Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this final iteration of our long-standing series "Dialectics Deep Dive", Matthew Furlong joins Breht to discuss Althusser's essay "Contradiction and Overdetermination" and in the process they discuss many aspects of dialectical materialism and Marxist philosophy.

Check out Part 1 of this episode here: https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/dialectics-deep-dive-iix-contradiction-and-overdetermination-pt-1

Check out all our Dialectics Deep Dive episodes here: https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/size/5/?search=dialectics+deep+dive

Files

Comments

Saya Clarke

So happy to see this! I’ve recently gone back to these episodes alongside reading Fredric Jameson’s book ‘Valences of the Dialectic’ to finally try and get my pea sized brain to genuinely comprehend Hegel and the entire continental philosophy traditions more broadly. Also it’s just lovely to see RevLeft in my feed today. Hope you and your family are well Breht!

Gabriel Alvarado

Love these. Lots of it go over my head but compared to the first episode of the series, it’s become easier to comprehend.

Ian Stockdale

Dear Breht and Matthew, Kudos on another fascinating discussion. While I was somewhat disheartened to hear that it was to be the final installment of the Dialectics Deep Dive series, having gotten a lot out of them, I feel honoured to have my question answered in such a thoughtful, comprehensive way. It was indeed helpful, Matthew, although I must say that I’m much more comfortable with the concept since clutching my pearls back in February. It goes to show, liberal/bourgeois indoctrination is pernicious – often subtly disguised and pervasive – even those of us guarded against it are susceptible. The Alan Watts clip was not only fantastic but, touching as it did on Hamlet’s famous P or -P soliloquy and the divine right theory of kingship, was nothing short of serendipity. You may recall my AMA question regarding Malcolm X and his proposal of James VI&I (King James I of England) as a candidate for the true authorship of the works of Shakespeare. Like you, I’m also a fan of Matt Christman (I hope he’s doing well) and was an avid listener to his Cushvlogs. On two separate occasions, he addressed questions from the chat (not from me) regarding the Shakespeare Authorship Question. The first time he simply dismissed the question with something like ‘Of course Shakespeare was Shakespeare, come on!” The second time he voiced an oft-heard canard: questioning the motives of anyone doubting the author’s identity as, essentially, classist snobbery – that we have a desire to exalt aristocracy as magically imbued with qualities unobtainable to the common person. I can only assume Matt was asserting this, in good faith, from a place of ignorance regarding the details surrounding the Authorship Question generally, and of the fact that Malcolm X was a prominent doubter, particularly. Matt’s reaction was not only ad hominem bullshit, but a typically liberal form of ad hominem bullshit, in that it highjacks our egalitarian impulses in order to dismiss and obscure the truth. Of COURSE the son of an illiterate glove-maker from provincial Stratford-upon-Avon could have produced works of literary transcendence that display mastery of French, Spanish, Italian, Latin and Ancient Greek if, for instance, he had been given an education by a team of tutors led by one of Europe’s foremost scholars of Latin who also happened to be the former tutor to Michel de Montaigne, as James had. There is nothing magic about aristocracy/monarchy, it’s simply a matter of material conditions. I take this issue personally because I actually published a book a number of years ago, entitled “Shakespeare: the King James Version”, wherein I lay out my argument for the candidacy of James VI/I. I would like to send you both a pdf copy of my book. I would have no expectations of anything on your parts, simply a hope that you’d like it (obviously) and that you’d give me whatever feedback you feel like offering (even if you didn’t like it or find it convincing). What do you think? Please advise. Cheers and solidarity, Ian

Travis Nell

Starting around 21:47, whats the source of that sample? I may have missed the sourcing of you mentioned it, but it's interesting!

nickw

Great chat and thank you for that Alan Watts clip. I needed that. It helps to open the mind further 🙏

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Saya! I hope you and yours are doing well too, my friend! We do have a couple eps outside this series on Hegel specifically too, especially one with Todd McGowan if you missed that one! :)

Rev Left Radio

Thats great to hear! Its definitely our most challenging series, but I am glad to see folks still wrestling with them and getting useful stuff out of them overtime!

Rev Left Radio

Wow, this Shakespeare issue is really interesting! Ive never dove into it myself, but have come acrossed it peripherally over the years. Ill have to check out your book and dive down the rabbit hole as I am not informed enough on that to have an opinion. You can send me a pdf (for which im grateful) at andersonbrett2011@gmail.com! As an aside, I am a huge fan of Montaigne, and was deeply into him in my 20s for some time. Havent thought about him for some years, but was nostalgic to hear him mentioned here haha.

