Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Philosopher Scott Sehon joins Breht to discuss his new book "Socialism: A Logical Introduction". Together they analyze arguments in favor of capitalism, argue against them, and defend socialism as a superior form of socio-economic organization in the process. They discuss different definitions of socialism, social democracy vs. democratic socialism, have a friendly back and forth about the Soviet Union, the role of morality and values in political debate, wealth inequality and its deleterious impact on society, the contradiction within capitalism between free markets and monopoly formation, democracy v. markets, and much more. 

Get 15% off any book in the Left Wing Books Library HERE

Files

Comments

Lefty In Training

I think this conversation shows the tension between a Marxist wanting to agitate and educate the masses by meeting where they are but not tailing their ideas. On the extremely stupid side, we have the MAGA Communists and those folks who think appealing to the masses' reactionary sentiments does anything for the socialist revolution. Thankfully, Professor Sehon wasn't one of those, but I feel his analysis based on philosophical argumentation and stats and figures only allows his conclusions to go so far. For example, it sounds like he is for democracy in the workplace in principle, but also doesn't sound like he is completely against private property. A Marxist analysis and an analysis of the argumentation that happened since Marx's writings would suggest to me at least that there is in fact not a spectrum between private property and no private property. Even if we accept that something can be called socialism and not have fundamentally banned all private property (I disagree with his position about not worrying about what properly is or isn't socialism), any private property leaves the door open to counter-revolution and backsliding into capitalism. Yes, there is going to be a spectrum during the transition to communism, but his placement on this spectrum of somewhere before the complete abolition of private property seems to be an end in itself. Basing my opinion just on this interview, I think his position illustrates the limitation of not having a class analysis or a theoretical framework for the nature of things like the state and capital. But getting back to what I feel is the importance of the interview and perhaps the utility of his book by a Marxist, where is that sweet spot between not presenting everything at once (ie. Marxist jargon, the necessity of revolution, etc.) but still properly presenting Marxist principles and not simply progressivism/reformism? I may look into getting the book in the future to see where on such a spectrum I feel his argumentation lies.

Daughters of Delos

Thank you Breht. Another great show with a great guest. Looking forward to the next. Your Comrade Across the River

Derek

Brehtz you mentioned something along the lines of, "democracy is part of our program" as socialists. But for Marxists is this really true? It has always seemed to me like the Party is pretty supreme, which itself tends to operate with only limited forms of democracy, even internally. Meaning, there is often a hierarchy whereby the Executive Committee is the only group that truly exercises democracy on a daily basis. But that's little more than a representative oligopoly, in the sense that those people are elected within the Party but then have extraordinary executive power during their term. I realize some of these structures historically have emerged in part out of necessity, due to the criminalization of revolutionary parties and activities. But I never got the sense that democracy was a core value to most Marxists given the reality of (in most cases) bringing about revolution while still a minority of society. This to me is one of the fundamental contradictions of the revolutionary left.

Bill

While political democracy is continually being put into check by both liberal parties, there still remains loose remnants of representative democracy via an electoral process (despite our suboptimal choices)- so the bigger problem as I see it- and the one where I believe we can make inroads with the right- is the utter fascist totalitarianism of the workplace which plays a far deeper role in our day to day lives than government. So the breadcrumbing of a representative democracy in a government run by capitalists is all well and nice, but it is honestly just a false appeasement and does nothing to address our day to day subjectation to wage slavery- in fact it seals it. So I believe this is the argument socialists need to keep bringing home over and over and over. It’s the one issue most everyone who works for a living can agree on- work sucks. I also think we can gain broad support in a pro-environmental stand and an anti-war stand (which worked for the Bolsheviks). All other issues while important become wedged and used against us. In my day to day conversations at work, I enjoy inciting the Trumpers by pointing out the injustices in the work place - they fall right in line ever.single.time- and in fact, btw, far more vociferous in fighting for workers rights than the liberal democrats at work who just fall in line with administration. It’s very interesting. Anyhow, thank you for the wonderful conversation- I truly need to hear these kind of arguments and feel the inspiration it brings to me. Otherwise it’s so easy to fall into despair.

