Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht finally dive into the German Revolution of 1918! Together they discuss this rather ambigious revolution, give a detailed overview of events, and reflect on what lessons we can learn from it. From the toppling of the Kaiser, to the brutal fight between social democrats and communists (including the horrible murders of Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht), to the rise of the Freikorp and the Weimar Republic (and beyond), they help listeners understand the importance, the successes, the failures, and the tragedies, of this often neglected revolution.

----------------------------------------

Check out the 3-part series on YT mentioned in the episode HERE

Follow RLR on IG HERE

Subscribe to Red Menace on your preferred podcast app

Files

Comments

Ethyks

Awesome, I don't know much at all about the details of this revolution. Looking forward to this one!

Rev Left Radio

You are not alone! we talk about how many people even on the left dont know much about it, including myself before studying for this episode! So hopefully you find it informative!

Vincent

Re: the relationship between the left and the military, I think it would be interesting if you had on Greg Stoker who does a podcast called Colonial Outcasts and does a show with MintPress. He's an anarchist but doesn't do red fash shit and makes a lot more sense to me than most anarchists and is a former soldier. So, I think he would have a lot of thoughts about that and I think you talking with him would be really interesting

Lefty In Training

Definitely a great episode. Like you said, I only knew the bare bones, namely that the SPD squandered a revolutionary moment. Nice to have such an important event fleshed out a bit. Sounds like the reactionary elements that won out tailed the reactionary nationalist sentiment of the moment. Sounds a bit like the MAGA "Communists." Though I might actually have more sympathy for them than the SPD, as the left was more influential back then and the masses seemed more militant.

Danny Boy

I have been wanting to learn more exactly about this topic, thanks for reading my mind.

Jordan

Great episode! Any German rev history books yall would recommend?

BiggerBird

I’d be interested in an episode on explicitly socialist and communist organizations in the US and how they work. I feel like a lot of people are super atomized and aren’t even aware some of them exist.

Lawrie Coombs

One of my comrades over in the UK, Ben Lewis is involved in the Marxism Translated project. Primarily this involves translations of material from early German social democracy into English. Seemingly there's still tonnes of stuff currently unavailable in English. Another comrade Matt is doing stuff from Polish including some early Rosa stuff. Great comrades here's a talk he did with Cosmonaut - would be an idea if you got him on show maybe.

Ian Stockdale

Top notch episode. Do you think it would have made a difference if Rosa, and others caught off guard, had followed Liebknecht and given their full throated support for revolution from the beginning of the organic uprising?

SprocketMusic

I think another important parallel between this and the Russian Revolution is that question of when to act. Rosa and the KPD tailed the masses here at a moment which simply was not right. In Russia, on the other hand, the Bolsheviks were faced with a similar dilemma in July of 1918. There was mass antiwar action as Kerensky's attempts to continue the war turned catastrophic. The masses were actively looking to the Bolsheviks for leadership, since the Bolsheviks been the anti-war faction all along. The Bolsheviks, unlike the KPD, refused to tail them. They decided to wait it out because Kerensky would have crushed them, and that would have been the end of the party. They fsmously made their move a few months later, (with far far far fewer numbers than the spontaneous July uprisings). When the legitimacy of the provisional government collapsed, the Bolsheviks were correct in reading the room. They could roll right in and there would be no mobilized force to stop them. It's a rare instance where the Bolsheviks, even though they enjoyed broad support, actually ended up taking advantage of a lull in momentum instead of riding a wave of mass uprisings.

atesah

honestly you and Alyson are a match made in heaven. You make each other better people, teachers, intellectuals and political elucidators. I’ve learned so much from you both not just politically but also how to treat a comrade with love and respect. I’m no where near as smart as either of you but I think I have an earnest heart like you both and through the political education you all are giving me I know where to direct my heart ♥️

Lana

This is so well said and mirrors exactly how I feel about them and this show! ❤️‍🔥

Bill

Well said! Feel the same way. It’s why I’m glad to be a patron- not only to support these guys but to know that there are others who feel, think, and believe in things like I do.

Colton Burross

Great episode Breht!! I loved this episode and I’m actually moving to Germany next year for school!! I would love in the future if you did an episode on the Weimar Republic! I think it would be awesome to talk about Bertolt Brecht and how much he used theater to contribute to Marxism! Brecht is the father of dialectal theatre and I’m a big fan of The Threepenny Opera which is a critique of capitalism!

Foko

Great episode!! Opening the ep straight into Breht’s absolutely baller ass essay was a beautiful move. You and Alyson are both such brilliant and dynamic orators, your work together is really on a level of its own. Comparing this revolution with the Bolsheviks really underscores the importance of organizational discipline and unity. I’ve thought often about discipline and organization within the military and how the training they undergo creates a person to person solidarity that then forms the basis for their ideological unity. It’s something Che stresses at several points in his writings too, and is part of why I imagine he treated desertion and treachery as seriously as he did. As with meditation as a form of mental discipline, I would be interested to learn about contemporary leftist orgs’ work to build collective unity among themselves - something that I worry is much more difficult to accomplish in the atomized world we live in today.

Lesley Braver

Seconding the request for some Brecht!!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much for those kind words! We deeply and genuinly appreciate your support. :) I totally agree with your analysis too. Here in Omaha we are working on building collective unity among orgs and to take advantage of the influx of people interested in organizing after the election. Just had a huge meet up with like 50+ people from several different orgs intended to create a shared unity and personal familiarity to help build something bigger. We are even launching a Socialist Night School as an educational program for local organizers and the public. But yes, discipline, unity, solidarity, connecting forms of struggle, etc... this is our task, locally, nationally, and internationally.

Rev Left Radio

Thanks Colton, and congrats on your move to Germany next year, thats awesome. My family is german and Id love to visit it sometime. An ep on the Weimar Republic is def something Alyson and I are thinking about, and perhaps having Jon Greenaway back on to talk Brecht could be very worthwhile!

MLDad

What a great episode! Thank you!

Eli 🇵🇸

Came straight here from the recent DSA-focused episode!