have insightful questions for consistently great guests. That said, I do think you could maybe try working around loose themes? You and Alison could cover a text, and then have an interview and/or an essay episode that is in some way related to that topic. If we're looking at, for example, your recent episode on the 18th Brumiare, that might be followed up with an interview with an expert on that period of french history, or with an essay episode tying Marx's analytical insights to contemporary political situations. I think if your goal is to distinguish Rev Left more, then keeping to loose themes like that might be worthwhile? Keep up the good work, and don't burn yourself out too much! ps. I'd kill for an epsiode, Rev Left, or Red Menace, about Leslie Feinberg and their book Transgender Warriors. Feinberg did a lot to bring Marxist analysis to trans and queer issues, and I think more comrades should familiarize themselves with their contributions. Especially given the current political climate.

maeva

i’ve loved everything you’ve put out on rev left; interviews, text breakdowns, anything you do with alyson, current events, long rants, etc. so i’m just excited for whatever you’ll put out next! tbh even if you started doing political movie analysis’s on stuff like dune 2 id be locked in hahah

maeva

also side note- i’m currently subscribed to both red menace and rev left,, but if everything from red menace will get published here, should i just keep this one? because i want to support both you and alyson,, but does she only get paid from red menace funds?

Keelan Swift

I have also been wondering about subbing to RM again for this reason! And I’d love some political analysis of Dune 2. What a film.

Dakota

count me in on also wanting to hear Breht's takes on Dune 2

Breakerofchains

I’d honestly say the monologue type episodes are for sure a good idea but it might be even be better as a teaching style episode. I do agree interviews are over saturated and should only be done if they are very entertaining and high quality. So like 2 eps a month doing a teaching/monologue style episode, 1 current events and maybe the last could be a free episode so maybe it could be another current events one or a very good interview or miscellaneous book talk or essay or something of that sort or even another teaching/ monologue style one for a total of 4 eps

Ian Stockdale

My only comment/concern is that I hope this change won't affect your Dialectics Deep Dive series because I'm heavily invested in it at this point. Also, thanks for paying attention to Tucker Carlson etc. because it's important but I certainly don't have the patience to do so.

Josh Ruston

I think it was marshal macluhan that paralleled the release of technology on populations to carpet bombing an area and not really being able to know the true effects of it until much later… yeah, we’re the test subjects for sure… side note! I don’t know if you’ve ever listened to desaparecidos but they have a song called “greater Omaha” and you pop in my head every time I listen… you’d love their music though (the left is right has been my top listened to song for years in a row)

Atallah

Didn't realize it until you said so, but yeah 90% of the podcasts I listen to are interview style. Variability in quality aside (i think rev left interviews are done well), i think the main difference is the ability to convey a clear message. Sometimes I'll listen to a two hour interview but not really walk away with 2 hours worth of understanding on that topic. I've loved your monologues/essays before and I'd personally love to see more essay content! There's more to reflect on and often the structure causes them to stick with me more. There are a few video essayists i follow, but you'd be the first audio essayist!

Mackenzie parvin

I’m taking your advice here . Whenever I have the urge I’m gonna practice Spanish on Duolingo or do guitar

Mackenzie parvin

Lol I went on a date and the new girl I was with said it was an old person thing to ask other people what they thought of dune two .

Mackenzie parvin

Breht i know there’s tons of pods that do things similar but if you maybe take a Marxist lens on books you’ve read , movies you watch etc

Mackenzie parvin

Also as a middle school teacher you should be concerned about there social skills it’s horrifying

spinitch

follow whatever’s inspiring you most in the moment! i love all you do and can’t wait for more

LeftoverComputer

I don't mind the interviews, they might be popular/oversaturated, but yours are still unique. I really like the episodes where you read an article or something and react to it. I also like when you share what books you're reading! Additionally, my favorite episodes are usually the current events type ones - so the "crisis" series you were talking about sounds really interesting to me

LeftoverComputer

When I was kid and I would complain to my dad about being bored, he would say "you're lucky to be bored" and it used to make me mad as a kid but now I think about it and appreciate it a lot lol

Adam

Let Breht speak! I've really enjoyed your episodes where you do monologues on current events. It's always cool to interview an expert for the history, but general positions on things you do a fine job. If I don't agree with all of your points, you articulate them in an agreeable way.