Lefty In Training

If we use the USSR as an example, it was more democratic in practice than the US has ever been, even with its flaws at various points of it existence. I'd recommend picking at least one of these books to read: https://youtu.be/6N9dgX5Ivxo?si=zOrFBn-U9IfPuM4E. As for a revolution, it is not as if some small cadre of party officials initiate and conclude the revolution themselves. As was always stressed and acted out was the requirement that the masses must be the ones to initiate and conclude the revolution. A handful of people, if they could even start a workers' revolution, would be crushed by the throngs of masses not on their side. But revolutions have always been the way economic model changes have come about, and, by their very nature, they are an authoritarian imposition of one side's ideology on another. Please check out Engel's On Authority. It's very short.

Derek B Local Man

Kind of a left field question, Breht, but do you have a book recommendation on the French Revolution?

Rev Left Radio

I agree with your analysis wholeheartedly, and this is exactly the type of critical engagement I love to see. Some people would listen to an ep like this, disagree w the guest, and then slander and attack our show as a whole lol. But having people on from different parts of the left, and seeing what they have to contribute, and engaging with those ideas and positions critically, is the principled approach and you display that wonderfully here. I also think a logical/philosophical approach to these problems is a piece of a much bigger puzzle but is inadequate in and of itself. But still, that piece is valuable and worth slotting into its place for sure! Scott is also a cool, nice, thoughtful guy, which made him a fun and worthwhile guest!

Rev Left Radio

Very interesting take. I agree that material conditions can constrict democratic processes under socialism (as it does under all class society. Under capitalism, democracy is always curtailed, cornered, kept domesticated, limited, etc.). Since socialist struggle and success depends on the masses taking revolution into their own hands, there is something inherently democratic and bottom up about socialism intrinsically. yes, socialist states have failed to mobilize or keep mobilized this pressure at time, and that has led to the ossification of bureaucracy and hierarchy (as in the middle and late soviet union), but theres also been dialectical responses afterwards (like Mao's China, actively trying to prevent that). Democracy within the party is important, and in line w both the Vanguard concept as well as Democratic Centralism. On top of that, structures like Soviets, local councils, and a dialectial interplay between the masses and the party deepen this democratic strain. I do not want or advocate for an ossified hierarchical bureaucracy whatsoever. When they occur, its a result of either imperial pressure, total war, or revisionism: all things we must combat.

Rev Left Radio

If you have Audible, I really liked their Great Courses series on the French Rev. Its basically a semester lecture from an expert in 30 minute increments. I listened to it while I walked the streets of Paris a few years back and thought it was great: deeply detailed without a strong bias either way. We also have our episode on the French Rev which I am proud of. AS for specific books, depends on what your looking for, what perspective you want to hear from, etc. No one single book jumps to my mind, as Ive read and engaged with so m any different documentaries and podcasts and YT videos and books over the years that nothing in particular stands out immediately.

Rev Left Radio

Deeply thoughtful response as usual, Bill! I really appreciate your views and feedback. I Agree that there is a certain anti-establishment strain for MAGA types while dems now tend to be pro-establishment, but that of course changes and shifts with time, adminstrations, etc. I assume if Trump gets, that energy might flip! We shall see. Its a perrennial problem with anyone invested in either of the two parties or any given politician, the get more radical when out of power and more domesticated when their guy or party is in power. But as for your overall argument about the workplace being the important site of struggle to emphasize, I totally agree.

Bill

Hey don’t mean to intrude but one source of information on the French Revolution that I found particularly interesting was Chapter 4 in Thomas Piketty’s book Capital and Ideology. The chapter title is Ownership Societies: France. It has more an economic bent to it but that’s what makes interesting (surprisingly). The chapter describes what the French Revolution accomplished and what it didn’t accomplish with easy to digest data to back it up.

SaSeigneurie

The fact that you are bringing people from the wider "Left" shows how dedicated you are to advancing the conversation to better human conditions. However, sometimes it is important to hold one's principles even if it means challenging those potential allies. In this particular conversation, the guest, a philosopher, starts by arguing that he is not interested in definitions but in "substance". However, he does use terms with the premise that listeners agree with him, such as "authoritarianism" and "democratic socialism[sic]". It is a missed opportunity to challenge such views, particularly since it can help such people to evolve (though it is harder for academics, something I am familiar being myself in that universe). I always refer to people like G. Horne and V. Prashad who refuse to enter into bickering arguments while at the same time holding firm to their principles. Cheers. E

Derek

Engels, short n sweet. Yes I've often thought about how even direct democracy itself is authoritarian because the majority imposes its will on the minority. Outside of 100% consensus models (which I've participated in through union negotiations within a school district) you can't get around this aspect of collectively getting things done, and even w consensus you are binding future people (or your own future self) to the decision made. It now must be carried out w fidelity (which means accountability, inherently an imposition of authority) or there was no point in taking the time to come to consensus in the first place. Thx for the book recommendations. I will definitely read something from Hakim's list. Great stuff!

