Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht return to do a follow up conversation to their well-received previous episode regarding this topic, "On Mysticism: Ego, Suffering, & Love". In this episode, they dive even deeper, discussing what enlightenment really is, the universal accessibility of Non-Dual awareness, the arguments for and against Perennialism, the mystical branches of Abrahamic religions, Buddhism and Taoism, meditation, awareness, fascist mysticism, and much more. 

Support Rev Left HERE

Check out all Red Menace Eps HERE

Follow us on IG HERE

 

Outro Song: Lonely Heart by Neva Dinova

Files

Comments

oranjest1

justin sledge collab when

SprocketMusic

In 1977, the Vatican appointed Oscar Romero as Archbishop of El Salvador, he was a bookish traditionalist, and generally perceived as someone who would not rock any boats. Five weeks later, his friend, Father Rutilio Grande, was assassinated in 1977 (by the U.S.-backed military dictatorship) for organizing the poor. Romero changed completely. He preached radical solidarity amongst the peasantry, and denounced El Salvador's displacement tactics and torture state from the pulpit and on the radio. He helped expand efforts by radical priests (like his martyred friend, Rutilio Grande) to turn rural churches into a resistance network, and mutual aid distribution centers. Mysticism is often seen as a deeply internal thing. But Romero experienced that ego death socially, through his work with the peasantry. He spoke of service to them not as a mere obligation but as a blessing in and of itself. He identified with the people, and saw in them the face of God so clearly, that he called the very idea of Self an "idol to be overthrown." Romero was assassinated while conducting mass in 1980, but shortly before, he produced some rather prophetic writing that I feel links Dr. Huey P. Newton's concept of Revolutionary Suicide with some profoundly mystical liberation theology. He said he did not fear death because he did not believe in it. "If they kill me, I will be resurrected in the people." I think this idea is the key to the future human evolution that you're talking about. Our evolution as a species so far has been characterized almost entirely by our ability to organize as collectives. In my opinion, the non-egoic human will evolve en masse if - and only if - we, as a species, create social conditions that encourage practitioners of radical solidarity rather than crucify them.

oranjest1

yo Brett not sure if Alison has commentary on this idea after this point but around 58 mins you mention that youre not sure how someone like Evola can be a perennialist and see the beauty/sublime in the truths youre talking about and then twist it to something fascistic and still reconcile it a few things ive been thinking of lately such as fighting and violence (i'm a martial artist) and peace, enlightenment, and perceptions have sort of collided here while listening to this dialogue. i saw a channel the other day called "War Yogi" which is about the violence inherent in the yoga tradition and how they stressed that these understandings made you a better warrior but it didn't click with me with that in mind it all makes visceral sense to me now, and also sort of helps me see the whole idea of the "Swastika" being a borrowed symbol from hinduism, connected with yoga as it is the clarity to me being: a perennialist like Evola or a mystic that can't or won't adopt egalitarian concepts uses these ideas as a tool. same as we might for something else like seeing the viability or inevitability or absolute requirement of communism to survive as a species. which is like .... sort of hitting me in the head with simplicity (using ideas as tools?? who'd have thunk it). same as the historical chivalric ideal: doing violence and being good at it brings you closer to God. so adopting more of these truths feeds into a lack of fear and comfort in violence and horror, which //Can Be Used// to fascistic ends very comfortably. again this simplicity sort of hurts me to think about like i must be missing something.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

This was an incredible episode! I always know the episodes are going to be fire when Alison comes on (not that Bret’s solo episodes aren’t fire or course 😉). Thanks for this.

Jocelyn Atkins

I have been listening to both Rev Left and Red Menace for years now and I am very much indebted to you for a better understanding of..well many things. I was not raised with any kind of faith or religion but I find myself feeling a kind of hunger for something spiritual and I can get down with your ruminations, Breht, regarding your journey on the path and especially, your OCD, which is a thing I struggle with as well. I am not practiced or anywhere near a kind of enlightenment but I am very curious. There is a theme, however, every time I hear you talk about this, that I keep tripping up on. So here is the question: The idea of the dissolution of the self--once this happens how does the self desire? I am using desire in a Lacanian sense. How do we continue to participate in an investment in the human world? How do we maintain friendships, love affairs, our relationship to appetitive needs, food and joy? How do we do politics without a self that desires? If we understand the tension, as I do, between desire and drive as being exemplified in the dialectic, where does the human world come into view? Is this not the collapse of the dialectic? Which in my opinion, is the fundamental structuring concept of all human life, but also something that is a "good" and is what makes us beautiful, albeit flawed. And to boot, such a collapse in my opinion is impossible for a being simultaneously constituted and undone by language. How can we understand this within the frame of a self that no longer exists, (which I still remain unconvinced is even possible for above stated reasons)? Thanks--Jocelyn Atkins