Rev Left Radio

Its a YT video called "Alan Watts on Life After Death" by Motivation Madness. Not familiar w the channel, just liked the video!

Rev Left Radio

Glad it hit for you! I love Alan Watts and hes a HUGE influence on my worldview, and has been since a coworker gave me his tapes 15 years ago!

Ian Stockdale

Cool! I will send you the copy. Yeah, Montaigne is such a delight to read. As you may know, 'Shakespeare', whoever that may be, was deeply acquainted with Montaigne's work.

nickw

Nice! I find when if I’m engaged in theory and political action and neglecting my mediation practice I really start to struggle mentally / emotionally. Meditation is key for me to stay engaged but I need the constant reminder. On aside note, my book club is reading ‘the origins of capitalism’ by Ellen Wood. If you haven’t read it, it’s an incredible example of using a historical materialist, dialectical method to explain the contingent conditions that game rise to capitalism. Short easy read too.

Dakota

“Parallelogram of forces” - sounds like what’d we’d call a free body diagram in engineering. You sum up the forces to determine equilibrium, eg gravity wants to schlorp an airplane into the earth and the lift generated by the wings want to send it into space. The resultant equilibrium is its cruising altitude, a compromise between contradiction. My reading of Hegel and dialectics generally strikes me as a philosophical way of talking about system dynamics/dynamical systems.

Matthew

Hi Ian, I'm glad that you enjoyed the episode and found my response to your question helpful! Thanks also for offering to pass along your book; I'll get Breht to send it to me once he's received it from you. Also glad to see that you are both Montaigne enjoyers! His thoughts on death and friendship have been influential on me for a very long time.

Matthew

I think that's a very fruitful way to look at dialectics: a philosophy of system dynamics/dynamic systems. Thank you for this comment, Dakota!

Matthew

Hi Saya, You may find helpful the great Jean-Luc Nancy's book Hegel: The Restlessness of the Negative (1997). It is challenging, but brief, and good enough that I've kept it kicking around on my bookshelf for the better part of 20 years now. I also highly recommend Pierre Macherey's Hegel or Spinoza 1979), which is also challenging but very, very helpful. Lastly, What Should We Do with Our Brain? (2004) by Catherine Malabou (a student of Jacques Derrida) is a fascinating and accessible Hegelian (corrected for materialism) consideration of neuroplasticity and neuroscience. It's under 100 pages long and features an introductory essay by the French neuroscientist Marc Jeannerod. I hope that these may be useful to you at some point in your studies!

Ian Stockdale

Thanks, Matthew - I've sent the book to Breht - I hope you enjoy it and would love to hear your thoughts. "I may presently change, not only by chance, but also by intention. It is a record of diverse and changeable events, or undecided, and when the occasion arises, contradictory ideas; whether it be that I am another self, or that I grasp a subject in different circumstances and see it from a different point of view. So it may be that I contradict myself, but, as Demades said, the truth I never contradict." - Michel de Montaigne, "Of Repentance"

Saya Clarke

Thanks for these! I will will check them out for sure. The one by Malabou looks particularly interesting.

Max

I really enjoyed the series. Thank you!

Lefty In Training

Loved the series. My only complaint is that I've been so dialectics-pilled that I was thinking about the dialectic between pain and pleasure during my massage.

PuebloCO Jenin

I super enjoyed this episode, especially about the unavoidable currently engaged already been hit by the iceberg Titanic decline of Western imperialism. Question, would you please come back to telling what the outro music is? It's so hard for me to look it up when I can't Shazam it while it's playing on my phone.

Rev Left Radio

hahaha! Love that. Its a fascinating duality to explore. Over years of meditation, I start to kinda enjoy low level pain as merely intense sensations. There is pleasure in pain, and pain in pleasure for sure.

Rev Left Radio

Im sorry, I keep forgetting to add that in the shownotes! When I have lots of links and stuff to remember I tend to forget to put the outro song details! Ill try to remember going forward. This one was "Easy Answer" by Dope Knife

MLDad

Great ep. I want to schedule a vacation just to relisten the whole series! Love you and Matt's conversations, hope you keep cooperating in the future!

Finlay

greatest rev left series. cannot wait for matthew back

PuebloCO Jenin

Where is that clip available?.... Ah, I see Travis Nell asked also so now I have the answer