MLDad

I felt the same way

Seany G

On the earlier question about rhe importance of morals and values in developing a philosophical approach, there is a term in philosophy called "Axiology". In section 2 of the entry "Moral Development" in the IEP (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy) there is a brief description of its realm of inquiry - https://iep.utm.edu/moraldev/ But more broadly, thr term Axiology often means the "study of values". The SEP (Stanford Encyclopedia kf Philosophy) has a better explanation : https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/value-theory/ Kt csn be argued that "Axiology" is the basis of all other branches of philosophy (after epistemology, the study of questions of knowledge, like "how do I know what i know?", I suppose). This is because political philosophy has to define first what is important to each political position. I think the discussion in today's episode brought this out clearly.

Phoenix

Loved the episode. Great straightforward arguments against capitalism. However, I did start saying “BOOOOOOO, BOOOOOOO…” out loud while walking my dogs when he said he believed that nation states would be necessary to ensure equality. The state apparatus is inherently violent and irredeemable. Concentrations of power breed corruption. You can’t abolish class if you still have a state. Forgive the crude analogy, but it’s like saying we’re going to give the prison a makeover and give the prisoners a monthly field trip. I know this guy doesn’t like “labels” but what would you call him? He sounds like a liberal socialist to me. He can’t even imagine the possibility that smaller self-governing communities might be the only way to achieve a truly democratic. People clings to states in a way that makes no sense to me. I also think the “circular firing squad” criticism of the left is incorrect and painfully overused. One of the main differences between the left and the right is that the left is always looking for a better way to move forward. This includes constant discourse and debate. It’s messy but it’s necessary. Thinking that we can stop arguing and come to a solution right now so we can see it implemented in a generation or two is ludicrous and counterproductive. As it was mentioned in the episode, we are laying the foundation for generations to come. It’s a huge incomprehensible undertaking. This is a long game. You can’t rush the process. If the endless discourse bothers you, go to a therapist and figure out why. Learn emotional regulation and healthy boundaries so you can participate in a productive way without getting fussy because everyone isn’t in total agreement on how to go about the social revolution. Look at the big picture. Progress means constant reconfiguration, it’s not a straight line. I’d rather have the circular firing squad thinking critically and challenging each other’s theories for a few generations than prison makeover. Seriously though, find a therapist if you’re so bothered by it. I promise there’s some kind of trauma or false belief behind it. Ok thanks for coming to my ted talk.

Reagan

Thought this too, thanks for articulating it! The guest’s point about “substance vs semantics” was particularly frustrating to hear. Like there literally are /substantive/ differences between how marxists define socialism and other terms and how the guest defines them, and the guest dismisses those differences as “semantic” multiple times. So annoying

Foko

Years ago I listened to the revolutions podcast series on the French Revolution and thought it was well done: well-explained distinctions between the various parties in the conflict & their ideologies, a thorough play by play of the events w a good amount of primary sources. However, be critical as the host basically lost his credibility w me during his series on the Russian revolution later on.

Foko

I really agree bill! In my experience people are animated by struggle in their workplace almost more than anything else. It’s one of the things i really appreciate about Richard Wolff and his org democracy at work - they have a clear focus on labor issues affecting the working class, and electoral issues arise only as corollary.

Bill

Thank you Foko. I’ll check out democracy at work!

Finn 415

Hey there. I never write down the kersplebedeb/ left wing books discount code. Is it still happening? What is it again?

Jack Hall

Who was the recording of at about 50 minutes in?

Comrade Sukhov

Breht, you should’ve pushed back more on your guest’s criticism of the Soviet Union and Stalin. He completely disregarded the notion of the Soviet workers actually having some sort of saying in the way their factories were run or that Stalin wasn’t necessarily the powerful dictator he’s often portrayed to be in Western media. Sehon’s idea of a workplace democracy is not the only valid one and there’s no guarantee that it would function at all. Also, socialism is already more democratic than capitalism, so adding that extra adjective makes no sense from philosophical standpoint. Demsoc itself is a radlib concept with no revolutionary potential even in the slightest. Socialism without the will to make advancements towards communism in the long run is already quite sus. The label however is useful for the rhetoric of the reformers/opportunists who want to take advantage of the workers’ legitimate dissatisfaction with the capitalist system.