Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this patreon exclusive episode, Breht reads and responds to a long ass article from American Affairs, written by Alex Hochuli, on the failures of the millennial left in the US and around the world over the past 10-15 years, titled "Omelets with Eggshells: On the Failure of the Millennial Left".

Read the full article here: https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2024/02/omelets-with-eggshells-on-the-failure-of-the-millennial-left/

Files

Comments

Jo Vinova

"🤮....I want power babyyyyy 😏" only 10 minutes in and I'm reminded why I love Breht's commentary on texts lol

Matt Pierce

Sean and Andy interviewed Cutrone on The Antifada. Interesting listen but he's more interesting descriptively than prescriptively.

Rev Left Radio

Oh nice, ill have to check that one out. Love Sean and Andy.

Isaac Matthew

Great commentary, always helps on a long work day. Vincent Bevins was interviewed on True Anon, he's definitely becoming sympathetic to leninism. Best part was you reacting to them mentioning hong kong and the hunger games symbol 😭

d

Excellent episode, thank you for going over this

Jo Vinova

Speaking on the role of leadership in movements, that's something I've thought about a lot this past year or two. There is a diminishing quality of life of the working class due to the continually increasing gap in income inequality, among other factors, due to the greed corporate elites. As their greed drives them to become more daring in their accumulation of wealth, they move closer and closer to a point where the masses will mobilize in opposition. We're seeing this currently with many movements rising these past few years and an increase in the counciousness of the working class. As stated in this episode and the episode with BRG, the right is organizing. I feel we are at a point where organizing within our circles is crucial if we have not done so already and we should not wait on leaders to appear. We have to become the leaders. We have to start organizing. Organization, leadership, and education is in demand. We must supply it.

Brant

Nice to know we're the same age, and also that I'm not the only one who despised that article.

Gabriel Alvarado

Exactly, we need to start developing leaders, similar to how the right does, without their reactionary ideals. I’ve thought we should copy some aspects of how the right organizes and develops orgs and so on, especially at the grassroots level, but make even more clear our goals and values. So that way we aren’t tailing reaction and even bring too light what the right is incapable of doing and how bankrupt it’s goals are. We essentially need a “project 2025”. Let me know what you think, I could be walking the line of revision, so I like to invite criticism

Gabriel Alvarado

I’ve even took it upon myself to start taking communication classes and leadership classes to develop my capacity to potentially be a leader, if need be. We need to start our own leadership and communication classes, and bring in the next generation and those who share the same or very similar values and ideas as us but not dogmatically of course

Bill

That was a lot to take in and digest, but your commentary truly helped. Thank you. The article sites many shortcoming of the « Left » that I’m certain many of us are already well aware. Certainly Hochuli articulates these complaints well in this brilliant essay. However, while the criticism is appreciated, I don’t see failure. I truly don’t. Particularly not with the Millennial Left. What I see is dialectics at play. And in dialectics there really is no marked line in the sand success or failure- but instead, merely, a change in trajectory (and in that itself, perhaps, the best marker of progress). What I have seen in the last 15 years, without a doubt, is a change in trajectory- as a result of of the Left’s response to all prominent issues stemming from capitalism- from the Great Recession, to the failures of neoliberalism, to climate change, to prison/police fascism/racism, to techno feudalism, to resurgent right wing nuttery, to ongoing worker alienation/displacement, to the housing crisis, to the Palestinian genocide. The millennial left has been fighting a multi-level, multi-facetated, multi-front war- and in my opinion, winning at changing the trajectory of history, of opinion, of political power, and of language. These wins may not be blatantly political, but they are cultural and social- and perhaps this is the middle way to ultimately gaining power. Sure there is more work to be done, but think about what HAS been achieved- we had a socialist presidential candidate, the language of Occupy stuck, BLM became mainstream for better or for worse, there are pro-Palestinian protests that are striking fear in the Democratic elite, our cultural relationship with work has changed dramatically post-Covid, minimalism and anticonsumerism are on the rise, patriarchal religion is dying, we have wonderful Marxist podcasts, new Socialistic journals, a rising big tent DSA, and on a micro level thanks to social media and the internet, I have access to many other like-minded people that 20 years ago would be impossible for me to know. So while the challenges seem insurmountable and the reactionary/fascist response to the swift dialectical trajectory change appears brutal, I truly believe we have had successes and that we are on the winning side. Patience, hope, and solidarity.

