Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht analyze the results of the recent presidential election and explore its various meanings. Together they discuss the grotesque hollowness of the Democratic Party, the identity crisis of the post-Trump Republican party, dealignment and realignment, the end of neoliberalism, the rise of the illiberal Right around the world, strategies for developing the socialist left as a serious player on the electoral terrain, how Trump might navigate the Israel issue, the end of neoliberal identity reductionism, the importance of solidarity across identities, building power outside of the Democratic Party, neoliberalism and neoconservatism, challenges to liberalism, Tenant Organizing, the Labor Movement, how Trump's second term might (or might not) be different from his first term, and MUCH more! 

Support Rev Left and get access to bonus episodes: www.patreon.com/revleftradio

Follow RLR on IG HERE

Subscribe to Red Menace on your preferred podcast app

Files

Comments

Emilia Contreras

hell yeah i was waiting for this inevitable banger to drop

Colton Burross

The only race issue that cost the Dems this election is how they don’t care about Palestinian lives

Lefty In Training

I think even beyond thinking through different strategies, we just need more people out there organizing period. We should also be thinking about overarching, strategic topics, but these answers ultimately need to be found through practice. People need to get out there, know their neighbors/coworkers names, make mistakes, survey the class character of their community, etc. Otherwise, I fear people either become doomers stuck in their own heads or develop some savior complex that makes them avoid organizing until they've come on to this perfect idea that'll bring about the revolution. [Insert relevant Mao quotes here]

Ty

The democratic party is not a vehicle for the expression of left wing politics. They are the final bulwark against it. -Breht Love the analysis.

Hana

This tenants union thing is great. It's real hope potentially. What do you think about that helping to build international solidarity? I'm thinking about how many hedge funds own vast amounts of property across nations/continents/the planet! Thousands of council homes here in the UK have been got rid of and huge numbers replaced by "units" that are frequently sold off-plan to foreign investors as well as the parasite class of the nation. Wonder what opportunities that could offer left-wing organising worldwide... Unformed thought at this point but yeah... Would love to know what you might think of that?

Eoghan

Good discussion. I agree with the need for a marxist electoral presence. I think it's easy to dismiss this idea from an ultra-left standpoint but the fact of the matter is that in a lot of countries elections is the only time that most people properly engage with the political process. It's something that's seen some minor success in Ireland where there's a unashamedly Marxist party that consistently polls about 2-3% despite it's tiny size has elected a handful of politicians. It conciously acts as a pebble in the shoe of the establishment and keeps other center-left parties honest by calling out their hypocricy. A comrade of mine wrote a pamphlet on Lenin and the Bolsheviks writings on electoralism a couple of years ago which might be of interest to some. You can find it online by searching: "Lenin, Elections and Socialist Hegemony" by Seán Mitchell (afraid to post a link in case it gets caught in a spam filter). The main thesis from what I remember is that people forget that the Bolsheviks were involved in Duma elections for more than a decade prior to the October revolution in a hugely anti-democratic atmosphere. Definitely lessons to be learned from that period of time.

Karolina

yeah, when I filter in Patreon Recent posts by Podcast, the last entry is Yahya Sinwar: Living and Dying for National Liberation from Oct/20. Seems this newer "posts" are not classified as "podcasts"? This is my understanding, as I cannot see them in my podcast app (not Apple though)

DD

Was anyone else getting audio issues throughout this?

Jeremiah

I implore anyone who considers themselves a Marxist to get organized. Join FRSO, or if you're not a Marxist-Leninist that's fine, join a mass organization like NAARPR, SDS, or a local anti-war or climate justice org. Like there's honestly no excuse to not be doing *something.* And showing up to stuff is great, but the best thing you can do is to actually take up roles in these organizations. Sign up for the security team at a rally or march. Join car brigade or bike brigade. Help facilitate meetings or take notes. If you have extra resources, put them at the disposal of a fighting organization. If you want more inspiration, read Fight Back! News to see what others are doing and how they're winning. Also for Breht, it would be super cool to get someone from FRSO or Fight Back on this show, like Mick Kelly or Richard Berg. Just a recommendation 💚🙏

Amanda Joy Moon

The best way to control the opposition is to lead it ourselves. ~Vladimir Lenin

Juche Stalin

Yeah, I'm experiencing the same issue in a different player as well.

