Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Matthew from our Dialectics Deep Dive Series joins Breht for an end of the year patreon discussion about the current state of Canada. Together they talk about Trump and Trudeau, Canadian imperialism and neocolonialism, the immigration issue in Canada, Canada being integrated into the USA this century, Luigi, and much more!

Files

Comments

Adriaanus Stephanus

I really enjoy and appreciate your conversations with Matthew. It’s great hearing some Canadian analysis every now and then (the US steals a lot of our attention for obvious reasons). I guess it will all be the same once we’re forced to be the 51st state :-/

Rev Left Radio

I hope you enjoy the convo, and yes we talk about the 51st state thing in depth and take the idea seriously fwiw! :)

Michael Xin

Like many leftists before him, Matthew's audio equipment was assailed by reactionary technical issues

atesah

Matthew is awesome! So excited for your 2025 collaborations with him. This episode and especially your other recent episode with Torkil have really invigorated me for the 2025 struggle we have ahead of us as communists. It’s beautiful and inspiring to hear the work you, Matt and others are planning in the future and keeps me steadfast and focused on my own work to do. Rev left is my guiding (red) star and I’m eternally grateful to you all 🥹Clear eyes, full hearts, 2025 here we come baby!!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so much for those kind words and for your direct support of the show, we couldnt do it without comrades like you. Truly! I send my love to you and yours and wish you the absolute best in 2025

Wes Rich

Great episode and nice to catch up with the politics of our neighbors to the north. And yes please come out to LA! A live event with Alyson would be so much fun.

Lana

The Socialist Night School sounds amazing!! 👏 Glad to hear you’re lecturing. Getting in some teacher practice! ☺️ Wish we had something like that here.

F. Guevara

Every episode has been such a treat to listen to. I am eternally grateful to the broader Rev Left family for all of their amazing work. Truly the only thing keeping me sane!

Andrew Blake

I'm thrilled to hear about your night school... it's the first time I've ever wished I lived in the Midwest. Truly heartwarming to know you're doing something so meaningful with your talent and platform.

Matthew

Having reviewed the episode, I see where I went off track during the discussion about universities and I want to correct that before it drives me nuts: The question about Obama's injunction that everyone should learn to code was meant to lead into a discussion about how universities are not just trying to generate the "human capital" requisite for this or that role in the labour force; more insidiously, these blanket exhortations to go into programming, or computer science, or business (the big one when I was coming out of high school in the late 90s), engineering, or law, also help act as wage suppression measures by contributing to labour surpluses in any given field. Each of the disciplines I just mentioned has, in its turn, been represented as economically "future-proof" choices for young people - the sick irony being that precisely these representations have helped ensure that they aren't "future-proof" choices at all, but rather just another trap set for workers by the bourgeoisie. The problem of immigration as neocolonial extraction is roped into all of this. That's why that final academic working experience I had in Computer Science, where the vast majority of students were immigrants, was so maddening and demoralizing. Additionally, I wanted to note that, on the conservative side, the "phase transition" I mentioned in Canadian politics began over 30 years ago, when the Progressive Conservatives lost an election so badly they were reduced to 2 seats in Parliament and lost official party status. They thus then merged with the further-right Reform Party, creating the Conservative Party of Canada and ultimately giving us Pierre Poilièvre - Stephen Harper's former Renfield. So, if anything, what's happening inside the Liberal Party right now is sort of a game of catch-up in terms of destroying the former "centres of gravity" I pointed to in our conversation. Thank you everyone for your kind words about this episode!

Matthew

Parenti's Blessing 🙏

Lhasa Apsos for Palestine

Hi Breht! Loved the episode. Apologies for asking something non-episode related, as I have dived into the Rev Left back catalogue recently (absolutely love it), especially the episodes on Engels. I was seeing if you or Alyson have engaged with David Graeber and David Wengrow’s book, Dawn of Everything? It’s really taking on Engels’ approach to anthropology and stretching it, as well as bringing in so much modern evidence and literature into the discussion. They of course (Graeber) have an anarchist approach, but a highly dialectical and intellectually serious one that grapples with Marxism and perhaps can contribute to our own lens on “deep history” and anthropology. The book is an undertaking, but man…I would give an arm and a leg for you and Alyson’s take on it!

Brad Northcote

Great episode! It's awesome to get some socialist analysis of events in my neck of the woods. Thinking back through years of hearing an "At least we're not the U.S." refrain, it was inevitable that discourse would reach its limits...even if a formal annexation would be rife with contradictions, too.

nickw

Great episode! It’s striking but not surprising as a settler colonial state how similar the issues discussed in Canada are to here in Australia. And thanks to the ineptitude of the labour government, we are about to vote in a racist ex cop who used to lock up Aboriginal kids for a living as our next PM.

Dave Miles

I came here to say the same thing… Settler colony built on genocide and dispossession..✔️ Provider of raw materials for the Imperial core…✔️ Was subservient to the British Empire, now a vassal state of the US…✔️ Both ex-Brit settler colonies have tied ourselves up to the US and we’re about to sleepwalk into WWIII. Although it seems Canada was spared the “privilege” of having a democratically elected government dismissed for the heinous crime of trying to exercise its sovereignty…

Spiderdijo7

I hope Luigi stays strong. He obviously is a man with principles and the conviction to carry them out.

Foko

I really highly recommend the YouTube channel “What is Politics?”, who put out an extensive series of videos on Dawn of Everything a couple of years ago. Everything that channel puts out is really excellent, I hope it’s useful to you.

Ken S

Okay, this feels serendipitous, because after starting to listen to RevLeft from the very beginning, on Jul 10 2023, and winding my way through the whole catalog, i'm only a *few* eps from being "caught up" to the present and you're talking about 'Canada,' where i was born and where i live (albeit in protest 😛), and whose flag i burned only to see it cracking up here. Not a serious believer in "signs" but what the hell, let's treat this like it is one. It's been 557 days (and counting) of Breht & comrades helping to deprogram me, helping to radicalize me, helping me go back in and rescue my inner child- who it turns out is a sweet, kind kid, even after all of this antisocial "society's" work to turn him into a cowardly little fascist asshole, like i *was* becoming- to rescue him and claim a do-over raising him, to become a better man. One who tries to be bit more like the Buddha, a bit more like Isa (PBUH), a lot more like my mom, whose example i didn't appreciate nearly enough until her last day on Earth (Jun 29 2019). More like the friendly voice in my ears for a year and a half, raging and crying and laughing and teaching, a dear friend i've never met. As thanks for your many gifts, comrade, the time feels right to offer you one besides the Patreon pittance i can afford- it's not much more than a name-drop, but it's from the heart, and comes as part of a whole collection you helped inspire. https://vm.tiktok.com/ZMkHRJqw5/ If you like it, hope you'll check out "i was one" next- it's ~15 mins long, but yo, i've listened to you for... like... 700 (very edifying) hours so far 😋

Nino Di Renzo

I'm currently reading this book. Definitely an undertaking, but very rewarding and challenging to any dogmatic beliefs we may hold about our prehistoric past.