Adam

I uninstalled fucking reddit while listening to this

C S

please please more essays. your essay on buddhism and the left changed my life. i can sometimes hear you restrain your analysis to keep the interview flowing but im here for you and your analyses. thanks man

Jordan Sandvig

New patreon member but was just thinking about how your public episodes should be solo and you can do your interviews on patreon, at least that's to say it would be great to hear more solo pods

DC

I'm here for it. Reading the comments, everyone else is too. So, as someone else said, "do you." Fyi, I would voluntarily and anonamously copy edit your essays, if it would be helpful. I'd love to read your written, sharpened words, but if you just plan to release them as audio, that's cool too.

John

There’s a lot of value in the interviews you do with people that aren’t platformed much. With that being said, your own analysis and essays would be a great pod as well. Finding what works best for you and your life is still important. Excited to see what this venture in expanding the pod will be.

Hunterchuck

The AI putting Hitler in English made him sound like a good guy that's got my back.

Rev Left Radio

1) Very fair points. I certainly think it has a role to play in our efforts all around. But as you said, it must be used consciously, not compulsively, and for our collective ends, not for personal egoism. In general, its a good idea to at least reorient your relationship to it such that it is healthy and takes a reasonable and proportional place in your life. The addictive, compulsive, time-destroying elements of it are what I am wary of. 2) I agree, and far from never doing interviews, I think I just want them to be in the mix with RM eps and monologue eps, that way we hopefully can get the best of all formats and have variety to boot! 3) You are absolutely correct here. In fact, we have an ep on Haiti and Cuba coming from members of Hood Communist and BAP who went to Cuba and who are organizing against the colonization and imperial narratives aimed at Haiti! That aspect has always been a part of the show, but you are correct, I can def do it more often and highlight those struggles even more! 4) Great point here as well my friend. I will definitely try to do more of this, and have even thought of doing a series of such eps for the monologue style essay eps I was talking about! Thanks for all this wonderful feedback and for your continued support of me and the show. It really means a lot.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for this valuable feedback! I take it to heart and agree with you. IF I do read written essays on air, I will keep in mind the need to infuse it with a speaking style is more accessible and engaging than mere reading...

Rev Left Radio

Thats a fair point haha! The monologue essays would be less ranty than patreon eps fwiw! But yes, you make a important point and I will keep it in mind!

Rev Left Radio

Damn Keelan, thank you for those kind words. It really means the world to me to hear that our shows have been so useful for you. Thank you for your long standing support of me and our shows. <3 Thank you for the feedback as well. I almost forgot about that Zinn reading I did back in the day haha. I loved that. Ill def try to always keep things fresh and varied! I have made a full recovery from the crash lmao as has everyone else (except Julian... hes still a little banged up.. XD)

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Andrew. I really appreciate that, as well as your support.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for this feedback!! I appreciate your support deeply.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Felisha, that truly means a lot to me. I appreciate it deeply.

Rev Left Radio

haha thank you Tiffani, I hope so too! I want warmer relations with my neighbors! One of the best compliments I could ever receive is that someone got more deeply into Buddhism and meditation in part because of our work. So thank you so much, and I wish you the best on your continued spiritual journey.

Rev Left Radio

I will definitely continue trying to sprinkle in shorter episodes and monologue style eps tend to be in that 45-60 min range! In any case, I think a variety of episode styles seems to be the consensus and the most fun for me as well! Casting a wide net and having all types of eps seems best.

Rev Left Radio

Your point about loose themes is a GREAT idea! I will def keep that in mind going forward. I have not heard of Feinberg or that book, but will look it up right now and put it on the list!!! Thank you.

Rev Left Radio

haha thank you so much for your support! An episode with Alyson and I on AI, consciousness, Nature, and silicon Valley coming soon! ;)

Rev Left Radio

Great idea, the variety is, I think, where I wanna go. Having a little bit of everything every month!

Rev Left Radio

We are recording another DDD ep this weekend! Glad you like them so much and thank you for the feedback and support!

Rev Left Radio

haha YES, I have been a fan since I was a teen, even went to a Desaparecidos concert once (it was GREAT). I remember listening to Greater Omaha when I lived in Montana at the age of 17! Almost two decades ago at this point. I was and still am a huge Saddlecreek fan, as that is Omaha's contribution to the world of music during my lifetime. It has left a permenent mark on me and I now get to introduce my kids to all that stuff as well, and they like it!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutety! AS a father and future teacher and human being, I am very concerned about social media's impact on the development of younger people whove never known a world without a million screens

Rev Left Radio

haha as a father I find myself saying things to my kids that I as a kid rolled my eyes at lol. Funny how things come around like that! But yes, boredom is generative and young people today should have to experience it from time to time!