JK

Love you Brett, but I would personally like to see you put less of a focus on the mystic and meditative stuff on rev left and focus more on Marxism. I feel like the mysticism is better left to shoeless in Dakota. But that’s just my personal opinion

Eric Ripa

Great episode as always. I really enjoy these episodes and how you weave it into politics. Good dynamics between you and Alyson. As for your argument around if everyone should move towards enlightenment or if society as a whole should, personally I tend to lean a bit more towards a model where there are elders and wisdom passed down through practices and cultures. I recently read Braiding Sweetgrass and from that it sounds like this was/is a big part of indigenous culture, where the values of gratitude and sharing is instrumental and learnt very early in life. Not everyone need to or necessarily should go down the path of enlightenment but I agree that the teaching and effects are essential for the human race to evolve past our current shit show.

Radiant Sun Warrior

I think these episodes are a nice little break from the regular stuff. If you don't like it don't listen 🙉 I don't think doing these episodes somehow robs Bret and Alison of the time they could otherwise spend on the real meaty political content.

Radiant Sun Warrior

First though: these comments are awesome! Ya'll have such a diverse and piercing insight, I love to read it. I had a strong experience of ego death or that momentary ecstatic non-ego experience, but a strong thought followed which was that ego itself is an evolutionary development in consciousness. A return to a non-ego self would be in my opinion an evolutionary regression. I think coming into oneness and peace is beautiful and worthwhile for itself, but I push back against non-dual egoless self as being the next evolution. I get the sense that the ego phenomenon is a natural force of evolution in conscious thought that propels life forward . It's a manifested expression of a divine life force. It is our separation of things that allows for the sophisticated understanding of the natural world, and that leads to all forms of advanced science and social structures. I won't speculate as to what a world would be like with billions of sentient creatures with no ego, but I do posit that the existence of the ego, and it's ability to separate us from feeling a part of the whole of cosmic experience, is itself a development. Maybe you have to lose a thing to understand what purpose it plays, but to discard it permanently seems like a mistake. Love and solidarity comrade, I like what you do here.

adresz

Always such a delight when the delving duo comes on to talk! It's so interesting how Breht talks about consciousness and how humans may evolve to reach a higher stage of it altogether. Do you guys think animals and other sentient beings like plants experience the consciousness that you talk about, connecting with everything? Like we don't know for sure if we have a similar experience like that of other beings. Like how does a mushroom - if it does - experience with consciousness? Do they undergo enlightenment? Or are they already like in a higher realm? What about a jellyfish? The ones that don't have a central nervous system but do have sense organs? Is their awareness the same as consciousness? So many questions! And for the "hate" comments: the way you two engage with spiritualism does not lack a revolutionary vision, you always emphasize where you stand and how you relate those things to your politics and even make critiques of them and I think it's beneficial for everybody to hear. Love and solidarity!

Jordan Merrill

Really cool episode. I wish there was a recommended books list to delve into some of the stuff you two talked about. Especially on the spiritual practices and dealing with the ego.

Rev Left Radio

Haha Alyson is a fan of his YT channel and turned me onto it, so its not impossible :)

Rev Left Radio

Beautiful injection of Romero to this discussion. I really should do an episode on him and his life at some point. And this is the perfect way of mixing these religious and mystical elements into revolutionary politics. I agree with your conclusion wholeheartedly as well. Thank you for listening!!!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much for the support, my friend. Longstanding too. I really appreciate you and your feedback.

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate your perspective and value your feedback. I know this stuff isnt for everyone and sometimes splits the audience a bit. I still hope we put out enough political stuff that a random ep on another topic from time to time isnt too much of an imposition! But again, I hear you my friend.

