Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Professor and author Matt McManus returns to the show to discuss his newest book, "The Political Theory of Liberal Socialism". Together they explore the major themes of the book, hash out the disagreements they have between revolutionary Marxism and democratic socialism, explore critical thinkers like Karl Marx, Thomas Paine, Mary Wollstonecroft, and John Rawls, wrestle with the questions of revolution and communism as the ultimate goal of socialism, and much more.

"Providing a comprehensive critical genealogy of liberal socialism from a sympathetic but critical standpoint, McManus traces its core to the Revolutionary period that catalyzed major divisions in liberal political theory to the French Revolution that saw the emergence of writers like Mary Wollstonecraft and Thomas Paine who argued that liberal principles could only be inadequately instantiated in a society with high levels of material and social inequality to John Stuart Mill, the first major thinker who declared himself a liberal and a socialist and who made major contributions to both traditions through his efforts to synthesize and conciliate them."

Check out our other episodes with Matt HERE

Outro Song: "Best of All Possible Worlds" by Ajj feat: Kool Keith & Kimya Dawson

Support Rev Left HERE

Follow us on IG HERE

Files

Comments

Payton M

Great conversation! I really enjoyed and appreciated it and will definitely be listening to it again soon. A couple thoughts: 1. I think matt is too hard on the USSR and "maoist" China. I'm pretty sure disruptions in normal climate behavior also caused a lot of the famine in China, not sure about USSR. But like Breht says, these are people that have just made revolutionary breaks with centuries of autocracy. The historical knowledge and experience is not yet there for full democracy. Same as all countries today it seems. 2. I agree the world obviously isnt completely material (cause if it is, isn't freedom completely illusory and even our thoughts are predetermined by matter and motion?). Its being mediated by the features of the human animal. Our brains for instance, our sensory organs, etc. which we probably can't fully understand untill we transcend it but then we get into science fiction stuff. 3. I'd basically consider myself a liberal socialist in the sense that I like liberal rights and freedoms minus property rights as written. I think it is a great time to come out with this kind of ideology as well. The internet and the new frontier of patreon substack etc might allow an intellectual base of support to emerge for this. Maybe it cohere's into an alternative ruling media elite over time but I'm not sure about that. Thanks guys, I loved the episode if you couldn't tell!

Lefty In Training

For better or worse, I'm biased towards more focused methodologies or frameworks than eclecticism (or whatever the opposite of eclecticism is). For a Buddhist analogy, I favor Theravada schools moreso than Mahayana ones. With that in mind, I guess I'm just not sure what liberalism adds to socialism that justifies fusing the ideas. Maybe the book goes into more details, but the only reason I got from the episode was that liberalism would steer socialism away from "authoritarianism." On that point, I thought the section on authoritarianism was the weakest of the episode. You two didn't seem to be arguing from the same set of facts. The speaker seemed close to going into anti-communist Great Man Theory propaganda. And I don't know every communist, but I don't know anyone who unironically thinks Stalin or Mao did nothing wrong and tries to "exonerate" them. Overall, good discussion and good luck to the speaker on developing their idea. Just don't know what liberalism is offering socialism here.

nickw

Thoroughly enjoyed this Ep. Love how you guys have really constructive conversations despite some differences. Really important for the Left.

JK

Great episode. I was thinking to myself what topic I’d really love to hear you cover next. Could you get someone on and do an in-depth analysis of “The Revolution Betrayed”?

Katherine Mays

Hi! I feel like psychoanalysts have helped developed an understanding of consciousness that is more in line with "reality" and so many scientific fields are saying "actually our definitions are breaking down upon closer inspection" and I'm coming to the conclusion that everything is "life" and everything should be respected by asking instead of telling. Opening something up to study it destroyes that thing. A "user guide" to consciousness is still really bad.

KK

I'm curious - how does a 'liberal socialist' differ from the (very much alive as a concept of) 'libertarian socialist', of which Chomsky is a very famous example? Wikipeida has the latter down as 'an anti-authoritarian and anti-capitalist political current that emphasises self-governance and workers' self-management' which seems to be pretty much the same as what Matt said about liberal socialism, right?

Hana

Oof. This one was good but... Straight faced delivery that democracies don't "allow" famines while the US - a self-described democracy if no more than that - is absolutely allowing its citizens to starve by posting police outside supermarkets in flood-destroyed communities. Good lord. May not be a famine but my god it's deliberately keeping desperate people from food. That and the description of the Soviets' contribution and suffering in WW2 as a fig leaf blew the guy's credibility for me. The blindspots were glaring and have to be ideological since the fella clearly isn't stupid. A lot of the conversation was really interesting but that stuff is breathtakingly ignorant.