Jeremiah

Probably a Zoom recording and they were having connectivity issues. Idk what their setup is but I think the workaround is to have each participant make a recording of their own voice with their own equipment and then someone edits them together

Clint Blakely

Breht and Alyson, I know this might seem like a minimal aim of the pod but it’s very comforting to hear people who share and expound upon my own response to the election. Nearly all my friends are some form of liberal and it’s hard to empathize and not get smug when I see them devastated and despondent, when I’m like, oh so now things seem bad to you? Thanks for this ep. Very inspired to hear about tenant unions, going to try to get involved with that work in the metro DC area where I live.

Saanal

Woo. Lots of thoughts but I’m just going to pushback on something that I think needs to be attacked because once again we minimize and dismiss what you call “identity politics” (uncannily, in a similar way the right wing does). Firstly, Leftist thought does not survive under populist rhetoric. Baffling to have to say this when you see how crippled leftism comes out when it tries to ride on this rhetoric. It is in a way almost anti-political and relies heavily on a REAL homogenous identity. It is a useless mask for any ideology that relies on “educating the masses.” This is why the right-wing can historically use such rhetoric more efficiently for their agenda: they aren’t planning on letting the needs of the people dictate them. Now, keeping that in mind, he idea that race or gender had nothing to do with it when the campaign on DEI, scapegoating of “foreigners”, and JD Vance, played such a major part is absurd. Let me be clear, it’s the rhetoric here that is in contention. To say that there is structural racism and misogyny but it has nothing to do with hindering a black woman in getting elected doesn’t make any sense. Was it the largest or most defining element to her loss? No, I can agree with that. But to ignore the rhetoric that Trump’s campaign used in order to posture some populist idea of a leftist movement because we know identity politics isn’t popular with the right wing voters is so wrong headed. It reminds me that I don’t think there’s much community here with black or brown people. You tried to reposition it on “liberals” when you called it out but we know the rhetoric you are attacking is largely being said by the exact groups we are talking about—you just knew how it would sound if you said it. Most actual liberals, if you were clued in, were pretty happy to blame latino and black and muslim men. Plenty of “I tried to help you but fuck you” rhetoric going around. (Sidenote, but no latino is surprised that latino americans have a large conservative base. The entire idea of a hispanic identity in the US is a US concoction. A significant amount of the people that register as hispanic don’t even speak spanish fluently. Even still, latinos aren’t a monolith and can easily be the most hateful of other latinos, especially when they want to be in-group.) Anyway, to get back to the point this is why so many left wing groups in the US will gain and then quickly lose traction with black or brown people. You show your ass every time any sort of “loss” comes into play (and people moving right in policy is a loss for leftism not just liberals) and we know who will be the first to blame. Also, a perfect demonstration in micro of how populist rhetoric will always end up throwing the baby out with the bath water.

Fateez Oomuk

Regarding misogyny as the reason why Harris lost, I’ll just say that if Ivanka Trump ran in 2028 she would wipe the floor with anyone the democrats put up.

Rev Left Radio

Spotify took it down!!! some copyright shit, probably from the news clip we played! Should be up on apple and soon on YT hopefully.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, sorry it was a situation where I had to record from home and had some connection issues and worse sound quality than usual. We try to avoid that but for super timely eps sometimes its our only choice. Hopefully it wasnt too distracting or hard to keep up with

Rev Left Radio

Yea, the initial connections might be tentative or weak, but certainly being more organized in general is a necessary prerequiste for more internationalist forms of solidarity, connection, and work! But yea, with an almost global housing crisis, tenant organizing will be worthwhile and effective in MANY places outside the US as well as inside, and could eventually form some basis for internationalist cooperation.

Rev Left Radio

Hmm. looking into that now!!! I am not sure whats going on with that!!!