Flynnit

There's a anti-capitalist mindset coming up, we need to concentrate it because the mindset is changing and is growing but it is not focused and we need to make it more focused and sharpen it

Derek

I am admittedly speaking on an area I've only read like 2 books on, but when you think about the Bolsheviks and the initial slogans they seized power on, it gives me pause about whether it's even possible to come to power in a world dominated by reaction without a certain amount of opportunism. I mean, my read is that Land to the Peasants was less about some purist socialist principle than it was the fact that it's already what peasants were taking into their own hands. Meanwhile it reinforced petty bourgeois attitudes and accumulation and so enhanced those contradictions. Similarly, Power to the Soviets was more because those institutions had some popular legitimacy than because they had previously been central in any way to Bolshevik ideology. Right? At least that's the sense I've gotten. As someone who cares deeply about being principled and truthful, I find these issues really challenging and I think about them a lot. How much do you have to water down your propaganda in order to be palatable to the masses? And at what point do you cross the line into just playing dirty politics like everyone else? And is it possible to build a just system while copying unjust tactics? These things I keep wrestling with and have no clear answers. I only know that it's not in my heart to pull the wool over people's eyes and seek power at any cost.

Derek

...and I strongly suspect that any vanguard party that seizes power before it has achieved true majoritarian support (the Bolsheviks only had it in what, a city or two?) will quickly find that their dictatorship of the proletariat will have to turn pretty authoritarian and minoritarian in order to keep power.

Jo Vinova

It could be useful to analyze how the right organizes, but the right and anti-capitalist/anti-imperialist left are fundamentally different in who they serve. Their resources differ because of that so I would assume not much of the right's organizing tools would transfer to our organizing. And oh jeeze this is the first time I'm hearing of "Project 2025" and after looking it up I want to chalk that up as conservative elites milking their base for funds while feeding them more propaganda with the book they are selling and the subscription on-demand classes. Which actually reminds me of a Tiktok I saw of someone making like a anti-capitalist degree syllabus outline of like what classes would be taught. Also reminds me of the Spotify playlist "So You Haven't Radicalized Yet" which actually has RevLeft episodes. Also cool to see you taking those classes man! I just organized a movie night last weekend to watch 5 Broken Cameras with some family and friends which was received pretty well! We're doing a book next.

Spence

In response to your asking for our opinions on your opinions, I agree with most everything. But I must admit that I am concerned not that the millennial left made an error in pursuing horizontalist models, but the fact that organized models have become so deeply unpopular in the western psyche, and that the fetishization of the individual is so pervasive, that I don't know that it can be overcome to create a mass line. I am worried that we are stuck in a sort of "you first" revolutionary pesimism. A billion people spread across the world waiting for Lenin. And because that horizon is so disappointing, I don't see an option other than local harm reduction, thus looping me back into more horizontal organizations despite wanting more. All of this is to say that we are in such a pre-revoluntionary period that discussing revolution is probably detrimental. For Lenin to declare "all power to the Soviets" there had to be Soviets. So should we be more focused on building Soviets than building a communist party?

Jacob Bucci

Bungacast is pretty decent if a bit cranky, I just write it off as them being British. They punch left from the left better than most, a few times they’ve interviewed people from the Trotskyist/neocon pipeline and then roasted them in the after interview debrief which I found funny.

Michael Xin

Speaking of Hong Kong, I was in uni at the time in the UK and Hong Kong students were organising for the protests. They wanted to construct what I misheard as a "Lenin Wall". When I asked them some more questions about Vladimir Lenin, they looked at me quizzically and asked what some Russian had to do with the Singer-songwriter. They were making a John Lennon tribute, and had no interest in actual revolutionaries. Now that I look back on it Hong Kong Protests were certainly a colour revolution organized by an amateurish, ignorant, and infantile bunch of liberals, who seemingly wanted HK to join the NATO west! The protests sprouted from economic realities, yet the loudest voices were making completely alien demands for liberal democracy.

Rev Left Radio

These are all great points, especially your point about dialectics and how nothing in that framework is truly a failure. I think you grasp dialectics better than the author, and your analysis shows it. I agree with your take. Within every ostensible "failure" are kernels of success that can and should be appreciated and advanced. Any future successes will ultimately grow out of these ostensible "failures". This dialectical apprehension of change is spot on.

