Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Alyson and Breht wrestle with the possible rise of artificial general intelligence and its implications. Together they discuss the Silicon Valley Techno-Cult and their religious search for immortality, their hubristic attempts to "build god" and escape death, their neoliberal subjectivities and how that manifests in their work, how AI might manifest under the capitalist mode of production, the horrors and contradictions of "capitalism without workers", deflationary critiques of AI, humans as transitional creatures, consciousness and its complexities, intelligence without consciousness (philosophical zombies), Nietzchean nihilism, real religion and what it offers, embracing the inevitability of your own death, and much more!

Files

Comments

Daughters of Delos

Thanks for the program!!! Love the analysis you both bring to your topics. Always your Comrade Across the River

Gaige

Idk if this contributes to the conversation at all but I wanted to mention something about the ability to face death. I think you can almost never guarantee a dignified death. It almost entirely depends on the hand you’re dealt. It would take an extreme person to not panic if they meet their end by not being able to breath that comes on completely out of nowhere. I understand this may be an extreme example in which you were not speaking to, but as someone who saw panic from a very strong person because of a sudden, suffocation style death, I had to make the point. Older people who know death is around the corner, or young people diagnosed with an unbeatable condition have a much easier chance to die with dignity. Ultimately, I’m just trying to say that you could have an understanding and respect for your own mortality and still die with panic. An obvious statement that I know you understand as well but I felt a need to say it. Anyways this conversation was fun to listen to. Solidarity!

SprocketMusic

I have ADHD, and I can say from direct experience with neurotypical people that they have no way whatsoever to conceptualize my form of consciousness, and I can, at best, socially perform well enough to imitate theirs. Even with genetic neurodivergence aside, so many of our cognitive processes are actually patterns shaped by trauma and other direct experiences. I would argue that it's near impossible for one person to even conceptualize what the full range of human consciousness looks like experientially, let alone the perceptive universe of bats and cephalopods and computers.

SprocketMusic

As for death, Fannie Lou Hamer, American civil rights activist, said, "If I fall, I fall five feet four inches forward in the fight for freedom." In this way, I believe we are all immortal because we are all participants in class struggle, and thus, participants in history. Everyone alive is a link between the past and the future - part of a historical continuum - regardless of whether we are remembered or not. The only question is which direction our 5'4" falls in.

Brant

I really appreciate this episode. As a side note, AI is definitely taking away jobs. I just watched 700 people at my company (all the same department) lose their jobs to automation 2 months ago.

Caleb Zerger

For anyone who liked the thoughts on cephalopods there’s a sci-fi novel called “a mountain in the sea” by ray nayler that explores the intersection of cephalopod consciousness, AI, and capitalist exploitation. It’s a fun quick read and pretty well written/interesting check it out!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely valid point. And I do not know how I will die or respond to my death, it was more of a wish than a promise in that regard. But I can absolutely imagine many panic-inducing deaths that I would not be able to face w "dignity", if that is even the right word to use here!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. AI takes many different forms, and it seems inevitable that with enough time, they will make work as we know it obsolete, and throw capitalism into an irresolvable contradiction.

Curtis Carll

Breht, as a buddhist, aren't large language models sort of absurd when talking about human intelligence? Buddhism is so deeply rooted in the training to escape the confines of language, recognizing the language is duality & division, a false representation of reality. And here you have artificial intelligence driven entirely by massive amounts of language, as if language is what makes us human. It does make me wary of what will ultimately pop out of these things but not that it'll be anything like humanity.

Derek

Just wanted to share a progressive use case for AI, cuz I have been reading a lot of Marxist or philosophical or historical texts about domains I have very low familiarity on going in, and so I regularly use Bing's copilot AI to ask things like, "What might Horkheimer and Adorno mean when they say that intellect's true concern is a nullification of reification?" It helped me process dense philosophical concepts quickly when they were so specific they'd be unlikely to turn up in a Google search. 😜

Bill

Super interesting conversation. I really enjoyed and appreciated your intelligent perspectives. They triggered some of my own thoughts: One, on a Buddhist bent, I think it’s important to some extent to avoid dualistic thinking. For example, the tendency to use us vs them arguments. If we emphasize oneness, then « us » and « them » are obsolete as « we » are simply the collective outcome of the universe (define that as you’d like). In this vain, I have little fear of AI. It may simply be the evolution of our universal oneness. My second thought is a little darker : In Marxist thought and philosophy, on the other hand, there is a clear duality at work (perhaps dialectically) where there is a definitive « us » and « them » - It is in this duality that my fear of AI becomes relevant. While I appreciate Alyson’s argument that some fear is overblown, particularly in light of AI’s current capacity, if we take the science out 5,10,50 years, I believe the fear could become more justifiable. Imagine the capacity and the utility of AI at future points where it lies in the hands of delusional capitalists. Isn’t it striking- yet totally expected- that fear of AI is already being stoked? What is the motivation for that stoking? Can AI become a proxy for bad behavior? A scapegoat? Can the denouement of a cold war race for this technology as a means to gain power and control in the name of *national security* cause willful destruction AND be blamed on an AI itself? Can AI also be blamed for a « harsh » (or fascist) resolvement of the climate crisis (imagine the worst here- populations decimated intentionally) . Aren’t tragic outcomes in the name of capitalist progress already part of our ruling class modus operandi? Couldn’t AI take this to the next level when the consumer class/working class becomes obsolete and thus expendable? Think 50 years out where an AI powered robotic technology can serve all the needs of the surviving few. At that point capitalism will no longer be necessary. Marx will be proven right- Socialism will prevail. But suppose it’s a socialism that exists simply to support the extravagancy of the surviving rich? I am acutely aware of how conspiratorial this all sounds, but is it? Is it crazy to believe that delusional capitalists will have no boundaries to what they are capable of inflicting on others to ensure their survival- particularly if they have the scapegoat of AI - all in the name of scientific progress.