Rev Left Radio

Right on, and ill look into your recommendations. Am def interested in such a convo for sure!!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for this feedback, and yes one of our aims is definitely to make people feel less alone and have resonance with others who they might not be able to have in their personal lives. Have non-mainstream politics will always be challenging in this way, thank goodness technology allows us to connect across space and time with one another!

Rev Left Radio

I agree that the Right uses identity politics just as much as the left and that they weaponized particularly misogyny in this campaign. In the episode, I said something to the effect that "racists and sexists def exist, but if you are the type of person who would never vote for a woman or a black person, you are almost certainly already a committed republican". Liberal racism in the WAKE of the election is also very, very real and grotesque. But their racism isnt about the identity of their candidate, its aimed at those who didnt vote for their candidate - and many of them think it was sexism and racism from non-whites that was the issue at play. Identity politics treats groups as monoliths, and thats another reason its ineffective over the long run and off-base as a strategy. All black people arent one thing, all Latinos arent one thing, all white guys arent one thing, etc. So I agree with you on that. My main point, which I made very clear in the episode, is that we are not saying to IGNORE the very real dynamics of race, gender, etc. Its that we need to recognize them and address them in order to help move beyond identity-based division and toward solidarity. That solidarity cant exist without addressing the genuine oppressions and needs of marginalized people, but never building that solidarity and emphasizing identity differences (without ever addressing the material needs of various communities) is a losing strategy employed by teh Dems and THATS what we were critiquing.

Anton Pannekoek

Other settler colonial states (NZ, Canada, Australia, UK) had (white) female leaders in the past. I would at least count out sexism as a major factor in the US election results. And if that transfer is correct, I would also doubt the "racist" aspect, since Barrak Obama was elected two times.

Anton Pannekoek

That may be true, but she never could because she wasn't born in the US.

Jördrider

"Oh those damn Hispanics and their misogyny. It's all their fault." Meanwhile in Mexico they elect a female president.

Danny Boy

US culture is very different from the other English speaking countries. The fact that they had female leaders is basically irrelevant to people who believe in American exceptionalism.

Nico

Your deep sense of empathy, compassion, and passion for this human existence is so moving. You're like an antenna! I feel like with the way the world is feeling lately, it's so refreshing to hear someone feel so deeply about their fellow humans, analyzing systems challenging them, trying to imagine better ways of living that benefits not just a few but the many. Spreading awareness and making information accessible..I feel like these dialogues, discourse, exchange of ideas are so vital. I feel like the world is vibrating lately. On a cosmic level that I've never experienced before. It's a deeper vibration. An ancestral howl. Like the human spirit. Energy. Energies clashing in time and space creating friction or resistence. A necessary kind that's only natural like when atoms collide. I think where we are as a society /as a people try to resist the natural evolution it causes that misalignment. Disorder to order back to disorder ad infinitum. Patterns. Like a fractal or sacred geometry. Cycles in birth and death, resurrection common themes in soooo many religions. People don't realize it but I think we're already in a new era, a Renaissance, a new Revolution and new Enlightenment. We're not going to be able to really see the unique role the internet played in all of this until 100 years down the road...like looking back retrospectively at how the printing press or certain tools effected the French Revolution, The Enlightment, The Industrial Revolution and so on. Lately I've been thinking so hard about how do we as a country as a society move forward, and I keep looking to the past for answers or some universal truth or singularity and singular event or purest form of being. I can't tell if intellectualizing too much can be detrimental and create a limitation, or blockage or if it's necessary and needs to be flushed out. So many people demonize thinking. Of course there has to be a balance between theory and praxis right? But someone's gotta be having the conversations and processing the data and stimuli and asking the questions and getting the gears turning . Thanks for all that you do. 🌹

Pj

One question I had was about the pre-existence of a labor movement. I know it was crucial to USSR, bit how critical was that in China or how critical is it curreny in the Philippines or India with their maoist movements?

Dirt Fox

Wanted to say how refreshing of an episode this was. These are two comrades really thinking through the current moment and its challenges. A huge departure from the liberals in my life simply doomscrolling and pointing fingers.