Rev Left Radio

These are crucial strategic questions, absolutely. We can see the error of purity politics that alienates the masses and fosters needless sectarianism, but we can also see the error of rightist opportunism, deceiving people, etc. As the Buddha reminds us, we must seek the middle way (The Marxist Center, if you will), wherein our core values and principles are front and center and made clear, but our tactical approach is flexible and takes seriously the actual historical, cultural, and ideological conditions that we find ourselves in. Neither ultra-left dogmatism and sub-culturalism, nor right wing tailism and dilution!

Rev Left Radio

maybe I will do a monologue essay ep trying to wrestle with these ideas, cuz you really put your finger on something essential here.

Rev Left Radio

Hm, really interesting stuff here... Ill have to ponder this for a while. I think the problem you are centering really is under-appreciated. Basically is an argument for base-building as a necessary premise from which to build a vanguard party, which I think I actually agree with.

Rev Left Radio

LMAO wow that Lennon-not-lenin thing was always a joke for me; to know that it actually happened is wild lol... I agree, Hong Kong Protesters were a sort of color rev formation, made up mostly of radlib student types with no real buy-in from the masses. The US LOVES when such movements begin to rise so they can bolster them in every way imaginable. the fact that these protests were included in this article was the first thing that made me skeptical of some of this analysis.

Liv

Highly recommend If We Burn! Your commentary on this article and the book dovetail so well together! Both make clear how historically and contextually uninformed we are in using the same failing tactics of 2010-2014 mobilizations. As a young person who wants to organize successfully and different than ‘the left’, these kinds of conversations are so vital to learning purpose, stake, and impact. The part about ‘horizontalism leading to tyrannical clique leadership’ really hit home with me and shows how important it is to step away from the activist echo chambers and actually touching down with neighbors and your immediate community. Thanks as always!

Spence

Thanks for the response! So, for example of something that I think looks something like a base, my wife works for an indigenous non-profit organization in Canada that is a coalition of others across other cities called Native Friendship Centers. It is one of the largest employers in my small city- hundreds of employees across several departments and dozens of sub-departments. They do everything from childcare, to youth programs, to financing new public housing, to funding indigenous arts, and even to anti-colonial political education workshops. It is an indigenous organization, but its workers and leaders include all kinds of people. What it is is a hierarchical mutual aid organization, with more working class power than the Communist Party of Canada (of which I'm a member) could ever dream of. What it lacks is a greater political horizon. To play devil's advocate, these orgs are also heavily subsidized by our social-democratic party in power, which is of course ultimately capital serving and under the thumb of the Canadian state and finance. Even so, being from the US I have also never in my life seen real, tangible socdem gains and structures like I've seen in British Columbia, despite its many problems. In a deep irony, the closest thing to the organization of the Native Friendship Centers that I saw in the US was actually my time in the Army. Anyway, I think American communists may be interested to learn about these large, powerful organizations. "All power to the native friendship centers!"

she's all rat

The thing I always grapple with is, the West has marxist-leninist parties, with room for improvement for sure, but they exist. We need organization, education, structure, discipline, and it seems more reasonable to be part of ML parties that already exist with this framework, and to build/hone that, than to reinvent the wheel. But they've been deeply unpopular for decades and I can't see that changing, as someone else commented, because of the choke hold horizontalist, rad lib mentality has on the struggle. An injection of Maoist mass line work also wouldn't hurt. But it feels like the existing party structure is the fastest and simplest route we can take to gaining the experience and the positions we require, despite how much they currently leave to be desired.