Rev Left Radio

Hey Jocelyn, thank you for the feedback and GREAT question. I too am far from enlightened (whatever that means ;) ), but the way I would address your question is like this: In ultimate, final enlightenment, the self-structure dissolves, which is to say, the sense of being a seperate, psychological self falls away. But this is and always was an illusion, so in some sense nothing really changes at all, youve just seen through something that wasnt there. And if it was never there, then how could taking it away negatively impact your relationships, deepest moral values, and commitments? Additionally, when the self dissolves, there is an immediate feeling of being life ITSELF (not a self experiencing or navigating a life), a feeling of being deeply connected with everyone, and a natural sense of loving compassion, interrelatedness, and a tender caring for all sentient beings. In the context of personal relationships, this would serve only to make them healthier as you are not engaging in them to get something for yourself (validation, love, lack of lonliness, etc.) but are engaging in them free from any such considerations, freeing you up to be truly and deeply intimate and selfless in relation to those you love. Politically, we see the suffering of sentient beings as our own suffering and therefore we seek naturally and without forcing anything to alleviate that suffering. There is no more running away from others suffering as something "out there" or "not me". This provides an even more robust and solid foundation for a truly generative and progressive politic. Again, what falls away is something that was never there, but was an illusion constructed from compulsive inner thinking. So losing it is just the shuffling off of a burdensome illusion. Desires that are wholesome and serve others can still be cultivated. Its not so much that you LOSE your personality, but rather you have a part of your awareness that can transcend that when it is not being used, making your ego-personality-mind your "servant" rather than your unquestioned master... Does that kind of get to your question? Ultimately, in psychoanalytic terms, I think it transcends the LACK. It evolves beyond it.

Rev Left Radio

I resonate with that idea. And even in my structure, the development of a healthy ego woulud be part of the process, so everyone would have that to go through. Perhaps its precisely with aging into elderhood that it would become more and more available to more and more people, and one could imagine a hypothetical world in which teh majority of elderly people do awaken spiritually and serve as leaders and caretakers of the younger generations as they continue to evolve upward. Our elder leaders into todays world are as far from enlightened as possible though, thats for sure. Thought provoking reply though my friend, thank you!

Rev Left Radio

Yea, I understand if these topics arent interesting to you. I get that. Its not for everyone, but since it doesnt displace or reduce the political stuff I think it could be one of those things you just decide to skip while you wait for the stuff you actually enjoy. Enlightenment is not idealism, though. It is the full transcendence of idealism. It is the raw, ruthless, unbuttressed truth at its deepest levels. Such reality cannot be idealist, as it is instantiated in the body and material world. It is dialectical in a deep sense as well, which I laid out in my speech "dialectics and liberation: insights from buddhism and marxism". But I appreciate the honest feedback, and I take it to heart.

Rev Left Radio

I largely resonate with and agree with your argument here. I try to stress that transcending the ego is also to INCLUDE it. it is not to kill or annhilate the ego, but rather to rise above it and see it from a deeper and higher POV or awareness. This allows the ego-personality-mind to be utilized in daily life and set aside when its not needed, rather than running 24-7 at all times and tricking us into thinking that is what we ultimately are. So enlightenment would entail the transcending of the ego-personality (which is a form of emotional and mental maturation, allows the nervous system to rest, and gives us a refuge from psychological suffering and egoism). Its a dialectical evolutionary process (maybe) wherein there is continuity and rupture, higher forms of awareness transcend and include lower forms, the process is driven by contradiction, etc.

Rev Left Radio

Great question. I think about animal (and infant) consciousness as a form or pre-self awareness. Going through ego development is a natural evolutionary advance over that animal awareness in the same way that POST-self awareness is an advance over ego identification. So an infant or an animal does experience a sort of self-less awareness, but without having gone through the development of an ego, it remains fundamentally primitive. Most organisms evolutionary trajectory wont rise to the level of ego/intelligence, as they fill ecological niches where such development isnt selected for. My guess is cosmically only a relatively small amount of organisms have evolutionary trajectories that take them in this direction and thus allow for civilizational development. As for where consciousness itself begins and ends in the tree of life, thats an unknown and depends on the nature of consciousness itself (is it a force of nature that is instantiated in everything (pan-psychism), is it an emergent property of highly developed nervous systems (scientific materialism), or is it something else altogether, etc.) We simply do not know. Though it would not entirely surprise me certain plants and animals that we assume are unconscious do have some level of consciousness that we cant comprehend. Thank you for the kind words and your support of the show! <3

Rev Left Radio

P.S. maybe we can think about the ego stage of consciousness as self-consciousness, which most animals (and infants) do not have yet. This self-awareness would be a necessary step in the direction of transcending the self, and would thus be more advanced than forms of awareness that lack self-awareness (ie. pre-self awarenesses).

Rev Left Radio

There are so many directions and teaching styles and approaches out there that it is hard to give a general recommendation without knowing what might appeal to you in particular. I might recommend A Path with Heart by Jack Kornfield as a great starting place!

Wes Rich

I got so much out of this episode. I really love when you and Alyson team up. Always such an amazing back and forth.

JK

Thanks for the reply and even mentioning it at the start of your next episode. You’re a real one. Keep up the good work. When a batch of podcasts drop on me, Rev Left is always the first in queue to listen to. Side note, have you been following or hearing the work we’ve been doing in the Revolutionary Communists of America yet?