Mackenzie Parvin

Idk I think her being a black Asian women played a little into the right wings identity . When a white man ran with the exact same policy’s he beat trump .

Ryan Campbell

I love you guys so much this was the best analysis

YepX

I sent you guys a direct message.

Lawrence G Trovinger

Hello, neo-liberal zombie is not done. It's a zombie, it will consume more brains.

Ben

agree with you, i think breht and alyson may have gotten a little lost here in pushing marxist analysis and lost a bit of nuance. if racism and sexism are still the problem we can all acknowledge they are in this country, then i think it’s not wrong to acknowledge they play a small part in electoral choices. this is not me saying at all though that kamala would have likely won had she run on left populism edit: i think it was acknowledged that it plays a part, i just wasn’t super comfortable with how heavily it was downplayed. i accept that i could easily be still influenced by my liberal upbringing though, lol

Mackenzie Parvin

It’s a country founded on racism and sexism . We’re one of the only countries to never have a woman head of state that’s not a confidence

Jessie Warner

It’s great to talk about internal left division but its also easy to not put your platform behind a party or organization. If one never tries one never loses and if one doesn’t subordinate oneself to a revolutionary party they can always maintain purity. Many people on the left spend too much time talking themselves out of/justifying not doing something. Love the show and the work and believe we will all have to become partisans to make this work.

Shane

Thanks for this analysis. As veterans of all this now, I know we all have each other and will get through this one way or the other. The 21st century challenges we face as leftists in the imperial core would likely make Lenin's head spin. I have no freaking clue how to proceed from here, but I'm just appreciative to call you all my comrades. Thank you for all you do.

EndlessToil

Breht or Allison would you either if you have Hassan Piker on or go on his stream? I'd love a rev left/red menace cross over with Hassan.

Rev Left Radio

The appreciation is mutual, my friend! Thank you for your longstanding support, its means the world to us. <3

Nick

The Palestenian Youth Movement seems to have brought together a lot of organizations imo. I see DSA, PSL, JVP, SDS and a number of other organizations coming together for local demonstrations with PYM. It's still far from a mass movement but it's good to see. There's also a big demonstration planned for Jan 20th in DC with a number of union leaders and socialist organizers coming together (even Jill Stein lol). Maybe we can get organized into a big party at some point

Saanal

I got you and I haven’t relistened to the segment so I will take your word that I misunderstood you and was probably already antagonized by a lot of the other opinions outside that I can into this episode with. You basically nailed it in this post so I really have no contention here.

BammEs

This episode and Guerrilla History's together are everything I needed to better understand these elections as a European person

A Gardener

Excellent analysis, comrades. I want to push Alyson on one point. I am more optimistic about electoral party prospects. Hear me out, and I invite critique. I think 2024 has provided an opening. The left (broadly speaking) has grown considerably in number since 2016. Rs and Ds are historically unpopular, and both are in an identity crisis (for different reasons). We have battle-tested social and multi-media propaganda tools, and we have realtime communication and group decision-making apps. We know for certain that the US left (broadly speaking) can ground game an IRL electoral win if we have enough notice and if we pool our focus. Even if we are outnumbered, attacked, and our opponents raise millions. Consider Bernie’s primary wins in early states. Under a left coalition party, we just need one solid, high-profile electoral victory to prove it can be done. Folks are sick of losing and are willing to try anything that proves effective to beat the duopoly. I think many folks will join any winning left party in droves. And most importantly, ➡️ we must prevent the Berniecrats, the Squad, and the Progressive Caucus from re-absorbing any disaffected forces ⬅️. If the Dems rehabilitate, more people will die, and the opportunity will have passed. Now, if you’re still with me, allow me to preempt 2 objections. 1. “Why bother with elections when what we need is to change material conditions?” you may ask. I hate this country’s stupid elections. But even just ONE prominent, confrontational, anti-duopoly elected **with a functioning, rambunctious party that people can actually join** would be enough to set the stage for much larger opportunities. Right now we are dying. Even a basic social democratic 🤮 coalition party calling for the provision of essential services we need to survive in an era of weekly climate disasters would save lives, build capacity, and buy a little time. 2 . “We just don’t have the numbers,” you may reply. We don’t have a Maoist cadre, but we do have unprecedented numbers if it’s a coalition. We have to work with what we have today because we are dying today. Here’s the math. You take most Greens, add majority of DSA, add disaffected Berniecrats, invite highly motivated anti-genocide voters (esp Muslims/Arabs), and toss in the entire freak show menagerie of left sectarian orgs. All of em, especially the really annoying ones that we will fight in the coming years. The Bolsheviks can fight the Mensheviks after the February revolution, if you will. In fact, that would be the point—a coalition of parties that otherwise can keep fighting each other about nuclear energy or Trotsky or whatever on their own time, but a winning coalition nonetheless. I’m talking about a coalition party around a 3-point universal agenda. Healthcare for All. Housing for All. End the Wars. …or something like that. We can finalize it at The First National Congress. Then we identify a high-profile electoral target, and we put all electoral energy into it that normally gets siphoned by the Ds. We can do this. We have experience and tools that we didn’t have before. The window is closing and the planet is overshooting all climate targets. This strategy can score a win, save lives, and set us up for the next fight. Thoughts?