Big Nasty

Thank you for sharing this

Derek

That would be amazing! On that note, I am really excited about the new direction for RLR. For me, it's not so much that interview shows are overdone, but that I think you can provide something needed and valuable that not a ton can right now: namely, the distillation of theoretical and practical concepts in a way that a generally intelligent person can follow. A lot of socialist stuff is so wonky or it's dated and very challenging to wrestle with contextually. I'm excited to learn and grow from your attempts to systematize some of your current thinking, as I still have serious questions around my own ideological commitments. Don't get me wrong, I've been convinced that capitalism is anti-human for decades. But when it comes to exactly what should replace it and how, I still often feel some disillusionment there as well. Not least because it's blatantly obvious that a typical revolutionary moment is a bloody and unpredictable set of events that is bound to end up so far from where it started. Even my experience in the #RedforEd movement in AZ (hardly socialist or revolutionary!) showed me up close how little the typical participant in a mass movement really understands what they're fighting for or what they want. It's often more of an emotional gestalt of something like, "I'm being taken advantage of and I'm mad as hell and ready to do something!" I think it's a bit hubristic to think we can aim and unleash those volcanic forces and expect to remain in control, although others have managed to certain degrees. Then again, often at the expense of civil war, along with the consequent further bloodshed, rape, famine, etc. The horsemen of the apocalypse often ride with revolution! 😜

Derek

Curious, would the PSL be a more recent example of this, in your view?

she's all rat

I don't know enough about PSL, but I was really just thinking about the classic "communist party of _____ (insert western nation)" type parties. The ones that have that 20th century heritage. I know there are issues and criticisms, but I can't help but think, why throw the baby out with the bath water if we agree on and need a leninist approach? I dunno I think I just get so burnt out on how many parties there are, the splintering, the in fighting. It's our only fucking forté 🫠

Brett

Excellent episode. This is Rev Left at its best, dissecting a deep and thoughtful essay that I agree maybe 90-95% with but adding in the “Revolutionary Left” perspective that is vitally missing

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Brett. I really appreciate your support and this feedback. So grateful that you enjoy this sort of episode.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I def need to read that and have Bevins on the show sometime tbh. I am so glad this episode resonated with you, my friend. Thank you as well for the support of the show. It means the world to me. <3

Rev Left Radio

I agree that joining and making better existing orgs is superior to re-inventing a million micro-orgs. Absolutely great point. I should have made that clear in the ep. Joining an existing party or org and helping to grow it is the right move.

Breakerofchains

The point about how there needs to be a democrat running like Trump did on the Republican side to actually win is spot on! But just to add to that: I unfortunately don’t that person will ever get far, at least not anyyyy time soon. Because if there’s one real difference between Dems and repubs, it’s presentation. (As we all know) Repubs are less refined so it was much much easier for someone like Trump to bulldoze through and do what he did. Once Dems stop pretending to be morally superior then this can actually happen 👀

Foko

Absolutely wonderful analysis, Breht -- these are my favourite kind of patreon episodes; not necessarily centered around an article but rather using your deep knowledge of history and theory to expound on a real contemporary strategic problem facing the revolutionary left today. I haven't read this since my early 20s, but remember really liking "The Tyranny of Structurelessness", an essay published in 1970 by Jo Freeman, a feminist activist from the southern US. I remember the essay being a general overview/critique of the exact sort of horizontalist approach we see so often today, but then ending with an actual plan for how to more effectively organize political decision-making power within a movement. It was refreshing and clarifying to read, coming out of Occupy in particular, and I wonder if it might still have some lessons to offer today. Here's a link: https://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm Thank you again!

Mexican Stalin

The problem with criticizing the millennial left is that even Lenin himself wouldn't be able to launch a revolution with the material conditions we live in. In past revolutions revolutionaries could send their comrades to help village 1 with medical needs and use the relationships they created in that village to help village 2 that was starving connecting both of them into a larger community. Nowadays our problems are too big and complex to deal with how are we Marxist supposed to help poor people who need medicine or who are drowning in student debt or homeless. Capitalists bureaucracy is the reason modern day revolutions fail at least in the West we would need highly educated certified comrades who could navigate the bureaucracy to provide assistance to the proletariat we would need comrade doctors who could diagnose and treat people and write them prescriptions in a movement big enough to help them buy that medicine and to buy buildings to house the homeless a movement big enough to build credit unions to give Fair loans to people to pay off their student or medical debt this takes millions of dollars that only groups like the Democrats could muster. In conclusion the material conditions for revolution at least in the West do not exist the best we could hope for is Democratic socialist who could ease the pain temporarily. Ps. sorry for the long response and poor grammar this is just my analysis I could be totally wrong.