Mackenzie parvin

In the Dune universe we killed all the robots after they tried to assert control like 3000 years ago. It’s now punishable by death to kill anything smarter than a calculator .So humans have to do the math to transverse the stars . Kinda new dark ages but in space . I always found this idea Kinda interesting . What if we hit a new dark age .

Mackenzie parvin

Breht i think you’d really enjoy the movie “the Hit “

Foko

i thought about this at my restaurant job yesterday - the payment system went offline for about an hour at the start of the day, so tickets wouldn't send, nobody could pay with their cards, and the manager was freaking out because this basically made the whole restaurant inoperable. it made me think about what even 24 hours of global internet shutdown would do to us -- it would be complete chaos everywhere. part of why i think it's so important to keep ourselves at least partially rooted in the physical world. I don't know if you have ever read the book "everything for everyone" but it is a really fascinating series of fictional interviews with survivors of the global revolution/collapse from the 2030-2060s. they do spend a good amount of time discussing the collapse of the internet during that period of time and the resulting calamity that ensues. i don't like every part of the book but it has plenty of fascinating & thought provoking speculation about the near future that makes it well worth the read.

Mexican Stalin

Intelligence without consciousness. Feels like life right now smart enough to work for money play video games order food but not conscious enough to understand the exploitative system that makes it possible and not conscious enough to change it

Mexican Stalin

It would be hilarious if these billionaires spent all this money on a capitalist AI only to immediately become communist when it gains sentience 🤣

G Z T

As a machine learning guy, sometime critic of the libertarian/fascist robot cult of "Less Wrong", and Orthodox Christian, I just wanted to say you guys did a great job of hitting all the right notes on the things I know about and bringing more insight on the things I don't. I especially appreciated the quick remark at the end about the weirdness going on with far right converts to Orthodox Christianity which I think really hit the nail on the head. I don't know if you've run into the work of Sarah Riccardi-Swartz, but she's a scholar who's been documenting a lot of the weird stuff going on in modern American Orthodox circles.

Rev Left Radio

Great point. I agree. LLMs are not intelligent in any meaningful way. There might be forms of AI that are, but LLMs are not that. I also agree that our tech reflects back to us our already existing paradigms and confusions and premises, many of which are examined and transcended through spiritual practices. But spiritual practices and those who engage in them will always be a minority in any given society. In any case, as humans weathering these storms of technological evolution, traditions like Buddhism absolutely help keep us grounded, in the moment, and focused on real life.

Rev Left Radio

1) Fair points! It may very well be 2) I think we can distinguish between relative truths and absolute truths. in absolute terms, we are all one. In relative terms, we are riven by divisions. But yes, I agree, under capitalism AI will more than likely evolve in a more dystopian way as the system itself is dystopian and cant produce liberating technology without undermining itself historically. I share your fears... 3) I dont think its conspiratorial at all. I think its a legitimate fear and necessitates struggle in the here and now, as well as in the near future. AI will simultaneously create and sharpen fundamental contradictions within capitalism while also being in the hands of the rich and their corporations, thus being used as a bulwark to maintain their positions and the unjust hierarchy that created them.

Rev Left Radio

I love that aspect of Dune. So creative and interesting. Such tech may be a sort of Great Filter cosmologically, forcing intelligent species who develop such power to either kill it or be killed. I do think we will go through more Dark Ages as a species, I jsut dont know when or why...

Rev Left Radio

Foko, great point about staying rooted in teh physical world. I often think of a solar flare or cyber attack or something that brings the whole techno-order down, even temporarily, and what its consequences would be. The less we rely on this tech, the more robust we make ourselves. But our society as a whole seems to be going all in on teh tech...

Rev Left Radio

lmao def!! I even think if Aliens came down to Earth, teh first question I would have is "how do you organize your society?", and how great it would be if every intelligent species higher than us achieved communism and make that very clear lol. OR maybe they wont visit until we mature to that level in teh first place, our rotten class societies being seen as proof of our immaturity and unreadiness for contact!