SprocketMusic

In 2020, the Democratic Party raised $340,000,000 in the first month of the BLM uprisings alone. They successfully mobilized tens of thousands of volunteers, and channeled enormous mass energy into the electoral arena. Even then - even with the chaos and fear of COVID crashing everywhere - Biden managed to squeak out a very very narrow victory. They were never going to be able to duplicate that. Biden even said while running in 2020 that he planned on being a one term president; he painted himself as the only one capable of beating Trump. He also actively courted the progressive vote, even though everyone knows that he's center right. Kamala actively courted neoconservatives and Cheneyites, and snubbed even centrist faux progressives in favor of militaristic rhetoric. She's also got a genocide on her hands. It's extremely reductive to say that Biden won because he's a white man, and Kamala lost because she's a black woman simply because their policies are similar. They were campaigning under extremely different conditions, and with different campaign strategies.

Supreet Kaur

You should also try and get Kansas City tenants union on. They are planning to launch a national program for social housing after local successes.

M

You had me until you said race and gender didn’t have anything to do with it and anyone who’s racist or sexist voted republican. Please don’t lose your nuance in refuting an over exaggeration from liberals.

Red

do you really believe enough people to shift the election voted for Trump solely because Kamala is a woman and Black? I mean, really think about that. If you were able to quantify that and gave those votes to her, I would confidently bet she still loses.

Red

the only way this works is through buy-in from a broad voting base, and that does require a certain level of retail politics i.e. an ability to materially demonstrate an alternative to the duopoly through material means. Mass mobilization toward mutual aid and tenant unions, for example, all under the banner of a single party. The amount of discipline and unity of thought required to make that cohesive on such a scale isn't challenge the U.S. left can meet in its current form. Say, for argument's sake, that obstacle is overcome, I fail to see what an electoral win can actually accomplish. To me, the purpose of new political party should be more about disruption and diverting people's attention toward the alternatives they can create for themselves, rather than just winning a seat so that they can watch a sole leftist candidate be completely ineffective in changing anything through the state

Red

One of those woman heads of state was elected in Mexico, while the media class blames Latino voters for not wanting a woman head of state. I think it's a safe bet there's something else going on there.

Juche Stalin

Did you ever find a solution for this, FTRTTS? I still don't get new episodes for my patron's feed.

Rev Left Radio

I am very glad to hear that, thank you for listening and for the support!!

M

Where did I say that? Brett said race and gender didn’t have ANYTHING to do with it and I am saying they had SOMETHING to do with it. Of course I don’t think that was the primary reason she lost and he won. But that doesn’t mean you can write off the votes she lost because she’s a black woman and votes he won because he advocates for race and gender specific oppression. As I said: don’t lose your nuance.