Andrew Blake

I don't like the dismissiveness of Marxist left basically from jump, nor the omission of any discussion about the huge influence of propaganda in incapacitating entire generations of potential revolutionaries. Other than that the article was pretty solid. After your BRG2 ep I'm wondering if our best bet might not be trying to take over DSA and turn it into a vanguard party. Long shot for sure but they have Marxist caucuses already and there's no other real option for getting organized on a mass scale. Maybe regional tenant unions?

Andrew Blake

CPUSA is notoriously revisionist and had been basically radlib since WWII... been in the news recently as well for their liberal shenanigans. Last ep with BRG he made a strong case for joining one of the Marxist caucuses in DSA... has me strongly considering it

LM

Hey Breht! I'm here because in this ep you asked for information on the Platypus Affiliated Society/Chris Cutrone in the comments. I'm not a member and can't speak on their behalf, but I can share a relevant anecdote. I'm a member of a Maoist org in Chicago. We recently hosted a movie night centered around some of the New Left anti-imperialist movements and the lessons we can draw from them. Some folks from Platypus attended and contributed to our post-screening discussion. Afterward, they invited our org to participate in an international convention they held at the University of Chicago this past weekend, which we accepted. One of my comrades actually ended up speaking on a panel with four other people, including Cutrone. I will say, our interactions with the Platypus members who invited us were positive and our invitation was undoubtedly offered in good faith. In their invitation to us, they made clear that "the speakers are representative of different tendencies on the left we want to put into conversation" and that they would "welcome any and all criticism of Platypus itself." I was unfortunately unable to go to the event, but according to my comrades who did attend, it was largely comprised of white men with vague anti-Stalin sentiments, apathy toward internationalism, and a confusion of what socialism means. My comrade summed up Platypus as "giving primacy to nonsense ideas of left politics that boil down to the intrigue of competing ideas, and taking no interest in scientific understandings of socialism, capitalism, or functional practices for overcoming capitalism in a globally applicable way". Cutrone in particular presented some especially bad takes, such as "anti-imperialism is no excuse for anti-americanism" and "the benefits of american life do not come at the expense of the third world". I was previously familiar with him from his interview on the Antifada podcast (mentioned by another commenter as well), where I recall he expressed admiration for Thomas Jefferson. He also spouted off some zionist apologism on another podcast recently and is quite vocally anti-Hamas. Tbh, I think he is kinda a piece of shit. Anyway, thank you for the episode. I listened to it with my partner while we drove from Milwaukee back to Chicago and we both found it very relevant and inspiring. Love & solidarity!

Yohance

I think talk of a missing revolution in the 2010s is more accurate than a failure of the millennial left. The massive labour mobilisations post-covid show that we’ve already adapted tactics somewhat, and trade union consciousness is definitely an advance on horizontalism even though it has its own issues and limits. I’d even argue the Palestine solidarity movement shows an increased understanding of primary and secondary contradictions among the average leftist.

Jacob Wilson

Hi Breht! You'd asked for more information on transitions in the US & Global economy into and through the neoliberal period, and I came to highly recommend "The Making of Global Capitalism" by Leo Panitch and Sam Gindin. It's an excellent accounting of the transformations of the political economy of US hegemony.

Luke

Hi Breht, here's an episode of this is revolution with Hutchuli (sp?) https://www.youtube.com/live/sUIyLa_Ygqc?si=G_tu4ekR4a350JtE His analysis seems fair enough to me but short on solutions. On one hand these failures seem to be exercising political muscles that have long since atrophied under neoliberalism and post modernism if you like, perhaps in the future those muscles can be properly used. I do think that the west will have to go through a protracted decline alongside the rise of an alternative developmental model that is more beneficial for the working class and poor before it can be revolutionary. Multipolarism may have some openings but also will have many closures as well. The co-optation of left values in corporations is particularly disturbing. It can be interpreted as progress in civil norms at best or simply pivoting from monoculture to recognizing subcultures as discreet markets to cultivate. Cultrone, an old Spartasist, is a bit all over the place to me. He does a weekly show on Sublation Media (the Cultrone Zone lol), Doug Lains current iteration of his old show. Recently pretty bad on Gaza imo. He occasionally has profound insights but effectively sounds like the last paragraph of a Trot newspaper denouncing all parties involved and how we need some imaginary perfect vanguard party. Basically makes the left defeatist and depressed by being perfectionists. It is something everyone seems to struggle with walking that line between irrelevant subculturism and incoherent big tentism. Nice work