SprocketMusic

An episode on Romero would be awesome.

Payton M

Where'd the liberal socialism episode go?

Daewoo

Conflicted on the discussion about evolution/human development/consciousness development?. Keep hearing you bring it up when talking about spiritualism and enlightenment or whatever. Now that we humans are aware of evolution, isn't it our duty to rebel against it? We've developed ways to cure disease and treat genetic pitfalls due to evolution. We save children born with defects and cancer-causing genes. Is the 'next step' in human (cognitive) evolution important? I understand the argument that the ego was likely important in the development of humanity and society and it could one day be 'obsolete.' But how certain can you/we get for this? It isn't quite as concrete as class struggle. We know that we come from a stateless, communistic life and will return to it (or die out as a species in the attempt). What do we know about the ego and how it can develop?

Nico

I think the ego develops through stream of consciousness and awareness of self, and shaped by a mix of our subjective experiences and environment. The human brain is pretty amazing! Human beings have such a dual nature. The ability to feel emotions as tools to perceive threats, or pleasure, and to process these emotions, and influx of hormones that have drug like effects, that enhance our experiences and ensures some kind of survival. We are both thinking creatures, and feeling creatures, we have reasoning, and ability for deep emotions. Both are equally as important for survival. There are sooo many experiments that show once your mental survival is threatened, even if you're otherwise healthy physically, you eventually start exhibiting physical symptoms that could be equally as threatening if not more. I think where people come into conflict with their ego, is when they have certain perceived needs, that are more (emotionally) ego driven, that have a sense of urgency to be met (for mental survival), and it impedes on someone else needs, and a power struggle ensues. The ego needs to be put in check by using reasoning. But as a society we don't really prioritize reasoning as a skill that's worth building upon. When people have to think too hard into things they get frustrated and overwhelmed, this is by design. Everything about our capitalistic society is aimed at driving our ego, emotions, aesthetics, appealing to our senses and pleasures, appealing to our emotions and sense of self. We get rewarded with fleeting dopamine hits in the form of fleeting consumer products and fads and social media likes for example. This system is aimed at controlling our sympathetic nervous system (our antiquated lizard brains). I think so many people in the 1960's especially realized this and were experimenting with mind altering substances as a way to kill the ego, to look beyond our human conditioning to get to the core of consciousness and what it means to be human, and seek liberation through those means (nirvana, ego death, enlightenment aka "woke" as it's called disdainfully nowadays). But indegenous cultures have been using meditation and altered states of consciousness for answers to fundamental philosophical questions for thousands of years. I don't think it's worth diving more into the ego, we know that we can become hijacked by it, and it can be used against us by powers that be, what we need to do, is combat the systems of oppression that are aimed at our egos, and keep our reasoning. Philosophy is amazing in that aspect, as there are so many thought experiments that get the gears rolling, and can condition our minds for deeper thought and reasoning. It doesn't have to be dogmatic, or binding systems of belief, but just food for thought. I think having these conversations and normalizing open dialogue, and discourse with the aims of understanding each other on deeper levels without the ego taking over, is also helpful. I think it would take a total restructuring of society to pivot away from this ego driven, individualistic society. If it's not going to happen at the macrocosmic level (top down), then starting it at the microcosmic level (ground up) is more attainable. But I think it takes a certain degree of faith, and people are so drained and fed up. By design of course....Sorry for the rant comrade. Be well 🌹

Nico

I think about this all the time! I believe that other animals and sentient beings do have a stream of consciousness but because they operate differently than we do, we can't even conceive in our limited capacity what that would even look like. I feel like a lot of the time humans assume that other beings must just either operate similarly as if the universe revolves around us, and we are the standard, or we are above everything - But then I think what if these other sentient beings are more advanced than us in some way mentally, and we just have no way to quantify it due to our own mental limitations? You could argue for example hypothetically "there's no way plants are more advanced then us, look at everything we've built!" Yes, but maybe that's the problem with humans and the human condition. Maybe we grow too much, too fast, unchecked, like a cancer. Maybe the best thing for longevity and living in harmony with nature is to live small scale, in a more sustainable way in harmony with other sentient beings, and not get too big for our environments and capacity.

Nico

I agree. I think we need to transcend and operate in a way that includes the ego. But with balance☯️

Devin

Hey Breht, how about Zen Buddhism? I’ve read some books from DT Suzuki, Shunryu Suzuki, Dogen, and Thich Nhat Hanh for example. Any others that you think would be good to check into?