Rev Left Radio

Yea, Matt and I have always had those disagreements, but I still value his work and I know, as you said, if you can get past that, there is lots to learn from him and these conversations!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for the feedback, and I agree with you. Even on the liberal part if by liberal you mean, as you make clear, the basic legal rights and freedoms (minus property ownership), and I think if any socialist society had the chance to develop without external intervention of any sort, we'd see those liberal legal rights fit just fine with a socialist economy. Its precisely because of the never-ending opposition and interventions by imperialism that make that impossible at the moment. This is just another reason why imperialism needs to be utterly and completely wiped off the face of the earth. Nothing beautiful can grow in soil that is purposefully poisoned.

Deven Toast

In democracies, Mao can't pay the clouds not to rain because the majority of people voted to allow the rain

Rev Left Radio

Yea, I think, in the most charitable interpretation, we could think of liberalism strictly in the legal rights sense (minus private property rights imo), and theres no reason in theory why a socialist society couldnt also have those basic legal protections. But its because of imperialism and the violence of the global capitalist ruling class that forces socialist experiments into defensive postures internally and externally, since we all know imperialism's game when it comes to undermining any society that doesnt capitulate to it fully. I like Matt a lot and learn from him a lot, but I noticed he didnt answer the Chile example I tossed at him, because that really is the problem that all forms of so-called non-authoritarian socialist ideas and strategies face: brutal, uncompromising and violent opposition from the ruling class. If Allende would have taken an approach like Cuba, China, Soviet Union, etc. it would have been called "authoritarian" but almost certainly would have survived... In any case, thank you for listening and for your thoughtful feedback, as always!

Rev Left Radio

Yea, I think thats basically right. I called it a form of democratic socialism which amounts to the same thing. Both liberal socialism and libertarian socialism are advancing the same basic idea. Historically, it hasnt seemed to work precisely because of immediate and overwhelming imperialist intervention, and here in the US any attempt to achieve socialism democratically would be attacked and dismantled by the ruling class, its grip on the legal and political system, the corporate media, and finally, the deep state/fbi/cia if push came to shove. Thats the perpetual problem for anyone arguing for this approach and I do not think they have dealt w that problem sufficiently, which I tried to make clear to Matt in this discussion!

Deven Toast

Just finished this episode. I was definitely skeptical at the beginning but Matt is very level headed and his analyses are pretty firmly grounded to his beliefs which is more than can be said about a lot of people. I do think there is a level of idealism to some of his points. I guess I don't fully understand his point in this book. He is in line with Democratic Socialism but is also open to revolution if necessary. I think he's looking back on the Chinese and Russian revolutions with a very abstracted vision of their ideals, problems, and attempted solutions without caring for how precarious and uncertain their material conditions were. All that said it's refreshing to have a very level headed, intelligent, and well thought out guest on the show from the more liberal traditions. It's not often liberals have such detailed and grounded discussions with principled leftists. Leftists are so used to conservative talking points and bad faith arguments that I think we can be at a total loss sometimes trying to articulate points to a liberal, if that makes sense.

Payton M

I saw Hakims video on tiananmen and it crystallized that idea for me. I don't want to sound too corny quoting rage against the machine but it seems true that "hope lies in the smoldering rubble of empires".

KK

Got it, thanks. I wonder why Matt think it’s a political philosophy that needs ‘rehabilitation’ , isn’t it still very much alive and well? I mean, anyone who know of / has read Bookchin (like you Breht!) knows it’s never gone away! What am I missing??!

Forrest Staub

I think its very strange how he simultaneously claims to be pro worker control, but rejects the idea of a workers state. He is anti authoritarian but supports the workers authority to recall representatives at any time when he was discussing marx's writings on the French Civil War and critique of the goethe program. Seems like liberal socialism is an idealist formation that wants to skip socialism and go right to full communism

Forrest Staub

And maybe even "skip to the end" was the wrong phrasing, but that it wants to skip a lot of the struggle that will be necessary to overthrow capital and also form a bulwark against counter revolutionary formations

oranjest1

Matt's a sharp guy and good debater but around 1hr 29 he's lost some respect because he stops arguing in good faith. I'm not sure if thats on purpose, that its just a line of argument thats worked before for him that he will use often, or if thats just an honest gap in his framework he jumps in and sidewalls your point about direct irrefutable gains and difficult consequences (defeating invading armies and contributing to helping the world at large is a bit more an abstract idea and has little to do with your point) and pivots it into how ideas are used to justify willful atrocities that are helpful to the ruling class bit ridiculous

Gabriel Alvarado

My family has been trying to guilt trip me into voting for Kamala because “women’s rights” are on the line…. They tell me I’m privileged to be able to not vote and I should feel guilty for it. I told them it’s a privilege not to be bombed with someone else’s tax dollars. I truly can’t take these liberals anymore

Nick

Wouldn't the dust bowl be considered an American famine? Famines can occur from natural conditions (which of course can be exacerbated by humans). It's a weird line of argument that democracy = no famine ever.