Tim Fitzgerald

Interesting episode and discussion. Unlike (I'm assuming) most others here, I don't consider myself a Marxist per se, although I certainly acknowledge the contributions of Marx and Engels, Lenin, Mao, and Stalin. In discussions with other revolutionary socialists, I frequently site you, Breht, as the type of principled ML that I respect a great deal. For that reason, I thought I'd share this here, that I posted on social media, in good faith and wondering what your response might be. "What lessons did the USSR experiment teach? It didn't prioritise worker control. It didn't shy away from centralised power and control. It didn't see individual self-determination as a priority, at least in the immediate term. Of course, arguments can be made in defense of strategies used. I sometimes hear MLs say things like "we need to learn from the mistakes of the USSR". I rarely hear an acknowledgement of mistakes. Concerns around centralisation of power, lack of worker control, lack of emphasis on self-determination (even acknowledging that this is secondary to the good of society as a whole), lack of a prioritisation of a credible strategy in pursuit of true communism - all largely met with some form of sneering hostility." The 'sneering hostility' part certainly isn't applicable to RevLeft - much more to terminally online (self-identified) MLs.

Tim Fitzgerald

This was from further discussion: "[It] definitely is hard to say what the USSR could have achieved, and how strategy might have been different [absent external Western pressures]. Similarly, it's hard to know the direction that CPC might take if and when it becomes the dominant global economic power and military power. I appreciate that the CPC doesn't appear interested in taking on a role as global hegemon in the way that Western powers have. But, this could definitely happen by default with continued erosion of Western hegemony, and assuming we don't have catastrophic society-collapsing war during the throes of dying US empire. A critical point here is that we don't know how China will (or how the USSR might have) used more global power one way or the other. I'm skeptical, to say the least, about its use to usher in a less centralised, more worker-controlled mode of governance, with more emphasis on individual self-determination, and increasing priority on lessening of state power towards a stateless society."

Justin Jones

What ep is that? Has me curious as I’ve long written off DSA and am not optimistic about PSL as being able to break through to gain mass support even though I think they are the best bet atm… it seems like maybe exposing more of our ideas in a DSA setting could be a better strategy than just being within a vanguard party that the vast majority view as fringe whackos. A vanguard party seems to be ideal for that rupture but it has to actually be viable first and its viability in modern states I think means much greater numbers or as many as say the social democrats in Europe / Russia in the early 20th

Alex De Marco

Damn this was good. Found myself holding myself accountable. Protesting and organizing and obstructing is an essential part of delegitimizing authority, but planning and executing a real movement and the ultimate advancement of society...that is serious pressure. We need much more thought on a plan and process with the ability of course to adapt to the unexpected. Expectations kill movements. Predicting politics in the U.S. right now is like forecasting weather in the mountains.

lolamortem

I'm egregiously late on this but I really enjoyed this episode. I'd love to see you do more of these article readings. As much as we joke about newspapers on the marxist left, articles still have an important role especially in keeping track of ongoing debates. I'm definitely of the opinion that the left is on the back foot at the moment, more akin to the early days of the worker's movement or at best the couple decades before the formation of the second international. For this reason I share the pessimism around the false hopes of social democracy and leaderless movementism as well as Cosmonaut Mag/Marxist Unity Group's reclamation of the second international and radical republicanism. I'd love to see you engage more with these tendencies as I think they provide some good ideas for how we build a communist movement in societies of bourgeois democracies. And regarding the horizontal/vertical question in organizing I'd recommend Rodrigo Nunes' Neither Vertical Nor Horizontal. I don't know if Bevins mentioned him in his book but Nunes was in Brazil during the protest movement. I really loved the episode you did on cybernetic revolutionaries since it introduced me to cyernetics and I think going deeper into Beer's work would be very helpful and clarifying. I believe his lectures outlining his book Designing Freedom are up on youtube. Lastly a really good second opinion to check out on this article is from C Derrick Varn's show on youtube. He's a really knowledgeable guy especially on this matter. He's known Hochuli, Cutrone, and Jager for years and was in Platypus for a while but he definitely doesn't share Cutrone's weird conservatism. I also bring him up because I think he's be an excellent guest if you'd ever consider it. Thanks again for all you do Breht, you've been central to my political development for nearly a decade.