Mackenzie parvin

I think you’ll be a great teacher I just am sad cause I can’t imagine the same output in rev left and shoeless . . Also I’d advice you to maybe hide the pod you talk about communism . I’ve gotten in a little controversy for posting very generic anti war stuff on IG and I’m in Cali .

Rev Left Radio

I relate to that deeply. Comparing your behind-the-scenes to a infinite array of stranger's highlight reels creates real suffering and low self worth. Struggling financially, as I do, and seeing the obscene display of money by dumbass YT influencers and twitch streamers and shitty rappers really impacts me on a subconscious level. I feel bitter about having to not be able to afford healthcare while some 19 year old dipshit who makes videos for 8 year olds rakes in millions of dollars... I too long for a bygone era of no-internet. I sometimes think it would be so helpful if a solar flare took out the internet for a year and people had that time to connect and reflect on this tech and what its doing to us. Thank you so much for the kind words tho and your LONGstanding support of the show. Means teh world to me. <3

Rev Left Radio

Thank you!! haha yes, I sometimes do have to restrain myself in order to give the guest the space they deserve. Ill def mix it up and bring a little bit of everything to future eps!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much for the support Jordan, and the feedback. My only concern w putting interviews behind the paywall is that it makes the guest unable to share it with people in their lives and reduces the amount of people who hear it! But in any case, I will commit to doing a wider variety of show types, including monologue essay style eps!

alli

I loved the section where you break down some books you’re currently reading. i just got a library card and am checking out digital minimalism, would love to get more of your recommendations! as far as episode suggestions, i really loved the collab you did with Left of Projector and would definitely enjoy more marxist media analysis. I had never watched Solaris but heard a lot about it, I enjoyed watching it on my own and then hearing your thoughts on it. thanks for all the hard work you do :)

TheCatMan

Thank you Breht, would love to hear more of your personal analysis, but if there's one person I'd want more interviews of it's definitely Matthew Furlong. I've been on a philosophy kick for months but nothing else seems as easy to grasp for a high school drop out like me than your work together.

Noah_Schu

I always appreciate your rawness on these episodes, Breht. Thanks for your sentiments on social media addiction. Idk how long I’ve been telling myself I need to develop my discipline around my phone usage. I definitely felt called out at the pulling your phone out at a stop light comment lmao it’s funny but also damn, the attention economy has got me down BAD! lol Also love that you have a guilty pleasure of engaging the intellectual work of reactionaries and libs. I listened to the Jordan Peterson and destiny conversation recently and was thinking about what some of your retorts might’ve been. Appreciate your contributions to the podcast world man! Be well!

Daewoo

I'm waaay late on this one, as I often am, but I still want to give my thoughts. Anything you do Breht, as long as it is principled as you have been since I started listening a couple years ago, will be worth listening to. I appreciate the interviews that aren't focused primarily on marxism. The way you connect it back to marxism is good though. The ASU speech you recorded for us to listen to was amazing, and a great listen. The care you took crafting the speech was apparent and your reading was great. If you were to focus more on your own thoughts, as well-written and reasoned and agreeable as they would be, I could see an echo chamber forming. You arguing with a Sam Harris podcast or whatever the hell else is enjoyable too. And the Dialectics Deep Dive series is probably your best series rn. I personally would wish for more film discussion as that's a special interest of mine, but that's also selfish and overdone. I need to hear your thoughts on how Nolan dealt with communism in Oppenheimer. Have you seen Come and See yet? I think you should examine is the settler question in the United States more often, deeper, and from more aspects. Fuck it, start attacking the breadtubers. I wanna see you take Atun-Shei (who I enjoy) down a peg or two. I hope podcasting hasn't lost it's spark for you Breht. I worry with the departure from Guerrilla History (as amicable as it was) and now a desire to test out new things, with the already busy schedule you have returning to school for teaching, that the coda of RevLeft could be approaching. I don't want to be a doomer, but it's natural for things to run their course and come to an end. Probably just my own personal paranoia of seeing other media I've been a fan of close down a lot recently. Love and solidarity.

Daewoo

About social media. I find it both disgusting and incredibly important. And those combine to make me insane. I see the slaughter of human beings, then I see mock drafts for the upcoming football season, then I see slightly funny post, then screenshots of footage of police murdering a teenage kidnapping victim, then an informative post about a piece of media I enjoy, then more slaughter by my own government, then the funniest thing I've ever seen in my whole life, then a celebrity I'm a fan of says racist shit. It's all rotten and makes me more rotten, but I want to know all of it. Cycling through all the emotions at an ever increasing pace is totally not healthy and I can see these repeated cycles causing long-term damage that could result in emotionally debilitating mental illness.