Rev Left Radio

Wow thank you for this feedback, and it means even more coming from someone with knowledge and experience in this area. Thank you for listening and supporting the show, my friend. I have not heard of Riccardi-Swartz, but will check it out!!

Adam

Hey Breht, I listen to the show "what magic is this?" By a dude, Douglas bachelor. It's broadly about spirituality and the occult. You've been taking up the challenge of synthesizing spirituality and Marxism lately and I think it'd be awesome to hear you two hash some history and ideas out. The occult seems like a dirty concept to most of the left, but I feel like it could be valuable to our movements if we understood it and wrestled with it. He's not overtly political on his show but definitely someone who believes in the great love for humanity. He said he's busy until fall but I was hoping to get some wheels greased for something. Keep up the great work man!

Kaylee & Jacob

Incredible episode and very thought provoking. I have seen myself and many others on the left open up enormously to the religious and spiritual side of life. Breht and Alyson I am dying to know if either of you have heard of the author David Lewis-Williams and his book The Mind in the Cave. If not I would highly suggest looking into his work both in that text and in Inside the Neolithic Mind. I honestly think you would both find it totally fascinating as I do now. He considers himself I believe to be a cognitive anthropologist, and through these works he is attempting to trace back what he argues to be the hard wired cognitive presence of a religious impulse as well as the construction of a tiered cosmology across almost all documented human societies. He traces it back tens of thousands of years using ancient societies and cave art as well as looking at more contemporarly examples across the world.

KungFuKenny

Loved the episode, as always. I found the conversation of religion interesting and thought provoking. Yet, on a personal level, struggle with taking religion seriously in almost any context. As someone who was raised catholic in a conservative community, and I’ve found some of my best comrades over our shared disdain and experiences with religion. As a personal reflection, I grapple daily with the intricacies that weave through our material world. Working in healthcare, especially with young individuals facing disabilities, I'm constantly reminded of the profound impact technology has had in alleviating suffering. Reflecting on this, I'm hopeful for the potential of AI to further advance solutions and address challenges. That said, I dream everyday of what an egalitarian society would do to alleviate poverty and inequality for all, and for those disabled individuals. Love and solidarity!

Irene

I had such a great time listening to this episode. When I studied anthropology in college, we discussed the idea of religiosity being “inherent” in human beings a lot and there are some fascinating takes on it, from neuroscience to cultural anthropology, about the universality of ascribing meaning to phenomena that may or may not be explainable empirically. Anyways, that was over a decade ago so now I’m inspired to find some more current research on the subject. I treasure these conversations between you two and find them valuable, inspiring, and much needed in the world. Thank you!

Francis Fish

I've been professionally writing software for nearly 40 years. Here's my thoughts: 1. LLMs are basically very large predictive text boxes. Instead of just guessing the next word, they can guess whole documents. 2. As a consequence of 1, and this cannot be stressed enough, they are *not* databases. You can ask questions, sure, but there are no facts as such. It will make things up. For example it's been known to cite academic papers which perhaps *should* exist, but don't. 3. Machine learning AI as such now, has things like discriminator functions that can say whether a piece of data is likely to fall in a particular mathematical space. We now have the computing power to make millions of those calculations very quickly. This is where the self-driving car comes from, a very mechanical sifting of data very quickly. There's nothing intelligent about it except the algorithms, and they are an entirely human creation. These machines can drive very successfully in dry conditions in California - and as far as I know nowhere else. To illustrate point 2, the Dilbert creator, Douglas Adams, recently had a "conversation" with ChatGPT where it convinced him of various things. Well, it simply reflected his biases back at him, because of course it did. That's what it does. It's not a conversation, it's selecting the next thing in the predictive text box that your questions tune to your own biases. The other thing about point 2, is the current tech should be nowhere near anything that involves people dying or any kind of life critical decisions. It makes stuff up, and doesn't understand causality. You may have heard the phrase "the operation was a success, but the patient died". This will happen without a lot of safeguards in place and is a really stupid idea. Point 3 - this means that these systems can't improvise in novel situations, which you really don't want when they're in charge of vehicles that weigh several tons and will squash you flat. One AI startup made a system that looked at photographs and tried to identify "criminals". Yes, the fools reinvented phrenology and didn't have the wit to realise. Also ... are you more "criminal" if the photo was taken in dark lighting conditions? Who knows? There's an interesting book called "Weapons of Math Destruction" by Cathy O'Neill that's worth a read. It looks in some detail about how some things in the carceral state have become self-fulfilling prophecies. It discusses the biases of training data really well, if I recall.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for the feedback Irene. Im happy it resonated with you and I appreciate your support

MLDad

How do you know you can imitate their form of consciousness? Howndo you know they can't conceptualize yours? Individual subjective experience is not transmittable, that would be magic. We infer what subjective experience corresponds to a given external behavior pattern we observe in the other, but that's our own thought, not the other's reality.