Ed W

Hi. Thanks for asking for our opinion on podcast formats. I personally highly value the interviews. I've learned and been exposed to a lot through them, and am thankful for that. I also very much appreciate their non-sectarian nature. I don't listen to many other interview podcasts because either the content or themes are boring (not useful) or ill-informed, or the interviewers are too hyperbolic or juvenile. I don't much like the monologues (or monologues in general), but perhaps would more if they were scripted (though, honestly, I'd generally prefer to read an essay than hear somebody recite it - so if you also posted your essays maybe this listener would be happy). Another option might be to have different folks interview YOU on various topics. I also like that the interview format can break things up (compared to a monologue) and can inject curiosity and the possibility for co-creation and nuance. My 2 cents. Thanks again for all you've offered.

Something Occidental

Love the idea about more long form essay style episodes. I've enjoyed every time you've done something like that, and while I really enjoy learning about new things from your guests, I definitely would look forward to more of your thoughts. I don't listen to lots of pods, so I don't feel the interview saturation. But I still would prefer the change. Especially like to hear about what you're reading. Thanks for all you do, and for including us!

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Im a teacher too. The simple solution is don’t add colleagues, especially bosses or don’t have social media altogether. If you must have it, keep it private or behind an alias.

Nik Arnoldi

I’ve always admired your work and principled stance on all subjects. I think there is something strong there, especially understanding that if something is free, then your attention is probably the commodity. I want to share with the community that I just lost my job after a student said “UN is funded by Hamas” and I told him that was untrue and that they should share their information sources with me.

Nik Arnoldi

I strongly agree with that. Also, keep your support on the DL until you develop some strong. union connections. It’s not hard to get the ax for saying the wrong thing.

Mackenzie parvin

Despite what Fox News says most teachers especially those over about 40 are conservatives

Josh Ruston

Ahh man I’m jumping on late with this but it just jumped possessed my brain… Todd McGowan wrote a book recently “enjoyment left and right” that I think you’d love and I think is particularly relevant now… his books do tend to be pricey but I’d be happy to buy you a copy.

Clint Blakely

+1 support of more essays. I got so much out of the ep on Buddhism & Marxism — listened to it many times. It’s like you have a sixth sense for knowing exactly what I want to hear about, so please talk about whatever’s on your mind!

Dave Miles

Greetings from the Imperial Fringes😹 Mate, I’m behind you with whatever you’re going to do- but don’t throw the interview format out completely. I’m still trying to line up a brilliant speaker from the First People of so-called “Australia” who is keen to tell their story to the world. And RevLeft is the best platform for that. Love and Solidarity from Naarm (Melbourne)

T

The new direction you described at the beginning sounds really promising! I like the segment on what you've been reading as well, thanks for the episode

Benny Boy

Hi late to the party here ... I like the interview format and feel you are very good at it. However, I also find your personal views insightful and you are excellent at making complex ideas accessible and understandable. A 50/50 split of interviews and the essay format would be preferable for me, rather than a 67/33 split in favour of the essay form. You may know this already but Chris Hedges does a similar thing on his podcast. Finally, occasional but regular episodes on the practical and pragmatic aspects and ways of getting involved in the political sphere from you and Allison together would be good (and may perhaps provide some evolution, though you may have done this previously)

SprocketMusic

I love the idea of scripted, nuanced, deep analytical solo episodes, but I think you are drastically underestimating how important your interviews are. Rev Left really helped me get grounded on issues I'd have otherwise ignored, and the interview format made that possible. Maybe today it's an author of a book I've already read. Maybe tomorrow it's organizers from a faction that I'd never heard of in a country that I know relatively little about. The barrage of perspectives not only amplifies these voices in individual episodes, it conveys broadly how far-reaching the tendrils of U.S. imperialism are, how much there is to learn, and how humble we must all be in our pursuit of liberatory knowledge since there's no way any singular person could become an expert in every class conflict in the entire world.

Eric Ripa

What really brought me into the Patreon was connecting with the human side of your analytics episodes regarding Palestine. I really enjoy the long form conversations, and I think there is room for more “polished” and scripted versions of this format for the regular feed. With that said I have also loved the interview episodes, I think that is a great way to help people find new people and voices, and hopefully also help more people engage with the local communities if the guest is closer to them. I don’t know if you consider the conversation like episodes as interviews (say the anarchospiritualism episode), but those are also great because it allows you and your guest to venture out on tangents instead of sticking with a question/answer type interview. Anyway, I guess I’m say I like it all! :)

Chase

I think that’s a great idea for the direction of rev left

Jon Silver

Love your commentary episodes Breht!